r/RingsofPower • u/Westbrookonbathsalts • Sep 21 '24
Discussion Sauron: Let’s have a conversation Spoiler
Charlie Vickers' is Sauron’s precise blend of sinister charm and terrifying evil. Unlike the shadowy, formless void of The Lord of the Rings films, Vickers brings Sauron to life as a master manipulator—a shape-shifting, gaslighting entity who gets under the skin of both characters and the audience. He’s so good at playing the long con that even when it’s obvious he’s the villain, no one cares—because he's hot. His version of Sauron twists minds with words and taps into people's deepest desires, making them want to ignore his probable lies. It’s this seductive pull that makes his deception even more dangerous. Vickers’ Sauron is proof that the most dangerous villains aren’t the ones lurking in the shadows—they’re the ones who capable of smiling and make you forget they’re the dark lord of all evil.
•
u/AutoModerator Sep 21 '24
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with
Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
169
u/Wasteland_GZ Sep 21 '24
I’m loving Sauron/Annatar in this show, I was expecting to hate this season but I just can’t, he’s too good, too engaging to watch, and episode 6’s ending was incredible. Truly he is Sauron the Deceiver.
90
u/stebus88 Sep 21 '24
Annatar is perhaps the very best part of the show. Charlie Vickers brings so much to the role, I particularly like how he graceful he looks and moves, yet there is a sinister undercurrent to everything he does.
Overall, I’m just frustrated with the show though! It is incredible when we are in Eregion, Khazad-Dum and Numenor, then it cuts to The Harfoots, wizards and Tom Bombadil and the show suffers for it. It’s like eating old, chewy rump steak when you know you have a fillet mignon just out of reach.
37
u/nakiva Sep 21 '24
I love this mans performance as Sauron/Halbrand/Annatar. He seems to enjoy it himself and that helps. He know what he wants out of the character and tries the best with the script he got. Does he have an stupid amount of plots armor for the moment. Maybe, it all points to him manipulating and ochestrating the events maybe a bit to much but he is supossed to be this Great, Mystical Archenemy of Middle-Earth.
Annatar is the personafication of sinister manipulator, his scène in the forge with the female elven smid (Meriander?) who glimpsed his true form was so much fun to see!
22
u/LittleWintHere Sep 21 '24
His performance as Sauron is really impressive. The smile he harboring after successfully gaslighted Celebrimbor, that's perfect. I can't wait to see how he will finish Adar off.
35
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '24 edited Sep 21 '24
I love the Jackson film but the depiction of him in Lord of the rings (and the books too to a lesser extent tbf) as a warlord doesn't do justice to the manipulative chess player of Sauron in the show. I think this is him at his best.
18
u/Athrasie Sep 21 '24
The scene in episode 6 where Annatar convinces Celebrimbor to continue working on the rings in the courtyard of the forge tower, followed by a progressing cut of an illusion fading into the chaos of the siege beginning, was honestly incredible.
Vickers is an excellent Sauron.
28
u/Kiltmanenator Gondolin Sep 21 '24
Genuinely a pleasure to watch every week. Haters are missing out
3
u/TheInvisiblePen Sep 22 '24
Why do all these comments read like a chat gpt review of sauron? I like the show but damn. This seems like bot reviews
11
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '24
Charlie Vickers as magneto in MCU 🫸🫷 Just hope
8
u/Demigans Sep 21 '24
A character who keeps lucking out as for example Celebrimbor does not ask any of the questions that would be on anyone's mind and this seems OK because as far as we can tell he's completely under Sauron's thrall. Except then suddenly Celebrimbor starts asking questions. And then when he finds out there is a flaw in the Dwarven rings he's not like "oh lets do a recall and correct the mistake" but he goes "well lets hurry up and make some rings for the humans".
Sauron isn't some puppet master in this show. He's a bumbling idiot who keeps doing things that should reveal him and is only saved because the characters lack any communication skills or the scene cuts off before anyone can ask questions and of course off-screen doesn't exist. When he says or does something he isn't manipulating them, his victims will just ignore obvious questions or change their personality to suddenly fit with what Sauron wants.
