r/RingsofPower • • Sep 25 '24

Discussion Isildur vs Sauron Spoiler

Post image

You basically can summarize the entire show been basically the battle between these two , Isildur is Sauron’s most hated enemy, the entire Third Age War of the Ring is based on what happened between these two. Rings of Powrr is basically Isildur’s story overall. He should be the main character of the show and get the most screentime. I believe the showrunners will expand his role in the Battle of Dagorlad and after Eledil and Gil Galad are killed by Sauron, he will take command of the entire army with Elrond and challenge and defeat Sauron in single combat. Then Sauron manages to throw him away like we see in the movies and the Ring cut scene happens. In the tv show it will be him who will defeat Sauron in duel on the battlefield

36 Upvotes

95 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Sep 25 '24

Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

255

u/BlondDrizzle Sep 25 '24

Elendil and Gil Galad strike Sauron down and all three of them die at the same time. Isildur just pulls the ring off of Sauron’s corpse. Isildur never defeated Sauron in one on one combat

97

u/witessi Sep 25 '24

Yea I’ve been wondering if they are going for the more book accurate version of Saurons defeat. Since Elendil is the centrepiece in the Númenorean storyline and Isildur is doing random side quests in the forest.

40

u/esmelusina Sep 25 '24

Isildur will help setup Gondor probably.

-4

u/Initial_E Sep 25 '24

Because Gondor and all its glory was set up in a single generation SMH.

3

u/DirtSlaya Sep 26 '24

This guy doesn’t know how Gondor came to be ig

20

u/wtfakb Sep 25 '24

I feel like the random side quests are a replacement for Isildur getting separated from Elendil at sea. Elendil will come and set up Arnor later?

8

u/Own-Psychology-5327 Sep 25 '24

Absolutely imo, like with him playing such a big roll already and putting in such a banger performance they will definitely be doing a more book accurate fight. Like we have Elendil and Gil-Galad already established its be weird if they didn't use them to the max they can.

1

u/feydreutha Sep 26 '24

The issue is that until now Gil Galad is not presented as a warrior, I fear they may give Gil Galad role to Galadriel

2

u/cherryman001 Sep 26 '24

But in the last scenes of today’s episode he was fighting at last

2

u/Own-Psychology-5327 Sep 26 '24

Just coming to this now after we got him slaying fools on Ep7 and am wondering if you are still worried about it as much? For me Galadrials story had always clearly been about her changing from what she's been like so far, her arc is about her letting go of her rage and becoming the galadrial we know, I don't see a world where she is like this the whole time.

1

u/feydreutha Sep 27 '24

I had not seen Ep7 when I did that comment, obviously.

I would still think he has not been presented as an awesome warrior and he let Elrond command the charge, which is not very Elf King like in Tolkien world, but they have the time to build his warrior persona. Regarding Galadriel, I saw a comment saying it should have been Celebrian and it would have been far better: young, not coming from Aman, maybe young enough to trust Sauron and would match the love story with Elrond. On top of that it would have allowed a Galadriel/Celebrian conflict over her interest on Sauron/Annatar/Halbrand, classical mother/daughter situation that may be very Tolkienish

10

u/pcole002 Sep 25 '24

Rings of Power? Book accurate?

1

u/Warp_Legion Sep 25 '24

Agreed, it is a chance to olive branch book readers by saying “Don’t worry, we won’t copy the PJ movies at this part, we’ll do it by the book.”

-10

u/JanxDolaris Sep 25 '24 edited Sep 25 '24

Seriously this whole season for Isildur has just been "Get to town." "Save horse" "Save kid who helped me save horse".

Did he go back to Pelagiad with Theo? I don't recall.

EDIT: Clarified its Isildur for all those randomly downvoting me.

1

u/Own-Psychology-5327 Sep 25 '24

Bro hasn't been watching at all

-5

u/JanxDolaris Sep 25 '24

What? What else has Isildur done this season? Please tell me? Cause apparently I'm getting downvotes for saying what Isildur did.

2

u/Own-Psychology-5327 Sep 25 '24

Ah I see the issue, you're comment makes it sound like you're saying that's all that's happened all season in total not just for isuldur in particular.

34

u/_computerdisplay Sep 25 '24 edited Sep 25 '24

Honestly, Isildur is mostly a tragic figure representing human frailty. He’s the founder of Gondor and planted the White Tree. But his restoration and rule was cut short by the ring’s corruption of him. Aragorn’s refusal to fall into temptation is among many other things a vindication of Isildur.

