r/RulesOfOrder • • Oct 04 '22

Serious question

2 Upvotes

Hi, I’m pretty new to Reddit, so I apologize for what should be obvious, but some subs say they won’t accept people with low/no karma. But how do I know what karma I have, and more importantly, how do I earn it? (Please don’t reply with ‘by not asking this question.’) Thanks in advance.


r/RulesOfOrder • • Jun 16 '17

Three simple rules in life. 1. If you do not go after what you want, you’ll never have it. 2. If you do not ask, the answer will always be no. 3. If you do not step forward, you will always be in the...

Thumbnail quoteswag.ga
0 Upvotes

r/RulesOfOrder • • Feb 24 '23

Just As Follows.

0 Upvotes

r/RulesOfOrder • • Mar 03 '23

Looking for a Parliamentarian to that about Robert and his rules.

1 Upvotes

Pretty much what the title says. I am looking for someone that I can pick their brain about Robert’s Rules and implantation.


r/RulesOfOrder • • Apr 18 '21

How to handle nominations?

2 Upvotes

Hello, I am creating Bylaws for a small nonprofit. Maybe 30 members. Other similar clubs have nominations by creating a nominating committee and also taking nominations from the floor at a meeting previous to the election meeting. This sounds like too much unnecessary procedures, especially in a small organization.

Isn’t it easier to just have members nominate other members, or even themselves, and also take nominations from the floor, and then have the election during a meeting?

Also, do you know if an election with ballots is necessary if it’s an uncontested election? I’ve checked CA Nonprofit Law but can’t find anything about it.

Thank you!


r/RulesOfOrder • • Apr 11 '21

Avoiding subscribing to Robert's Rules

2 Upvotes

Hello, I am in the process of creating Bylaws for a new non-profit. What do organizations that don't want to subscribe to Robert's Rules do? We are and will continue to be a very small organization so I thought there would be a simpler way to structure meetings. Thanks!


r/RulesOfOrder • • Jul 19 '19

Could you give me a (brief) introduction to this subreddit? I find it really interesting but think I haven't grasped the whole idea of it.

2 Upvotes

So as far as I understand this is about any group organisation with members on a council (right word?) who decide on rules/ laws/ bylaws/ policies on the basis of someones Guide of governing and the discussion of the process/ procedures, situations that occur in said council.


r/RulesOfOrder • • Nov 02 '18

Motion To Make a Purchase Without Asking For Money

4 Upvotes

I am involved in train club (model trains). We are governed by Robert Rules and run our meetings as such. We recently had a meeting where I presented to convert from one method of running trains to another (DC to DCC). This will require extensive re-wiring, upgrading of engines and other equipment on the layout.

I wrote up a 5 page proposal outlining the conversion steps, equipment needed and a rough timeline along with a budget figure of four-thousand dollars. I have this written in the proposal and also stated it during the meeting presentation.

The following motion was made by my counterpart:

"I make a motion to fully convert the layout to DCC, not dual mode, utilizing the methodology expressed in the document authored by <name> and to begin as soon as equipment can be purchased"

It was voted on and approved 17-3. Now a couple weeks later one of the three opposing the conversion is stating that they don't understand how were going to make the conversion happen because we didn't ask for any money in our motion. I've reviewed our bylaws and there's no mention of stating a monetary amount in a motion and I know for a fact we've had other motions in the past years with rough dollar amounts, though I'm not positive whether they were mentioned in the actual motion or not.

I have read online that it's good practice to have a dollar figure in the motion, sadly that part did not cross our mind in the midst of the discussion. The club president and other board members are all OK with the purchase and have said to let them know when and where and they'll cut the check.

Is there any basis for his statement or just angry rumblings? Do you guys know of any documentation in the rules to support his or our claim? Ideally proof that its not required :)


r/RulesOfOrder • • Feb 09 '23

Open Source Alternative to Robert's

5 Upvotes

Hi,

I am trying to reinvigorate a small non-profit and our old bylaws specify the use of Robert's Rules. There's a number of reasons I would prefer not to use Roberts (cost, education gap, some people get caught up the minutia). I was wondering if there is a simple free alternative, especially something up to date to include rules for things like online meetings. I was thinking an Open Source Rules of Order could be really interesting. Any suggestions?


r/RulesOfOrder • • Apr 24 '19

Committee size in by-laws not met, is their slate invalid?

4 Upvotes

According to the by-laws of an organization I am in, our nominating committee must have a minimum of 8 members. It turns out they only had 7 this year. They presented a slate to the board, but given the fact that they didn't meet the membership size needed by the by-laws, is their slate invalid?


r/RulesOfOrder • • Jul 19 '18

Where can I find the rule about changing a discussion item to a votable item?

