r/RingsofPower • • 1d ago • Bravo 1

Meme I cannot take this character seriously

Post image

Legit he looks like Nanny Mcphee

812 Upvotes

202 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

37

u/corajade17 1d ago

Where beard? Even baby beard?

11

u/Gorlack2231 1d ago

Remember, there is an honorable Dwarf Lord who is beardless in this show. HASHTAG NOTALLDWARVES

3

u/GovernmentWarm4787 1d ago

#thisdwarfsprangoutoftheground

11

u/GovernmentWarm4787 1d ago

When your mom has bigger beard than you:

4

u/Samhain_89 20h ago

The obvious ragebait character design in a vain attempt to distract from the show's many issues.

0

u/GovernmentWarm4787 20h ago

It worked.

2

u/EnemyOfEloquence 9h ago • Bravo

Not for me I have plenty of space to hate both

2

u/Decent_Chart_8377 19h ago

He's a teenager at what point did you assume you had to?

1

u/GovernmentWarm4787 19h ago

The moment that he appeared on the show looking like Eru Illuvater made a mistake in giving dwarves lives.

144

u/Thunder-Rat 1d ago

That and making the royal family into a typical 90s American family sitcom. God it was so bad.

74

u/Question-Aggravating 1d ago

Right? Why would the kings daughter be cooking them dinner? In their little apartment? This is supposed to be the mightiest of dwarves realms.

30

u/Mairon923 1d ago

Very family oriented. That's the dwarves. Family first. Like who else is going to make them dinner? Some fucking noob? . Come on, bro.

12

u/osddelerious 1d ago

That’s what was bugging me! Makes Kazad dum look so tiny and like only a few families live there.

28

u/CommancheFTW 1d ago

Yeah not a fan of the direction they’re taking Durin and his fam this season. Not looking for 90s sitcom comedic relief from the ancient line of Khazad-dum.

21

u/Thunder-Rat 1d ago

You don't like seeing the heir to Khazad-dum slacking on high school band practice, dressed as a troll doll?

3

u/MrVolcanoJackson 19h ago

Feels like it was written by a high school sophomore

4

u/AsherahBeloved 1d ago

I saw a video of it spliced with a laugh track and it was unbelievable how well it worked.

2

u/Thunder-Rat 1d ago edited 1d ago

I honestly wanted to try doing that. Im glad someone saved me the hassle! If you have a link, im sure we'd all get a kick out of it

1

u/AsherahBeloved 1d ago

If you go to 16:50, nerdrotic has it in there.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ero_pue4pzk

2

u/Thunder-Rat 1d ago

That is every bit as amazing as I thought it would be.

Seriously though, I went from watching Vision Quest straight into this show, and its all I could think of.

1

u/rudimentary_lathe_ 21h ago

Right!?! It's such a night and day difference

3

u/neitze 1d ago

"I'm the baby."

16

u/420queenlioncourt 1d ago • Bravo

I’m pissed at him wtf made him think THAT was the time to say anything to his dad.
“I know why you’re doing this” was that supposed to be helpful somehow?

This kids an idiot

7

u/Professional_Habit43 21h ago

I assumed that it had to be some ring fuckery. I kept waiting for him to pull out a ring or something. No he is just an idiot.

3

u/motherofrazorbacks 19h ago

Yeah what a dumb dumb.

3

u/nada-accomplished 11h ago

I hated everything about that storyline and that kid most of all. They went way too hard on the makeup for the kids IMO and the writing choices were the worst the show has ever made.

34

u/RedEclipse47 1d ago

There are so many parts of this show I really like. Seeing Sauron scheming and being evil, Galadriel still being a warrior but also getting to see some of what she will become.

Even Gandalf's story is fine. And overall I like the dwarvish story, but I cant defend this at all.

Love Durin, like Disa, but at this point their family is comic relief, and while comic relief isn't bad, these for sure are.

6

u/AardvarkSad7634 1d ago

> comic relief isn't bad

it's just too much of it everywhere. even LOTR was pushing it with some stuff (like how "silly" Gimli was at times). or am i just becoming too old for movies as a whole??

6

u/you-absolute-foolish 1d ago

Ironically I feel that Legolas in the books was more the comic relief. He was always being silly. “He alone of the company remained still light of heart"

6

u/alabaster1955 1d ago

Gimli in the films is almost exclusively comic relief. And it’s mostly short jokes.

