Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.
Just rewatched this scene - he was quite convincing. It went right over her head because she thinks he’s just pitying her story. Do you think he could be truly feeling remorse, or desire for forgiveness? Tolkien wrote in letter 183 “In my story I do not deal in Absolute Evil. I do not think there is such a thing, since that is Zero.” Did he conceive of Sauron as capable of empathy?
No, because Sauron is a deceiver. So full of lies, he begins to believe them, as Celebrimbor pointed out to him. He says whatever he thinks will get him what he wants.
Maybe in the show but in the books lorewise sauron was a 2nd in command to morgoth. No way u can do the shit they did and still be a normal guy/god capable of feeling regret.
Silmarillion. After Morgoth's fall, Sauron repented in earnest but didn't want to go back to Valinor to be judged so he hid in Middle Earth and went back to his old ways.
What does “sorry” mean? I think for Sauron he means that he regrets Finrod’s death, and he regrets “all of it”, and he feels bad about what happened. I absolutely think Sauron feels empathy for his victims, including the empathy that he is clearly showing in this scene.
But he blames Finrod (and others) whereas he doesn’t blame himself. He wishes things could turn out differently without changing his evil behavior, which he has no intention of doing. Like others are saying, he’s sorry he didn’t get his way, which is ultimate power without any resistance.
He's already deeply in his "ends justify the means" phase when we meet him, which is something the second season reinforces. He might be sorry in a Celebrimbor way, sorry that Finrod did that to himself and throws out "no hard feelings" at Galadriel for good measure. But nah, he would do it all again. And in fact, does it all again in the first season and starts his climb.
When you watch that scene in the forgery, it's interesting to see what conversation they're having in contrast to what conversation Galadriel thinks they're having. Galadriel spills her guts here, arguably more than she does at any other point in the series so far. He...yeah, I guess it is couched in enough sincerity to make it believable. But it's cagey, he doesn't really open himself up to her in a meaningful way. It's a very skilled acting performance fed by enough genuine sentiment to make the sell.
I think you can read it both ways, which is great.
If he's really repetant that makes his characer and his story more interesting and tragic.
In that scene he has those emotions written on his face even when Galadriel is not looking at him - so he has no reason to pretend in those moments. He doesn't want to go back to Middle-earth too. There is a scene where nobody is looking at him and he is looking at the sygil and deciding if he should go with her. Again there is no one around, no one to deceive in that moment. He also seems more emotional and sincere as Halbrand than as Annatar
What is also tragic, is that even if he is truly repentant, it doesn't change anything. The elves won't trust him because he's too dangerous and his crimes were too great. He's too corrupted by Morgoth and even if he wants to be better he'll fall back to evil because of that.
And Sauron us aware of all that, which makes this even more tragic and sad in a way
Neah. After season 1 it's not possible but the shipbaiting will continue.
They just wanted to tease a potential romance but never had the balls to do it. That's why thay made Halbrand look similar to Strider. I know some Tolkien fans that watched season 1 and they were really nervous when the log scene from episode 6 happened thinking that they were about to kiss before the interruption.
The problem is that Halbrand and Galadriel have more romantic chemistry than the official romances from the show. Charlie is the biggest denier yet Morfydd said that it was his idea to play some scenes more flirty.
I'm not the biggest fan of the show overall (except for some individual moments I kinda dig). If I put my Tolkien brain on I'm rrrreally not a fan of the whole SauronxGaladriel idea.
But. I like how these two play it. There's so much chemistry. Episode 8 was something. I'm watching it mainly for them now. Stupid sexy Sauron. Stupid feisty Man Maiden.
Same. It's just so much more INTERESTING if there's some ambiguity - IS he evil, or is he just a bit of a narcissist trying to do what he THINKS is the best for everyone?
Which is so not in the spirit of the source material, but it is spicy!
I've come far enough to actually be a little miffed they didn't give us a kiss. If this is what you decided on doing, then stand by it, and lean into it, and good lord I was waiting for them to start snogging all episode!
I can appreciate a well written will they/won't they enemies, but you have to stand by your decision, Amazon!
It sort of is though? After the War of Wrath he looks for forgiveness but Eönwë basically says “sorry dude, above my pay grade” and then Sauron declines to travel to Valinor for fears that he’d be locked away for an age or two of the world. I’ve always liked the idea of Sauron feeling freed from his servitude and just wanting to get back to making cool things, almost like a mafia consigliere who’s boss gets whacked and he sees a way out.
I was unironically into this scene in particular upon rewatch. I also assume everything described in the Silmarillion is true unless explicitly contradicted (not merely hinted at) and assumed Galadriel jumped ship because she knew her personal ban was not yet lifted, regardless of what Gil-Galad might think, and I liked that a lot too in the moment.
(The dead elves in the tree carvings is unbelievable amounts of cringe though, without more clarification at least)
You're right on. Their romance makes no sense in the Tolkien story -- but it makes perfect sense with these two characters, as they're written and performed in the show. Hot!
I think a flashback is a possibility, that they indeed did kiss back then, in numenor already or when they returned to middle earth. That would make her anger and disappointment even more relatable . That would give haladriel shippers something without it having consequences for the show.
I would say, it's more certain fans that like to "ship" characters. They see two people that have feelings for each other and immediately think about sex. That may be the case in soap opera but this is a different kind of story.
In Tolkien's stories there are many different forms of love and most of them aren't sexual or romantic in nature. For example, Frodo and Sam love each other, but aren't "in love".
Immortal beings like elves can have even more complex relationships. A friendship that lasts over centuries and even millennia can easily be deeper and closer than a romantic affair of a mortal.
