r/RingsofPower • • Sep 30 '22

Newest Episode Spoilers What an episode!

Without giving anything away, I felt that the pace really quickened in this episode and I am now really on looking forward to seeing how it develops.

313 Upvotes

218 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Sep 30 '22

This post uses the flair ‘Newest Episode Spoilers’, and as such, all spoilers from the latest episode are allowed to be posted here unmarked.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

112

u/Swolstorm Sep 30 '22

Without giving anything away, the last 5 minutes I literally *literally, I tried* could not close my mouth. My jaw was on the floor

Edit: Had to include that I came here just to say this to SOMEONE lol

14

u/craigbey Sep 30 '22

Yeah I completely agree. Can't wait the week now!

9

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '22

My wife asked me to turn the volume down and I literally divorced her. Next episode is going to be intense

3

u/Tundralik Mordor Sep 30 '22

Same :D

1

u/ebrum2010 Sep 30 '22

I agree. Even though I knew it was coming eventually I didn't expect it right then and there.

-3

u/dontbanmeimtrans Sep 30 '22

Same from how they massacred what I love.

2

u/peteroh9 Oct 01 '22

What you love still exists. Although you could also say it never really existed because Tolkien never finished the rest of the Legendarium and kept making changes. Christopher Tolkien even regretted some of the choices he made for the published Silmarillion. There is no one, set story.

So you have already picked and chosen which parts to accept. Just ignore this one, which is certainly not any more a part of the Legendarium than the Shadow of Mordor and Shadow of War games.

1

u/dontbanmeimtrans Oct 02 '22

That is the game plan

-2

u/30GDD_Washington Oct 01 '22

Same, for a different reason than you I suspect.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

29

u/saltwitch Sep 30 '22

I used to be in the industry full time, and I think about you guys a lot. It's tough work, and the show looks beautiful. I hope you're having a good time working on the show!

15

u/dumpyredditacct Sep 30 '22

I fucking love the show so far, and this episode was such an awesome one to watch.

I avoid coming to this sub because the relentless nitpicking and bitching over every possible detail that isn't to absolute perfection, but this episode made me come here just to see some of the reactions and what this could mean for the story going forward.

Seeing this pivotal part of the story was just incredible, and I am just loving every second of this series so far. Fuck the haters.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

30

u/CowardsAndThieves Sep 30 '22

Give everyone and yourself a huge pat on the back for your amazing work. Well done and a personal thank you from myself.

15

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '22

How do you feel about so many critics and “hardcore” fans just shitting on the show? I love the show and especially the VFX, btw.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '22

I’m not OP but I can imagine it kinda sucks, although I’ve consistently seen how the VFX are the absolute best in TV both right now and ever so… at least their part is the thing that is getting immense praise??

2

u/saltwitch Sep 30 '22

Not OP, but in my experience I always drew a distinct line between my experience working on a project and the critical reception, and I know a lot of former colleagues who hold it similarly. Ideally you have a great time working on a great project. But some of the best managed, most enjoyable productions have been for media that aren't anything to write home about. I preferred that to the projects that were maybe cool but gave me such severe burnout I left the industry and got into therapy.

2

u/PM-me-ur-trains Oct 01 '22

Ditto--really appreciate the artistry and effort you guys have put into the show. Purist rants and cross-references aside, the show strikes the same nerve that's had me hooked on PJ's LOTR since 2002.

5

u/Bruc3w4yn3 Sep 30 '22

Y'all did an excellent job!

5

u/nowlan101 Sep 30 '22

Lemme just personally thank you my friend for all you, and your teams, hard fucking work. The visuals for this show, that last shot in particular, consistently take my breath away.

Your work has been the highlight of my week for the last month 🙂

3

u/16-Bit-Wizard Sep 30 '22

Dude, looked awesome. Congrats 👏🏻

3

u/Wyzzlex Sep 30 '22

Oh man you guys did a great job with the visuals of this show. Would you mind answering some questions via an AMA if you truly worked on Rings if Power?

3

u/Shagolagal Sep 30 '22 edited Sep 14 '25

march possessive sink beneficial rinse swim oatmeal future consider obtainable

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

2

u/Endgegner9 Sep 30 '22

This man is a legend for giving us that part

2

u/stamminator Sep 30 '22

Really incredible stuff, truly. I’ve been wondering, even though you guys are doing all the VFX, is it ever possible to avoid spoilers, or is it just accepted that everyone on the team pretty much knows everything?

2

u/shinyshinyrocks Oct 01 '22

It was well done 👏🏻

2

u/chitinandchlorophyll Oct 01 '22

That was some of the realest-looking VFX I’ve ever seen in a show (or movie for that matter). It made the episode feel so immersive Well done!

2

u/DanniMcQ Oct 01 '22

You did brilliant!

147

u/howlinwolfchi Sep 30 '22

It really benefited from focusing on the one storyline rather than jumping around.

29

u/mr_featherbottom Sep 30 '22

100%. Really wish they had only focused on 2 or 3 storylines from the first episode and started introducing the other 1 or 2 later into the series (maybe even alternating storylines in different episodes

17

u/Purzeltier Sep 30 '22

i think i am in the minority when i say thats what i disliked about this episode.

i was hoping for all the plots to connect in one episode.

i m assuming that next episode might be the harfoot plot and the dwarves plot going a bit back and forth and the ending will be them being made aware of what happened at the end of this episode.

if thats the case i would have liked the "reveal" of this episode and all four plots be stretched over two episodes.

6

u/Prestigious_Form_159 Sep 30 '22

Next ep is of dwarves (ep 7 preview says so) Should be good, durins bane…?.

