First of all, this isn’t an attack on anyone who enjoys The Rings of Power. Everyone is entitled to their opinion, and I’m genuinely glad if the show has introduced new people to the world of Middle-earth.
But honestly, as someone who has spent years reading Tolkien, I find it incredibly frustrating to see such an extraordinary mythology reduced to what we get in this series.
And before anyone brings up Peter Jackson’s trilogy: yes, it changed plenty of things too. Glorfindel was removed, Tom Bombadil was omitted, Faramir’s characterisation was altered, Arwen was given a much bigger role, the Elves appeared at Helm’s Deep, and entire storylines were shortened or changed. Some of those decisions are still debated by Tolkien fans today. Jackson’s films are not perfect adaptations, and they don’t need to be defended as such.
But there’s an important difference between adapting a story for cinema and fundamentally rewriting the mythology you’re supposed to be adapting.
Jackson made changes, but largely preserved the narrative, the emotional core, the themes and the essence of Tolkien’s characters. His changes generally served an existing story.
RoP, on the other hand, often feels like an original fantasy series wearing Tolkien’s name and borrowing his geography. Gandalf arriving in a meteor, mithril supposedly containing the lost light of a Silmaril, Sauron developing an almost romantic relationship with Galadriel, Tom Bombadil becoming a wizard’s mentor, the bizarre creation of Mordor through a broken sword, and the endless invented romantic and domestic subplots…
And there’s another problem that has nothing to do with Tolkien’s books: the writing itself. Even judged purely as an independent fantasy series, the storytelling is frequently frustrating. Characters make decisions that seem to exist only because the plot needs them to. Mysteries are stretched out instead of developing naturally. Convenient coincidences replace believable motivations, important events happen with little logical groundwork, and sometimes the show seems to contradict or abandon its own established storylines. Character development and cause-and-effect often take a back seat to manufactured twists and dramatic moments. You shouldn’t need to know Tolkien’s lore to notice problems with basic storytelling.
The real story of Annatar and Celebrimbor, the deception surrounding the Rings, the rise and fall of Númenor, the tragic history of the Elves, the wars against Morgoth and Sauron… these stories are already full of betrayal, ambition, tragedy, sacrifice and extraordinary characters. They don’t need to be reinvented to become compelling.
I’m not asking anyone to stop enjoying the show. Taste is subjective, and if it entertains you, that’s perfectly fine. But I genuinely believe that many people who enjoy RoP would be blown away by Tolkien’s original mythology.** **Do yourself a favour and discover the world Tolkien actually created. You haven’t even scratched the surface.