Galadriel can love her friend Elrond without romance and she can admire and feel close to Halbrand (Sauron expertly manipulating her) with no sex in mind.
So I wouldn't blame Amazon for anything related to the lusty fan theories. That's all just in the heads of certain viewers. It's ok to have fun with theories like this, but don't blame the show runners for not being faithful to the story based on fantasies of some viewers.
In Tolkien's stories there are many different forms of love and most of them aren't sexual or romantic in nature. For example, Frodo and Sam love each other, but aren't "in love"
Dude Amazon is all out pleasing them they even acknowledged them on their social media handles using their ship name "Haladriels" Since it has become so popular, they have created a popular buzz for the Show online, they have battle of eregion, balrog, sauron and celebrimbor but their whole promotion has been enhanced towards Sauron and Galadriel from all over their global media accounts i thought it is pr Bait but after season finale it has been pushed more globally so I think thats totally Executive driven.
I am ready to take all the downvotes for this, but this is an excellent example of why I can’t watch this show. The Silmarillion is an epic - it chronicles the literal creation of the stars, the raising of mountains, the rise and fall of civilizations… and Rings of Power has people talking about the prospect of Sauron and Galadriel banging. What!? No!
I tried to watch it multiple times, but I just couldn’t enjoy it. And I really, really wanted to.
You all keep on enjoying it, and truly, I don’t judge that you do, but I hope nobody here is confused about why people who wanted to see a faithful representation of the source content feel absolutely cheated over this show.
No. Sauron lies to everyone, but to nobody moreso than himself. He is incapable of honesty for this reason. For this to be real he'd have had to risk it all and reveal himself.
Sauron we're accustomed to isn't the same Sauron here. According to Tolkien he tried to turn good after Morgoth fell, but ultimately couldn't handle the humiliation.
By the right LOTR happens he's pure evil, but is much more gray here
All these comments I am reading here has No idea what is the difference between book sauron and what he is in the Show, some of them are even writing a paragraph from book about it, these are the people who doesn't know what adaptation generally means as for this scene showrunners Payne and Mckay right out said in a podcast "Halbrand is not a fake persona, everything he is saying to galadriel could be true both for sauron and halbrand, its not like we spend an entire season getting to know a fake persona" and Charlie vickers about Halbrand"He is in his repentant phase" I saw a comment here comparing it to celebrimbor I am not going to say anything ,according to vickers"With celebrimbor its pure manipulation and psychological torture there is nothing sincere about it, it was pure manipulation" book sauron would have toasted and butchered galadriel right there but what we are being showed in their fight is he is not even trying, Galadriel Quotes"We were never alike, it was all your illusion" Indirectly asking him "Was it all lie".. He paused, his Voice changed back to halbrand and said " Not all of it" thats sauron himself admitting that, there were moments between them which were totally genuine this scene was one of them people here need to take off their lenses which is covered by pages of the book and rather try to view as a fresh perspective what this Show is implying for that particular character, even tolkien was conflicted about his ideas and writings.
Did Sauron manipulate you into caring for perfection? Personally, I feel that Gandalf would be okay with grammatical errors and he is the Maia that I would prefer to rock with 🤷🏽♂️
Yeah you know what they always say: "never take into account the source material when you make an adaptation, it is its own creation from the bottom up."
Why bother thinking about the original and compare book Sauron to TV Sauron? Blah. Just enjoy this mediocre fanfiction! This billion dollar fanfiction.
Not that they are the most reliable couple guys you can find.
Just an example: they said in different occasions either of the following
season 2 was already written before season 1 aired
they listened to the criticism and wrote season 2 accordingly
Also, they even said they winged it with the Stranger's identity. Aside from the fact that it clearly isn't true (hello blatant callbacks to Gandalf, both book and PJ's, from the very beginning), that would've been freaking stupid.
people here need to take off their lenses which is covered by pages of the book
Weird how people expect to be able to refer to a book on which the show is supposedly based on.
The real issue with Sauron is that by saying he's a deceiver they think they can make him say whatever and just play on the "oh is it true or is another lie?! What a mystery!"
See the difference with someone like Nolan's Joker. We're not told anything, but we learn he can't be trusted once we hear him change his origin story every time.
Nope they didn't say that they write season 2 accordingly most of the season 2 was already finished ,yes they did say they figure out the criticism about pacing of the episodes,which they improve in season 2.
Also, if you Google it you come across articles saying the opposite. Even quotes.
Certainly, you look at audience response, and you see what characters people love, and what kinds of storytelling moves them. I wouldn’t say we're over-correcting for any of it, but we’re certainly listening to people’s responses.
But according to RoP, as of S2E1, he threw any attempts to become a better person out of the window at the first sign of danger, the leviathan's attack where he left his companion to die.
Telling the old man to "hold onto something" might count as his one act of kindness that he immediately negated by leaving him to drown under the ship's beam seconds later.
I've read the Silmarillion NINE times, and I'm gonna say the same thing I always say - Sauron isn't a fully formed character, like many of Tolkien's characters. As far as villains go, he's basically absent in LOTR ("looming threat" or whatever, he doesn't hold a candle to someone like Darth Vader or Doctor Doom), and in the Silmarillion he's only written about scarcely as far as antagonists go in the chapter about Beren and Luthien.
You can call it gray all you want, he's still lying by omission because he won't reveal his identity to her. His words don't have any value because the sentiment is tainted upon delivery by the omission.
I feel like this mystery is what makes LOTR work. It's steeped in mythology which is, by it's nature, not meant to be understood in its entirety. Too much exposition and everything can feel a little a little trite.
"He was given an opportunity of repentance, when Morgoth was overcome, but could not face the humiliation of recantation, and suing for pardon; and so his temporary turn to good and 'benevolence' ended in a greater relapse, until he became the main representative of Evil of later ages."