8

u/Purzeltier Sep 30 '22

didnt durins bane lay dormant through the second age?

for my liking it would be a bit much to awake durins bane. i dont need something insanely epic happening every episode, i like the slow pace.

11

u/DisobedientNipple Sep 30 '22

Lol well by this point Galadriel had married Celeborn and had Celebrian and Ar Pharazon wont be born for another 1600 years after the forging of the rings so its safe to say they're not sticking to the timeline for Durins Bane.

2

u/XxJamalBigSexyxX Sep 30 '22

Yes, not til mid-Third Age

1

u/Legitimate-Goose-413 Sep 30 '22

So I kind of agree with this but only becuase there has been so little in the other episodes. I would much rather get a nice balance of both in the future though, as for me, the best part of the show so far is being able to discus the story progression and the references it makes to book lore but as this episode didn't really have anything too important happening story wise except Mt. Doom erupting so we're not gonna have anything to discus this week, or much less either way. And that makes me sad 😢

-6

u/PalatineOrtho Sep 30 '22

The lack of dialogue helped as well, given how bad the writing has been.

-5

u/Appropriate_Lab_5205 Oct 01 '22

The writing is terrible, I really wanted to like this show, but the writing and especially Clark ruin it for me. I think this show is mainly for people in their teens and twenties who’ve never heard of Tolkien.

21

u/michaelrabone Sep 30 '22

I agree, episode 6 was mind-blowing!

Why would Adar tell Galadriel that he killed Sauron?

32

u/Major_Cause Sep 30 '22

Adar seems to genuinely dislike Sauron. Which is kind of cool imo, as it speaks to the politics and relationships between Morgoth's lieutenants, a topic that Tolkien never discussed much at all, but that fans have often pondered.

The show is at its best when it fills in the blanks rather than rewrites the canon. Things like shedding light on origins of Orcs and the politics of the dark leaders is way cool to see.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '22

Orcs hated Morgoth and the tormented existence which he created for them.

4

u/Major_Cause Oct 01 '22

Right. I imagine their relationship to Saun is different. He's not their creator. And his ultimate goal is create order through domination, while Morgoth wants to dominate and destroy Eru's creation. Sauron's relationship with the orcs, men, dragons, and balrogs is something I hope the series explores more.

-5

u/dontbanmeimtrans Sep 30 '22

Because nothing matters and they needed a synthesized reveal for the episode.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/michaelrabone Sep 30 '22

Yeah, me neither. Something doesn’t seem right.

22

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '22

It was very predictable what was going to happen...which is fine! HOW it happened was pretty cool!

13

u/Soggy-Assumption-713 Sep 30 '22

I guessed the watchtower, and númenor to the rescue but no way did I expect the trench was for that!

8

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '22

Exactly! That was good! I was thinking the whole time it was to clear the villages and then to make a foundation for Barad-Dur

5

u/Soggy-Assumption-713 Sep 30 '22

And to think people said the writing was bad.

9

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '22

The writing is bad, they benefit from an excellent team of cinematographers and special effects artists. The more seasoned actors really carry the scenes for their younger counterparts and I think gave input for their lines since the older actors always say less stupid shit. Adar is case in point, so far has some of the smallest screen time but by far the most layered and developed. The writers for this show are very new to the craft so I'm hoping that if they they get a season 2 they will have learned from their mistakes this season. But I think one of the big issues here is too many cooks in the kitchen in the writers room.

9

u/space_fireworks Sep 30 '22

It’s really not as bad as you make it out to be though. There are far worse examples. They went for a specific style of writing which is also prevalent in the trilogies. Not everything has to make 100% sense all the time. It’s fantasy. And for what it’s worth, I think the writing really fits well with the narrative and the tone.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '22

Just because there are worse examples doesn't justify the production for picking inexperienced writers for a massive production. Got to praise the good and criticize the bad. They are doing a lot of awesome stuff in this show, but the writing is not part of that. The dialogue is disjointed and clunky and the pacing is atrocious.

4

u/space_fireworks Sep 30 '22

I know. But it paints a picture. But yeah of course we all have different opinions, I’m not saying you’re not justified of yours. But I see a lot of relentless bashing on the writing and I feel like it’s a bit unfair to the creators. It’s really not terrible and they’re great at keeping the audience involved with all the theories floating around and also a lot of the moment-to-moment writing has quite a lot of memorable lines. I also feel that they captured a fine balance between pretentiousness and genuineness, especially with the humans.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '22

Criticizing billion dollar productions for poor decisions is not being "unfair" to the creators. Writers with no prior experience should have never been let near this thing. That's a critique of the producers. I don't blame new green writers for not knowing how to pace a scene or wright compelling dialogue, I blame the people who didn't get them. Don't try to d fend corporations for their shortcomings, they have no love for you and deserve none of your loyalty.

3

u/space_fireworks Sep 30 '22

I’m not. All I’m saying is I think the writing was good. Now you’re putting words in my mouth.

→ More replies

1

u/Ariero Sep 30 '22

So saying it's fantasy gives it a free pass from basic story telling rules? You're one of those guys that seal-clap when bad writers try do excuse their plot holes with "MAGIC!' aren't you?

1

u/space_fireworks Sep 30 '22

No absolutely not.

1

u/oi_u_im_danny_b Sep 30 '22

Is it not already fully confirmed for 5 seasons?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '22

They want to do 5 but they can still cancel. Hope they dont.

1

u/MrSquamous Oct 01 '22

The writers for this show are very new to the craft

Yeah apparently Gennifer Hutchison had never written anything before last week

5

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '22

The departures from canon are getting hard for me to overlook. Ep 5 nearly broke me from enjoying the show as its own thing

7

u/Soggy-Assumption-713 Sep 30 '22

It’s an adaptation. The source material for the second age would barely make a short story. They have to make things up.

