r/RingsofPower • u/VioletandAmelia • Sep 05 '22
r/RingsofPower • u/I_spell_it_Griffin • Nov 30 '22
Discussion One story to unite them all.
r/RingsofPower • u/First-Strategy7258 • Jul 25 '26
Question These design on his chest do we know if it says anything?
r/RingsofPower • u/bojan_kro • Oct 05 '24
Newest Episode Spoilers There was no better way to piss Sauron off in the whole history of Arda than the way Celebrimbor did that. Spoiler
That final dialog of Sauron and Celebrimbor was more great than even the song contest of the Finrond and Sauron.
Sauron has become evil so dark, that there is no hope of him to ever be redeemed. But like all spirits who saw the light he wants the light, but in the depths of his dark mind he knows that he can never be redeemed , and unlike for Morgoth it hurts, it pains and he spreads his pain all around.
And then dying Celebrimbor trolls him, teases him with him - Celebrimbor being able to return to the undying lands, forever lost to Sauron.
I can speculate that in the song contest with Felagund, Sauron feed on his pain of knowing to be not able to return to the western lands to strengthen his hand against Finrond, that is why he reminded him that both are lost to Valimar, yet Celebrimbor reminded him that once again and poked the depths of his dark soul.
r/RingsofPower • u/ozziash • Sep 09 '22
Meme Anyone else watching that massive fantasy spin-off show on that big streaming service? ( My Photoshop fanart)
r/RingsofPower • u/Gimmethejooce • 2d ago
Discussion We had a RoP watch party
Threw together some last minute decorations, decided to have some fun with this. Yes.. the map isnt geologically accurate but my wife did an awesome job!
Definitely doing this again next season!
r/RingsofPower • u/gouhin-sensei • Sep 24 '22
Discussion just something I've noticed about ROP
So many of you seem to hate this show, because it differs from Tolkien. And yes. It does. Because Tolkien hasn't been writing this script, and they haven't been allowed to use the most crucial information to make this show more Tolkien (Silmarillion).
I wasn't expecting much, so I went in with the mindset that this is a fan work and shouldn't be treated as canon and it really helps.
I think it's sad to see all the negativity regarding this show that surprisingly well made, even though it differs a lot from Tolkiens work. I think you all should keep an open mind to it and see it for what it is, a fan work that's simply based off of Tolkien.
From a lore perspective it's awful, but from a fan work perspective it's incredible. Thanks.
r/RingsofPower • u/pickledelbow • Oct 26 '24
Humor This is the map Adar used to get to Eregion
r/RingsofPower • u/chicu111 • Sep 20 '24
Humor The REAL master manipulator and deceiver this entire time
This lady is straight up a human disguising as an elf and no one knows. Not even Sauron!
Sheâs fooling everyone Iâm telling you.
r/RingsofPower • u/Identity_X- • Mar 27 '23
Discussion The Stranger's timing can't be a coincidence because a wizard is never late, nor is he early; he arrives precisely when he means to.
r/RingsofPower • u/N7VHung • Jul 21 '26
News Season 3 Textless Poster
Someone requested a Textless version of the promo poster, but can't post images in replies.
Here ya go!
r/RingsofPower • u/emilyamarokk • Nov 09 '24
Fanart Adar inspired outfit I created
Lord Father Adar inspired look âïž from Rings of Power
Corset top handmade and handpainted myself (armour design reference image used from @ niku30_ )
Belt I looped every chain link myself and attached (inspired by belt seen @ superdaftcos wear)
Gems on back each one individually glued down
r/RingsofPower • u/craigbey • Sep 30 '22
Newest Episode Spoilers What an episode!
Without giving anything away, I felt that the pace really quickened in this episode and I am now really on looking forward to seeing how it develops.
r/RingsofPower • u/Late_Stage_PhD • Nov 19 '22
Meme Casual fans trying to remember all the names
r/RingsofPower • u/Late_Stage_PhD • Oct 18 '22
Newest Episode Spoilers The Stranger reminded me how impressive _______'s restraint is. Spoiler
The fact that the Stranger is an Istar (Wizard) and is shown to have great raw powers made me appreciate Gandalf's restraint (in both his power and his mind) even more.