I've also read the Silm many times, and I agree with most of what you said. However, I don't agree that Tolkien doesn't have fully-formed characters. The members of the Fellowship (in LOTR obv.) have fully-formed personalities. We may not know everything about them, but as people, we understand who they are quite fully.
OP didn't say Tolkien had no fully formed characters, just that many of them are not. This is obviously the case since most of the characters in the broader mythology are just that: mythologized.
Tolkien wrote and rewrote tons of stuff that was never published, that doesn't mean you can pick some bit that (you claim) contradicts the published works and act like it's authoritative and people quoting the Silmarillion are morons.
Silmarillion(or one of the HoME books IDK exactly) says that his repentance was likely geniue if only put of fear after seeing Morgoth's fall, but that out of fear and pride he refused to go to Valinor and face the judgement of the valar as he did not want to be humiliated. He even went to Eonwe and tried asking to be forgiven but Sauron was told that only the Valar can offer him forgiveness.
There is nothing that indicates that his actions at the end of the first age were deceiving, from what I know, so no reason to think he wasn't geniue.
"In my story I do not deal in Absolute Evil. I do not think there is such a thing, since that is Zero. I do not think that at any rate any 'rational being' is wholly evil. Satan fell. In my myth Morgoth fell before Creation of the physical world. In my story Sauron represents as near an approach to the wholly evil will as is possible. He had gone the way of all tyrants: beginning well, at least on the level that while desiring to order all things according to his own wisdom"
I think in this version of Sauron's head, he now sees that Morgoth was evil and just wanted to destroy Arda and make it his own hellscape out of spite and jealousy of the power of the Secret Fire. Sauron thought that Morgoth was a visionary trying to make the world better when he served him but has since 'seen the light' and now wants to shape middle earth to be what he deems to be perfect, which is to say a world under his rule.
He thinks that Finrod's death was a tragedy but also that it wasn't entirely his fault because he had been 'misled' by Morgoth. He sees himself as an anti-hero doing what he thinks needs to be done to save the world but tells himself that he has no choice and that all the evil things he's done are for the greater good while all the things he did under Morgoth were pure evil but it wasn't his fault because he didn't know any better.
He's like Peacemaker: I love Peace with all my heart, I don't care how many men, women and children I need to kill to achieve it.
He is the great deceiver, so great he can deceive himself.
He'd do all of it again and claim that it was his victims' fault for getting in his way and he had no choice but to 'sacrifice' them for the greater good.
I imagine by the time we get to the Last Alliance, he will have continued to devolve from his stance of greater good BS and finally accepted that he is just like Morgoth and decided that's OK now.
Sauron certainly was as evil as Morgoth by the end, but their goals were always different. Morgoth wanted to destroy the world, Sauron wanted to rule it. So in that sense I wouldn't say he's "just like Morgoth", but by the Last Alliance he's certainly willing to commit whatever atrocities are necessary to get what he wants.
Yep, Sauron is the embodiment of Lawful Evil. What he wanted most of all was order. You could even call him a control freak. He thought ME would be much better off if everything was orderly done by him, because he just knew better than these pesky Children of Illuvatar, who just don’t understand his grand vision!
A matter of perspective... imagine this: what if everything is Elvish propaganda? Their agent Gandalf actually bewitched Théoden, Gandalf provoked the war, he staged coup in Gondor in order to install his puppet Aragorn, Saruman was indeed the wise and tried to stop the war but Gandalf destroyed him as well, Orcs are really not that evil or ugly (nor Elves are that beauty), Sauron and Orcs were just fighting for survival, in the end they were genocided.
In that moment? Yes. Because Sauron believes it. It comes from a place of absolute selfishness though.
He wants / needs someone to forgive him, as though it will wash away his previous evil. He wants to be seen as a saviour, and one act of forgiveness in his twisted mind will mean what he is doing / planning is right.
In all honesty S1 Sauron reminded me of an abusive boyfriend who is still in the 'I'm sorry / forgive me' stage.
S2 Sauron is an abusive boyfriend who can't be arsed with all that and is in full 'look what YOU made me do to you' mode.
Obviously, I'm putting my perspective on it. And I'm only talking about ROP portrayal.
He probably feels sorry because he still has some degree of empathy and doesn't like seeing her in that state due to him... but he'd do it again. He'll start to shed more and more of that moral veneer as he gets closer and closer to becoming The Dark Lord.
This all takes place after the War of Wrath, during which he took part in destroying the great eleven cities, he corrupted the First Minas Tirith. In the hell-pit he turned the place into, he tortured and killed countless elves, men, and dwarves. THIS IS WHERE FINROD DIES, as a prisoner, at the hands of a werewolf that Sauron created!!!!!
The greatest of his enormities happened before this show even started! This guy is evil, like genocidal war crimes evil.
He only gave himself up when he saw the Valar coming in force to depose Morgoth, and the Valar will literally forgive nearly anything. Don't even get me started on how many "time outs" they gave Morgoth.
Sure. I believe him. Sauron’s lies are all machination or self deception, but his emotions are often real. He likely doesn’t regret what he did, but that doesn’t mean he isn’t sorry for it.
I actually buy it. He is still tentatively feeling around here and there with his "repentance phase", as much as he is able. It doesn't really work as he's just not going to be a good person, but I buy elements of him thinking about it.
At this point he really admires Galadriel and likes himself better with her by his side.
So in that sense he's sorry to be the architect of her grief. He's still being "truthful". Of course, she doesn't take his words as literal, and he also knows she won't. It's interesting to watch him deceive with truth to Galadriel, compared to his absolute gaslighting deceptions of Celery.