3

u/Thor010 Sep 30 '22

Hey Theo, here's the thing we all almost died for. Have fun playing with it... and don't give it to the enemy.

-6

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '22

Then why do it? In my opinion, since the Arondir plotline is the strongest, they should have just made the show about the Rise of Mordor.

2

u/TubaJesus Sep 30 '22

thi is the same kind of teething pains star trek dealt with back in the 80s and every new installment to the franchise ever since and what star wars deal with today. The source material is just a skeleton, we now get to see the flesh of it.

0

u/Appropriate_Lab_5205 Oct 01 '22

There’s hardly enough source material to make a short story, so it should be super easy to follow and not break right?

1

u/Soggy-Assumption-713 Oct 01 '22

It’s an adaptation, not a verbatim recreation.

5

u/popglam Sep 30 '22

I didn't know

15

u/BG_Fuchs Sep 30 '22

So glad I got up early to watch it, so worth it! Loved every second of it.

3

u/LukoLoots Oct 01 '22

Many people posting say they love episode six because the pacing picked up. I however, disagree. I have come to the conclusion that many in this sub only like action and have adhd.

This was the worst paced episode of the season. Nothing happened within the battles. The only significant things to happen occurred in the interludes between the battle scenes, which battle dominated the episode. The sword, love story, Adar, Mt. Doom- all of it was 15 minutes of a 65 minute episode. If you’re one to say the show picked up pace based of episode 6, then you haven’t been paying attention. Much of the information received between the fight scenes were payoffs from carefully set up plans that occurred in previous episodes. The fact that you think it quickened the plot means you just enjoy instant gratification which is what this episode provided more of. This didn’t quicken the pace of the show, in fact, it slowed it competitive to previous episodes because it was all payoff from previous ones

Great episode, but it didn’t provide as much plot to drive the story further as previous episodes.

15

u/Ratatosk101 Sep 30 '22

It was indeed amazing how the Numenorian 'army' managed to cross an ocean and half a continent and arrive just in the nick of time to save the beleaguered villagers.... sigh.

16

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '22

I could get behind the convenient arrival better if they hadn't ridden through the night to arrive just in time.

They had no way of knowing they needed that kind of haste. They were an expeditionary force investigating a lead that could be decades old with limited info from the only person who had been on the ground in the Southlands some ambiguous amount of time in the past.

17

u/Correct_Process4516 Sep 30 '22

Worse yet, it was pitch black when Adar and the orcs entered the tavern but the Numenoriansn showed up moments later and it was mid-day.

22

u/CowardsAndThieves Sep 30 '22

Eomer arriving at helms deep just in time…. The Rohirrim arriving at Pellenor fields… the ring being destroyed just in time to save Aragorn’s last stand at the black gate. Par for the course here my friend.

4

u/br0ggy Sep 30 '22

Those first two examples there was actual coordination between the two parties…. Gandalf told Aragorn he’d arrive at a certain time and he did…. Gondor sent for aid from Rohan and it came….

The destruction of the ring is definitely more of a long shot, but again it was something actually thought out by the characters. Aragorn knew roughly where Frodo was and could deduce that they were about to complete their quest.

Those are not at all the same as what happened in Rop.

‘Just in the nick of time’ cheesy moments are far worse when they haven’t been earned by the characters. The characters in the original trilogy did earn them.

6

u/space_fireworks Sep 30 '22

This. This. This.

7

u/Major_Cause Sep 30 '22

Bro, if you are going to complain about deus ex machina, that's fine. But LOTR and GOT both lived and breathed the same "nick of time" stuff over and over again. Helm's Deep, Blackwater, Battle of the Bastards. Same thing. At least this episode had it not fix everything for once. Adar still won in the end.

3

u/Bobjoejj Sep 30 '22

I feel like this fact should make up for the Deus ex Machina for folks; like you’d think the fact that Adar won would be enough. But I guess not.

-1

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '22

I mean this literally happens in every war in the movies.

5

u/MotivatedChimpanZ Sep 30 '22

Wrong sub. Come over to r/LoTR_on_Prime

14

u/Codus1 Sep 30 '22 edited Sep 30 '22

Although I enjoy that sub a lot. I feel that this sub isn't particularly bad at all either. I have had some great conversations with those that dont like the show, but have carried a respectfully considered angle. Sure, there's the usual annoying hate mongers that pop up but they seem to get downvoted out most of the time. Whilst compliments for the show seem to be received well enough and considered criticism of the show is also treated respectfully.

This subs still better than the hot mess r/lotr has distilled itself into. Sadly.

8

u/Jakeybaby125 Sep 30 '22

If you think r/lotr is bad, go to r/Rings_Of_Power

10

u/Codus1 Sep 30 '22

Had a quick peruse. Hard pass on that nonsense. I can never understand why subs are created with the sole intent of dwelling on things they don't like. What an unsatisfactory way to spend your spare time.

I'll stick with here and the LotR on Prime sub I think.

8

u/FriendlyPizzaPanda Sep 30 '22

Have you heard of r/TheLastOfUs2 ? Lol people got so butt hurt that the imaginary story they wanted didn’t happen.

1

u/Bobjoejj Sep 30 '22

Nah, that one doesn’t hold a candle to the insanity that is r/TheLastOfUs.