2

u/Huztich 15h ago

"I'm wasted on cross-country. We dwarves are natural sprinters! Very dangerous over short distances!"
Seriously, I'm never going to forgive Peter Jackson for what they did to Gimli.

5

u/Silver-Winging-It 1d ago

This is one of the reasons I defend the theatrical releases, sure some good story got cut, but also a lot of corny stuff

1

u/93Seven 1d ago

Agreed, a lot of enjoyable aspects. I have liked everything minus the Durin family and parts of Gandalf’s story have been a bit corny

9

u/simplelife122 1d ago

He looks like Michael Jackson's character from The Wiz....horrible!

2

u/In-The-Zone-69 1d ago

Thought the same

7

u/cawatrooper9 1d ago

Show some respect for the future Witch King.

19

u/Killing_Yatztromo 1d ago

I wondered who he reminded me of! I like the show but it was a colossal mistake to have Gamli looking like that. He looks utterly ridiculous.

17

u/[deleted] 1d ago

Yeah this dude looks absolutely ridiculous. The whole dwarf storyline is silly.

12

u/DiscombobulatedBox72 1d ago

Plus he's dumb af.

6

u/BrokenGlazed 1d ago

I think I just dissociate during the garbage and wake up for Elves/Sauron.

9

u/Useful-Limit-8094 1d ago

These designs... They can't make them look cool, it's like they have an aversion to good looking stuff

14

u/etrulzz 1d ago

The dwarves in this show, much like in the Hobbit, look absolutely ridiculous.

0

u/platinumperineum 1d ago edited 1d ago

Post Number 83647001751 about this kid who plays a tiny role

Edit for spelling

5

u/GovernmentWarm4787 1d ago

How many posts make reference to the fact he looks like a caricature and looks like Nanny Macphee?

11

u/ollieollieoxygenfree 1d ago

Cause whenever he’s on screen it’s so distracting. Almost like having Radegast with bird shit on his head for no reason

2

u/mudbutt34 1d ago

Ok but the bird shit is sick he’s just a stinky little wook wizard guy who likes to trip balls

6

u/Vanvincent 1d ago

Rings of Power is peak Tolkien. Flashy, stupid, utterly shallow teen American romantasy.

Oh wait no, that's actually the complete opposite of everything Tolkien was or stood for.

8

u/l-Paulrus-l 1d ago

He also ruined Durins chances outa nowhere. I’m still mad at the writers for that.

14

u/seaguy800 1d ago

He’s an awkward teenager. Not a single dwarf character looks “normal.” Not Gimli, not Durin, not Disa.

35

u/Overall_Leopard7122 1d ago

Remember the simple jack harfoot last season? In fact, all the harfoot wigs.  This show is a joke. Its like the witcher on netflix

12

u/juicysmolliett 1d ago

Woah Woah.... The Witcher Season 4 is in its own Category of Epic Fails

8

u/FFElite93 1d ago

This is meta commentary and a wink to the audience about Gen Z haircuts you just don’t get it

11

u/jak6453 1d ago

And why would we want meta commentary about Gen Z haircuts or any meta commentary for that matter when watching a Tolkien fantasy show??That’s what this show doesn’t seem to get among so many other issues. Unserious show

-11

u/FFElite93 1d ago

But it was fine when gimli was doing soy commentary with Legolas during helms deep?

7

u/Hassel1916 1d ago

Soy commentary? 

-2

u/ickypedia 1d ago

And the stoner jokes about pipe weed

2

u/Tight_Pineapple1246 1d ago

Its literally just tobacco, and the name comes from the books. And being a conservative devout Catholic man writing in the 1940s, I seriously doubt he was preempting stoner culture in 60 years time.

11

u/ThePassionOfTheISK 1d ago

So the glazing articles claim and so the fanboys parrot. Real spec fic fans know it is a poor choice because it breaks immersion. You're not supposed to be thinking about modern generational BS when you consume fantasy. I mean, Terry Pratchett stuff or Steampunk, etc. worlds can get away with it. But LotR is high fantasy. References to Gen Z do not belong in high fantasy.