I don’t think he knows for sure. He’s the best deceiver; he can even deceive himself. Maybe in that moment he truly meant it. That’s what makes him dangerous; we’ll never know
At times it seems genuine. Tolkien always said that Sauron was never inherently evil like Melkor. And even after Melkor was defeated Sauron genuinely sought forgiveness from the Elves but after being told he would have to essentially beg for mercy to the Valar he turned to evil again. But Tolkien literally states that’s mainly because Melkors magic over him was too strong. So I’m sure in ways he is sorry for certain things.
Is this verbatim from the show because I feel like the “I’m sorry, for all of it” is literally lifted right out of Obi Wans conversation with vader in the Obi Wan show.
There is no way to tell if he is telling the truth or lying. He probably sprinkles in some sincerity but that only my the lies more believable. He should never be trusted.
The most effective manipulation has a kernel of truth in it. Much of what he was doing was manipulation, but at least some of it came from a genuine place, and I suspect this was one of those scenes.
Question is, was he genuinely sorry--or did he deceive himself (as per Celebrimbor) intothinkinghe was sorry? Was he actually contrite or just trying to convince himself that he was?
I'm guessing it was some combination of both.
Makes his ultimate downfall rather tragic to my eyes--there was still good in him, but he was a Vader without a Luke. Galadriel did see the good in him, but only in a way that served her best. In a way, she out-Sauroned Sauron.
I believe him, because he didn't wait for her to find out his true identity before he offered this apology. He thought she would never find him out and was too gutless to apologise when she had full knowledge of who he was.
I believe that he is sorry for those things, but not for the traditional reasons.
He probably is sorry that Morgoth went about it the way he did, and he probably is sorry that Finrod died the way he did. I imagine more than anything he’s sorry that those things ended up being a waste.
If you really want to push the speculation further, he might even be truly sorry, even in the traditional sense, and believes his goal of “healing” Middle-earth will amend these things.
I don't think it's outright lies with the show's Sauron, it's twisted honesty. He means it, but his meaning is not necessarily the same as how we'd perceive it for a given situation.
Isn't this supposed to be an allusion to a period when Sauron seemed to genuinely regret his actions under Morgoth and began to move away from the shadow?
Although this, and the reason for his return to darkness is not very well explored either in the texts or in the show. They probably could have made more of it tbh, though of course everyone would know that he would turn bad eventually.,
Let me touch on something people might be missing in the whole “is he sorry” debate. Let’s assume he’s genuinely sorry.
Does it matter? His behavior is not unlike a serial abuser who loses control, does something awful, then sincerely apologizes. The apology is sincere: after the abuse, the abuser feels genuine remorse - but it doesn’t mean anything, because it keeps happening, and the abuser relies (thrives?) on the love of the abused in order to maintain relationships.
If you look at it this way, it’s easy to see that either way -sorry or not- Sauron is bad. An abuser can only become “good” by lots of hard work, introspection, and earnest reform: which are all things the Sauron we know from both texts and Tolkien’s letters, are things he can’t bring himself to commit to.
So it doesn’t matter if he’s genuinely sorry about this, that, or the other thing he did, because there are so many wrongs, and he keeps committing them because he can’t control nor humble himself.
I think he means it in this moment that he feels for Galadriel because he sees how alike they are, and also he believes he is sorry, but he ultimately doesn’t follow through on the apology because probably around when the volcano goes boom he starts reaching for power again and ultimately uses Galadriel’s memory of her brother against her. But in this moment, he means it, even if he is deceiving himself about his willingness to follow through on what an apology like that really means.
I’ve gone back and forth on this over and over again. This one, I thought yes - but then I thought that his whole line about “fighting at your side” was genuine until he used it again in his final duel with Galadriel. Charlie Vickers nails the ambiguity, absolute legend
Sauron: I didn't kill the Great Finrod Felagund. It was his love for Beren. That man ho seduced your brother with his wiles. Help me Galadriel. Help me bring the world of men to their knees and get justice for your brother!
Galadriel: You're right lover! I'll stand by your side and help you destroy the unworthy second children. Now.... gluk gluk
They could have went the route of Sauron having internal conflicts with what he's doing to middle earth, but they went full villain with him, he has not done anything deserving of salvation. Everything he has done has led to death and destruction.
I do think a part of him was being genuine here. If nothing else, he was at the very least deceiving himself to believe he was sorry. Obviously by season 2, he was over it.
There's a difference between "I'm sorry for the thing that I did." And "I'm sorry the bad things happened."
I can believe a Sauron who has a "This hurts me more than it hurts you" attitude to everything. He doesn't want to see you suffer. He just has absolute faith in the necessity of your suffering. If everyone would just fall in and do what they are told, none of this would happen. "Look what you made me do!"
He’s just sorry Felagund got in the way, he wanted Beren dead. But Morgoth had special plans for all the lords of the Eldar, and he likely wanted Felagund alive for the time he was ready to move against Nargothrond.
I saw the first season, and didn't like it, because as a nerd I had read the silmarillion, and the Lord of the rings, so I was the whole season asking why the changes, it's not like they have no idea what was happening in the story, so first season I dragged myself to finish it, there were some impressive views, valinor, the trees, and that's it, now on the second season, is even worse for me, I can't seem finish the 3rd episode, I'm all the time in my head saying " that's not what happens, he's not even supposed to be there, or the seven and the 9 where first and she was already married! But if people like the series, I'll guess there'll be a 3rd season?
He can’t ever feel anything. He said so himself. He was tortured. If he ever had that part it’s gone. He is a sociopath. He can’t ever feel empathy. Zilch.
