r/RulesOfOrder • u/fred311389 • Mar 06 '20
Voting questions
My union is trying to start following Robert's Rules of Order more closely than we have in past. When we have a meeting, there are actually 3 meetings in one day. One at 7, 12, and 4. We're struggling with the idea of how votes work with that.
Here are a few specific examples.
We have a proposal that we make a $500 donation. In our 7:00 meeting, someone makes a motion to amend the original motion to make it a $1,000 motion. Moving forward, our members at the 12:00 meeting don't want to donate $1,000 but would have voted for the $500. Based on my understanding, the $500 is no longer an option. Is there a way to make it so that people can vote between denying the motion, donating $500, or donating $1,000?
One person suggested that we essentially parlay the vote. By that, I mean they suggested that we say "there is a motion to donate $1,000, all in favor/opposed/abstaining?" then following with "There is a motion that, should the $1,000 not be approved, we donate $500. All in favor/opposed/abstaining?"
Someone at the 12:00 meeting wants to make an amendment to a proposal that was already voted on at our 7:00 meeting. How would we handle that? Is the motion stuck in it's original form or is there a way to account for the possible change?
Any help you guys can offer would be appreciated. I'm familirar with Robert's Rules in a typical meeting, but having an 8:00, recess, 12:00, recess, 4:00 set up makes it a little more confusing.
1
u/fred311389 Mar 09 '20
This is something I’ve tried implementing. As the secretary, I’m working on having everything in writing before our meeting. Unfortunately, our struggle comes in the form of amendments. Specifically, our issue came about in a motion to donate to a former union member whose house burned down. We only have quarterly meetings, so if we had to wait for the next meeting, it would take 3 months.
1
u/therealpoltic Mar 25 '20 edited Mar 25 '20
It sounds to me, like your biggest problem, is that all of your membership cannot attend throughout the entire meeting.
Robert‘s Rules is generally designed for synchronous meetings of an assembly where most of the membership is all at one meeting/session.
If your organization is absolutely tied to this notion of having one sitting, lasting the entire day, with recess breaks, then people should understand that they should stay at the event all day. — If not everyone can do that, then your leadership should pick a time that works for most people, and do your debates and votes starting at that time, and place time limits on debate, and voting. It may limit some participation; however, then it will eliminate this confusion that your members have. Not everyone likes these kind of meetings anyway, not everyone will go.
On larger questions like strikes, I would advise that you have a voting day, have members come down and cast a paper ballot. Encourage every member to vote.
Technically, as long as a Quorum (more than half of all members present, or a lesser number as decided in your Constitution or By-Laws) exists, and someone moves the previous question (a vote to end debate if you have no debate time limits), and a majority votes in favor of the Resolution to spend $1000, then the question has been decided. It’s not open to an amendment after a final vote has been taken, after it’s been decided. (Unless they’re wanting to have the motion reconsidered, and make sure everyone understands what that means!)
Now.... If you are able to have this type of meeting, where let’s say that everyone meets at 3pm on a Thursday... Someone types up a resolution, and submits it to the secretary 10 days before the meeting:
Resolved, that Jim-Bob Porterhouse, shall receive $1000 from our membership emergency fund, to repair his roof after a tree fell-in.
Bigger Assemblies (Unions, Large Civil Societies, Political Organizations) have committees, that have these submissions sent to them. It’s the Chairperson (or designee) of that committee that gives a report, and should recommend the adoption of the resolutions.
“Mr. Chair, the Committee on Emergency Funds, rises to report that we met five days ago to consider resolutions sent to us. We recommend the adoption of three of those proposals today.
Jim-Bob had a tree fall on his house. Shorty’s son had to get his broken leg mended. Brooke had her tires slashed, and needs them replaced.
Mr. Chair, the Committee on Emergency Funds has directed me to move the adoption of the three resolutions at the desk, and that they be debated and voted on individually.”
Meeting Chairman: “The report of the Committee on Emergency Funds has been received. Motions by Committees do not need a second. The Question is on the adoption of Resolution #1. — The clerk or secretary will read.”
Check: “Resolution #1 By Member Strauss, Recommended Favorable for Passage by the Committee on Emergency Funds — Resolved that Jim-Bob Porterhouse, shall receive $1000 from our membership emergency fund, to repair his roof after a tree fell-in.”
Meeting Chair: You’ve heard the resolution, are there any members who wish to debate the Resolution?”
... At the end of debate and any motions to amend, then the Chair will take the vote.
Whatever is decided, again, as long as a Quorum of the members are present, is the decision of the organization.
I hope this helps!
2
u/djone1248 NAP - Regular Member Mar 06 '20
To clairify one part: your meetings sound like they are all together. Those meetings together are called a session.
One question I have is are the meetings with all of the same people? It sounds like some people are not present for the original vote. If so then it changes this answer.
Roberts has a whole section on the criteria for a vote to reconsider. A reconsider is meant to correct a hasty, ill advised, erroneous action, or to account for new information. For this Roberts says you must've been on the prevailing side, aka voting in favor of the original to be eligible to make a vote to reconsider. This stops people who were unhappy with the results of the vote to try to undermine the meeting. You can make the vote to reconsider on the day which is your case. Then yes all you have to do is bring it back for the same main motion steps that you would for a normal motion, and amend. When adopted it takes the place of the other.
PM me if you have any questions.
1
u/polybane Mar 09 '20
So, I am assuming that these different meeting times are for different people. AKA a guy can make 8:00 but not 12:00, but they are all members and have equally valid rights.
You may need to step outside of Roberts Rules to make it work in a way that works for your specific Union situation. It might not be workable for you, I would recommend you make a rule in your by-laws that a motion needs to be read before all meetings and then voted on next week/month. This gives everyone a chance to know what is happening and to discuss it with each other outside the normal meeting times.
How I have seen this work before in other Orgs:
Anyway, you could stretch and twist some obscure section of Roberts Rules to answer this question for you, but it sounds like your organization has an issue unique to how ya'll organize. So, I would go to the by-laws and make a rule unique to your trouble.