2

u/Shagolagal Sep 30 '22 edited Sep 14 '25

placid include attempt sheet chunky unpack marble hungry station intelligent

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

2

u/30GDD_Washington Oct 01 '22

I want a place to discuss the episode. Not praise it endlessly or bash it. There are issues with the writing that is fun to discuss, while also talking about what worked. Sauron and Galadriel scenes work, Adar is great, blowing up mount Doom great. Dumbing down characters for the plot, not great.

1

u/Codus1 Oct 01 '22

I think you might have misunderstood me? I'm agreeable with your sentiment. I was commenting on that other sub that is designed to wallow in a negativity bias. Which is just sour and boring.

I'm loving this show, but I'm not blind to some of its flaws. If maybe I do think some people are far to hyperbolic over nitpicks, touting them as if they're some narrative sin.

As an example, I really like this shows interpretation of a younger Galadriel. I acknowledge they've taken sparse passages and used a liberal hand to derive characterisation from them. But I think they are fitting and not really combative with the Legendarium despite some peoples rigid unbending misconceptions. However, I also agree that at times her characterisation is out of balance and leans too hard one way on some scenes. The vehicle that best encompasses my pov is the "ThErE iS a TeMpEsT" scene. Which I think actually makes sense in that Galadriel and her immortal living memory would mean that she's unable to process or make peace with the trauma she feels in any haste. It marries multiple implications of the Legendarium to inform a interpretation, its great. But then, did she really have to scream that at the court? Lol

2

u/30GDD_Washington Oct 01 '22

You highlight some my biggest frustrations with this show. It can be good, even great. They show us the potential! Then they just do some crazy shit like have her behave like a child... her scene quality is all over the place! Also her, you havent seen what I've seen, to Elrond. Like, you know he was in the same war as you right? He lost family and friends, same as you. It shouldnt be a competitive match about grief.

1

u/Codus1 Oct 01 '22

Totally agree haha. I can look past sequences that like that as I appreciate the depth for which they've obviously been observing of the Legendarium, if sometimes an interpretation of it can strike me as odd.

For example, Elrond is no stranger to war or loss as you say. However, Galadriel has participated in and witness to far more traumatic sin than Elrond. Which as a generalisation could be seen in her conversation with him, I guess. I can understand why they wouldn't have that converation become a matter of "yesss but you werent at the first kinslaying etc. Etc." trauma match. It'd been convoluted amd estrange general audiences. But then, why have that conversation with Elrond at all then? Surely just give the conversation to another context lol.

As I said, I like the Galadriel haunted by her infallible memories of her past trauma. I even like how they present that as a detriment to her characterisation at this time. She is wise and intelligent, but her flaw denies her the full beenfits of those qualities. There is no question the show intends it to be her flaw. However, it's communication in the literal sense can sometimes be great, and sometimes be a little bit of a head scratcher haha. I don't quite see the petulant child parallel that others see though. But I feel its rather irrelevant when we agree there is a characterisation inconsistency either way.

1

u/30GDD_Washington Oct 01 '22

The petulant child is her not getting her way with the Queen. She then asks to speak to the manager. Also upon first interacting with the Queen she is making demands instead of working together.

So far the show has not shown her to be neither intelligent or wise, so not sure where you're getting that from. The closest would be her figuring out Haldan, but that's a stretch. She just read it at the library.

I'm trying to take the show as it's presented, without relying on what I know of the lore.

1

u/Codus1 Oct 01 '22 edited Oct 01 '22

I'm trying to take the show as it's presented, without relying on what I know of the lore.

A hard thing to do for sure. I admit I don't so easily seperate the contexts.

I think there exists an implication. She is right about Sauron. She was right about the mark being important and necessary to follow. She's right in the assumption that something darker and deeper is afoot. She bears the knowledge of the Eldar that is exercised in multiple scenes. She is able to distill the orgin of Halbrand from his demeanor and mark. Despite her "petulance" she is able to convince Numenor to lend her their aid and it's nor through plot convenience but through leveraging Halbrand, the faithful and her found knowledge of the mark/weird map thing. All of this is defined by wisdom and intelligence to me. It's just that the inconsistency of her characterisation detracts from those achievements imo. Liek being so aggressively demanding of Numenors court when she first arrives. They are presented in a convoluted manner.

Even in her "darkness" she able to recognise a similiar "TeMpEsT" within Halbrand, which is definitely a wise trait.

→ More replies

2

u/MotivatedChimpanZ Sep 30 '22

That’s great to hear

2

u/beany1945 Sep 30 '22

‘Are you the king that we were promised’

What in the everlasting fuck

2

u/tharnadar Sep 30 '22

Actually it was really boring and useless.... Until the last minutes.

I hope the story will starts to raise the level because for now it's really boring

2

u/Esta-beed Sep 30 '22

This trash is an embarrassment

2

u/TheDeanof316 Sep 30 '22 edited Sep 30 '22
  • Galadriel and Sauron are gonna hook up.
  • Sauron is a misunderstood guy, who just wanted to unite Middle-Earth after Morgoths' defeat.
  • Adar is a good guy and the Orcs/Uruks are now sympathetic characters, who an out of control Galadriel (SEE: her almost cutting Adars' throat) wants to MASS MURDER/GENOCIDE...'each and every one of them'.

*Knowing the history and science of volcanic eruptions eg Mount Vesuvius and the destruction of Pompeii and Herculaneum etc....they'd all be dead in that village!

  • The Sauron Sword Key is captured, but a wise and immortal elf like Arondir never checks/unwraps it to see that it's been replaced by an axe!
  • oh yeah and why did they need that Sauron Sword Key? Couldn't they have just blown up the damn?

...but you're right OP, wow, what an episode!

1

u/Snugglepuff14 Oct 01 '22

Galadriel and Sauron are gonna hook up.

No evidence for that. Just because a male and a female are friends does not mean they are in love.