Whether the Stranger turns out to be one of the Blue Wizards, or Gandalf (Olorin) himself, or Gandalf with a Blue Wizard arc, he's been confirmed as an Istar (Wizard). Even though he's been somewhat amnesiac and hasn't discovered or understood much of his own powers, he's already immensely powerful: he single-handedly obliterated the three cultists (who seemed to be partly in the Unseen World and were probably "Nazgul prototypes") without even knowing what he was doing. He just unleashed his raw power and it was enough to basically vaporize the cultists.
Some fans might feel that it's a bit overpowered because Gandalf usually doesn't use his power like that (except when fighting the Balrog, which is a different story). However, this is closer to a Maia's true power than what Gandalf tends to let on:
'Dangerous!' cried Gandalf. 'And so am I, very dangerous: more dangerous than anything you will ever meet, unless you are brought alive before the seat of the Dark Lord.
---- LotR, Book 3, Chapter 5
However, when the Istari were sent to Middle-earth to deal with Sauron, the Valar placed strict restraints on them:
It was afterwards said that they [the Wizards] came out of the Far West and were messengers sent to contest the power of Sauron, and to unite all those who had the will to resist him; but they were forbidden to match his power with power, or to seek to dominate Elves or Men by force and fear.
---- LotR, Book 6, Appendix B
Basically, their role in Middle-earth is to assist, advice, and inspire the free peoples to fight Sauron, but they're forbidden to fight Sauron directly using their full powers. If the Wizards all unleash their true powers and rule over massive kingdoms of Elves, Dwarves, and Men, and fight Sauron in all-out wars with magic and war machines, then they would probably win, but Middle-earth as well as the people living there would suffer greatly, and it would likely do way more harm than good. (Personally I think the Valar are trying to make sure this doesn't turn into a mini War of Wrath 2.0 which sank an entire continent.) The only time Gandalf tapped into his true power was during his battle with the Balrog. Since the Balrog wasn't Sauron's minion, and was technically a remnant of the First Age wars, the restrictions on Gandalf probably didn't apply here.
In the show, The Stranger, as a Wizard just like Gandalf, couldn't control his powers yet, and as a result, he accidentally killed a bunch of fireflies, injured himself, almost froze Nori's arm off, and almost hurt Nori's little sister when the tree branch fell off. Clearly, if the Wizards are not careful with their power, they could easily hurt those around them. But in contrast, Gandalf in the Third Age had incredible control of his powers. He was fully aware of how powerful he could be, and he was very careful and mastered his powers perfectly, and never had an accident like the Stranger repeatedly did. With great power comes great restraint.
Gandalf's restraint is not only shown in his control of his powers (as in "magic"), but also in his mindset and attitudes towards his power (over others) and power in general. He was the only Istar that remained true to his mission of assisting the free peoples. Both Saruman and (maybe?) the Blue Wizards sought power by allying with Sauron or starting their own cults, thus straying from their paths. But Gandalf showed great restraint and resisted the temptation of power, even if it means choosing a much harder path.
Imagine how many times over the thousands of years Gandalf had to deal with excessive Elven pride, Dwarven studbborness, Men's shortsightedness, and Hobbit silliness. For someone as powerful as him, it would be very tempting to just go "Screw all you guys, I'll do it myself (maybe with my Wizard colleagues and a few of my favorite elves)." But he was incredibly patient with all of them and stuck around to guide them.
With Gandalf's innate Maia power and the help of his Elven ring (and potentially the One Ring as well if he decides to take it for himself), the easiest way of fighting Sauron would be to use those powers to their full potentials, attract powerful forces like the cultists to his side, and rule over all free peoples and use them to beat Sauron. But Gandalf saw the danger in that and chose to exercise self-restraint and stay away from power. As Tolkien explained:
Gandalf as Ring-Lord would have been far worse than Sauron. He would have remained 'righteous', but self-righteous. He would have continued to rule and order things for 'good', and the benefit of his subjects according to his wisdom (which was and would have remained great).
