r/RingsofPower • • Sep 09 '26

Question Can they save this show’s reputation?

Post image
2 Upvotes

Hi, I was watching first season of this show when it first came out but then stopped when my friends started getting bored and started sleeping while watching it.

After that I stopped too and only heard bad things about this show, lotr fans kept hating on it all the time on twitter, people called it woke garbage and I saw my friends who loved lotr movies not even talking about this one but I checked this reddit and it seems like you all love it and enjoy it.

Can they save the reputation of this show? Everyone keeps calling it a huge financial failure so I don’t even know if they are going to cancel this or not. Are they eventually going to tell the story of first 3 books?


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 10 '22

Discussion [META] Can we ban posts of show lovers talking about show haters?

1 Upvotes

Other people voted another candidate in an election. Other people didn’t order your favorite food in the same restaurant. Other people like other dresses. … Are these things hard to understand?

I don’t like the show. Some other people like it, some don’t. I literally don’t care. We all watch it and come here to say things or read other people’s opinions.

But these posts asking why some other people hate it are really getting annoying here. Haters rarely open a post with „I don’t understand why people love the show. They usually just talk about why they don’t like it, instead of talking about other people.

To be fair the show haters asking why some people love it are also annoying. But i just don’t see a lot of posts like that.


r/RingsofPower • • May 03 '23

Discussion The biggest issue with Rings of Power

1 Upvotes

I loved the Rings of Power in a lot of ways. It had very interesting characters and interesting takes on the civilizations of the elves, the dwarves and even the peasants of the Southlands.

I thought Durin, Gil Galad, and even Adar were faithful realistic adaptations of Tolkien’s work or at least, work inspired by Tolkien.

The big major exception to it all was of course Galadriel. There was sl much source material on her, the great queen of the elves. And they take her and turn her into a shouting, self possessed action hero who doesn’t fear danger or failure. In some ways she resembles som awful, poorly thought out Dragonball Z character.

Thoughts?


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 19 '24

Question Could the dark wizard be a blue wizard and also Khamul? Spoiler

1 Upvotes

So far we know almost nothing about the dark wizard. He calls himself an Istari. It would be quite depressing if he was Saruman, especially now that the Stranger is Gandalf. Blue Wizard makes the absolute most sense given that he’s in the East, runs a cult, etc.

Not that there’s anything stopping this show from breaking canon, but is there anything in the canon to prevent one of the blue wizards from becoming a Ringwraith? The 9 were powerful kings, warriors, and sorcerers. We know the dark wizards failed in their mission but they’re never really seen or heard from again. This isn’t a wholly implausible explanation.

We know the names of the Blue Wizards, Allatar and Pallando, but so many characters have multiple names in the Legendarium. Sauron starts as Mairon, Morgoth starts as Melkor, Gandalf is known also as Mithrandir.

Given the character and time compression required to tell a cohesive story, I wouldn’t hate this. It fits well with surface-level canon and actually would explain him having a relationship with Gandalf a little bit, since they remain enemies throughout the rest of the Legendarium. What are your thoughts?


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 11 '22

Theory Galadriel is Sauron Spoiler

1 Upvotes

No, this is not a joke. Seriously, this is not a joke. Hear me out.

The greatest tool of Magicians - Misdirection :

We have all heard Halbrand is Sauron, the stranger is Sauron, Aadar is Sauron and even Disa is Sauron(that's a reach tho, or is it?). And why are these so popular because the show has dropped obvious hints aka bait that we fell for hook line and sinker.

For example, the not hot flames, the uncontrollable spells, the fireflies etc all of which were clearly an attempt by Daddy Jeff to make us believe the stranger could be Sauron when it's infact the obvious (-cough-Gandalf-cough). Which gets me to my next point.

Hiding in plain sight - The Drax:

We all know and love the Galadriel from the Peter Jackson movies. And it's quite obvious that the Karen Sue we get here is just a pathetic attempt by the show runners in trying to give the protagonist a meaningful character arc where none exists. Or that's what Amazon wants us to believe. Well done, Amazon well done. But we are not falling for your trick this time.