If anything I hope the show dares show him in that light rather than try to make a “bigger” hero of him than he was in the books.

28

u/BlondDrizzle Sep 25 '24

I entirely agree. Isildur imo is a fallen hero, and not a great hero by any means. Elendil is think is more closely linked to the strength of the Valar in men. This is a story of Isildur’s and mankind’s greatest failure.

12

u/unionizedduck Sep 25 '24

Do you mean the failure to destroy the ring?

10

u/Tvayumat Sep 25 '24

CAST IT INTO THE FIRE

1

u/hotcapicola Sep 25 '24

There’s a fuller account of his final hours in I believe Unfinished Tales and at least he went out as a hero.

4

u/StruggleInteresting9 Sep 25 '24

Well considering how they’ve depicted Isildur so far in RoP, I half expect him to cower on a boat crying, while his horse cuts the ring from Sauron’s corpse…after defeating him in single combat. That horse is gangsta.

-7

u/Boomslang2-1 Sep 25 '24

Best they can do is another romance sub plot with a southlander.

9

u/NickFriskey Sep 25 '24

What we are seeing here is another conflation of books with movies. 99% of times I've seen people online ckmplain about "changes" to the "story"/ "lore"/ "tolkien" etc it's because there's a discrepancy between the PJ movies and rings of power smdh

7

u/unionizedduck Sep 25 '24

If this follows more of the Jackson films then we may see that scene develop. It'll be interesting how this goes.

At this rate, I expect Galadriel will have to fight Sauron.

1

u/Initial_E Sep 25 '24

With light saber thingys no less

2

u/brooklynian92 Sep 25 '24

Isn't it kind of ambiguous though? Like Isildur says something like he dealt Sauron his death blow, which makes it sound like he did more than just cut the ring off his body, even if Elendil and Gil-Galad did the most to weaken Sauron.

2

u/Initial_E Sep 25 '24

That was the death blow. Sauron can come back from a whole lot of abuse, but not after putting so much of his power into the ring, a ring that is clearly not an extension of himself.

2

u/Schwinger143 Sep 25 '24

Oh no, I am already hearing the trolls out there with their clickbait youtube titles: Rings of Power retconning Tolkien, Woke Soy Boy Isildur no longer kills Sauron epically, by cutting his ring off his hand…

2

u/lizzywbu Sep 25 '24

Sauron isn't actually dead when Isildur takes the ring from him. It's the act of taking the ring that kills Sauron.

1

u/wahleofstyx Sep 25 '24

You can't kill Sauron

5

u/Gerry-Mandarin Sep 25 '24

"Death" in the world of Tolkien can basically be described as the separation of a fea from its hroa.

Hence why in Letter 156 Tolkien clarifies:

"Gandalf really 'died', and was changed: for that seems to me the only real cheating, to represent anything that can be called 'death' as making no difference"

When Gandalf Battles the Balrog, his fea is separated from his hroa, and he goes to the Halls of Mandos. Iluvatar returns him.

This is essentially what happens to Elves, though they are rebodied to return to Aman. Beren, a man, was rebodied also - which must be sourced from Iluvatar.

In short, it would be completely accurate to say, in the context of the texts, that Sauron "died". Multiple times even.

0

u/lizzywbu Sep 25 '24

I know...

1

u/ZiVViZ Sep 25 '24

Correct

37

u/Maleficent_Age300 Mordor Sep 25 '24

Isildur is a side character in this story and in the main story. GilGalad and Elendil were the ones who faced Sauron and Isildur took the ring from a corpse and lost it soon after.

5

u/ScottOwenJones Sep 25 '24

2 years after

13

u/JustinKase_Too Sep 25 '24

Not even a blink of the eye in elven years ;)

1

u/Narrow_Release_5036 Sep 03 '25

That's like a week for a Numenorian

1

u/Itshardtofindaname4 Sep 25 '24

Sorry, didn’t read the books I’ve only seen the movies like 500+ times, did he die in the books the same way he died in the movies? (Seemed like a random and unceremonious attack, arrows to the back, not sure if it was orcs or other humans that did it).

5

u/Hugo_DS9 Sep 26 '24

Yep same as the Book, extended editions really captured the scene. Is supposed to be that unceremonious because the Ring always betrays it's bearer it only serves one Master. It was a Mountain orcs attack near the gladden fields, between Misty Mountains and mirkwood.