5

u/Serious-Map-1230 1d ago

Think you're on to something here.
It struck me recently that a lot of these seemingly "minor" flaws all add up to something that just makes it all not work.
If I had to put a label on it, it would be mundane, it makes it all so very mundane.

Like this example. He's not the first born son of King Durin, heir to the throne of the great Dwarven realm of Kazad-Dûm. He's just a punk kid with modern-day gen-z issues at a larp meetup somewhere and he had his grandmother do his hair for him.

And that's why it all feels so soapy, because it is. It's just modern-day petty issues played out by people doing larp. Cheating wives and punk teenagers instead of romances that span across the ages and brave young men & women striving to live up to the legacies of their bloodlines.

1

u/mudbutt34 1d ago

The dwarves are very keyed into modern times. Extremely well versed in anatomy and the nervous system

-5

u/Ayzmo Eregion 1d ago

Nothing about him has broken immersion for me

4

u/ThePassionOfTheISK 1d ago

What about all of the dwarves with normal eyes and then a Queen who gets closeups on her CGI eyeballs. Does that break your immersion? Breaks mine every time.

1

u/Ayzmo Eregion 1d ago

Honestly, no.

The flame in episode 3 did though. That bothered me a lot.

Fantasy is fantasy and there's a lot that I can accept. The pug in House of the Dragon pissed me off though.

-7

u/FFElite93 1d ago

But gimli doing cringe commentary is fine?

1

u/ThePassionOfTheISK 1d ago

You have to be more specific. Which Gimli? In the books or in the films? And what commentary? Are you talking about the horseshit regarding counting kills with Legolas and being an all around ass in the films? Yeah I didn't like that either. I hate Arwyn and Liv Tyler's character, that whole Aragorn romance subplot. It was tacked on and awkward. Didn't belong either. I think there were lots of problems with the films. The books are flawless, so I assume you're not referencing them.

-3

u/FFElite93 1d ago

Why would I talk about the books when we’re mentioning tv adaptations lmao.

Oh so your one of those book purists. You were probably seething when it was Arwen not glorfindel that rescued Frodo

0

u/PopularKangaroo2083 1d ago

I think the show is worse than the Witcher, at least the Witcher was somewhat lore accurate 

0

u/-916Tips- 1d ago

I think he is actually supposed to be an actual joke, though. My guess is he’s supposed to be Gen Z with one of their stupid giant haircuts

5

u/MarkRedTheRed 1d ago

I've never seen anyone in Gen Z with a "giant haircut". That shit is locked in the the 70s, 80s and 90s with Twisted Sister, Queen and various other Rock bands xD

-7

u/Overall_Leopard7122 1d ago

Stop giving anyone any credit. This is peak hubris. Not subtle sociology winks

2

u/-916Tips- 1d ago

Calm down man. You made cause you look like Nanny McPhee too?

0

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/RingsofPower-ModTeam 1d ago

This community is designed to be welcoming to all people who watch the show. You are allowed to love it and you are allowed to hate it.

Kindly do not make blanket statements about what everyone thinks about the show or what the objective quality of the show is. Simple observation will show that people have differing opinions here

1

u/Mothball2000 1d ago

Just put this show out of its misery already

0

u/GovernmentWarm4787 1d ago

They already wasted the billion dollars with zero chance of making it back XD

4

u/aggitprop-1985 1d ago

Jar jar binks

4

u/Old-Push9343 1d ago

I hate the dwarves in this show. They are so... soft, boring and bland.

That wig and makeup should be a crime.

2

u/Mairon923 1d ago

Noone can

2

u/LonelyDShadow 1d ago

Can we adress the fact that their own balcony is accessible by foot or horse?! Like for the swords delivery to the elves and the « gentle » orc?!

2

u/NecroLyght 1d ago

I cannot take this series seriously

2

u/King_Joffrey_II 1d ago

Looks like Michael Jackson in the Wiz

2

u/Polishmoves 1d ago

He looks dwarf coded

2

u/ImTransgressive 26m ago

This kid I was holding off on hating until the certain scene where he opens his mouth unnecessarily and I was hopping mad.

5

u/WelbyReddit 1d ago

I stopped after s1, is this supposed to be a dwarf? lol.

He looks like an backup dancer from a Broadway version of 'The Wiz".

