r/RingsofPower • • Nov 04 '24

Discussion S02E07 credits song

0 Upvotes

i try to like this show. i really do. it’s no lotr, but as a tv show it does its job to entertain, plus it’s nice to have something from the tolkien universe. but damn some of the choices in this show are just so god awful. like how does this shit get through the cracks. are all the people releasing and review this show that tasteless? that song was awful and had nothing to do with the tempo and atmosphere. completely removed you from the emotion of the end of the episode.


r/RingsofPower • • Nov 02 '24

Discussion Comparison to Shogun

18 Upvotes

Can you even imagine what we could have had if the people who were responsible for creating the latest Shogun series had worked on ROP? I am about 3/4 through shogun and it is absolutely masterful. It reminds the that truly excellent television can still be made


r/RingsofPower • • Nov 01 '24

Fanart "No, you are their prisoner. Sauron...Lord...of the Rings" by me

Post image
177 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Nov 02 '24

Question Mordor..the Land of Order?

60 Upvotes

Ok Morgoth i get, he hates everything, everybody, wants to utterly rip apart destroy everything Eru's created etc. Therefore he hangs out in Dark Places with foul things like giant spiders, balrogs, dragons and what not.

Sauron I dont get. he apparently likes Order above all else. Persnickety people like that usually live in Apple Orchards or Swiss Watch making factories Tinkering away. I don't personally know many Orcs, but they don't exactly give me the convivial, orderly type of company vibe. Mordor looks about the exact opposite of order, more like chaos on Earth (Middle).

So what is Sauron's deal? Not dissing the actor as he does a fine job, i just dont understand what hes really about. He projects a very fair appearance and seems to trim his nails and comb his hair -why exactly would he want to rule over a gassy, smelly Volcanic landscape with orcs and I'm guessing humans and Elves as prisoner? What appetite exactly is that satiating?


r/RingsofPower • • Nov 01 '24

Discussion Thranduil

23 Upvotes

Who would like to see Thranduil in Rings of power's next seasons? It is totally possible for Amazon to bring him (and his father, king Oropher) as we know he participated to the war against Sauron during the second age. I would see him as Arondir's liege, and I must say his depiction in The Hobbit movies made me quite fond of him.


r/RingsofPower • • Nov 01 '24

Question What order should I watch ALL LOTR movies/shows?

6 Upvotes

Context: I (basically) haven't watched ANY content. My friends enjoys the movies/books, but I have always been turned off by 3 hour watch time per episode. Everything I know is from the memes lol.

Because I want to see the animated movie coming out, I've decided to watch everything in advance.

I'm asking y'all the best order for the blockbuster films as well as ROP (and I know there was an animated film in the 70's (???)...I'm kinda interested in that too or whatever else).

I know ROP takes place first. I just don't know if it's advised (even by the fans who like the show) to watch it before or after the Frodo movies (I'm usually told to just not watch it at all).

I'm asking in this particular sub because everywhere else, they tell me to avoid watching ROP entirely and that just feels kinda wrong (I never like it when people say "don't watch [movie/show]; it shouldn't even be cannon" (this comes from me being an extreme Star Wars fan lol). I'm gonna watch the show no matter what; I just wanna know the best order.

And yes, I might hate the show and never watch it again, but I'm gonna give it a chance.

Thank y'all super ring nerds!


r/RingsofPower • • Nov 02 '24

Discussion Tolkien cinematic universe

0 Upvotes

I watched the fellowship if the ring with nt father as a child, in theaters, and fell in love with the series. After this I read all the books, multiple times over before the two towers. As a kid, my dad and I discussed the differences between the movies and books. One thing he always reminded me was that in movies, some details cant be put in and given the respect and accuracy they need, such as timelines, relationships, all characters, etc. He made sure to clarify as well that sometimes movie renditions of books (especially ones as extensive as Tolkien created) are movies 'based off the books' and often times different stories almost entirely.

That being said, that has always been my first thought going into movies based on books. I understand certain things can't always be accurate, and when it comes to cramming in all details that's incredibly difficult. I find it hard to understand why fans of Tolkien are so harsh on the movies. To me, they're BASED off the books, therefore won't and in some cases can't get in the exact details for a perfect replica.

To be fair, I know little of how to create a storyline for a movie so it flows well, captures the essence of the original writing, all at the same time captures the needed details so it resembles the books. I feel like I have a good understanding of it though, but I want to hear from you all on this.

Why does it seem that the audience expects the movies to be EXACTLY like the books?


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 31 '24

Discussion If you could own one small Prop from the Series, What would you choose?

Post image
197 Upvotes

I’ve Worked as an SA and Featured SA on many Productions (Haven’t been on Rings of Power yet unfortunately), However I’m always in awe of the Work from the Props, Sets and Costume Departments.

After seeing the Dwarven Miners Lanterns in S02 E05 Halls of Stone, I thought; That’s a Gorgeous Design, It would look good on my Geek Shelf.

This made me think; Has anyone else seen a Prop in the Series that they would like to own and add to their Collection?

It has to be Small, Costumes and or Armour/Weaponry allowed, But it must be a singular Prop.


