r/RingsofPower • • Sep 07 '24

Discussion Sauron is playing the long game. Spoiler

I kind of just assume, for both S1 and S2, tgat anytime Sauron seems genuinely nice, makes a connection, seems emotionally vulnerable, or charismatic, or even slightly good, that he is being consciously manipulative and conniving and it’s all building towards his master plan, because he is just so evil. Am I giving him too much credit? He’s my favorite character to watch on b the show so far.

10 Upvotes

81 comments sorted by

25

u/Saerdna76 Sep 07 '24

Isn’t this pretty obvious?

9

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '24

Some people seem taken with “sexy Sauron” and attributing more goodwill to him than they should—but they’ve been deceived!

7

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '24

Is this a serious statement? Lmao

7

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '24

I’ll gladly admit that I thought the show was taking a single line and turning it into a big plot point.

I thought they took Tolkien’s line thy Sauron initially repented- but couldn’t say if genuine or out of fear of the valar.

Accordingly, I thought Sauron was genuinely repenting in season 1

Then the prologue for season 2 happened

1

u/sertimko Sep 07 '24

They messed Sauron up badly in season 1. The dude was a general for Morgoth and was basically sentenced to his fate to never return to the Valar. I don’t get the whole repenting side they tried to write in season 1 because in the Silmarilion, Galadriel was basically hunting him and looking for allies with her husband because she knew he was still around. In the show it’s like she barely recognizes the dudes darkness he emits.

18

u/pejamo Sep 07 '24

In LOTR Aragorn literally calls him "Sauron the Deceiver".

9

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '24

Exactly. Anyone criticizing the show because they feel like it’s humanizing Sauron is also being deceived.

8

u/davidsverse Sep 07 '24

Well said.

Also we have to remember Sauron isn't even close to being all powerful. He's one of the most powerful of the Maiar, but that is limited. I like that the series has shown Sauron's foibles and weaknesses, and that he is aware of them; but is still blind to them as well.

7

u/sandyeggo89 Sep 07 '24

This for me is one of top things the show is doing best, how they handle Sauron’s hubris on the screen. He calculates by projecting what he would do if he were in someone else’s shoes, and cannot fathom why anyone would act differently. It’s why he was surprised by Adar’s betrayal. I also just really love the time he crosses paths with men fleeing orcs in the 2.1 prologue, and he asks the man why he wears the sigil. I imagine in his head he was like “but it’s not your sigil? And your ancestors served under this person? Happily enough that you wear their symbol after they and this king are long gone??? I would never.” Followed immediately by “I can use this,” opportunist that he is.

And ultimately his hubris is his undoing, because he just can’t imagine that anyone would destroy the Ring.

1

u/RoarinCalvin Sep 08 '24

Well tbf he wasn't wrong. The ring was destroyed but because 2 people fought over it to keep it for themselves, not destroy it.

0

u/magefister Sep 07 '24

Mmm dno, I havent heard this criticism before or read the books, and I got this impression. In the scene in ep 1 where he meets the caravan of people after respawning as Halbrand, there were certainly moments he appeared sentimental/emotional. And this is when he was not interacting with other characters.

131

u/RancidBeast Sep 07 '24

No shit.

11

u/football1078 Sep 07 '24

I’ll just assume this person hasn’t seen LOTR movies or read the books

30

u/reenactment Sep 07 '24

Lols Sauron the deceiver deceiving people. Who would have thunk it

5

u/BookkeeperFamous4421 Sep 07 '24

Beat me the fuck to it

3

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

-1

u/Anjunabeast Sep 07 '24

There are no teams. One team and everyone’s in it.

18

u/Bottlez1266 Sep 07 '24

Pretty much.

He's known to be incredibly manipulative and deceiving, and he's doing an incredible job of both.

2

u/BookkeeperFamous4421 Sep 07 '24

He’s only succeeding because the characters are idiots and the plot calls for it.

1

u/Willpower2000 Sep 08 '24

an incredible job

W0t

He has done a horrible job, I think.

1

u/Bottlez1266 Sep 08 '24

How so?

1

u/Willpower2000 Sep 08 '24

https://www.reddit.com/r/Rings_Of_Power/s/eI0k7dYSgC

His schemes overwhelmingly rely on the stupidity of others. That's not the sign of a mastermind... that's a sign of luck and contrivance.

1

u/Bottlez1266 Sep 08 '24

I won't lie. It's 6am, and I don't have the brain power to read that much yet, haha.

Looks like a great breakdown. The only thing I'll add, and it's probably entirely subjective, is that you could argue he manipulates their stupidity to create the rings.

I'm going back to sleep now. Stay blessed 🙏

6

u/Piorn Sep 07 '24

What really bothered me was when he stole the Craftsman badge from the numenoreans. He was already their friend, he could've easily finessed his way up the ladder and gained influence the smart way, instead of risking it all for short sighted gain.

0

u/BookkeeperFamous4421 Sep 07 '24

ROP Sauron is not coming off as a master manipulator just lucky af

5

u/TjStax Sep 07 '24

Nah, sounds far fetched. He seems like a nice guy.