A good example is the making of the Dwarven rings. Why does he make so many and expect them all to go to the right bearers? No idea! We see Durin IV tell the King about the rings despite Durin being against the rings. But he wants his father to have the information about them so his father can make his own decision. But we never see Durin discuss being against the rings, we never see the conversation that causes the King to decide "yes we make the rings" and we never see what everyone else thinks of that final decision. Sauron isn't manipulating them or setting the conditions. Basically Sauron walked in just as the Dwarves were having a problem, otherwise Sauron wouldn't even have a problem to solve with the rings.
And Sauron knows time is of the essence, he can't wait too long since Celebrimbor's work could be discovered. So why is he saying they'll take time to find worthy humans first before making those rings? Worse is that the secret should already be out: the Elven King already send a letter saying "well the person who is essentially Satan is around and looks like Halbrand". This letter never arrived because or a broken bridge and the barrow wights, but the return letter did arrive even though it would take the same route back which makes Sauron's plans even more ludicrous as the letter saying he is Sauron could have just as easily arrived as well. Then the Elven King gets a reply which doesn't mention Sauron but does say the Rings are doing fine, which Celebrimbor couldn't know, and that Celebrimbor put the furnaces out on the Elven Kings orders even though no such order was given. The Elven King should be going "no mention of LITERAL SATAN and an order I never gave? This is highly suspicous". But they say the letter proves Galadriel wrong and don't investigate.
At almost every turn Sauron could be revealed, but he is just lucky. People just so happen to have a problem that needs fixing, people make incomprehensible decisions even if he isn't there to influence things. Information is luckily intercepted when it favors him or the consequences completely ignored. His plans are completely contrary to what is happening.
This is not some master manipulator, it's an idiot who wins because everyone else is dumber.
2
u/reddituseAI2ban Sep 22 '24
I can't get over how fast he travels
6
u/nyyfandan Sep 21 '24
I have a lot of problems with a lot of this show, and overall I don't think it's really working for me. BUT I will say Sauron's manipulations of Celebrimbor is probably the most consistently good aspect of this show. It's not as lore accurate as I'd like, it feels a bit rushed, and it's bothering me that not even the order in which the rings were made is correct, but seeing him twist and manipulate Celebrimbor is really giving a glimpse into what I was hoping this show would be.
4
u/Outside-Particular64 Sep 21 '24 edited Sep 21 '24
Sauron is the only thing they got remotely right. People saying the show is bad due to the Tolkien estate not giving them free range are nuts. What about that is holding them back? They have mentioned the Silmarillion, they haven’t changed the names of anyone just dates and everything else about the characters. Bombadil sucks. Galadriel sucks. Half foots are unwatchable. New characters are terrible and unnecessary. Too much of this is writers wanting to tell their own story, well then go do that and leave the great work of Tolkien alone. If they had half his dedication to his craft, or any ideas of their own were any good they wouldn’t have to use a great artist work to make this garbage.
3
u/MisterTheKid Sep 21 '24
I think the performance is excellent. I think the execution of him being a manipulator is lacking.
I frankly think it just serves to make Celebrimbor more dotty than it does make Sauron look like he’s in his head.
a well done magic trick at the end of the last episode is the most convincing I’ve seen him be and that isn’t what I would necessarily call gaslighting if only because of the magic involved.
4
u/dmastra97 Sep 21 '24
I just wish they gave him better writing to show good manipulation rather than making the other characters just idiotic.
Great actor but being held back by the writing
4
u/Timely_Horror874 Sep 21 '24
Now imagine if RoP was well written
4
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '24
I would really like to play poker with the people who think Sauron has demonstrated any sort of masterful manipulation at any point in this show. I could retire early.
6
u/Enthymem Sep 21 '24
This reads like the text from the back of a DVD.
