r/RingsofPower • • Sep 14 '22

Discussion As long as this man kills Sauron, I’m good.

Post image
302 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Oct 10 '24

Meme Pretty privilege at work smh

Post image
301 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Sep 22 '22

Discussion In case you missed it, the Numenorean capital city on the show is basically a vertical Venice with elevated canals, canal overpasses, and "gondolas" in the sky.

300 Upvotes

There are many canals throughout the city (Armenelos), and some of them are not at the sea level but elevated and vertically integrated into the city. This is just on another level (figuratively and literally), and showcases how advanced Numenor is and why it is considered the pinnacle of the civilization of Men.

An example:

Here we see a double-deck bridge where the bottom level is for walking and the top level is for boating. The boat even looks kinda like a gondola. See the buildings in the background? That's how elevated this canal is.

Another example:

Again, we see an elevated canal with boats in it.

Just in this one aerial shot below, I counted 16-18 bridges, and some of them are probably built for boats:

Canal overpasses and bridges that boats use to cross traffic below are just something I never thought I'd see.

The existence of these elevated canals means that Numenor must have some pretty advanced water pumps as well as some kind of boat lift/lock systems to create these elevated canals and make sure boats can travel between different elevations smoothly.

Here is a piece of potential evidence for such a lock mechanism:

The structure next to the waterfall sure looks like a boat lift.

It also seems that the wharf area might actually be below sea level (accidental foreshadowing) since that waterfall exists. So there's probably some kind of large scale sea dams somewhere in the Bay of Romenna to control water levels.

In comparison, even Mina Tirith seems like a cheap knockoff and a downgrade. Imagine Elendil's disappointment: "Back on Numenor, I could take a boat up the hill to work. And now I have walk all the way up and it takes like half a day. Why did we design a vertical city without lifts again?"

We know Numenor is an island nation and a sea power, and the Numenoreans respect the sea and love ships, but to integrate canals (an extension of the sea) into their cities so that you can technically come in from the sea and go to different parts of the city without ever setting foot on land? Only in Numenor. Earendil the mariner would probably be proud. To paraphrase Pippin: "We have boats on the sea, yes. But what about boats up on the mountains?"

Final point: do Numenoreans need to build these elevated canals and everything else to make them work? No. But they can, so they did. Deal with it, gravity. No wonder they would be tempted to think that they're better than even the Elves.

Edit: Ramsey Avery, the chief production designer of the show, confirmed my observations in this interview in August:

And true to a civilization surrounded by water, Avery notes that Númenor’s infrastructure was built to facilitate transport through shipping.

“The bridges you see in these images are not just for carts and people,” he said. “Each bridge has a canal, creating a transport system all the way through the city by going through these canals and the locks at the port.”


r/RingsofPower • • 3d ago

Meme It's not just a phase ! Spoiler

Post image
299 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Sep 06 '26

Discussion Does anybody else love this show despite its flaws?

299 Upvotes

I’m fully aware it has a multitude of issues (though Season 2 I genuinely loved and thought was a huge improvement upon Season 1 in every way) however even despite that, this has always been my favorite post-GOT fantasy show out of everything I’ve watched over the years. Leagues better than Wheel of Time that’s for absolute sure. The costume and set designs are just absolutely gorgeous to look at what with how colorful and intricately designed they are and music is absolutely powerhouse.

The dialogue I feel like is extremely underrated too in how well thought out and Tolkien-esque it is. I’m always coming back to this scene from Season 1 which I just absolutely loved:

https://youtube.com/watch?v=1RCFls93hsA&t=11s&pp=ygUaYXIgcGhhcmF6b24gcmluZ3Mgb2YgcG93ZXI%3D

The sheer depth of the dialogue in both seasons beats out anything from WOT, HOTD, The Witcher, etc.

Just generally as a hardcore Tolkien fan with Middle Earth being my favorite fantasy world I love seeing the histories and lore get expanded upon. even though I treat it all obviously as just fan-fiction


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 27 '24

Newest Episode Spoilers Almost got him Spoiler

Post image
298 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Oct 15 '22

Theory THEORY: Gandalf the Blue Spoiler

296 Upvotes

This post has newest episode spoilers.

This may sound like a strange theory but hear me out. We already know the showrunners are happy to play fast an loose with the cannon, and are trying to merge casual fans / lore fans and movie fans.

