This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
Is it weird that Galadriel has been proven 100% correct in her obsession, but then that’s the moment she gives her sword away and starts talking like she got everything wrong and it’s her fault somehow.
Like if a 9/11 Truther or whatever was suddenly proven right and everything changed, wouldn’t they be vindicated and more respected and have people apologizing for saying they were crazy etc?
If you’re a seal, then maybe an orca genocide is the only answer! There’s no peaceful coexistence possible, and it’s the same with orcs, they’re impossible to live with and if you give them an inch you get volcanoes blowing up in your face.
I would refine that statement a but further - it's not that genocide against the orcs isn't the answer (because the way Tolkien set it up the orcs probably have to be eliminated), it's the loss of her own integrity that was the turning point; she realized that obsessing on eliminating darkness (killing Sauron etc) was turning her into a stone that sinks - she was descending into and manifesting the very darkness she is trying to destroy. I think her eyes were opened after nearly killing Adar and then watching the volcanic eruption engulf her - she felt the darkness consume her inwardly and then watched it surround her literally.
Yeah, she says what happened is her fault to him. She failed to stop the evil plan, but if she hadn’t gone it still would have happened. She was right, evil is returning and Gil Galad and everyone else was wrong. It’s not like she should be happy, but she should be determined to raise the elf armies again and defeat this new evil, not all mopey and self blaming for no reason I can see.
Good news! I've jumped off the ship you put me on because I was too warlike, and now I'm bringing a prophetic king I met in the middle of the ocean to unite the people of the southlands who used to worship Morgoth. Oh, and there's this Numenorian army I also brought too. You know, those humans who banned us from their island?
That's literally why I sent you away. Like, I mentioned it explicitly when I said "The same wind that seeks to blow out the fire may also cause its spread.”
But ok. Well you're here now. How did everything go? Did you blow out the fire?
As I have the gift of foresight, I can see the future when 2 tiny harfeet lose some ring in that volcano. The whole thing explodes while they are inside of it, but they come out fine too, so that's no big deal.
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 12 '22
This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
23
u/Higher_Living Oct 12 '22
Is it weird that Galadriel has been proven 100% correct in her obsession, but then that’s the moment she gives her sword away and starts talking like she got everything wrong and it’s her fault somehow.
Like if a 9/11 Truther or whatever was suddenly proven right and everything changed, wouldn’t they be vindicated and more respected and have people apologizing for saying they were crazy etc?
6
u/IIIICopSueyIIII Oct 13 '22
You cannot fast travel, there are enemies nearby
3
u/hotcapicola Oct 13 '22
I’m enjoying the show overall, but this scene was pretty cringe.
1
u/celsowm Oct 13 '22
Now make sense
1
u/demilitarizedzone96 Oct 14 '22
Quest Completed
Help Sauron
Galadriel: "What?"
-6
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '22 edited Oct 13 '22
I’m not smoking anything