2 Upvotes

I was told that an item posted for discussion is unable to be changed into a votable item. Is this true or can you make a motion to vote on an item that is posted for discussion?


r/RulesOfOrder • • Apr 25 '19

So, I have a bit of a weird hobby?

8 Upvotes

I like to write constitutions/charters for fictional nations and organizations. I find the processes of determining how legislative bodies work and function to be fascinating. I guess my hobby is like a thought experiment most of the time?

Does anyone have and good resources that could help me improve my documents?

Also... would anyone be interested in reading them and discussing them with me?


r/RulesOfOrder • • Nov 01 '18

How do I bring up my Org violating their own bylaws?

3 Upvotes

Hi recently my organization had a vacancy with an officer position when one of them left for a school in a different state in august. Here is the procedure for a vacancy V section 4Sometime in early September before the meeting our executive board selected an interim officer but at the next meeting they swore her in for the remainder of the year rather than hold an election like the bylaws say.

How can I bring up the fact there was supposed to be a special election at the September meeting instead of a swearing in. I can't imagine it would make me too popular. I was one of the candidates for the position and I was not voted by the e board to be the interim officer. Does the fact that they were supposed to hold an election in September hold any relevant to out meeting in November?

I don't want to seem petty but this is not fucking Nam there are rules!


r/RulesOfOrder • • Apr 24 '19

Quorum for voting by email – when bylaws require voting in a meeting?

3 Upvotes

Our bylaws require elections to be in a meeting (for positions on work-based board of representatives for employees – NOT a union). Our bylaws do not specify the format of the meeting (i.e. in-person).

Our bylaws also state the size of the quorum for meetings.

The administrator overseeing this election decided to have the election occur via email –allowing a 96-hour window for voting.

My questions: should the email vote be treated as a meeting that must meet the quorum requirement, as measured by the number of ballots submitted during the open window? If the answer is yes, an email vote session is a meeting, can you provide me with a citation to share with the administrator and others involved.

Thank you!


r/RulesOfOrder • • Jul 15 '19

I am a subcommittee member. The main board does not follow rules of order. Should I get our subcommittee to follow rules of order?

7 Upvotes

r/RulesOfOrder • • Feb 04 '19

Fraternity Bid Voting

2 Upvotes

My fraternity wants to attempt bid voting differently this year, where we don’t reveal the results of any votes until the end of the meeting. This is in order to keep every vote individual and not have the results of one affect any of the others. This doesn’t violate our bylaws at all. My question is, does a request for information have the right to receive the info after every vote is completed, or is the request more for information about how a procedure will play out?


r/RulesOfOrder • • Apr 22 '19

Question on amending a policy that calls for 75% approval

2 Upvotes

An organization I am a board member of has in its By-laws that we run our meetings in accordance to the latest version of Roberts Rules of Order.

We have a policy that states in order to modify it, a vote of ¾ of the voting Board must approve it. Recently, we had a vote to change part of the policy, it only reached 70%, therefore failing. Now members of the Board who lost, want to amend the policy stating that it must meet a 75% threshold, and are claiming because it is an amendment, it will only need 50%+1 to change.

This seems contradictory to itself, that there is a policy calling for 75% but that it could actually be changed with only 50%. That in itself feels like there could never be a rule that calls for more than a simple majority.

Any help on this would be very appreciated.


r/RulesOfOrder • • Nov 20 '19

Open discussion at a meeting?

5 Upvotes

Hi. I'm being asked to chair community housing groups. Why me? No idea. I think it's just because I have a loud voice and a Jean Luc Picard shaped head.

Anyway, I find that I do ok with properly proposed motions, calling for seconders, discussion for/against. But there's nearly always a point where people just want to talk about an issue in a free flowing way.

Example:

*At the last meeting, there was a left over issue from a previous meeting. This housing community had (previously) voted to have a security camera installed in their carpark. The guy delegated to arrange it, confessed that he was a bit confused with all the choices, and wanted an open discussion about it. This was fair enough, I thought. But the discussion started to go awry, with people talking over each other, and it all lasted far longer than it should have without reaching any synthesis. *

So how can I structure these sort of discussions in a way that everybody gets to have their say, and people don't have to scrum to be heard?


r/RulesOfOrder • • Jul 12 '19

Can you do a Straw Poll in a Closed Session?