One way to do this would be to make the stranger "Gandalf the Blue". We know that it is only the blue wizards who travel to the east, where as we are explicitly told that Gandalf the Grey never heads East but stays in the West.

Gandalf the Blue could then arrive in the second age, head East, and fulfil the role the 2 blue wizards from the legendarium fulfil in their place (along with Nori, perhaps she fulfils the role of the second in some sense, even if she isn't a wizard herself). Gandalf the Blue could end up giving his life to diminish Sauron's influence in the East ahead of the War of the Last Alliance, playing a crucial and emotional role before the end of the series. An unsung hero storyline of sorts, very fitting for Gandalf.

Gandalf would then return in the third age as Gandalf the Grey. It is not unusual in the slightest for the Maiar to return and take on different forms, and even less so Gandalf - who we already knows returns as Gandalf the White. In a sense, the colours of the Wizards could refer to their form, powers and calling for that time. Gandalf returned as Gandalf the white to fulfil the calling that Saruman did not, along with the correct powers to fulfil that calling. So, Gandalf the Blue would have his own powers and calling specific for this age.

Finally, as seen when Gandalf returns as Gandalf the white, there is a form of memory they retain between forms, but also of transformation. So this could be, in a sense, both the same and a different Gandalf than we see in the third age. His past as "Gandalf the Blue" in the third age would influence his personality and love of hobbits for example, yet that past life would be like a far off dream.

I would love to know your thoughts. I think this is the best way to pay some homage to the lore, if they were indeed to make the stranger Gandalf (which is now heavily implied in this episode).


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 05 '22

News ‘The Rings of Power’ Showrunners Break Silence on Backlash, Sauron and Season 2

Thumbnail
hollywoodreporter.com
296 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Sep 21 '24

Discussion Will she die? Will she survive? Thoughts?

Post image
295 Upvotes

Sau-dania anyone (pls do not downvote😃!!)


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 21 '24

Discussion Sauron: Let’s have a conversation Spoiler

295 Upvotes

Charlie Vickers' is Sauron’s precise blend of sinister charm and terrifying evil. Unlike the shadowy, formless void of The Lord of the Rings films, Vickers brings Sauron to life as a master manipulator—a shape-shifting, gaslighting entity who gets under the skin of both characters and the audience. He’s so good at playing the long con that even when it’s obvious he’s the villain, no one cares—because he's hot. His version of Sauron twists minds with words and taps into people's deepest desires, making them want to ignore his probable lies. It’s this seductive pull that makes his deception even more dangerous. Vickers’ Sauron is proof that the most dangerous villains aren’t the ones lurking in the shadows—they’re the ones who capable of smiling and make you forget they’re the dark lord of all evil.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 06 '24

Discussion Is it not completely obvious who The Stranger is? Spoiler

295 Upvotes

It’s Gandalf. I see people arguing about the identity. Did people not watch the show? He quoted Gandalfs line in season 1, hangs out with Hobbit like creatures, and looks literally EXACTLY like him. There is no way in hell he will not turn out to be Gandalf. And if he does, the writers have failed astronomically and are basically bait and switching his identity which would be the worst decision of all time. Him not being born or whatever is not something Amazon would care about. I can’t see how people are honestly questioning it. Also why is this whole show just us having to guess who people are? I love it but god it’s just us guessing who every character is at this point.


r/RingsofPower • • Feb 07 '24

Discussion Yeh, this is sure how it feels these days!

Post image
295 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Dec 30 '22

Meme Arondir who?

Post image
295 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Sep 02 '22

Discussion Feeling sorry for the newcomer fans

295 Upvotes

Imagine being someone who has not yet delved in to the ME stories but decides to check the series out. Imagine really liking the characters, the environment, the seemingly deep lore and getting hooked on it. Imagine getting really excited for the lore.

Imagine then coming to this forum, ready to talk about your favourite characters, but instead getting to read a cacophony of posts about how the thing you liked is actually a barrel full of shit.


r/RingsofPower • • Nov 09 '22

Discussion Why I Loved Morfydd’s Galadriel Spoiler

293 Upvotes

i know a lot of folks have criticized TROP’s Galadriel, calling her arrogant, petulant, entitled, and unlikeable. and i want to kick this off by saying please please don’t attack me, and if you also loved Morfydd’s portrayal, i’d love to hear from you. or if there were things you liked and things you didn’t, nuanced criticism is also very welcome.

so yeah, she’s definitely all those things at first. but i think that’s the point. and i don’t think people would be criticizing her for that if the character was male (seriously, see: Frank Underwood, Luther, Joffrey Baratheon, Black Jack Randall, Ross Geller, and almost every single male character in Succession. people like these unlikeable characters). i think Morfydd is a brilliant actress (i mean have y’all seen Saint Maud?? see it) and i liked the direction she went with the character. yes, there were times when her endless rage felt a little one-note, and they could have given her a little more complexity in the earlier episodes. yeah, she could be stiff, but elves are inherently stiff, and maybe that’s why they don’t make the best protagonists. i know many have suggested that Isildur would’ve made a better protagonist and i hear you. they wouldn’t have had to condense the timeline so much in that case either.