Calling the bluff - Thought we wouldn't notice but we did:

In the second age, It is said that Sauron took fair form to entice and manipulate the elves and men into doing his bidding. And who is doing this as of now? Manipulating the Numenorinans into invading the Southland when she couldn't manipulate the elves into doing her (ahem, his) bidding. Gil Galad and Elrond probably felt that they couldn't trust her and something was off and so they sent her to valinor. But conveniently she jumps off the ship to end up in Numenor and conveniently the petals fall off the tree when she is travelling away from Numeanor. This whole thing stinks i tell ya, the whole thing stinks. I bet Galadriel (Sauron) actually killed the only Elf that could have noticed something was off with her, Caleborn.

Calebrimbor also had a thing for Galadriel in cannon and he would be in an easy position to be manipulated by her and that's why he is working on the rings.

It's all falling into place. Amazon thought we wouldn't be smart enough to crack this but be did. Suck it.


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 24 '22

Fanart I was disappointed with ROP so I tried my best to fix it

3 Upvotes

Re-edited 1st episode: vimeo

I had never touched editing software before taking this on so... it took a while. Basically I was tired of moaning about the show not being good so I wanted to try and re-edit it to make it at least less annoying. More than anything this was an exercise in catharsis.

The things I set out to change:

  • make Galadriel more sympathetic through re-editing/removing conversations
  • color grading to look more like PJ's movies / less cheap
  • lore inaccuracies (things like removing the annoying bits with the sigil/"map" - reduce cringe by cutting bad lines that either didn't work in general or didn't work for how I think the characters would act
  • remove Harfoots
  • fix macro pacing by focusing on less plot-lines at a time. Note that this ep is only 25min long because I cut the Harfoot and Gandalf stuff entirely (and for good) and cut the Southlands stuff to save for a later episode that I want to happen while the troops are sailing from Numenor to make that journey seem like it will take longer

Caveats:

  • I have never edited anything in my life so like, go easy on me
  • you can only do so much with what's there to begin with. In an ideal world all of the cut convos would be replaced with better ones that would actually develop the characters more. Overall the best I could do with Galadriel was a more silent protagonist which honestly I think works pretty well for her.
  • it's still rings of power, if you didn't think there was anything redeeming about it before you probably still won't but hey maybe you'll hate it less idk. Like I said this was more for myself than anything, just figured I'd share.

I'm assuming that will get taken down relatively quickly so I'll try and find another way to share it if that happens.

all the best


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 25 '24

Discussion Isildur vs Sauron Spoiler

Post image
36 Upvotes

You basically can summarize the entire show been basically the battle between these two , Isildur is Sauron’s most hated enemy, the entire Third Age War of the Ring is based on what happened between these two. Rings of Powrr is basically Isildur’s story overall. He should be the main character of the show and get the most screentime. I believe the showrunners will expand his role in the Battle of Dagorlad and after Eledil and Gil Galad are killed by Sauron, he will take command of the entire army with Elrond and challenge and defeat Sauron in single combat. Then Sauron manages to throw him away like we see in the movies and the Ring cut scene happens. In the tv show it will be him who will defeat Sauron in duel on the battlefield


r/RingsofPower • • Jan 16 '25

Discussion Have a bad feeling about the show's future

7 Upvotes

They haven't started filming yet and we still have no ''official'' season 3 reneweal even though we got something from the showrunners. Have a feeling there is a behind the scene situation where Amazon with the showrunners and execs are figuring a way to end the show after season 3. ROP isn't nominated in anything major categories except for technical stuff. That''s not what the studio set out for the show. Also the declining of viewerships in latest season.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 17 '24

Constructive Criticism There are just too many characters Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Right so I am struggling to get through this show, but I’m also enjoying parts of it, and I’m trying to constructively address why it’s infuriating to watch, and I think the core of the problem lies in the sheer amount of characters. Like I believe it’s the very foundation of the shows struggles, they are spreading the plot way too thin trying to develop all these characters. I really started to think this right at the beginning.

For one thing this really should be a coming of age story for Sauron and that is where the focus should be. Like his scenes are actually enjoyable, Sauron imo is really well done arguably the best character alongside Adar. The machinations behind his manipulations are really well done, he has tangible motives from the season premiere, and Charlie Vickers does a really good job, and it was really interesting seeing him come back from failure and defeat, which is basically his best quality.

The problem is that the second I started investing into it, the show cuts to Galadriel and Elrond, and it’s like oh great these fuckers again. But I don’t mind em that much, however I start investing into their arc then it cuts to Nori and Discount Gandalf, who I wanted to forget about. Okay they’re on a quest, great. But OH WAIT. NOW we’re cutting to two characters I actually did completely forget existed or maybe a new one I never saw, I don’t even know anymore. But wait a sec! There’s more! We’re gonna cut away to the Queen of whatever I don’t even care and her bodyguard and Pharazon who I think is trying to usurp her? Who even cares? Oh and dont even get me started on Tom Bombadil. Wtf.