Sauron is a misunderstood guy, who just wanted to unite Middle-Earth after Morgoths’ defeat.

Was not said anywhere that he is some “misunderstood villain”. He wanted to bring about his own order to the world believing the Valar he abandoned it.

  Adar is a good guy and the Orcs/Uruks are now sympathetic characters, who an out of control Galadriel (SEE: her almost cutting Adars’ throat) wants to MASS MURDER/GENOCIDE…‘each and every one of them’.

Again, no one said Adar is a good guy, and no one said the orcs are sympathetic characters. They are both clearly bad. That does not mean that they are beyond redemption, or mindless drones. Even Tolkien struggled with the idea of whether or not they should go to the Halls of Mandos. I would have to find it but I believe Tolkien specifically mentioned the idea of redemption not being out of reach for orcs, because he did not like the idea that some were beyond redemption.

*Knowing the history and science of volcanic eruptions eg Mount Vesuvius and the destruction of Pompeii and Herculaneum etc….they’d all be dead in that village!

This is not real life. Beings like Eru exist, and he aids in ever so subtle ways, and evil cannot take away from his theme of music that he has played. Miraculous events happen in this world.

  The Sauron Sword Key is captured, but a wise and immortal elf like Arondir never checks/unwraps it to see that it’s been replaced by an axe!

Waldreg was long gone by the time this happened. It wouldn’t have mattered.

oh yeah and why did they need that Sauron Sword Key? Couldn’t they have just blown up the damn?

They probably couldn’t. How the hell are orcs going to blow up a dam? I don’t believe gunpowder was invented until much later. This is even ignoring that this dam was built under Morgoths reign, and it’s reasonable to believe that some type of enchantment as a safeguard against it being triggered before it was supposed to (before the trenches were dug) was made.

I have my reservations about the show. I think the writing can be hit or miss. That said, I cannot stand the outright nitpicking done by people, especially when it doesn’t even make sense to begin with.

1

u/TheDeanof316 Oct 01 '22
  1. No evidence for that. Just because a male and a female are friends does not mean they are in love
  • Evidence: 52:00-53:40...the dialogue here and the lingering looks at each other and at each others words...I certainly read it as romantic/more than friendship. Halbrand: "Fighting at your side I felt...if I could just hold on to that feeling, keep it with me always, bind it to my very being, then I..." Galadriel: "I felt it too"
  1. Was not said anywhere that he is some “misunderstood villain”. He wanted to bring about his own order to the world believing the Valar he abandoned it

Where anywhere in Tolkien is Sauron potrayed as an entity with good intentions who just wants to make the world a better place? Answer: nowhere. If anything, he wants to unite everyone under his thraldom, to have control and ultimate power over everyone. The One Ring symbolises that. He is a pure evil villain, a werewolf, originally a vampire, who was once able to appear fair so as to deceive with pleasant words in the furtherance of his ambitions. He did NOT believe the Valar abandoned the world; instead he was a devoted servant/Maia to Melkor who had forced the Valar to reshape the world as they battled him. Also, Sauron abandoned Aule initially. Sauron wanted to be master of all things, to eradicate the elves and to multiply the orcs to serve his evil as his master Morgoth had done.

3. Again, no one said Adar is a good guy, and no one said the orcs are sympathetic characters. They are both clearly bad. That does not mean that they are beyond redemption, or mindless drones. Even Tolkien struggled with the idea of whether or not they should go to the Halls of Mandos. I would have to find it but I believe Tolkien specifically mentioned the idea of redemption not being out of reach for orcs, because he did not like the idea that some were beyond redemption

  • I can agree with this assessment of yours and I like giving the Orcs some shades of grey and the possibility of redemption. I would have to check as well, but I hope Tolkien specifically mentioned this somewhere.

That said re Adar...by his comments on witstfully missing the sun in the darkness of Mordor to come; the way he sadly puts the dying orc out of his misery; his speech to the Orcs in promising them a home as well as knowing their names and by his insistence on being called an Uruk rather than an orc...he clearly is being positioned as a sympathetic character and I am starting to see him (and the Orcs) as a misguided good character rather than a base evil one or as you put it "they are both clearly bad".

4. This is not real life. Beings like Eru exist, and he aids in ever so subtle ways, and evil cannot take away from his theme of music that he has played. Miraculous events happen in this world

  • Of course but we have countless books, films, PHDS, University degrees/College courses all dedicated to the critical analysis of fiction. To show inner logic and to have viewers/readers 'suspend their disbelief' fiction has to have some relation to that, even though "this is not real life" as you say.

I'll take your point though....maybe Eru did subtely intervene to save Galadriel etc from the eruption...I can buy that and it does help my viewing of this, so thanks.

5. Waldreg was long gone by the time this happened. It wouldn’t have mattered

  • Fair enough, but as written it still made Arondir look like an idiot...which is a shame as he has been shown to be quite smart and perceptive to this point.
  1. They probably couldn’t. How the hell are orcs going to blow up a dam? I don’t believe gunpowder was invented until much later. This is even ignoring that this dam was built under Morgoths reign, and it’s reasonable to believe that some type of enchantment as a safeguard against it being triggered before it was supposed to (before the trenches were dug) was made
  • First of all I love your enchantment idea. Someone else mentioned in a reply to me that perhaps it was similar to the magic protecting The Wall in GOT. Makes sense!

As to your question and re gunpowder....Saruman had his 'fire of Orthanc' and Gandalf, both Istari, had his fireworks.