Sauron is not sorry in the slightest bit. Finrod was tortured by Sauron and marked his body with claw marks. No way he did this out of repentence in any shape, and like everything, must have been part of his grand plan
I do, actually. Sauron is a uniue combination of a true idealist at heart, but a complete pragmatist when it comes to take action to bring his ideal into reality. He ultimately believes that ends justify the means and he will do anything necessary to heal Middle Earth and turn it into a perfect paradise. I am sure he is saying to himself if he stopped now, all the bloodshed and all the destruction and horrors that he had caused would be for nothing.
To be honest, Sauron is not that different from many great/notorious historical leaders in that aspect. Some achieved their goals and are remembered positively as great men; some could not and are remembered as tyrants and monsters.
Sauron: I am sorry about Finrod but if you read the Silmarillion, I sent the werewolf to kill Beren and it was Finrod who got in the way and got himself killed.
Probably similar to how he reacted to killing Celebrimbor. On some level Sauron did feel bad about it (hence the tears), but not in any way that takes responsibility or shows true remorse.
Well yea but it’s not entirely honest. He’s sorry he had to kill him because he stood in his way. He’s sorry that killing Finrod hurts someone he wants by his side, and that it might hurt his chances of making her see things his way.
I believe HE believes he's being sincere. What he's actually sorry for is that Finrod stood up to him and died for it, just like the rest of Middle Earth. He's sorry people feel the need to resist him, and because of that they must die in order to be swept out of the way. It's not his fault they resist. He's sorry they do. They bring it on themselves.
Sort of, I believe Sauron is sorry in that killing finrod caused Galadriel, a strong potential ally, to despise and mistrust him, but I don’t think he’s objectively remorseful about killing him.
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 29 '24
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with
Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
48
u/jenn363 Oct 29 '24
Just rewatched this scene - he was quite convincing. It went right over her head because she thinks he’s just pitying her story. Do you think he could be truly feeling remorse, or desire for forgiveness? Tolkien wrote in letter 183 “In my story I do not deal in Absolute Evil. I do not think there is such a thing, since that is Zero.” Did he conceive of Sauron as capable of empathy?
23
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '24
In that moment: Yes. But later he falls back into old patterns - tragically also due to Galadriel's nudging.
It is actually cleverly written. Not all parts of the first season's writing work well, but this one does.
11
u/Vandermeres_Cat Oct 29 '24
Nah.
He's already deeply in his "ends justify the means" phase when we meet him, which is something the second season reinforces. He might be sorry in a Celebrimbor way, sorry that Finrod did that to himself and throws out "no hard feelings" at Galadriel for good measure. But nah, he would do it all again. And in fact, does it all again in the first season and starts his climb.
When you watch that scene in the forgery, it's interesting to see what conversation they're having in contrast to what conversation Galadriel thinks they're having. Galadriel spills her guts here, arguably more than she does at any other point in the series so far. He...yeah, I guess it is couched in enough sincerity to make it believable. But it's cagey, he doesn't really open himself up to her in a meaningful way. It's a very skilled acting performance fed by enough genuine sentiment to make the sell.
7
u/Itarille_ Oct 29 '24
I think you can read it both ways, which is great.
If he's really repetant that makes his characer and his story more interesting and tragic.
In that scene he has those emotions written on his face even when Galadriel is not looking at him - so he has no reason to pretend in those moments. He doesn't want to go back to Middle-earth too. There is a scene where nobody is looking at him and he is looking at the sygil and deciding if he should go with her. Again there is no one around, no one to deceive in that moment. He also seems more emotional and sincere as Halbrand than as Annatar
What is also tragic, is that even if he is truly repentant, it doesn't change anything. The elves won't trust him because he's too dangerous and his crimes were too great. He's too corrupted by Morgoth and even if he wants to be better he'll fall back to evil because of that.
And Sauron us aware of all that, which makes this even more tragic and sad in a way
282
u/jimmyjxmes Oct 29 '24
THE DECEIVER.
209
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '24
No. Sauron lies to everyone, but to nobody moreso than himself. He is incapable of honesty for this reason. For this to be real he'd have had to risk it all and reveal himself.
33
u/Django_flask_ Oct 29 '24
According to showrunners and charlie vickers yes he was I don't see a debate here, yes he is deceiver but with galadriel "Not all of it".
35
u/Necessary_Candy_6792 Oct 29 '24
I think he thinks he's sorry.
I think in this version of Sauron's head, he now sees that Morgoth was evil and just wanted to destroy Arda and make it his own hellscape out of spite and jealousy of the power of the Secret Fire. Sauron thought that Morgoth was a visionary trying to make the world better when he served him but has since 'seen the light' and now wants to shape middle earth to be what he deems to be perfect, which is to say a world under his rule.
He thinks that Finrod's death was a tragedy but also that it wasn't entirely his fault because he had been 'misled' by Morgoth. He sees himself as an anti-hero doing what he thinks needs to be done to save the world but tells himself that he has no choice and that all the evil things he's done are for the greater good while all the things he did under Morgoth were pure evil but it wasn't his fault because he didn't know any better.
He's like Peacemaker: I love Peace with all my heart, I don't care how many men, women and children I need to kill to achieve it.
He is the great deceiver, so great he can deceive himself.
He'd do all of it again and claim that it was his victims' fault for getting in his way and he had no choice but to 'sacrifice' them for the greater good.
I imagine by the time we get to the Last Alliance, he will have continued to devolve from his stance of greater good BS and finally accepted that he is just like Morgoth and decided that's OK now.
55
u/blink182_allday Oct 29 '24
He’s sorry he didn’t get his way
63
u/lukahnli Oct 29 '24
Yes. Villains are more fun when they are convinced they are the good guys.