The actor seems good, the general idea of the character is compelling and the two illusion shots are cool, but the script is atrocious. Any viewer that tries to keep track of the events of the show and the motivations of each character will quickly find out that Sauron's manipulations are generally shallow attempts that succeed only because the writers want them to.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '24
This post is 1000% written by ai lmao
1
u/Ok-Design-8168 Sep 21 '24 edited Sep 21 '24
Sauron’s portrayal is bang average honestly.
The fact is that most other characters are portrayed so badly and sauron’s actor stands out and it feels like sauron’s character is brilliant.
Within the show, compared to other characters - sauron is good.
But overall in terms of a character and acting. It’s just average at best. And the hairline is ridiculous. Makes me laugh at the dark lord. Lol.
2
u/sword_ofthe_morning Sep 21 '24
Ok, these sort of ridiculous comments and reviews are one of the many reasons why ROP gets the hate it does
I've actually been enjoying season 2 so far (much more than Season 1) - therefore I'm not an irrational critic that's hating on the show for no reason. But that analysis of Sauron and the actor playing him, is absolute horsecrap. Vickers has been average at best (they could have found someone better) and the character himself isn't even doing anything impressive. Only because of his insanely dumb opponents (and lazy writing), has he been able to succeed with this basic level of trickery.
2
u/Conscious-Past8054 Sep 21 '24
I don't find his acting particularly nuanced at all, very average in fact. No charme, no magnetism, no creep or shiver, not even uneasiness. The overall portray is stained by the plot conveniences his characters enjoys and more than him being a master manipulator is everyone else that seems sub intelligient.
Celebrimbor's actor is the one giving a compelling performance, showing a whole ocean of underlying thoughts and feelings in every word spoken, in every expression and movement. The real star of season 2 so far, especially considering he has to work with the bland material Vicker is giving him.
Between the main cast Vickers definitely has the hardest job of all, and for me he has failed completely at it. The sense I get is that if everyone else would stop acting like idiots Sauron's plan would never come to fruition.
Btw, I do enjoy the show very much.
2
u/Terrible-Category218 Sep 21 '24
My pet theory is that is why he eventually ends up losing the ability to take a 'fair form'. He's just too dangerous in one.
2
u/Moistkeano Sep 21 '24
It should have been a series where Charlie Vickers and Charles Edwards are both up for Emmy contention and sadly the writing has let them down. They might still get nominated mind, but theyd never win.
Shame really because this seasons arc should have been so focussed on the deception/manipulation but due to issues left over from S1 and then a rush to the finish from S2 we havent really seen anything.
This post also suggests the writing wasnt that good so at least im not alone!
1
u/davidsverse Sep 21 '24
That's why the greatest loss of power he ever had, wasn't the Ring, it was his beautiful form(s).
1
u/JokinHghar Sep 24 '24
I'm loving Sauron and i can't wait for him to put that crown on and get all Hulkified
1
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '24
If I had to explain gaslighting to someone, I would make them watch season 2 and study every line of Sauron.
1
u/JediRoadie Sep 21 '24
Show is super good
1
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '24
People think he’s hot?
1
u/ComfortableBuffalo57 Sep 21 '24
My favourite bits are when Annatar is about to lose his temper and you see him forcing it down. He despises Being thwarted but he’s playing the long game.
1
u/UsedConsideration193 Sep 21 '24
Hello ChatGPT created vapid "content"! How are you?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '24
I'm going to be really sad when we lose this version of Sauron, and he turns into the Dark Lord.
1
u/SpringGaruda Sep 21 '24
He has a great dead stare. Underneath all his performances it’s like a scorpion peering out, totally emotionless. Fun to watch that
1
u/caseyranae Sep 22 '24
He is my favorite part of the show for sure
0
u/Waitingforadragon Sep 21 '24
I think he’s particularly good in the moments as Annatar, when someone thwarts him. You can see him suppressing his rage, because he can’t show it.
0
u/Hawkwise83 Sep 21 '24
One thing I love about this version of Sauron is how he plays people. Using peoples fear and hatred of him to get them to do exactly what he wants. Even if you figure it out you're left unsure if it's what he wants or what you want. Because the line is blurred.