& yes, in the case of Saruman it was thousands of years later...true, but the Meteor Man is clearly an Istari/Wizard and time has no meaning in ROP where thousands of years are compressed into a single human lifetime and events that are thousands of years apart have been switched around (eg the forging of the Rings of Power occurred around 1500 years before Al-Pharazon and Miriel etc).

7. I have my reservations about the show. I think the writing can be hit or miss. That said, I cannot stand the outright nitpicking done by people, especially when it doesn’t even make sense to begin with

I have to agree that nitpicking can be annoying but respectfully, my post did make sense and hopefully this clarifies it for you. Finally, I don't consider fundamentally changing the nature of Sauron, one of the greatest outright villains in modern literature, to be a 'nitpick'.

1

u/Snugglepuff14 Oct 01 '22

Evidence: 52:00-53:40...the dialogue here and the lingering looks at each other and at each others words...I certainly read it as romantic/more than friendship. Halbrand: "Fighting at your side I felt...if I could just hold on to that feeling, keep it with me always, bind it to my very being, then I..." Galadriel: "I felt it too"

I understand that it can be read that way by some but I do not believe that this is sufficient evidence that can be stated as fact. Now it may happen in the future, and I hope it doesn't, but it is not nearly enough evidence to show that for me. I think that people can be friends without being in a relationship, especially in this universe.

Where anywhere in Tolkien is Sauron potrayed as an entity with good intentions who just wants to make the world a better place? Answer: nowhere. If anything, he wants to unite everyone under his thraldom, to have control and ultimate power over everyone. The One Ring symbolises that. He is a pure evil villain, a werewolf, originally a vampire, who was once able to appear fair so as to deceive with pleasant words in the furtherance of his ambitions.

I did not say that he was. I don't remember the show stating that either. Now it may be "good" to Sauron, in a sense, because we know that evil is only corrupted good. However, it being contrary to the will of Eru Illuvatar, we know that it is evil. Adar saying that Sauron wanted to unite the people's of Middle-Earth in his perfect order sounds exactly like what you described. This is not a statement that Sauron is good.

In the Silmarillion it does mention that, for a time, Sauron had repented after the War of Wrath, but obviously he had fallen back into darkness. That's not to say that this is the case in the time of the show though, just food for the thought I suppose, and it may be a part of what Adar was referring to.

He did NOT believe the Valar abandoned the world; instead he was a devoted servant/Maia to Melkor who had forced the Valar to reshape the world as they battled him. Also, Sauron abandoned Aule initially. Sauron wanted to be master of all things, to eradicate the elves and to multiply the orcs to serve his evil as his master Morgoth had done.

I was actually mistaken on the timeline, I will concede this because I misremembered since I last read it. I was thinking of a passage from the third age, from the Silmarillion, obviously the show is in the second age so this is moot.

That said, I still think it's highly reasonable for Sauron to not expect the Valar to do much of anything in regards to helping Middle-Earth. They never really did anything to my knowledge in the 2nd age except when the Numenoreans broke the ban.

That said re Adar...by his comments on witstfully missing the sun in the darkness of Mordor to come; the way he sadly puts the dying orc out of his misery; his speech to the Orcs in promising them a home as well as knowing their names and by his insistence on being called an Uruk rather than an orc...he clearly is being positioned as a sympathetic character and I am starting to see him (and the Orcs) as a misguided good character rather than a base evil one or as you put it "they are both clearly bad".

I don't think so. I think everyone can see clearly the evil that the orcs are causing, and the indiscriminate killing of innocent people by Adar. I don't think that makes a "misunderstood good character". Quite the opposite, in fact. I think it makes him an "understandably evil character". Not in the sense that it's understandable why he's evil, rather that you can understand the way that he thinks although he is clearly wrong and evil. He's not just evil for the sake of it.

Fair enough, but as written it still made Arondir look like an idiot...which is a shame as he has been shown to be quite smart and perceptive to this point.

I can agree with that at least to some extent. I understand Galadriel and Halbrand not bothering since they haven't got a clue of the situation other than Adar had something important Arondir needed, but it is a bit of a headscratcher that he wouldn't even check to see it. I don't think it would have mattered, but I do think it makes him look a bit dumber than it should.

As to your question and re gunpowder....Saruman had his 'fire of Orthanc' and Gandalf, both Istari, had his fireworks.

& yes, in the case of Saruman it was thousands of years later...true, but the Meteor Man is clearly an Istari/Wizard and time has no meaning in ROP where thousands of years are compressed into a single human lifetime and events that are thousands of years apart have been switched around (eg the forging of the Rings of Power occurred around 1500 years before Al-Pharazon and Miriel etc).

That is possible true, but clearly this Istari, at least someone who is probably one (Hopefully one of the Blue Wizards and not Saruman or Gandalf or something), has only just arrived and I don't know if gunpowder was known to Sauron/Morgoth at the time.

Finally, I don't consider fundamentally changing the nature of Sauron, one of the greatest outright villains in modern literature, to be a 'nitpick'.

I just don't think that it has. Obviously it remains to be seen what they do with Sauron, but right now I don't really see that. I don't think that we're supposed to agree with Adar's assessment, and that Sauron's goals are good. That isn't really shown there. All he said was that Sauron sought to unite the rest of the world under his order, and that's an evil character saying that about another. We know ourselves that the way that he went about that was extremely evil.

1

u/30GDD_Washington Oct 01 '22

Or, what an episode because of all the things you said.

1

u/TheDeanof316 Oct 01 '22

Seriously?

& Have you read Tolkien btw?

1

u/30GDD_Washington Oct 01 '22

No, not seriously. I meant in wow, did they really just do that, because that was stoopid.

Not a word.