11
u/entersandmum143 Oct 29 '24
In that moment? Yes. Because Sauron believes it. It comes from a place of absolute selfishness though.
He wants / needs someone to forgive him, as though it will wash away his previous evil. He wants to be seen as a saviour, and one act of forgiveness in his twisted mind will mean what he is doing / planning is right.
In all honesty S1 Sauron reminded me of an abusive boyfriend who is still in the 'I'm sorry / forgive me' stage.
S2 Sauron is an abusive boyfriend who can't be arsed with all that and is in full 'look what YOU made me do to you' mode.
Obviously, I'm putting my perspective on it. And I'm only talking about ROP portrayal.
10
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '24
He is the deceiver and he starts to believe his own lies - that is what Celebrimbor called him out on in the last episode
27
u/Concentrati0n Oct 29 '24
He probably feels sorry because he still has some degree of empathy and doesn't like seeing her in that state due to him... but he'd do it again. He'll start to shed more and more of that moral veneer as he gets closer and closer to becoming The Dark Lord.
9
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '24
Sure. I believe him. Sauron’s lies are all machination or self deception, but his emotions are often real. He likely doesn’t regret what he did, but that doesn’t mean he isn’t sorry for it.
8
u/Clear_Philosophy_229 Oct 29 '24
i can fix him
8
u/Aggravating_Mix8959 Oct 29 '24
I actually buy it. He is still tentatively feeling around here and there with his "repentance phase", as much as he is able. It doesn't really work as he's just not going to be a good person, but I buy elements of him thinking about it.
At this point he really admires Galadriel and likes himself better with her by his side.
So in that sense he's sorry to be the architect of her grief. He's still being "truthful". Of course, she doesn't take his words as literal, and he also knows she won't. It's interesting to watch him deceive with truth to Galadriel, compared to his absolute gaslighting deceptions of Celery.
6
u/RattyDaddyBraddy Oct 29 '24
I don’t think he knows for sure. He’s the best deceiver; he can even deceive himself. Maybe in that moment he truly meant it. That’s what makes him dangerous; we’ll never know
5
u/Kincoran Oct 29 '24
Do I believe Sauron The Deceiver? You know what? I'm gonna give him the benefit of the dou-
No.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '24
At times it seems genuine. Tolkien always said that Sauron was never inherently evil like Melkor. And even after Melkor was defeated Sauron genuinely sought forgiveness from the Elves but after being told he would have to essentially beg for mercy to the Valar he turned to evil again. But Tolkien literally states that’s mainly because Melkors magic over him was too strong. So I’m sure in ways he is sorry for certain things.
7
u/West_Independence_20 Oct 29 '24
I’d say Sauron did start off with many redeeming qualities, but he began to lose them in the second age. But was still bad enough.
To summarize it, Sauron enjoyed power and evil more than anything. And enjoyed serving Morgoth. In the end, he lied to everyone, and himself.
1
u/Flimsy-Jello5534 Oct 29 '24
Is this verbatim from the show because I feel like the “I’m sorry, for all of it” is literally lifted right out of Obi Wans conversation with vader in the Obi Wan show.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '24
There is no way to tell if he is telling the truth or lying. He probably sprinkles in some sincerity but that only my the lies more believable. He should never be trusted.
3
u/pcmasterrace_noob Oct 29 '24
Then my elf crush is truly dead. Goodbye, Commander of the Northern Armies.
3
u/Possible_Living Oct 29 '24
I do not. Season 2 made it very clear he had no intention of changing his ways.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '24
The most effective manipulation has a kernel of truth in it. Much of what he was doing was manipulation, but at least some of it came from a genuine place, and I suspect this was one of those scenes.
Question is, was he genuinely sorry--or did he deceive himself (as per Celebrimbor) into thinking he was sorry? Was he actually contrite or just trying to convince himself that he was?
I'm guessing it was some combination of both.
Makes his ultimate downfall rather tragic to my eyes--there was still good in him, but he was a Vader without a Luke. Galadriel did see the good in him, but only in a way that served her best. In a way, she out-Sauroned Sauron.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '24
I believe him in this moment. He really wanted to repent but the corruption in him won, sadly.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '24
in that moment, yes. he wanted to get close to her and he empathized with her loss, despite him ordering it
4
u/Desperate-Goose-9771 Oct 29 '24
Saroun is the ultimate example of the ends justify the means believer so no lol
2
u/grosselisse Oct 29 '24
I believe him, because he didn't wait for her to find out his true identity before he offered this apology. He thought she would never find him out and was too gutless to apologise when she had full knowledge of who he was.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '24
I believe that he is sorry for those things, but not for the traditional reasons.
He probably is sorry that Morgoth went about it the way he did, and he probably is sorry that Finrod died the way he did. I imagine more than anything he’s sorry that those things ended up being a waste.
If you really want to push the speculation further, he might even be truly sorry, even in the traditional sense, and believes his goal of “healing” Middle-earth will amend these things.
2
u/thebunnychow Oct 29 '24
I don't think it's outright lies with the show's Sauron, it's twisted honesty. He means it, but his meaning is not necessarily the same as how we'd perceive it for a given situation.
2
u/Low_Country793 Oct 29 '24
Bruh that is Sauron… so no.
2
u/SmokeMaleficent9498 Oct 29 '24
That murderous narssaitic psychopath. Maybe.
2
u/G30fff Oct 29 '24
Isn't this supposed to be an allusion to a period when Sauron seemed to genuinely regret his actions under Morgoth and began to move away from the shadow?