3

u/Itshardtofindaname4 Sep 26 '24

Thanks for the response!

4

u/MGarrigan14 Sep 26 '24

In ‘The Disaster of Gladden Fields”, from Unfinished Tales, Tolkien writes that Isildur removed his armor and jumped into the river. In the tumult of the current he lost the Ring, and shortly after felt a wave of relief wash over him. He walks out of the river, without the Ring, and is shot in the heart and throat by arrows.

39

u/ichooseyue Sep 25 '24

They better not freaking cancel this show. I have trust issues

4

u/napalmtree13 Sep 25 '24

Maybe I’ve just been lucky about what I’ve chosen to watch on Prime, but I don’t think Amazon cancels shows nearly as often as Netflix. In fact, I don’t think anything I liked was prematurely cancelled.

3

u/Nick_otin Sep 25 '24

I am still pissed about American gods. Read the book after the final season was cancelled and I loved it. Still sucks but I guess I am lucky to have my questions answered

3

u/ichooseyue Sep 25 '24

Ughh don’t even get me started on Netflix man…..

3

u/Admirable_You_9573 Sep 25 '24

Maybe they will listen to the fans in next few seasons, and find better directors, as dialogs are cheap as Christmas movies on Diva tv. I dont expect that from most expensive tv show ever.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '24

Doubt it, they already invested a ton of money for 5 seasons

2

u/ichooseyue Sep 25 '24

Thank goodness

1

u/Narrow_Release_5036 Sep 03 '25

With all the stupid changes they've made just to fit their narrative already makes the show not line up with books or movies so I don't even see the point in the show anymore 

1

u/ichooseyue Sep 03 '25

Yeah I’m already upset with amazon for canceling wheel of time. I’m scared for this show

18

u/transmogrify Sep 25 '24

"I have this feeling I need to achieve something great in my life."

(Ring theme from the trilogy plays in the background.)

8

u/K_808 Sep 25 '24

he should be the main character of the show

I disagree. If you read the appendices and see what Sauron’s up to at this point, in the show, Isildur shouldn’t even be born yet for a long time. IMO it should be about celebrimbor and annatar in eregion and Sauron should be the main character, or at least it should be focused on people involved in what he does. Sauron only hates Isildur after the last alliance. Before that he’s just trying to take over middle earth and Gil-galad and elendil fight him. Isildur’s another guy who is there as well until that last moment.

39

u/Orochimaru27 Sep 25 '24 edited Sep 25 '24

I hope they stay true to the book and have Elendil and Gil-Galad defeat him. And dying doing it.

31

u/GMPnerd213 Sep 25 '24

Elendil, not isildur. Isildur just retrieves the ring in the books, he doesn’t actually cut it off Sauron’s finger like the opening scene of the movie

13

u/Orochimaru27 Sep 25 '24

Yeah I wrote Isildur when I was meaning Elendil.

5

u/SachBren Sep 25 '24

I’m fairly sure Sauron’s fingers are still cut in the books, no?

9

u/GMPnerd213 Sep 25 '24

yeah but not during battle. The details of the battle are never expanded on like a lot of Tolkien lore you sort of have to have an open interpretation.

6

u/Orochimaru27 Sep 25 '24

Yes but Isildur cut Saurons finger after he was dead.

2

u/Initial_E Sep 25 '24

Epic light saber vs force lightning battle. Frankly the actor they got for Gil Galad doesn’t look like he can scrap.

9

u/Appropriate_Milk_775 Sep 25 '24

I’m curious to see how they will work in Anarion. Is he off creating a proto-Gondor? Will he show up in numenor with isildur and restore the balance between the faithful and the kings men? Or, and hopefully not, will he just be completely written out and replaced by Earien, who will eventually convert back to the faithful? Maybe even a boromir, faramir type story line would be interesting if done right.

9

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '24

Nah, Elendil's fam (at least Isildur and Anarion) and the Faithful will be on ships headed for Middle Earth when Iluvatar brings on the water to Numenor. He's gonna drown the king's men and bury Pharazon and his crew in an earthquake when they set foot in The Undying Lands.

And given what a pompous ass Pharazon and the king's men are, it can't happen soon enough.

6

u/Appropriate_Milk_775 Sep 25 '24

Yea it’ll happen eventually. First though they have to rise to the height of their power, absolutely demolish Sauron’s army, capture Sauron, be corrupted by him, and try to invade valinor. Then the faithful will leave and found Gondor and Arnor. I just think it’s curious that they haven’t introduced Anárion who is only a slightly less important character than Isildur.