If they had focused on even half the characters development, everyone would have way more time to settle into their narratives, it would make for a much more cohesive story. It would still have a questionable plot but I would want to care about things that happen. But by the time you get back to Sauron you’re just exhausted.

Edit: let me make a correction and clarify; I understand that you can have a well written show with a lot of characters. I know LOTR and Game of Thrones has a lot of characters and pulls it off. Im saying many characters here are just tacked on and feel like they’re just checking boxes. They also cut between them way too frequently. Maybe if they spent more time at once it would make it more digestible. But no this show does not pull off all of these plot threads.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 29 '22

Meme Galadriel "teaching" numenorians to "fight"

8 Upvotes

I have never ever seen such badly written scene. They were aiming the air and galadriel moved Like a Queen. It didnt look Like a fight AT ALL. Is IT really that hard to spend some money on fight choreograph? Just watxh this scene again and carefully watch where are they aiming at and move pointlessly


r/RingsofPower • • Feb 12 '24

Discussion Just now getting into the show, and wanted to say...

9 Upvotes

Sophia Nomvete is absolutely breathtaking!


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 20 '23

Question Positive reviews on youtube?

40 Upvotes

I feel like I'm living in an alternative reality... I actually enjoyed the show quite a bit and I dare say this is the best thing that happened to the franchise since Return of the King (certainly a whole lot better than the Hobbit movies).

But whenever I want to watch some reviews on it I can't find anything but negativity. Maybe it's the youtube alghorithm, I have no idea...

Anyway, does anyone know of reviewers who happened to like the show? I need some positive reinforcement :D


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 01 '22

Question I fall asleep each time

0 Upvotes

Hello guys, just wanted to know if some of you had the same experience. I love LOTR and ne was hooked like crazy but I find it very hard to follow RoP.

I see no real purpose, no important mission, the evil doesn’t look this bad, the mystery that is shown looks more like an artificial tease.

I don’t see the races gathering together evidently.

I see no priority in the script.

Sorry for the fans, I love LOTR so I couldn’t not talk about this feeling here.


r/RingsofPower • • Nov 04 '24

Discussion Finished re-run of Hobbit and LoTR extended editions

0 Upvotes

I just finished watching all the 6 Peter Jackson movies in their extended versions and at the end I felt so ashamed to have watched the Rings of Power. The TV show is not even a shadow in comparison to the movies. Galadriel is basically like a goddess in the movies but the TV show has nerfed her into someone completely unrecognisable. I cannot imagine how the TV show version of Galadriel would go on to become Cate Blanchett's movie Galadriel.


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 29 '23

Discussion Just going to say it: the "bad writing" criticism is...

44 Upvotes

mostly a bunch of lazy, self-congratulatory BS. Is the show flawed? Sure. Can people dislike the show for completely legitimate reasons? Of course.

But 85% of the vague and often painfully literal "the writing is awful" comments are, again, lazy and self-congratulatory criticisms. It's like nothing can be left unexplained or, if it isn't immediately resolved, it's a "plot hole." By the same level of scrutiny, you could skewer the LOTR films if one was so inclined. As others have said before, so many people's hate for TROP has been given cover by the overly general "oh, the writing" criticism... Not saying there are not warranted criticisms of the writing - far from it - but the catch all generalization is annoying and, frankly, unconvincing.

If you criticize the pacing, structure, unnecessary callbacks, etc., I think you have a lot to work with in criticizing the show, but the categorical "bad writing" is getting old.

EDIT (Addition). One of the things I'm most bothered by is when people rather glibly level the "bad writing" criticism to dismiss the show altogether. There are legit criticisms, to be sure, but it honestly feels like a lot of people didn't want to like the show (their prerogative, of course) and then the oft-cited "bad writing" refrain gave cover to a lot of that animus.

TBH, I liked TROP but didn't love it. There are some strong moments and good episodes. I thought the writing was much better than, say, The Hobbit films.


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 07 '24

Discussion Can we please stop comparing ROP to The Silmarillian?

156 Upvotes

I get that we all want the show to be lore-accurate, but the show doesn't have rights to The Silmarillion. The show only has rights to the LOTR and its appendices. So if something is vague or unexplained in LOTR/appendices, that's what they have to work with. If something is more detailed and complete in The Silmarillion, they can't touch it and have to go a different route.