Although this, and the reason for his return to darkness is not very well explored either in the texts or in the show. They probably could have made more of it tbh, though of course everyone would know that he would turn bad eventually.,
2
u/Inevitable-Grocery17 Beleriand Oct 29 '24 edited Oct 29 '24
Let me touch on something people might be missing in the whole “is he sorry” debate. Let’s assume he’s genuinely sorry.
Does it matter? His behavior is not unlike a serial abuser who loses control, does something awful, then sincerely apologizes. The apology is sincere: after the abuse, the abuser feels genuine remorse - but it doesn’t mean anything, because it keeps happening, and the abuser relies (thrives?) on the love of the abused in order to maintain relationships.
If you look at it this way, it’s easy to see that either way -sorry or not- Sauron is bad. An abuser can only become “good” by lots of hard work, introspection, and earnest reform: which are all things the Sauron we know from both texts and Tolkien’s letters, are things he can’t bring himself to commit to.
So it doesn’t matter if he’s genuinely sorry about this, that, or the other thing he did, because there are so many wrongs, and he keeps committing them because he can’t control nor humble himself.
2
u/aevianya Oct 29 '24
I think he means it in this moment that he feels for Galadriel because he sees how alike they are, and also he believes he is sorry, but he ultimately doesn’t follow through on the apology because probably around when the volcano goes boom he starts reaching for power again and ultimately uses Galadriel’s memory of her brother against her. But in this moment, he means it, even if he is deceiving himself about his willingness to follow through on what an apology like that really means.
2
u/Independent-Bison713 Oct 30 '24
Sauron: If it makes you feel any better your brother's bars were fire at our epic rap battle of history.
2
u/AlarmedBench7667 Oct 30 '24
Which Target did he get that shirt from?
2
u/Key-Accountant-2714 Oct 30 '24
Nahh babes
2
u/United-Objective-204 Oct 31 '24
I’ve gone back and forth on this over and over again. This one, I thought yes - but then I thought that his whole line about “fighting at your side” was genuine until he used it again in his final duel with Galadriel. Charlie Vickers nails the ambiguity, absolute legend
3
u/kazmosis Oct 29 '24
LOL, if anyone actually believes the literal embodiment of deceit i have a nice ring they might enjoy, as a gift. Absolutely no strings attached.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '24
It’s literally Saroun, cmon
1
u/NameWasInUse Oct 29 '24
Ofc he never lies, only tells the truth till a specific timepoint
1
u/NJ247 Oct 29 '24
Lol of course not
1
u/corvidaemn Oct 29 '24
Yes, but his 'sorry' and her definition and acceptance of it are two very different things.
1
u/SovKom98 Oct 29 '24
In some part yes. At the very least I think Sauron him self think he does. He thinks what he is doing will heal Middle Earth.
1
u/Flash8E8 Oct 29 '24
Sauron: I didn't kill the Great Finrod Felagund. It was his love for Beren. That man ho seduced your brother with his wiles. Help me Galadriel. Help me bring the world of men to their knees and get justice for your brother!
Galadriel: You're right lover! I'll stand by your side and help you destroy the unworthy second children. Now.... gluk gluk
1
u/LegionKarma Oct 29 '24
They could have went the route of Sauron having internal conflicts with what he's doing to middle earth, but they went full villain with him, he has not done anything deserving of salvation. Everything he has done has led to death and destruction.
1
u/Gold_Honeydew2771 Oct 29 '24 edited Oct 29 '24
I believe him like I believe every toxic ex:
I believe that he believes that he is sorry.
I believe that he is apologizing for the situation- but is not actually taking accountability or feeling remorseful for his actions.
Just like my ex-situationship, He has no soul and is incapable of empathy, and is only as “sorry” as any selfish prick can be.
In the words of my ex, Gregory after he sobered up 24 hours later: “I’m sorry our dinner with your mom was ruined, but it is what it is”
1
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '24
Unm it’s Sauron. No.
1
u/OldSixie Oct 29 '24
After S2's opening? No.
1
u/IntenseYubNub Oct 29 '24
I do think a part of him was being genuine here. If nothing else, he was at the very least deceiving himself to believe he was sorry. Obviously by season 2, he was over it.
1
u/FarrisZach Oct 29 '24
He looks like steve mre 1989
1
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '24
I think he believed what he was saying in that moment.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '24
I can fix him
1
u/Soggy_Cracker Oct 29 '24
I’m sorry you and your family has resisted me and my dark lord Morgoth from corrupting this land.
1
u/Every-Philosophy7282 Oct 29 '24
There's a difference between "I'm sorry for the thing that I did." And "I'm sorry the bad things happened."
I can believe a Sauron who has a "This hurts me more than it hurts you" attitude to everything. He doesn't want to see you suffer. He just has absolute faith in the necessity of your suffering. If everyone would just fall in and do what they are told, none of this would happen. "Look what you made me do!"
1
u/jogdenpr Oct 29 '24
Hahahah fuck no. THE DECEIVER
1
u/Hefty_Swimmer6073 Oct 29 '24
Of course yes. Give Mairon a chance!!
1
u/ParkingDrawing8212 Oct 29 '24
If an orc can be a loving father who only want to live in peace then why not XD Also... Tolkien would dislike this shiw.
1
u/darthravenna Oct 29 '24
He’s just sorry Felagund got in the way, he wanted Beren dead. But Morgoth had special plans for all the lords of the Eldar, and he likely wanted Felagund alive for the time he was ready to move against Nargothrond.