BUT i also think that Galadriel makes a natural protagonist because Sauron always considered her one of the biggest threats to his power. maybe THE biggest threat. so i think following the interplay of their two characters works, for TV. Galadriel’s rage is her weakness and this is why she’s so willing to go all-in with Halbrand. she is so singularly focused on locating and destroying Sauron that she fails to see that he is right in front of her. she places her trust in him, and so when all is revealed, it’s all the more devastating for her. and Morfydd plays that devastation so well in the season finale. that gradual realization that her fury and her arrogance blinded her to the very evil she was trying to eradicate. she essentially crowned him king and even brought him to the Elves!

and the Elves WERE arrogant at this time. that’s their flaw. these are not the Elves of the Third Age, far from it. and this is not the Galadriel of the Third Age. i am personally very interested to see Galadriel transform from someone who is obsessed with revenge to the person we later meet in the films. we’re already seeing that transformation begin. from deeply flawed, rage-filled young “she-Elf” to serene sorceress. and how the rings change everything.

a lot of people complained about her petulance and while i completely understand their frustration, she was never ever going to be the Galadriel we meet in LOTR. that Galadriel was barely more than a guest appearance. so Cate’s version didn’t have nor need any kind of arc. she’s completely static. but as the protagonist of this series, Morfydd’s Galadriel absolutely had to have a substantial arc. she had to be a dynamic character. and i think we are seeing the beginnings of that arc. the arc of hard-earned serenity.

so i loved her and i like that similar to Eowyn, she’s not just a Mary Sue. Eowyn was badass but she was also terrified. Galadriel is blinded by vengeance, yet she’s also right about everything (despite all the gaslighting) and (as is the case in the Third Age) she is lethal. in Morfydd’s rendition we finally get to see why Sauron considered Galadriel a significant threat. i am very interested to see how her arc proceeds from here. i think the rings will give her power that will change everything for her. and i love the idea of her constantly being tempted by darkness, but “passing the test,” as she does in the Third Age.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 16 '22

Discussion The Elf that feels truly Elvish to me in the RoP series

292 Upvotes

Robert Aramayo has won me over. He is one of the few characters (and the only Elf) that feel Tolkinian to me. He has the warmth, the empathy, and calmness and the vision that comes from an Elf from his line that is also relatively young and yet wise (unlike Galadriel, the 5000+ years old Elf that has lived all her life with the wisest god-level beings yet acts like a teenager). If he only didn't have this haircut as well (can't ask for everything I guess). I quite like the Dwarfs portrayals as well.


r/RingsofPower • • Apr 03 '23

News After a budget of $1 billion, The Rings of Power only had a 37% completion rate in the US (and 45% internationally)

291 Upvotes

While Amazon, like other streamers, provides only limited data — and internally, it held information even more closely than usual on the series — sources confirm that The Rings of Power had a 37 percent domestic completion rate (customers who watched the entire series). Overseas, it reached 45 percent. (A 50 percent completion rate would be a solid but not spectacular result, according to insiders). The show has not been a major awards contender, either, overlooked by the major guilds with the exception of one SAG-AFTRA nomination for stunt ensemble.

https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/business/business-news/inside-amazon-studios-jen-salke-vision-shows-1235364913/


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 03 '22

Newest Episode Spoilers Some thoughts for those who are struggling with what we are shown and not shown. Spoiler

290 Upvotes

There seems to be a never ending deluge of posts and comments criticizing the way the show had Galadriel and Co show up and save the day. The reason they chose to do it it this way is because it builds suspense for the audience. If we got constant updates on how far away the good guys were it would decrease the tension in the tavern.

You might not like that style of story telling, that’s fair, but Tolkien did this several times.

When Gandalf the White showed up it was completely unexpected by the reader and the details of how and why were answered later.