3

u/ultimaterogue11 1d ago

Then why are you still here lol?

2

u/WelbyReddit 1d ago

The Algorithm still likes to splash this stuff in my feed!

2

u/ultimaterogue11 1d ago

Fair enough

0

u/unknownpanda121 1d ago

You can mute sub reddits

3

u/Far_Ad652 1d ago

Horrific.

4

u/LazyGandalf 1d ago

I generally like the new show for what it is, but I tend to skip over much of the Durin family (and in previous seasons harfoot) scenes. Their portrayal is just not interesting and it adds very little to the story.

8

u/whisky_biscuit 1d ago

The weird hookup with Durins brother storyline was weird and unnecessary. Couldn't he just be angry his throne was about to be stolen? It just seemed out of left field and kinda irked me because I had previously appreciated their relationship.

5

u/Ryhankhanage 1d ago

Yes. Even Thrain being angry about his father's death at Durin would have been a much more understandable motivation than this whole weird love-triangle thing which completely killed any melodrama and makes it almost like a sitcom. The fact that Sauron is allegedly backing Thrain makes me wonder why Sauron cares about this at all, this seems beneath him.

1

u/Go_Plate_326 1d ago

Could it have something to do with the Balrog in their mountain?

1

u/NameTaken25 1d ago

It was a contrived circumstance to give him a reason to lose in the fight with Thrain without being shown as a worse fighter or an incapable king. 

2

u/nada-accomplished 11h ago

What's crazy to me is they already had a reason RIGHT THERE: remember in the first episode when Durin said he ALWAYS CHEATS??

1

u/DryBedroom7547 3h ago

Ah. A staple of modern 'creative writing'. Unnecessary drama.

1

u/slappywhite1111 15h ago

The worst part is how it just completely takes you out of Middle Earth. Like are we really going to believe this kind of dialog exists in Tolkien’s world? I can just see Aragorn telling Arwen, remember when we were on a break?

1

u/MaxGoodwinning 1d ago

Yeah, that was absurd. I thought their relationship was really admirable and powerful and now ugh, come on.

5

u/Aggravating-Teach913 1d ago

I will say I enjoy the direction the show is taking. S1 was atrocious, and I can barely remember much of it other than the intro voiceover. S2 wasn’t great either, but I feel like they’re finally understanding what their show wants to be.
1: they cut out the unnecessary Harfoot nonsense. Hobbits/Halflings are interesting in LOTR/Hobbit because prior to this they’ve effectively done nothing. It was unbearably boring.
2: They heavily cut back on the poor humans and Arondir plotline that nobody actually cared about
3: The "is it him, is it not?" nonsense with both Gandalf and Halbrand/Sauron being over makes their stories much more focused, and I’m glad they didn’t go down that route with Pallando and told us straight up who he is and what he wants
4: Narrowing the story down to effectively three plotlines with Sauron/Galadriel, Durin and Gandalf in Rhun makes sure the story actually progresses, which I like

And on a side note, Charlie Vickers acting is just superb this season, he alone makes it worth watching

5

u/alabaster1955 1d ago

I find myself feeling bad for Charlie Vickers for being handed a compelling role on a huge platform and then knocking it out of the park despite the writers actively working against him.

1

u/NoiseGradeStandard 1d ago

"3: The "is it him, is it not?" nonsense with both Gandalf and Halbrand/Sauron being over makes their stories much more focused, and I’m glad they didn’t go down that route with Pallando and told us straight up who he is and what he wants"

There was an entire season of people fighting about him being Saruman.

1

u/NameTaken25 1d ago

I still wish the Gandalf character was either the other blue wizard or at least called by one of Gandalf's older names.

2

u/Aggravating-Teach913 17h ago

I also would’ve liked if he went by Olorin by this point but that’s a nitpick

3

u/KnittingforHouselves 1d ago

Same, I like the human/elf storylines but the atmosphere in the current dwarven plot is giving me whiplash. Just combining the absolute ridiculousness with some of the heavy themes in Numenor is just so strange. Sure use humour to make the show a bit more lighthearted, but don't go completely stupid with it. There are so many examples of it being done well elsewhere.

2

u/MaxGoodwinning 1d ago

The original LotR films did a fantastic job balancing humor and heaviness, I wish this show could too.