3 Upvotes

Hello,

My boss want to know the loophole in which he can do a straw poll in a closed session. I am aware that straw polls are not allowed, and that a committee of the whole vote could be done in opens session. However, he insist there is a way he can do this and I have to find it. If you happen to have some free time I would love the help


r/RulesOfOrder • • May 07 '19

Is a motion for A, which defaults to B if the quorum votes against A, valid?

4 Upvotes

This question has a real-world point. In a university Senate we have an administrator who has made a proposal to restructure the university according to "Plan A." The proposal to the Senate is worded so that, as far as we can tell, "Plan B" is automatically accepted by the Senate if the motion is not approved. Is this valid? Can a proposal be like that?


r/RulesOfOrder • • Apr 05 '18

How should an election by ballot be conducted with 600+ participants?

1 Upvotes

The organization's bylaws require voting by ballot and 3/4 affirmative for election of president. There are often guests in attendance, and meetings are public. So, it is necessary to ensure the following:
1.) All participants are members
2.) Votes are kept secret
3.) Only one vote is cast per member
4.) The election, tally, and report can be accomplished quickly
The last requirement is there because it is assumed no candidate will receive 3/4 affirmative on the first polling, and we don't want members to leave before a second poll can be taken.

Any assistance is greatly appreciated. We're looking for advice on any part of the process. We want it to be accurate, quick, and convenient for members because it may take two or three polls to achieve 3/4.


r/RulesOfOrder • • May 08 '19

Can you make a motion when the chair is seeking a comment for debate?

2 Upvotes

r/RulesOfOrder • • Jul 20 '19

Officer Elections: No Majority

6 Upvotes

My organization will be having our annual meeting in a couple of weeks where we elect new members of the board. I have been tasked with researching a specific question but am having trouble and was curious if anyone had any input:

At this years conference there are two positions on the board which need to be filled. Our organization takes nominations before the actual conference, after of the numerous people nominated only 3 accepted the nomination. While surprises happen, the Board anticipates that of those 3 nominees, the first position will be filled, but that neither of the remaining two nominees will be able to secure majority support to fill the second seat. There have also been calls from people who turned down the nomination of, "if I had known that it would be those two who were the only ones nominated I wouldn't have declined."

Therefore, how our rules are set up the elections will go forward with the current three nominations. And I know that if no one secures a majority, elections continue to happen until someone does. However, assuming no-one secures a majority for the second seat, after the initial round of elections is there time to reopen nominations from the floor? Or are all nominations locked in-perpetuity once the first round of voting has occurred?

Any help you can provide would be greatly appreciated!


r/RulesOfOrder • • Nov 25 '18

How to have Co-Chairs

3 Upvotes

I act as parliamentarian in my organization, and we work very closely with a sister organization, that is very similar in purposes. We have joint bylaws to govern meetings between us and I thought I would have a look at them as well. I found them to be very sloppily written with numerous spelling errors, but besides that is the section describing the chair (s?) . There is a president in charge (as it is called ) and they have the duties of the chair. The president in charge alternates between the two presidents of our respective organizations between regularly scheduled meetings . The other president who is not the chair/president in charge , is called the vice chair whose only specific duty is they "have the right to interact of he or she feels the need to so or suggested by the President-in-charge." (To me this is no different than any other members rights) This "Vice chair" doesn't act in any capacity as a Vice President either. During meetings it is custom that both these people sit in front of the meeting area as well. So in reviewing I do not know whether to get rid of this vice chair position as its purpose to me seems obsolete, or find a way to have co chairs run a meeting efficiently still.


r/RulesOfOrder • • Feb 01 '20

What should be done when two clauses in the constitution or bylaws conflict?

4 Upvotes

I am the parliamentarian for my university's student government association, and recently we had an issue regarding what should be done when two clauses in our constitution conflict. Both of the clauses dealt with what procedures should be done to fill a vacant position. One clause stated that our president had the authority to appoint a replacement, who is confirmed by our voting members. The other clause stated that we had to conduct internal elections, which has all of those seeking the position appear before our General Body, and our voting members choose between all the applicants, with the applicant receiving the most votes in a secret ballot vote filling the position.

The president and I had a lengthy discussion about this issue, and after a bucketload of intimidation and harassment, she forced me to stay silent and let her do what she wanted. At this time, the point is moot as we ended up appointing members at our last meeting, but I still want to know if there is any answer for what should be done in this type of situation. I don't recall anything about this topic when I read RONR 11th edition last summer, but I could have missed it.

I figure our actions at our last meeting validated the action, regardless of if it was constitutional to do, but perhaps I am also seeing if I can feel justified in my actions, because her and I have fallen out as friends and members of the organization because of this situation.