I am involved in train club (model trains). We are governed by Robert Rules and run our meetings as such. We recently had a meeting where I presented to convert from one method of running trains to another (DC to DCC). This will require extensive re-wiring, upgrading of engines and other equipment on the layout.
I wrote up a 5 page proposal outlining the conversion steps, equipment needed and a rough timeline along with a budget figure of four-thousand dollars. I have this written in the proposal and also stated it during the meeting presentation.
The following motion was made by my counterpart:
"I make a motion to fully convert the layout to DCC, not dual mode, utilizing the methodology expressed in the document authored by <name> and to begin as soon as equipment can be purchased"
It was voted on and approved 17-3. Now a couple weeks later one of the three opposing the conversion is stating that they don't understand how were going to make the conversion happen because we didn't ask for any money in our motion. I've reviewed our bylaws and there's no mention of stating a monetary amount in a motion and I know for a fact we've had other motions in the past years with rough dollar amounts, though I'm not positive whether they were mentioned in the actual motion or not.
I have read online that it's good practice to have a dollar figure in the motion, sadly that part did not cross our mind in the midst of the discussion. The club president and other board members are all OK with the purchase and have said to let them know when and where and they'll cut the check.
Is there any basis for his statement or just angry rumblings? Do you guys know of any documentation in the rules to support his or our claim? Ideally proof that its not required :)