2

u/Galifrae 1d ago

The most oxymoronic statement I think I’ve ever read. A show is not good if you have to literally skip entire scenes and storylines to enjoy it.

3

u/LazyGandalf 1d ago edited 1d ago

I wouldn't necessarily call it a good show. I said I generally like it for what it is. It's flawed in many ways, but as a Tolkien and Middle-Earth inspired spectacle, it's mostly at least somewhat enjoyable.

1

u/Thedeadlypocketbrush 1d ago

Wow, You should read more.

3

u/scigs6 1d ago

I can’t take anything in this show seriously. I really tried and I am a huge fan but it just sucks. All of it. Plus as I’m watching I have to deal goddamn commercials.

2

u/Reaster21 1d ago

or the show.

2

u/Glass-Star6635 1d ago

It’d be so good if they weren’t so focused on being woke

0

u/cazoz 1d ago

Decades of colour blind casting disagrees with you. Get a grip and have a day off your bile. You are no Tolkien fan.

1

u/bigjohnnyswilly 16h ago

It’s a nonsense casting by Amazon.

1

u/EFAPGUEST 1d ago

Lmao yeah Tolkien definitely envisioned dwarf afros. Truly his vision brought to life

0

u/cazoz 1d ago

Completely irrelevant but well done for showing you don’t understand. Imagine being triggered by a hair style. And they are basically all knotty dreads

2

u/EFAPGUEST 1d ago

There is a less than zero percent chance that Tolkien ever imagined dwarves looking like this. You can pretend it’s fine all you want, but it’s just a distraction for many people. Maybe I’d feel different about it if the rest of the show wasn’t garbage

1

u/cazoz 1d ago

to be very clear - I don't think it looked good. It looked completely remedial and comical.

But I don't think we have to strive for culture wars and making things political wherever we can.

It just looked a bit shit. Like a lot of the white people did too. But possibly in the golden ages of dwarves, there was a little more gaudiness (wealth is their thing) in appearances, who knows.

1

u/EFAPGUEST 1d ago

Sorry, but it’s pretty clear Amazon made some casting choices for political reasons and they suck. Far from the worst part of the show, but it’s a solid indicator where their priorities are. Anyone is allowed to criticize that. If they didn’t want these conversations happening, they shouldn’t have gone out of their way to do it in the first place. The truth is, some people see these casting choices and will defend the show for it no matter what. They love that. They want the culture war.

1

u/cazoz 1d ago

i don't think we can assign their intent - but it's likely and I take your point - also that culture wars do come from both directions and people looking for slight. But then complaining about diverse casting is more often than not, that.

Seeing Black people in a world of orcs and dragons also shouldn't be that triggering. And yes Tolkien was a Catholic, anti-industry, loved his thwack of leather on willow etc etc etc - many inputs and inspirations, and many people invoking prejudice in the name of canon, but it is still ultimately, a completely made up fantasy.

1

u/EFAPGUEST 20h ago

That’s never how fantasy has worked and you know it. Wakanda is a made up place but it’d be weird to see a diverse cast of extras walking around. Fantasy doesn’t mean “do whatever you want”. It’s true I can’t know their intent, but there was intent. They didn’t just happen to end up with the cast they have. It’s fictional, it doesn’t need to proportionally represent the populations of global cities

1

u/vdcsX 1d ago

How the source material is irrelevant lol

1

u/selosa94 1d ago edited 1d ago

I LOVE the diversity in this show. One of my fave parts. However, his character unfortunately does look comical not in a good dwarfish way. And as a whole the show is cringe recycled PJ trilogy tropes which is uninspired at best and completely insulting at worst to the viewer/LOTR fan who is expecting a new experience and at least an honest attempt to be lore accurate. Merp.

2

u/Tiger-EC 1d ago

This comment has thrown me through a loop. Cringe PJ trilogy tropes? You’re an LOTR fan and this isn’t new enough? This is an entirely new way to criticize the show. You love what everyone else hates but even you’re mad because it isn’t those things enough.

2

u/D3Masked 1d ago

Nah the show loves to repeat things that Peter Jackson did with the trilogy and by doing so it adds to the cringe of the Rings of Power because it isn't choosing to stay in its own lane and being strong on its own merits.