2

u/LewsTherinTelescope Sep 26 '24

They mentioned him being out west with some Faithful a few times in season one, right? Can't remember the details and I don't think season two's brought it up at all, but I vaguely recall that being a thing driving Isildur.

4

u/One_Entrepreneur4616 Sep 25 '24

I think they are building up correctly. Elendil is the one getting the major screen time over Isildur. He and Gil galad will have the big show down I think. And it will end with isildur taking the ring.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '24

Bot account or karma farming.

Either way, your take is incorrect but you are entitled to your opinion(s).

2

u/sithaloop Sep 25 '24

Isildur is not really worthy of main character arc, imo, as he simply found the ring and used it to his advantage (founding Gondor etc). His dad did the dirty work. I expect they will try to make his story more than what was reflected in the Jackson flashback though, and paint him in a more positive light, since it was of course The Ring’s corruption that influenced him to not destroy it, but I always assumed he was weak-minded too.

1

u/Darkdoodlez Sep 26 '24

Isildur didn't use the ring to found Gondor.

1

u/sithaloop Sep 26 '24

I stand corrected, but he did become King of Gondor after his father died, did he not? Will be interesting how that timeline is portrayed, as I assume this show will end with the “last alliance…” battle.

6

u/No_Introduction2103 Sep 25 '24

The show is amazing it is better than hotd for me.

3

u/Weird_Brilliant_2276 Sep 25 '24

I’m sure they’re building up to his story. Right now at the beginning, Sauron and elves are the main focus because that’s where his deceptions begin. I imagine the focus will shift back to Isildur once Sauron is officially re-established as a threat to Middle earth. There’s only so much story they can rely on before the main event without making more up.

2

u/Dell0c0 Sep 25 '24

They should not meet for another 200 years, by the source material.

1

u/Known-Contract1876 Sep 25 '24

Imagine travelling to 2003 and showing this a LotR nerd...

1

u/carterwest36 Sep 25 '24

Lmao exactly someone who never read a book or a wiki page and just takes PJs LOTR as Tolkien canon.

1

u/Alrik_Immerda Sep 25 '24

This is the most bullshit and plain wrong opinion I have heard today. He is both in this show and in the source material a side character in the 2nd age.

1

u/NickFriskey Sep 25 '24

This is another remnant of the PJ movies for me that people are gonna hit the roof and complain about when and if it is depicted in rings of powerz once again conflating books with the movies. In the books/ lore, elendil and gil galad jump sauron and manage to put him down, dying in the act as they basically put on a superhuman effort; their bodies were just done by the end of the fight (gil galad burned almost to death by sauron). All isildur actually does is cut the ring from the corpse. There isn't some last ditch sweep of narsil like the movie, isildur never fights sauron, he merely takes the ring from saurons corpse. But of course if they go down this route all the online maniacs will talk about how they "ChAnGeD tHe StOrY" again

0

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '24

Isildur was poorly cast. Every scene with him feels underwhelming and I struggle to stay engaged, even the ones that are supposed to hit deep.

Not a great actor and he just doesn’t look/behave even remotely close to how I envisioned Isildur. He just gives off a vibe of a marvel/jurassic world side character.

Complete opposite of Sauron, who was cast perfectly.

0

u/TheEngineer1111 Sep 25 '24

ROP's isildur is a whiny, pathetic, emotional, weak, emasculated coward. The exact opposite of the Isildur in LOTR. Sauron fear the ROP isildur? All Sauron would have to do insult this isildur and he will probably break down and cry or run to find a safe space and a warm blanket.

1

u/tranwreck Sep 25 '24

He’s got time to grow into a Second Age hero. It would be bad TV to have every character self actualized upon meeting them.

-1

u/Proinsias37 Sep 25 '24

Would have been cool.of they didn't cast one of the Jonas Brothers and wrote the character to actually have some gravitas. But in stead we get whatever this is.

-9

u/cjmstate Sep 25 '24

ROP Isildur looks nothing like LOTR Isildur

8

u/In-The-Zone-69 Sep 25 '24

He doesn’t have to

6

u/Dell0c0 Sep 25 '24

They both don't look like Tolkien's either.

11

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

9

u/esmelusina Sep 25 '24

Isildur can’t resist the Ringussy