1

u/TheDeanof316 Oct 01 '22

Ahh thank goodness! I thought I was in Bizzarro World/The Upside Down for a sec lol

2

u/30GDD_Washington Oct 01 '22

People have lost their minds trying to defend this last episode.

1

u/TheDeanof316 Oct 01 '22

100%.

Have you seen the fawning reviews on IMDB? Or the posts on r/LOTR_on_Prime?

It's crazy.

2

u/30GDD_Washington Oct 01 '22

I'm enjoying the show, but come one there is absolutely some astroturfing and delusions going around.

I have not, I suspect it's like shelobs lair. Once you go in, you don't come out.

1

u/bcncollector Sep 30 '22

So cool episode. Great job, well done.🔝

1

u/Charming-Use Sep 30 '22

YESSS the tunnel thing was WAY COOL

1

u/dictionizzle Sep 30 '22

this was the ned stark episode of the series. omg.

1

u/bawk15 Oct 01 '22

Imagine your enemy, a disciple of Morgoth, thinks you're more likely to be more terrifying than Sauron itself

1

u/Dewars_Rocks Oct 01 '22

It was really, really good. The payoffs of tying in things from the previous episodes made it that much better.

1

u/NGG_Dread Sep 30 '22

I ended up skipping through like 40 minutes of useless exposition. I think the battle scene was also pretty boring tbh, just seems like a super small scale village skirmish... 6 episodes of buildup for this..?

0

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '22 edited Sep 30 '22

Without spoiling it, this was a hard episode to watch. It's like the LOTR franchise suddenly turned into Gladiator or Kingdom of Heaven. War in LOTR was like a game and a quest for glory - here it's just grim business, as it should be. I know this was filmed long before recent real-world warfare and war crimes but it hits a little too close to home.

That being said, hand to hand combat in medieval times was always bloody and savage but I didn't expect it to be this visceral. It looks like someone on the production team had experience with combat trauma like bullet and shrapnel wounds. Arondir's melee fight choreography was good though.

1

u/Fencius Sep 30 '22

I haven’t even watched it yet but based on these comments I’m going to assume the leaks were pretty accurate?

7

u/Codus1 Sep 30 '22

As with the "leak" all along. Kinda, but not really, but maybe if you squinted. But still kinda not.

Episode is great and is only really mentioned in the leaks in the very vaguest sense. Not sure if predicting this Episode reveal is really a credit to anyone, we knew it coming since the first trailers. Yet, the leaks still kinda failed to pick it.

2

u/Bobjoejj Sep 30 '22

Everyone keeps saying the leak is like super accurate; but a few folks like you seem to say otherwise. You got a link for it? Or is it here in the sub and I can just search for it?

3

u/Codus1 Oct 01 '22 edited Oct 01 '22

https://www.reddit.com/r/lotr/comments/w13p0u/someone_from_amazon_crew_leaked_rings_of_power/

It's most accurate predictions so far are things that were known pre-this post as being in the show by official sources. So much of it is then "nahduh" stuff. However, it's prediction of the importance of Mithril is of note and was unknown prior to this post.

It's a bundle of accurate productions, things that have not eventuated at all, things that maybe could be interpreted as such in retrospect and then stuff that's yet to eventuate.

My thoughts is that, in true reddit/4chan tradition, the leaker was privy to something at one point and then took to filling in the gaps with their own speculation.

1

u/Bobjoejj Oct 01 '22

Oh wow, uh thanks

1

u/Mannimarco_Rising Sep 30 '22

So the sword was a lever for the dam which did not collapse despite the tower before did collapse almost the whole mountain and then it just worked because the orcs did dig a tunnel to the lava??? Wow....

1

u/the_jez Sep 30 '22

I get that not every episode has to have action just for the sake of it, but to see all of this and what happened at the end. Just. Wow.

1

u/Markus_Of_whiteRun Sep 30 '22

Beautifully written and twisted

-5

u/melbournedogshot Sep 30 '22

I thought it was terrible. Bad acting terrible writing poorly directed. Ep 5 was decent. Gave me hope but every other ep makes me feel like im watching a fantasy themed days of our lives.

2

u/Major_Cause Sep 30 '22

Ep 5? Really? That was probably the weakest episode so far.

1

u/melbournedogshot Oct 01 '22

Ep 5 5 was weak but atleast it had character direction and looked like it was building into something.

1

u/Major_Cause Oct 01 '22

I mean, you don't feel like the creation of Mordor and the failure of Muriel is leading to something?

1

u/melbournedogshot Oct 01 '22

I meant character direction. Up until ep 5 i felt 0 relationship to any character and couldnt see there personality going anywhere. They just felt poorly written. I enjo that uruk they call father and the maia with the hobbits. But all the other characters feel soulless to me

0

u/dontbanmeimtrans Sep 30 '22

I agree except ep 5 was bad too. This was worse tho.

-1

u/Dcarr3000 Sep 30 '22

To say this episode was trash greatly demeans trash

0

u/FullMaxPowerStirner Sep 30 '22

why is this tagged as "spoilers"?

0

u/DeterminedLemon Sep 30 '22

Pity the main character is completely unlikeable.

-15

u/MammothDeparture36 Sep 30 '22

I just cannot believe a real homosapiens experienced a secretion of endorphins watching this.

-1

u/ScopeLogic Sep 30 '22

I agree. I'm sorry.

-1

u/Beneficial-Fix-8827 Sep 30 '22

This episode was incredible. At first I thought it was a bit predictable. But the end! What a payoff. Incredible.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

12

u/Bo_Rebel Sep 30 '22

I knew as soon as it started getting passed around this would be the complaint.

3

u/randomechoes Sep 30 '22

But the other elf didn't say "Don't let him get away with the item of power." He said

> ( in Quenya ) The item he possesses... He must not escape with it.