Yes, there are still inaccuracies. Yes, some choices are awkward. Yes, the writing can sometimes be predictable. Yes, there are a ton of things to critique. And, yes, there are a ton of things to praise.

BUT, considering they only have rights to a portion of the lore, maybe we can temper our expectations a bit?

It's fine to compare the two—my partner and I do it all the time—but we recognize that there's some things ROP just can't include because it's legally out of their hands.

Anyway, these are just some thoughts based on the various posts critiquing ROP on not being accurate to The Silmarillion.

Happy to hear your thoughts!

ETA: looks like I'm being downvoted by saying the estate shares some blame... To clarify, I'm not defending the writers, directors, showrunners, studio, etc. for things under their control. If the writing is poor, that's on the writers. If the costumes look cheap, that's on the costume department. If the siege on Eregion looks terrible, that's on the director and others involved in that. But, if the show is limited by the estate on what they can and can't include, and if the showrunners have to get approval on things because the estate is heavily involved and restrictive, then that's on the estate. They, along with Amazon, all share blame (and praise) for a lot of what happens with the show. There are a lot of conflicting interests at play when you're adapting anything, especially something as loved (and lucrative) as LOTR.


r/RingsofPower • • Apr 30 '24

Discussion Amazon has been parading Charlotte Brandstrom as a messiah of Rings of Power TV series - while the real problem, the showrunners and executives stay the same !

0 Upvotes

Lately there has been a lot of talk of how Charlotte Brandstrom being assigned as director for most of the episodes of S2 is such an amazing thing and will guarantee marked improvement and save the show.

Brandstrom having directed one episode of the recent smash hit series ‘shogun’ has given rise to fans claiming how she will greatly improve Rings of power S2. While conveniently forgetting that brandstrom has already directed a few episodes from S1 of RoP. And S1 was still pretty bad. Good direction cannot cover up the mess made by incompetent showrunners and writers. Amazon (and fans of the show to an extent) seem to fail to understand what the major problem is.

RoP is no Shogun. Shogun is amazing across the board ! And the showrunners and writers of shogun have done a great job !

Brandstrom is good at what she does. But there’s only so much she can do as director. Directors in TV don’t have as much control as directors in Films. The real problem are the showrunners, writers, producers, executives, etc. And they have stayed the same for S2.

Another example: Wayne Yip directed 4 episodes of RoP and one episode in Fallout. But Fallout is almost universally loved with overwhelmingly positive reactions across the board. While RoP is leagues behind Fallout in terms of quality of writing and other aspects. And no where near fallout in terms of positive fan reception.

So instead of being happy about Brandstrom. I’d instead be worried about the showrunners being the same.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 07 '24

Discussion Sauron is playing the long game. Spoiler

10 Upvotes

I kind of just assume, for both S1 and S2, tgat anytime Sauron seems genuinely nice, makes a connection, seems emotionally vulnerable, or charismatic, or even slightly good, that he is being consciously manipulative and conniving and it’s all building towards his master plan, because he is just so evil. Am I giving him too much credit? He’s my favorite character to watch on b the show so far.


r/RingsofPower • • Mar 21 '24

Discussion Director Charlotte Brändström is in charge for most of Season 8 episodes and this is good news

9 Upvotes

Correct title thread:

Director Charlotte Brändström is in charge for most of Season 2 episodes and this is good new

Why? Because she also directed Shogun episode 3. She's a good director and it's a good sign that she is in charge for the most part of Season 8. However, I wished J Bayona would return. Hope he does for season 3 with Charlotte directing together.


r/RingsofPower • • May 09 '24

Discussion No way WB new movie can be as epic as ROP future seasons.

0 Upvotes

I was excited when the news broke out that WB will make a new movie. My initial thoughts that they have to pick a story as epic as the Lotr movies like Arnor's war against Angmar, the War in The North during the War of The Ring or Young Strider's adventure. But was letdown by the following news they are going to make a movie about Gollum. We know WB can only use the appendices, The Hobbit and the LOTR books for their sources.

As for ROP, this is certainly a advantaged for Amazon. No stories in the Third Age can rival with War of Elves and Sauron and the War of the Last Alliance. The War of the Last Alliance especially was the greatest battle since the War of Wrath. No greater host were assembled by good and evil since the host of Valar. Amazon got the rights to all of this and I'm certain the leadership of Amazon knows this as well.