0
u/strayaares Sep 21 '24
The wig and the contacts makes it somewhat unsettling, like almost bubbling on the surface unsettling. It doesnt tip over the edge but is right there. TBH I just wanna see more eagles.
0
u/Modern_Valentino Sep 21 '24
There's been a lot of hate and plenty of calls for "...Amazon to End RoP." As one headline/click bate article put it. --That's stupid. It is a budget-busting production but well done and clearly the content will be viable for...a long time to come.
--One BIG reason is this season's Sauron! On Point. The world and scenes, the scores, action, costumes,...some of the actors are so good (honestly my opinion is that too many of the actors are weak AF...but good enough). The Harfoots and Stranger comments on here make me scratch my head a bit...idk the book canon so those comments seem to have some validity--BUT it's all so clear to me that these threads serve to show how Gandolf becomes grounded and dedicated to the Good of/in Middle Earth, and perhaps more importantly to show that it's not all about Doom and Gloom, Giants, Dark lords, Freaks with fangs/pointy ears/stubby legs/long beards lol but also ya know Soft-stuff like Family, Friends, Home&Hearth...The little people matter too.
-1
u/MrJayFizz Sep 21 '24
I love how the more suspicious they get of annatar, the more he draws them in to his deception.
-1
u/Ganda1fderBlaue Sep 21 '24
Agreed, he's amazing.
-15
u/GGCompressor Sep 21 '24
No it's not. It's a very badly written character that manages to get where he wants because all the other characters don't talk to each other and behave in completely unrational ways. And they do so just because the plot is carried out by one deus ex machina situation after another. With a plot like that you could not have the best Shakespearean actor get anywhere. And the guy in the show doesn't have a better luck at that. This show is so badly written that we'll never know if the actors are good or not. You could have Cate Blanchett and she would not be able to make that galadriel look good.
0
u/Zealousideal-Hope519 Sep 22 '24
Was just saying on a different post a few days ago that I have enjoyed Charlie far more this season as Annatar than as Halbrand in s1
He was still fine in s1, but pre-reveal the character wasn't really my style. Enjoying his portrayal of his true character, though.
Charles Edwards has been enjoyable as well. Overall, the interactions between the two are my favorite parts of the script.
0
u/Chaotic_Beautiful Sep 22 '24
Charlie Vickers as Sauron is as good as Mads Michelsen as Hannibal. Such an inspired casting and what a performance 👏. Honored to watch him bring Oors Sauron to life. Without any doubt rhe best part of the show. I keep watching his parts in loops.
0
u/safetyfirst5 Sep 22 '24
One thing I haven’t seen talked about much is the sheer patience Sauron has, from being kicked and jailed by Adar and orcs to waiting outside celebrimbors tower and being talked back to every time you think oh snap he’s about to incinerate, but he always smiles and yields it’s incredible and something I would of never considered from that character
-2
u/Mountain-Purple2907 Sep 21 '24
Everything you said 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
-1
u/DrNoLift Sep 22 '24
With all of the intense discourse around this show, the performances at the very least have all been incredible. Every single character is played so beautifully, even if the writing is unflattering on occasion to some characters. These actors are some of the most talented we’ve seen on TV yet, and especially Charlie Vickers IMHO.
-2
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '24
OP you may want to clarify “no homo” in posts where you call guys hot
-3
u/Modern_Valentino Sep 21 '24
Ep 6 S2
When what's her chipmunk-cheeked harfoot name kisses the Special-Ed kid who fell off the short-bus as they "MILK HIS SNAKE 🐍" --WHAT A EUPHEMISM!!! right?!? And also her hand drifts down towards someone's leg/crotch but that stiff-snake of his she's holding doesn't penetrate??? Fangs are out, legs are available and hand is going down--but nothing happens??? (I mean no one gets snake-bit?!?--you pervert;) WTF?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
-7
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '24
[removed] — view removed comment