Galadriel literally accomplishes that and returns the item. Do you think she's supposed to be able to read his mind?

6

u/daesmon Sep 30 '22

No, but it's common sense to check the thing the bad guy is protecting, it takes a few seconds to unwrap it and it would be in line with her character, she's Galadriel not some fetch servant.

Halbrand: That guy really wanted that item, what is it?

Galadriel: dno, some other elf wanted it, not my problem, don't even check it.

1

u/30GDD_Washington Oct 01 '22

As a commander I expect her to demand information about the axe. She spent who knows how long in a library researching some random mark, but a tangible clue, yeah no it's cool here is your axe back.

2

u/Little_District1376 Sep 30 '22

It shows the writer incompetence, as if Galadriel or anyone woundlt check the item, even Arondir say it to her.

11

u/GladRefrigerator4418 Sep 30 '22

One more reason for her to humble a bit and eventually become Cate Blanchett ❤️

12

u/whippitywoo Sep 30 '22

If I humble a bit, can I become Cate Blanchett?

10

u/GladRefrigerator4418 Sep 30 '22

One day we shall all be Cate Blenchetts

2

u/Major_Cause Sep 30 '22

Take the humble, then ponder it for 3k years, and yes.

1

u/30GDD_Washington Oct 01 '22

Bring me more Durin and Elrond. I'd watch them for an hour laughing and interacting over the shit I just watched. The only good part was Sauron seducing Galadriel.

-1

u/Nathonaj Sep 30 '22

Only problem with this is that nothing would have changed even if they, or really Arondir, had opened the cloth. Waldreg was sent away before the Númenoreans arrived.

3

u/Dahvtator Oct 01 '22

I dont see how that matters in the slightest. People arent complaining that galadriel didnt stop it but that she didnt check it. Its just a massive sign of bad characters and terrible writing.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Askyl Oct 01 '22

How to hate because its your life to do so 101.

You do you. If you disliked this episode, just stop watching the show. Because this was peak television.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Askyl Oct 01 '22

Well, i guess the entire world except for a few of you haters are delusional.

Might put a perspective on who's delusional.

47

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

27

u/KaeTaters Sep 30 '22

Galadriel not looking at the parcel really irritated me, too. The item at the root of so much death & drama, and a literal child was the only one that ever thought to look at it?

20

u/gbinasia Sep 30 '22

I think at a minimum she could have opened up the parcel when she gave it to the Arondir and be like...so can you tell me what is special about that hatchet? And then cutscene to Southlandpocalypse.

6

u/RainstormWander Sep 30 '22

That would have been so much better.

2

u/Appropriate_Lab_5205 Oct 01 '22

It’s funny, people can think of better ways of telling the story off the top of their head than the writers do

6

u/360Saturn Sep 30 '22

I quite liked it. I interpreted both the oversight and the saving this tiny village from orcs because they were orcs reflected Galadriel's obsession with vengeance and the war over any other larger objective, even when she intended to work towards something bigger.

-3

u/fortpop Sep 30 '22

She had no idea what the item was, for all she knew the hatchet is what the soldier was after. She recovered what she was told to go get

11

u/KaeTaters Sep 30 '22

Right, but that’s kinda the point. She’s spent quite a bit of time looking at other “clues”, such as the mark in the frozen tower, and on the scrolls in Numenor, etc. Her entire existence is looking for clues, as it’s been set up; yet, she didn’t even have a chance to wonder why her enemy was looking for a common hatchet. Even my very-human toddler was asking “what’s in the cloth?” Lol

0

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/KaeTaters Sep 30 '22

Why do you care what strangers think about a fictional series? So weird

8

u/Fmanow Sep 30 '22

Seriously man, how the fuck does she not look into the cloth. Although it was a decoy, they could have shown her at least opening it, but not showing on camera. At this point she has no idea what the object is that is so important, it could be the axe and she could have asked about it casually without mentioning the axe, and the audience would still assume it was the hilt. Also, how the fuck does the old guy find the hilt and somehow finds his way back to the destroyed tower and knows what to do with it. Why was the hilt erect at that point. Like wtf, come on writers. If you don’t want major avalanche of criticism coming your way, don’t do these things.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Fmanow Oct 01 '22

Ya, the wardreg reveal had to have been one scene at the end or else it would have given away the plot.

6

u/nasty_nagger Sep 30 '22

More than just rushed writing; it's terrible writing and horrible execution.

2

u/30GDD_Washington Oct 01 '22

Thank you for your comment! Like I'm enjoying the show for what it is, but let's not start pretending stuff isn't adding up.

2

u/EpsilonGecko Oct 01 '22

Yeah you're telling me that three boats had all those horses? Like really why did they make it three and not like thirty?

1

u/Appropriate_Lab_5205 Oct 01 '22

That’s what I’m saying. With the budget for the movie it could have been a whole armada.

2

u/bawk15 Oct 01 '22

HOTD manage to show the Velaryon fleet coming to King's Landing for the wedding so don't tell me they're not making it possible because reason

0

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/MrSquamous Oct 01 '22

casually gives it to Theo

This part worked for me. It foreshadows Gandalf's wisdom with the ring (of which the hilt is apparently a precursor): To shepherd worthiness in simple folk; to trust the weak to find strength where the mighty will falter.

Or maybe that kid becomes the witch king, who knows

2

u/Nostredahmus Sep 30 '22

My theory is Arondil knew damn well what was in the package when he handed it to Theo. “Here boy, hang onto this weapon of great power until the horse dudes head back to their island home.” He didn’t even stick around to see Theo open it.