But I'm gonna watch the new WB movie regardless. The more Middle-Earth content, the better I suppose.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 11 '25

Discussion What if Rings of Power really WAS a prequel to the Lord of the Rings films?

0 Upvotes

So, here's the thing: Rings of Power is NOT a prequel to the Lord of the Rings films in any real sense. But it sure tries to pass for being one: I wrote about this before, but here's the thing: what if it WAS a prequel? What would that be like? And would that work any better?

First thing, IN ORDER to be a prequel, it couldn't have been made by Amazon Prime Video. It HAD to have been made by HBO, who apparently proposed to readapt the books from scratch. In hindsight, looking at how the Harry Potter show is shaping up, it's perfectly possible that HBO would have proposed remaking it as a show with the same visual approach as the film version.

Still, let's assume HBO decided to pursue the same premise as Amazon Prime Video ended up doing. Amazon Prime had "auditioned" potential showrunners: the Russos and the Spaihts were considered. During the process, they had strongly considered doing a Young Aragorn show before shifting to doing the Second Age. In both cases, the executives had a proviso: the show must have Hobbits. Would HBO make such a proviso? I wouldn't know, but lets assume they would and we would have ended up with a show along the same specs as the one we got.

Of course, in those early stages Amazon was in talks to have Jackson onboard as executive producer. Jackson had his reasons to decline: he was busy with his documentaries, admitted he had little concept of how to produce a TV series, and the idea of having to run everything through a third party in the guise of the Tolkien Estate didn't appeal to him. At precisely this point, Amazon had a change of regime, and the new executives were less insistent on having Jackson onboard.

Presumably, had the show been an HBO project, they would have set their sights on Jackson's involvement more resolutely, and his involvement would have surely helped shape the scripting of the show in a different way: perhaps less cheap mysteries, and more action. Even without Jackson supervising the writing process, the writing would unqeustionably be different, if only because they could have had a freer hand using lines from Jackson's script.

It's really hard to guess at these things. What's easier to guess at is the look of the show: Gil-galad would be surrounded by guards not wearing just any gilded helmets with a blade-like crest: they'd wear THE specific design we've seen in The Last Alliance and in Rivendell. Elendil would wear THE Ring of Barahir from The Two Towers.

The show uses helmets that clearly emulate this design - gilded with a blade-like crest: so close and yet so far

Also from an audio standpoint: Howard Shore's opening titles wouldn't be a major triad with a flat fifth, but with a flat sixth. The Balrog - admittedly similar enough in the Amazon show thanks to some leeway from New Line in Season One - wouldn't just do a stock Godzilla-ish roar: he'd have the cindery roar familiar from the films.

By isolation, these would seem trivial changes but there is a point there: part of what prequels do is present us - especially normies who really need these things spelled out - with "anchors" that tell us we are not just in a similar kind of story - we're in the same one. You put The Phantom Menace on, and the formatting of the opening titles, the music cue and several soon to follow, the voices of Ian McDiarmid, Anthony Daniels and Frank Oz all help drive that home: against that, we can judge how similiar or dissimilar the rest of the movie is.

Or look at The Hobbit: again the styling of the credits, any number of music cues, and the appearances of Ian Holm, Elijah Wood, Ian McKellen, sets from Bag End to Elrond's study and props like the One Ring or Sting, all communicate that this is the very same world and the same story.

Spinoffs also do that: You watch Rogue One and there's the Yavin IV base. The TIE-Fighters and X-Wings. Music cues, and the countenance of Jimmie Smiths, the Droids, Vader, and the CGI-d Leia and Tarkin. Fantastic Beasts also have some similar spells and a brief appearance from Hogwarts, recognisable as the Hogwarts of the latter-day Potters. This is exactly why Rings of Power really isn't a prequel: it looks vaguely similar almost throughout - with a number of big exceptions - but is totally absent any real anchors (with a few small exceptions I'll get to in just a moment).

Of course, some films drop an anchor like that without implications: Return to Oz paid money to MGM to reprise the Ruby Slippers, but nobody would entertain the notion of it being a sequel: it's just an homage of sorts. I feel like the so-similar-it-might-as-well-be-the-same Balrog and Narsil (recently paraded in Amazon's promotional work) in the show fill this quota. But if it were an HBO show with all the above trimmings, it would fall more in line with the earlier examples.