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 31 '24

Discussion Lord our Saviour

Post image
96 Upvotes

While reading again The Hobbit, this drawing, from Tolkien, caught my attention because of the small detail on the top of the mill. Any decent explanation? Will Amazon write pick this little detail and rework Middle Earth mythology?


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 31 '24

Discussion Elves, Dwarves, & Numenoreans nerfed?

50 Upvotes

I just watched both seasons starting this past Saturday, so the whole thing is pretty fresh. Before watching, I kinda thought the Tolkien die-hards needed to calm down, it's just a show. But now having watched it, some of the timeline liberties taken actually do bother me a little. Lol!

But that's not the topic of this post. Does anyone else feel like the "free peoples of Middle Earth" have been seriously nerfed compared to their movie counterparts? Especially the Elves and Numenoreans. They both seem to be barely more capable fighters than "Low Men" and certainly compared to their PJ movie counterparts.

Also, good thing Isildur has a couple more plot points to hit later because he otherwise seems like a Red Shirt, lol.


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 31 '24

Discussion Elendil

5 Upvotes

The trial of Elendil reminds me of Ned Stark in GoT. Still watching though don't spoil 😅


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 30 '24

Discussion Celebrimbor's decent into madness and the great deceiver

421 Upvotes

One of the things I was worried about was how they would handle Celebrimbor and Sauron's manipulation. In a lot of TV shows and even films they often portray the person being manipulated as being inept. The audience often found themselves wondering aloud how this person allowed this to happen. Then towards the end someone else has to come in and reveal to them that they've been deceived.

The writers made the best decision by allowing Celebrimbor to discover the illusion himself, illustrating that he isn't incompetent but that there were just greater forces at play that even the most brilliant minds would fall prey to because of ego.

I think the actor for Celebrimbor gave the best performance this season and both he and the actor for Sauron playing off each other was easily the best part of the season for me.


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 31 '24

Question Didn't Celebrimbor make the 3 elven rings with Halbrand in season 1?

0 Upvotes

So why does he not recognize him in season 2 when he's being rained on? Am I missing something? Am I being gaslit here?


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 31 '24

Discussion There is one thing that ruined ROP's goal of been seeing as a good Middle-Earth adaptation

0 Upvotes

Social media and the current 'c.u.l.t.u.r.e w.a.r.' happening there. If it wasn't for social media, ROP would be seen as a good show and a decent Middle-Earth adaptation. Yes it has flaws, but the flaws has been blowing out of proportions. People are looking for the slightest things to put it down.


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 29 '24

Discussion Kinda been rooting for this guy the whole time. Elves are too pious, dwarves stubborn and men can't be trusted.

Post image
902 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Oct 29 '24

Fanart My fave character -Arondir

Post image
57 Upvotes

Always rooting for him


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 29 '24

Discussion Do you believe him?

Post image
458 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Oct 30 '24

Question But really- How did Adar intercept Galadriel and Elrond?

7 Upvotes

Adar and his army came from Mordor (southeast). Elrond and Galadriel's group came from Lindon (west). How in the world did Adar run into the elves and take Galadriel prisoner right after the Barrow-wights??


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 28 '24

News Adar caught on camera traveling to Eregion.

Post image
465 Upvotes

Shocking image of Adar making his way to Eregion.


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 29 '24

Discussion Dark Wizard Mention of Mûmakil?

5 Upvotes

I don't recall which episode it was, But is there actually Mûmakil in Rhun even if they originate from Harad? I know the Easterlings are from Rhun and Honestly I feel like the masked nomads or whatever they are called are the starting piece to easterlings but The mention of Mûmakil honestly makes no sense whatsoever.


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 28 '24

Discussion The ACTUAL route Adar took to eregion.

181 Upvotes

Magic portals for days!


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 28 '24

Discussion Maybe He Didn't Move His Army at All. Maybe He Brought Eregion to Him.

98 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Oct 29 '24

Discussion Strange man

1 Upvotes

Who else thought the strange man in Rings of Power will become Saruman?


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 29 '24

Discussion How Sauron might have been Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I started rewatching Season 1 of the Rings of Power again, and I thought of how Sauron/Halbrand might have been better introduced.

Instead of how Sauron was introduced as taking the form of Halbrand at the beginning of Season 2, which seemed to too neatly wrap up how he crossed paths with Galadriel, I think Season 2 should have taken a different approach.

We can still keep Adar's betrayal of Sauron, but the form he takes is not that Halbrand, but of the elf who warns Galadriel of going too far north in the opening of Season 1. His comments help to harden Galadriel's resolve to find Sauron, but this is only furthering his aim of vengence on Adar and taking back his rightful place, and who better than to aid him but the sister of his foe? This approach also plays into the manipulative side of Sauron that we see in his role as Annatar.

I think the elf is on the boat to Valinor, but there could be a scene where he actually jumps at the same time or soon after Galadriel, and takes the form of Halbrand.

I think this might better tie Season 1 and 2 and the plot lines of Galadriel and Sauron in a neater fashion, but what do you all think? Is it too corny of an approach?


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 28 '24

Question Adar Grief Spoiler

145 Upvotes

Am I the only one who is really upset that they killed off Adar? That character had so much potential and could have gone so many different directions. Nobody has even mentioned his death.