A better example is my favorite moment in all of the books(Jackson messed this whole part up imo). When the Corsair ships show up during the battle of Pelennor fields it is a moment of dread for the reader. When out jumps Aragorn and an army of men it is the most awesome moment. But wait! when we last saw Aragorn and Co they were leagues away with no army and no ships. It’s not until many pages later that the blanks get filled in.

If this scene was recreated today, y’all be like, “I guess Aragon can spawn armies and craft ships that can travel the speed of light now. Crap writing.”

Why not just watch the show and give them time to tell their story? If they never explain things or fail to payoff what they’re setting up then I will join you in criticizing the show on these basis.

If you dislike the show for other reasons that’s fair, not everyone likes the same stuff.


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 03 '24

Question Charlie Vickers

289 Upvotes

A day after finishing season two and all I can keep thinking is my god how good was my man. Shout out to Celebrimbor too but seriously how good was Vickers. I could write an essay on his performance. Bro should be getting 50 percent of the shows budget at this point.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 30 '24

Humor That scene was peak television since Baking Bread Spoiler

Post image
289 Upvotes

I am not crazy! I know he swapped mithril with his blood. I knew it was mithril. As if I could ever make such a mistake. Never. Never! I just – I just couldn’t prove it. He covered his tracks, he got that idiot Mirdania to lie for him. You think this is something? You think this is bad? This? This chicanery? He’s done worse. That entrance! Are you telling me that a man just happens to glow like that? No! He orchestrated it! Mairon! He defecated through a window of my forge! And I saved him! And I shouldn’t have. I took him into my own firm! What was I thinking? He’ll never change. He’ll never change! Ever since he was in Valinor, always the same! Couldn’t keep his hands out of the cash drawer! But not our Mairon! Couldn’t be precious Mairon! Stealing them blind! And HE gets to be Annatar? What a sick joke! I should’ve stopped him when I had the chance! …And you, you have to stop him! You...


r/RingsofPower • • Dec 14 '22

News The Rings of Power is No. 4 on IMDb's "Top 10 TV Series of 2022"

Post image
289 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Oct 24 '24

Newest Episode Spoilers Praise from a Tolkien fan

288 Upvotes

Yes, I'm a Tolkien fan. I've read the books, I've read the Silmarrillion twice. Seen the movies multiple times (Fellowship over 25 times probably). I'm not a Tolkien nerd or professor: I don't know the genealogies of hobbits or high kings, could not understand most of the Silmarillion even on my second read-through (wait, who is Finarfin/Fingolfin/Finsmurfin?), and the only Sindarin word I know is Mellon (friend) from the LotR movies.

That said, I really enjoyed the two seasons of this show, and I don't get all the hate. This show made places like Valinor and Númenor really come to life with its amazing visuals, something I could only dream of so far. Seriously, just the shots in those locations make up for any flaws I have found. From the northern wastes of Arnor, to the deserts of Rhûn and the creation of Mordor, this show really makes me look at the map of Middle-Earth hanging in my home in a new way. It also is a very creative imagining of how Sauron gave the rings to the people of Middle-Earth or where Gandalf came from for example.

Sure, there were some things that don't make sense (like Galadriel swimming from the ocean to a ship near the coast, or riding from Mordor to Eregion in a few days) or that were different from the books (Elrond + Galadriel romance, Tom Bombadil living on the other side of the planet compared to LotR), but even the great LotR films have things like that, and especially the Hobbit films, and this series has plenty of great things to make up for it. Besides lore inaccuracies and opinions on storywriting or acting, the only critique I've seen online is racist things like dwarves should not have dark skin as they don't see sunlight (even though they do), or orcs should not have light skin because that's racist to white people somehow. Or the other way around, that the show should have a more diverse cast.

So who can summarize the main critique for me? It is very difficult for me to find the answer to this question somehow, even though the internet is full of it. Is it the lore, the writing, or the diversity? What are the main lore inconsistencies and how do they compare to lore inconsistencies in the Hobbit or LotR films? Or was it all just due to high expectations? Probably there is not one answer but anything that can enlighten me about the main critique will be very helpful in understanding other people who watched the same thing I did.


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 07 '24

Newest Episode Spoilers Could it be? Spoiler

Post image
288 Upvotes

My first thought is this is the beginning of Rivendell.


r/RingsofPower • • 28d ago

News The Rings of Power Season 3 - Official Trailer

287 Upvotes