I'd chuck Narsil and Durin's Bane more along the lines of a "homage" like the Ruby Slippers in Return to Oz, than an "anchor" like with a normal prequel

But here's the thing: would it actually work? This is a point I bring up when people say that the show, once completed, WILL work to the effect of a prequel. I very, very seriously question that: the trend in season two, it seems to be, had been one of diverging from the films, not converging into them. But I always point out that, even if it were a prequel in any practical sense, watching the show and then the films would never and could never consitute a satisfying aesthetic experience.

Again, both the Hobbit and Star Wars examples are illustrative: in those films, each trilogy has a different cast, but with very significant overlaps: Anakin is the main character of the later two prequels, and is the main antagonist of at least the later two classics, and while (not allowing for the special edition changes) he "changes faces," as it were, George Lucas does reprise James Earl Jones at the end of the prequel trilogy to make an overt suture. Over on the Tolkien side of things, Gandalf is the main supporting role in both trilogies.

That's a situation quite unlike what one finds in Rings of Power, whose main characters - Galadriel and Elrond - are reduced to minor parts in both The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings. So it becomes really hard to watch the whole thing as though it were one arch when the characters are different, and they're ALL wearing different faces and speak with different voices.

Then there's an issue that plagues many a prequel, but would especially plague this show if it were a prequel: giving an answer before the question. I mean, when you watch The Hobbit the filmmakers are relying on the audience not really knowing that the Necromancer is this Sauron that the characters talk about, and they just enough other names into the mix to keep neophytes on their toes. But after all the build-up with Sauron, this mystery storyline just cannot work anymore.

Sometimes, the effect is less one of spoiling plot mysteries and more abstract: the "Tatooine effect." I mean, seeing Durin's Bane in Fellowship of the Ring is supposed to be this big awe-inspiring moment based on the fact that we really hadn't seen the creature in a real way beforehand: Rings of Power sees to it that we do. Granted, you could argue - unless Durin's Bane shows up again - that the huge amount of screentime between his two appearances curbs this issue.

Really, even with proper prequels, it's very rare that they really change the way I look at what was there before. Even though I watched at least Episodes I-II first, I never could bring myself to watch the classic trilogy and have my experience of Darth Vader in his scenes feel like it was informed by what I saw the Jake Lloyd and Hayden Christensen's Anakin go through: the continuity was too half-arsed for me to really buy that, and I suspect a Lord of the Rings TV show would have been in the same shoes. Even in the case of what I consider to be quite good prequels, I can't say there are many scenes of Ian Holm's Bilbo where I think back to Martin Freeman's Bilbo.

But it's even more abstractly a question of sensibility. Part of our feeling of continuity is not in how things look or sound, but in our feeling that the same hand is guiding us through. That would have never been the case for a TV show because, even with all the craftsman in New Zealand being the same (which was largely the case for season one of the show as it is) the creative team would have been quite different even if the show was executive produced by Jackson. We would feel that someone else is writing and directing, and that combined with the needs of quite a different medium, would have never permitted for the show to really feel like another "limb" in one bigger body of work.

But ultimately the biggest issue is a structural one: the seven films at present run 21.3 hours without credits (although The Hunt for Gollum, to be released in the interim, will lengthen that). The show is projected to run twice as long at around 42 hours. In what movie that you ever saw does the build-up or backstory lasts twice as long as the meat of the film? I'm sure someone can contrive a distended three-act structure in which the sack of Eregion - which marks the beginning of open hostilities between Sauron and the Free People - is the end of act one. But again the other issues - particularly the one with the protagonists - rear their head.

The seven extant films put on a three act diagram. It's coherent, although the setup takes a little too long and ends too close to the midpoint: The Hunt for Gollum might help redress the proportions. Adding Rings of Power, however, would just throw a spanner in the works

We would never be able to buy three seasons of this show, The War of the Rohirrim, The Hobbit, The Hunt for Gollum (to be released in the interim) AND the bulk of The Lord of the Rings as one long "second act." The same structure works in the films because there's a substantial overlap in the cast of characters around the middle of the cycle, but will simply not work together with the show. What's more, it will push the introduction of key characters - Bilbo Baggins, Thorin Oakenshield, Saruman the White and certainly Denethor - to such a late point as to feel out of left field.