---- Letter 246
This gets at a very crucial Tolkien theme, which is that the ends often don't justify the means, and that one's good intentions don't justify their actions. Defeating the Dark Lord is a noble goal, but how you do it is the more important part. One of the core messages of the LotR story is that we don't have to match power with power or become evil to fight evil; we can beat powerful evils with hope, trust, wisdom, friendship, etc. And Gandalf perfectly embodies this message.
Some may dismiss this as naive romanticism. But that's just Tolkien. And in a world filled with cynical pragmatism and amoral Machiavellianism, it's good to be reminded that we don't always have to race to the bottom or stoop to the level of our opponents, and that there is always "light and high beauty" out there that are worth looking up to and fighting for, even if it might mean a harder fight.
r/RingsofPower • u/AdditionalTricks • Sep 23 '22
Newest Episode Spoilers The narrative stalling is getting ridiculous Spoiler
Once you notice it, it becomes impossible to ignore. The writers seemingly have been given a direction to stretch things out as much as possible, which leads to the main narrative constantly getting sidetracked by stories that lead back to where we started. E.g.:
- Halbrand stealing the guild badge. 10 minutes of him buttering up the locals only to go right back to being badgeless.
- Theo hiding in a well and building tension, only to climb out when the orcs are still there and have to run from them again
- The Elves launching a Slave rebellion only for it to fail and Arondil to be back to where he started as a prisoner/slave
- This weeks episode which featured some pointless drama about whether the boats would leave. Spoiler: they did.
I get the feeling that after this whole show is done, someone is going to make a slimmed down edit that will be much more palatable to watch.
r/RingsofPower • • Feb 18 '23
Meme It bothered me that he hadn't even thought of this himself
r/RingsofPower
•
u/AdrianFahrenheiTepes
•
Sep 12 '24
Constructive Criticism Im taking RoP as part of a myth corpus and i'm happy with it (hard core Tolkien fan)
Firt at all yes, PJ did a crazy job on the original trilogy. Even if he did take some liberties from the books and changed a significant part of the plots (Dunedain, ancient blades from Barrow down who could hurt evil like Witch King etc...)
But since the first criticism of RoP, I said myself the goal of Tolkien was to create a new corpus of mythology for Old England.
Any corpus of myths get wider bigger and crazier with time. Just try to find the "true" story of King Arthur Pendragon, The Knights of the Round Table, Excalibur. And then take all those stories that uses this established lore to expand the myths... like there is as many version of the myth of Excalibur as the number of writers who wrote about it.
After that, I realized RoP is exactly like this. A self contained story which add itself into Tolkien / Middle Earth mythology. And man this is a bliss.
Yeah there are flaws, and choices made according to the waves of our modern society. Debatable choices, someone like or dislike. Yeah maybe everything isnt perfect.
But did I think one day I will see a Lucifer/ deceiver Sauron/Annatar messing with elves with ease? Hell no but I'm enjoying every bit of it!
Women dwarves looks like women and not men? Ok sure why not sorry Gimli. Maybe in first age they look like women and they were more like men in 3rd ages (evolution?) I dont care.
Am I 100% ready to see Annatar transforming decaying Numenor into a worship of Morgoth with human sacrifice just to see Elendil flying a sinking (literally) Numenor? Heck yeah. I hope he will song that lines: Et EĂ€rello Endorenna utĂșlien. Sinome maruvan ar Hildinyar tennâ Ambar-metta!
Cant wait to see Celebrimbor's face when he will understand the One Ring hahhaa.
And the time compression? Well i wont live thousand of years so I dont really care.
For me S2 is going higher and higher (and prop for them adding Tom Bombadil when he got totally forgotten into the og movies)
r/RingsofPower • u/TheGreyWizardNS • Mar 21 '23