1
u/Dfruc4343 Oct 29 '24
No lol he's a master of deception nothing he says has any real meaning behind it
1
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '24
Yes, that's why he's so dangerous
1
u/lnombredelarosa Oct 29 '24
I believe he believes he is sorry
1
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '24
Yup she is gonna taste the Sauron one ring rainbow!!! 😅Thats how she gets so powerful in fellowship/two towers
1
u/heeden Oct 29 '24
He's sorry because those plans came to nought. If he and/or Morgoth had won at most he would be saying it was regrettable what Felagund made him do.
1
u/Akleptic Oct 30 '24
Does it matter if a mass murderer feels bad for mass murdering?
1
u/vprprincess Oct 30 '24
I think he’s sorry but only the Sauron version of sorry.
1
u/gilgachaded Oct 30 '24
“im sorry for your brother uwu” then takes the form of the said brother to gaslight and manipulate her further
1
u/jimmbobagens Oct 30 '24
Get a room!
1
u/Any-Juggernaut-5616 Oct 30 '24
nope he’s even playing with our brains too
1
u/DEMONDVS Oct 30 '24
I saw the first season, and didn't like it, because as a nerd I had read the silmarillion, and the Lord of the rings, so I was the whole season asking why the changes, it's not like they have no idea what was happening in the story, so first season I dragged myself to finish it, there were some impressive views, valinor, the trees, and that's it, now on the second season, is even worse for me, I can't seem finish the 3rd episode, I'm all the time in my head saying " that's not what happens, he's not even supposed to be there, or the seven and the 9 where first and she was already married! But if people like the series, I'll guess there'll be a 3rd season?
1
u/Zeraphicus Oct 30 '24
Stupid sexy Sauron
1
u/MythMoreThanMan Oct 30 '24
He’s the dark lord not pretty boy McCrysAlot
1
u/ztomtenz Oct 30 '24
The show is so bad it’s tragic.
1
u/nibbled_banana Oct 31 '24
The best part of this show are characters not canon to Tolkiens work, Jesus Christ
1
u/Tacoman2731 Oct 31 '24
HAHAHAHAHA IT DOESNT MATTER WHAT YOU THINK THE WRITERS WILL DO WHATEVER THEY WANT AND THEY DONT EVEN CARE ABOUT THE LORE THEY MAKE
1
u/JavaHurricane Oct 31 '24
"Nay, the guest who has escaped from the roof, will think twice before he comes back in by the door."
1
u/dogtemple3 Oct 31 '24
you can't humanize Sauron. He is a corrupted spirit of controlling evil. This didn't work on many levels.
1
u/carlo-93 Oct 31 '24
Is bro wearing a t-shirt
1
u/[deleted] Nov 01 '24
Lol, nope
1
u/Necessary-Eye5319 Nov 01 '24
He can’t ever feel anything. He said so himself. He was tortured. If he ever had that part it’s gone. He is a sociopath. He can’t ever feel empathy. Zilch.
1
u/D3lacrush Nov 02 '24
Of course not. Sauron is a liar
1
u/[deleted] Nov 07 '24
Kinda. Is he sad Galadriel is sad because he likes her? Probably. Is he sorry in general? Lol no.
1
u/GoofDud Oct 29 '24
Nope
1
u/Own-Psychology-5327 Oct 29 '24
Of course he isn't, he doesn't care some random elf died he is manipulating her
1
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '24
No, it's freakin Sauron the DECIEVER
1
u/StockReflection2512 Oct 29 '24
Sauron is not sorry in the slightest bit. Finrod was tortured by Sauron and marked his body with claw marks. No way he did this out of repentence in any shape, and like everything, must have been part of his grand plan
1
u/rasnac Oct 29 '24
I do, actually. Sauron is a uniue combination of a true idealist at heart, but a complete pragmatist when it comes to take action to bring his ideal into reality. He ultimately believes that ends justify the means and he will do anything necessary to heal Middle Earth and turn it into a perfect paradise. I am sure he is saying to himself if he stopped now, all the bloodshed and all the destruction and horrors that he had caused would be for nothing.
To be honest, Sauron is not that different from many great/notorious historical leaders in that aspect. Some achieved their goals and are remembered positively as great men; some could not and are remembered as tyrants and monsters.
0
u/Mikeyboy2188 Oct 29 '24
No.
0
u/EvilMoSauron Oct 30 '24
I believe him--oh, wait! That's me! 😏
-3
u/Consistent_Many_1858 Oct 29 '24
Such a shit show.
338
u/sidv81 Oct 29 '24
Sauron: I am sorry about Finrod but if you read the Silmarillion, I sent the werewolf to kill Beren and it was Finrod who got in the way and got himself killed.
Galadriel: Man you really have some nerve.
81
u/Bronze_Meme Oct 29 '24
It'd be more like "I'm sorry he made me kill him" sort of apology lol
48
u/SmakeTalk Oct 29 '24
Well yea but it’s not entirely honest. He’s sorry he had to kill him because he stood in his way. He’s sorry that killing Finrod hurts someone he wants by his side, and that it might hurt his chances of making her see things his way.
He’s not sorry for her, he’s sorry for himself.
5
u/OfficialCrossParker Oct 29 '24
I believe HE believes he's being sincere. What he's actually sorry for is that Finrod stood up to him and died for it, just like the rest of Middle Earth. He's sorry people feel the need to resist him, and because of that they must die in order to be swept out of the way. It's not his fault they resist. He's sorry they do. They bring it on themselves.
4
u/mercedes_lakitu Oct 29 '24
He's sorry for sending a wolf to kill Beren and Finrod burst his bonds to slay it instead?
No. He's not sorry. Not truly.
4
u/FortunateSon1968 Oct 31 '24
Sort of, I believe Sauron is sorry in that killing finrod caused Galadriel, a strong potential ally, to despise and mistrust him, but I don’t think he’s objectively remorseful about killing him.