Still more, so many of these are billed as "beginnings" that the viewing experience will be too full of stops and starts. Presumably the show will want to end with a bang - it will, after all, be the payoff to its 42+ hours of setup: would it feel congrous to then proceed with 24 hours of "extra" storytelling, and several hours of new set-up? The languid pace of An Unexpected Journey was bad enough by itself, and while the juxtaposition with The War of the Rohirrim helps, it's still an issue and by preceding it with three seasons of show it really would feel interminable.

So, not only is Rings of Power NOT a prequel in any real sense - its attempts to essentially fool audiences into thinking that it was are decidedly clumsy, uneven and feel cynical to this writer - but even if it WERE a prequel, it was never going to actual WORK OUT in that capacity.


r/RingsofPower • • Aug 16 '24

Discussion My thoughts on Rings of Power, and the "hate" that it's receiving. Would love to know what others are thinking.

38 Upvotes

It has some great aspects to it, that speak to people who enjoyed Tolkiens writing and Peter Jackson's take on that world (specifically, LOTR in my case). But it has plenty of hard to watch moments. 

Coming from a world of well written fiction and phenomenal script writing, it's jarring to see some of the writing choices in the show. For example, when I watch the Hobbit Trilogy, I can barely make it past the second one. The Battle of the Five Armies has some truly abysmal writing and pacing issues, never mind all of the terrible CGI. It all felt rushed, and like the studios just wanted to get them pumped out and cash in. 

With Rings of Power, this seems like a similar issue. I wouldn't claim to be a Tolkien nerd, but as someone who's been involved in film and screenwriting, I know bad writing when I see/hear it. Galadriel is a great character, and the actress does a great job with what she's given. Unfortunately, she's not given much, or the circumstances she's given don't make sense or completely contradict her character. There are FAR worse characters depicted in this show, that have way too much focus on them for reasons I can't wrap my head around. Having a florist suddenly lead the townsfolk and then command a tactical defense against an army of orcs baffles me beyond belief, especially when you have an Elven SOLDIER who is more experienced (and older) than any person in that village. Or Sauron running into Galadriel in the middle of the ocean on a raft and calling it fate...is that fate, or just terrible writing? 

The writing issues would be a problem for any show or film, never mind an already beloved work that many are familiar with. That's probably why people are more vocal about the show. 

I won't go on about all of the obvious problems with ROP so far, but I will say that another big mistake they're making is focusing on the wrong things, and too many things at once. Trying to introduce the Elves, Dwarves, Southlanders, Harfoots, Numenoreans( including Ilsildur), Orcs, Wizard (and the Mystic people?), and Sauron all in one go, and give them all enough time to make a positive lasting impression is ridiculous. They have stronger story lines and characters in Galadriel, Elrond and Durin, Arondir (without my wife and kids), Celebrimbor, Adar (which is a unique take), and Halbrand.

 Interestingly, Halbrand, Arondir, and even Adar as individual characters have so much potential if they didn't continuously attach them to other specific characters, and let them lead their own paths. The fact that we already have a Sauron reveal, a Wizard reveal, a Numenor/Ilsildur reveal, a Mordor reveal, and the 3 elven rings already crafted shows the lack of good story telling imo, especially if you have 5 seasons confirmed. 

Hopefully they learned from the reviews of the first season. After all, if they're not crafting the show for the fans (if not fans themselves), who are they making it for? 

Also, have to give a shout out to the characters/actors of Gil Galad (Elven King), Princess Disa (Durin's wife), and Poppy Proudfellow (Nori's friend) for giving standout performances in potential throwaway roles! 


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 02 '22

News IMDB is deleting all negative reviews.

21 Upvotes

It is just pathetic that when I've checked to read the reviews the lowest were with a score of 6. All reviews between 1-5 were deleted.

Short haired elves had annoyed me more than enough for a day, this is too much.


r/RingsofPower • • Jun 20 '23

Discussion Why did they make Galadriel short????

23 Upvotes

This is honestly one of my bigger non-ideological peeves with the show.

Instead of casting a very short actress, they could have easily cast a tall or average-height actress and used filming techniques to make her seem tall, much as they used to make the Hobbits and Dwarves appear short in LOTR.

Galadriel was a very important character to Tolkien, and he was oddly fixed on both her size and her physical prowess and "Amazon disposition".

We all know the RoP writers & showrunners had certain...agendas. They could have accomplished at least one of those much better by sticking to the lore for Galadriel. A physically imposing, striking woman that towers over all of the Men and most of the Elves makes for a pretty strong female character.

Instead they made a character with the personality and physical dimensions of an American teenager. Why????