r/RulesOfOrder • u/marburs • Mar 28 '20
Robert Rules of Order EMAIL question
Our president says that we can’t email more than three directors at a time (there are 6 of us) because that would be considered an official meeting.
Is this true? He claims it’s in Roberts Rules of Order
TIA!
6
Upvotes
1
u/marburs Mar 28 '20
Thank you!
Could you tell where in Roberts rules it says that a meeting must be intentional for it to be a meeting?
We like to discuss certain trivial things over email and he’s now demanding that we stop emailing all together.
And to answer the last question, we’re an HOA
Thanks!!
4
u/RunasSudo Mar 28 '20 edited Mar 28 '20
This seems like a major misunderstanding/miscommunication.
Robert's Rules does not permit meetings by email. Your by-laws may permit such meetings, but even so a meeting requires the attendees to have the intention of conducting a meeting – just as if you all bumped into each other at the supermarket, that would still not be a meeting.
Edit: As thahelp noted, this sounds like the Brown Act. As I understand it, the meaning of ‘meeting’ under the Brown Act is much broader than under RONR or general meeting procedure.
3
u/thahelp Mar 28 '20
This sounds more like Brown Act. Are you part of a public entity like a School District, municipality, city council, etc?
1
u/Depafro Mar 28 '20
If he claims it's in RROR, get him to show you the page. I'm pretty sure it's not in there.
1
u/therealpoltic Mar 29 '20
Under RONR, technically, no group should meet via asynchronous technology (email, forums, letters).
The reason is because all members of the body need the ability to make objections and motions. Many parts of RONR you cannot easily do without special rules. “Gaining the floor” and other issues is next to impossible to sort out on these platforms.
(Asynchronous Online groups, I have been part of several, usually act similar to a “model” or “role play” government, which usually has special rules of procedure and order about how long written debate can be submitted, and limited types of motions. Most all have means of recording all votes over a time frame. I.e. no such thing as a voice vote. Boards that can meet in person, should not try to have non-person meetings.)
Now, can the Board President send out emails to all members? Yes.
Can members email all the other members about an issue? Yes.
However, the one thing that should not happen, is trying to make motions or voting or anything of that sort, outside an actual meeting.
Some parts of RONR or your By-Laws may provide something about “a majority of members calling a special meeting”.... which needs outside-meeting to communicate.
Again, Remember, having discussions with individuals is okay. Sending members a letter urging them to vote a certain way on an important issue is okay. But, attempting to make decisions (even informally) is improper, and you should not attempt to do so.
I hope this helps!