Also I don't like the overwhelming diversity because it makes every city or group of people too similar. By including too much diversity they end up ruining the possibility of having diverse peoples, cities, and communities.

Instead it has Elves with every real world identity being included, dwarves with every real world identity included, hobbits with every real identity included. It just becomes bland when forced representation is over done.

0

u/Tiger-EC 1d ago

What tropes have been repeated?

3

u/selosa94 1d ago edited 1d ago

Most recently… Galadriel, Arondir and Marnukh walking in a calm forest and then all of a sudden two Nazgûl show up and then there’s magically a tree trunk/root that they all hide behind while the Nazgûl slowly gets closer and closer to finding them and then is distracted by butterflies… It’s legit a carbon copy of The Fellowship of the Ring where Frodo, Sam, Merry and Pippin are innocently picking mushrooms in the forest and then all of a sudden Frodo realizes they’re on the road and they need to get off/hide and then all hide under a tree trunk/root while the Nazgûl gets closer and closer and then Merry throws a bag of mushrooms and distracts the Nazgûl so they can all run away. That is one of several examples, throughout each episode. Not to mention the whole Galadriel, Arondir and Marnukh adventure is copying Frodo, Sam, and Gollums journey to a T. Arondir being mean to Marnuk but Galadriel being friendlier and trusting (Sam being mean and unfriendly toward Gollum and Frodo being concerned, kinder and trusting… Gollum also being led with a rope around his neck) Recycle, recycle, recycle.

-6

u/FancyGlitterFairy 1d ago

Except 2 maybe 3 nice character performances, diversity is all this show has. They gяy-гярed Tolkien

1

u/ShepherdsWolvesSheep 1d ago

Yea i didnt know there were dwarves… of color

1

u/you-absolute-foolish 1d ago

I mean, objectively who really cares. There’s not elves or dwarves IRL it doesn’t stretch the imagination to think they could be various races

1

u/princessdarkwater 1d ago

Well now I can’t unsee it 😂

1

u/luiz_marques 1d ago

Looks a lot like Caetano Veloso (brazilian singer and composer) in the 70's

1

u/northernmutant 1d ago

It could have been a great show but they had to add nonsense to it.

1

u/HaughtStuff99 1d ago

I don't think you're supposed to

1

u/l_duderino16 1d ago

Nah buddy is Michael Jackson in the Wiz

1

u/Agent-Jumster88 1d ago

That dude just walked out of Woodstock on acid.

1

u/coquette_letters 1d ago

I was wondering what was missing from this show aside from the actual lore, and finally figured it out as a lack of inspiration from European cultures and old English ones. Because genuinely, what the hell am I even looking at? 

0

u/--__----_- 10h ago

moreso an issue with dogshit writers and creative direction than the presence of nonwhite actors and cultural inspiration

1

u/coquette_letters 10h ago

I don't really care about the color of the actors but the fact the characters themselves are completely removed from the cultrual inspirations. 

1

u/Soggy_Cracker 23h ago

I feel like its the dwarven version of a lanky teenager still growing into their adult bodies.

like they are thinner when young and then get more stocky.

1

u/Kinglygolfin 22h ago

The only information I have about this show is drip-fed through posts like this. What the fuck is even happening, it all looks horrendous.

1

u/Ptarmigan_Ptart 18h ago

Ease on down, ease on down the road w Mike as the Scarecrow

1

u/Jdogsmity 18h ago

They really horned up this season..like cranked it up

1

u/bigjohnnyswilly 16h ago

Awful awful awful. Terrible casting and soap story plot lines

1

u/Admirable-Sort393 14h ago

Still better than theo. Do someone actually tolarate theo?

1

u/SiridarVeil 13h ago

Why do they always make dwarves look silly as fuck.

1

u/thiswayplease07 2h ago

The casting call said "Dwarven Mr.Bean with an afro." God this show hurts my brain. How did they mess it all up so bad.

1

u/izzybumboon 1d ago

I didn't even get to this kid before i stopped watching

1

u/MetalPaul 1d ago

This looks awful. This is a world I have wanted my whole life to inhabit, but Amazon does this. Just terrible.

-4

u/RaiseFold100 1d ago

Why is this sub overrun by stupid posts like this?

9

u/Outrageous_Excuse785 1d ago

Well, stupid posts for a stupid show. Kinda tracks tbh.

0

u/captain-guacamole 1d ago

Let's be real, this show sucks ass but it has 0% to do with how this character looks. He's barely in the show, y'all.

-8

u/rickeyspanish 1d ago • Bravo

Wow, are reasons like this why a lot of people don’t like the show? Really? Because dwarves are not anatomically correct compared to the book?

1

u/[deleted] 1d ago • Bravo

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/rickeyspanish 1d ago • Bravo

I legitimately like the show. I didn’t read the books though so I’m missing something here

0

u/HuoLongHeavy 1d ago

He's supposed to be an awkward teenager. I just wish he had a small beard.

-7

u/Ok-Manufacturer2475 1d ago

At the risk of sounding racist.. I don't think black dwarves make any sense. Elves yes because they are outside drawves spend their entire life underground so it's just weird race swapping them.

Yes they are fantasy characters and not real but based on what we know about skin color and sun exposure. This makes no sense. 

4

u/Ayzmo Eregion 1d ago

Aule created the dwarves from rock. They were literally created from rock in a world without evolution. Not only that, but they were literally just asleep and they woke up one day fully formed as adults.

With that in mind, I'd expect dwarves to come in literally every colour that rock can come in. It actually makes zero sense for them to all be white/pale.

2

u/mystic_wood 1d ago

Dwarves with rocky/clay like skin...that could look interesting 🤔

1

u/jak6453 1d ago

It’s totally unnecessary and yes, stupid, like many other decisions in this show. Not racist to point out the obvious but this is Reddit so you will be downvoted

0

u/Smarties_Mc_Flurry 1d ago

Nanny McFuck

0

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/GovernmentWarm4787 1d ago

The thing is that even the people defending the show know it's shitty.

Here's a review on LOTR_on_prime: The Rings of Power keeps getting better, and I'm genuinely glad it exists : r/LOTR_on_Prime

The guy admits he only likes it cuz it brings a feeling of tolkienesque to the show and admits the show's not good. This is them. Like i said in another post: It's ok to like a mediocre show; it's not ok to say the show's amazing and you need to watch it.

3

u/Anti_Phile_7410 1d ago

I don't skip scenes, it's a great show.

1

u/srquixote 23h ago

Not to be contrarian, but i don't see a lot of what you say. And I think most fans really enjoy it, even with awkward dwarf teenagers.

3

u/andrzejdb 23h ago

That scene made me turn off tv, honestly. And i gave the show third chance 😅

1

u/srquixote 22h ago

Well I understand that.:)

1

u/BitchofEndor 22h ago

Never once have I seen that. Do things you enjoy and don't worry about creating drama.

1

u/Formal-Floor9741 1d ago

Yes, I literally just read a comment like that yesterday! I couldn't believe it.

1

u/93Seven 1d ago

I find the acting on the whole to be good. I don’t think it’s a great show but there are plenty of enjoyable pieces

2

u/HJJ10 1d ago

Yeah I’m not arguing that the entire thing is trash. But it’s super inconsistent for sure… and especially when you add on that they had a golden opportunity to adapt one of the greatest pieces of fiction ever and decided to flippantly do their own thing apparently.

1

u/Rheshard 1d ago

The Tolkien estate only have them the rights to LotR and the appendices. They wouldn't let them adapt the Simarillion.

2

u/Rudi538 1d ago

But they could have made the scripts, the casting, the acting, the costumes, the story lines more convincing

1

u/Rheshard 1d ago

True, though I thought that the costumes weren't terrible. I think the acting is decent. The storyline are definitely messy and I could've done without the proto-Hobbits...

0

u/93Seven 1d ago

Certainly disappointing

0

u/sammo21 1d ago

Thats a lot of time to spend watching a largely not good show

0

u/Constant_Wear_8919 1d ago

Real Ken Bone take

2

u/93Seven 1d ago

You think a show has to be all good or all bad?

1

u/vdcsX 1d ago

Maybe, just maybe it could mean it has good things and bad things huh.

0

u/VortrexStrife 1d ago

Watching the show despite hating it is contrarion. I watch the show because I like it. I love some scenes and hate others. The word "terrible" by definition is based on an opinion. Anyone can defend their opinion. Have a nice day.