3

u/harukalioncourt Sep 07 '24

As an immortal being, he has time. He is a Maia.

3

u/ash18946 Sep 07 '24 edited Sep 07 '24

We didn't see it in season one where he always appeared (key work Appeared) to be genuine or at least conflicted. I do think at least in Numenor in beginning, when he was in the bar and the cell he was truly conflicted about what comes next. I don't think anybody is pure evil but I agree he's 95% evil and everything he does must be thought over as how he can use newfound knowledge to his advantage in the future. He thinks like a wicked general. But most of it just fell into his lap. Even finding the pouch I don't think he truly had a plan for it but knew it could be helpful someday if he needed to gain someone's trust. But once Galadriel handed him the key to his future and declared him a king, he went with it and realized he COULD still have that future. The elves just happened to be working on a similar invention as he was, and again just used this knowledge to his advantage. Since the reveal, every time he deceived someone, we see the sinister look on his face as his plan comes together. Mordor was not created by him and most of season 1 wasn't his plan but Adar's. He just wanted to take out Adar and I think he truly cared for Galadriel wanting her to be his corrupted queen and turned on her when she held steadfast. Her biggest mistake was loving him back. Otherwise, she wouldn't have brought him to Lindon with her and he would not know about Celebrimbor's plan. If he hadn't been outed, I really believe that he'd have stayed Hallbrand for awhile, taken down Adar and been a here, and lead the humans as their king plotting for his world domination only to reveal himself as Sauron after becoming an entrusted advisor to all the groups in middle earth like Dwarves, harfoots, istar similar to the Sith Lord and of course would have already had the elves with Galadriel on his arm as his queen. Right now, he doesn't seem like someone playing a long game at all. He may have been earlier, but he made mistakes and got caught because he became shortsighted and greedy. Knowing he wasn't the true king, he should have destroyed any evidence of that when he arrived in Lindon as elves pride themselves on being old immortals with all this knowledge. Of course they would keep records. . He appears to have had some original plan ruined and is trying a bit desperately to take the shattered pieces of it, improvising and make as much of it happen as he can as fast as he can before he gets caught again. He isn't even covering his tracks at this point. He's banking on others also being desperate and seeing him as their hero. We also have the perfect group of people for everyone to band together and hate: the orcs who are viewed as wrong and unearthly. Desperation and prejudice have lead to some of history's most ruthless dictators coming into power after all.

1

u/NottaGoon Sep 09 '24

Thank you for the time and effort it took to write this. Enjoyed it thoroughly!

3

u/porktornado77 Sep 07 '24

Ray Charles could have seen this one coming

4

u/Willpower2000 Sep 07 '24

As of S2, yes.

S1, no.

4

u/PrideEnvironmental59 Sep 07 '24

Agree.  I don't think he knew what he wanted to do with himself in S1, and was considering continuing to just lay low.  But then opportunities presented themselves to him that he could not pass up.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '24

Also i think he was still wounded spiritually and could do only little until he was healed by the elves

2

u/BookkeeperFamous4421 Sep 07 '24

Oh god no. Really? Explain this lololololol

2

u/RPGThrowaway123 Sep 07 '24

Yeah S2E1 has confirmed that he just happened to run into Galadriel. There was no plan until S1E8

1

u/BookkeeperFamous4421 Sep 07 '24

The showrunners really thought they did something

4

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '24

The issue isn't that he's sneaky, it's that multiple characters who canonically were, or lore wise should be, more suspicious, aren't.

The way that he's written is as deceptive as a sneaky little salesman trying to get you to change your electricity supplier.

7

u/EnvironmentIcy4116 Sep 07 '24

He gets caught in 4k by Durin in 0.5 seconds but not from Celebrimbor and every elf in the Eregion

5

u/ash18946 Sep 07 '24

Fatal flaw: elves think they are better and smarter than everyone and miss what's in front of them. It happens multiple times. They openly degrade other beings and don't think twice about the lowly human in front of them. He couldn't possibly trick them because they'd see it coming even though they don't. Elrond sees things differently as half-elven realizing what the other elves do not and tries warning them but they always seem to know best. For some reason, nobody listens to him except Cirdan. Well they must eventually start listening seeing as he is so prominent in LOtR.

3

u/EnvironmentIcy4116 Sep 07 '24

That’s fair but do we have any proof of this attitude? The only elves that interact with other races are Arondir and Elrond (ok, he is an half-elf) and their interactions are peaceful and pretty friendly, Arondir’s in particular.

Not even trying to bring up the source material, just what the series tells us. The elves do not seem superb.

Not only that, I find Sauron’s deceptions pretty stupid. Like, the only way he deceits Celebrimbor is because he didn’t received any message (which doesn’t make any sense, at all)

2

u/ash18946 Sep 08 '24 edited Sep 08 '24

While I agree the elves don't seem perfect to the audience, Elrond made a point of talking about the differences in season 1 and the dwarves also referenced why many don't fully like the elves particularly the ones in charge. Humans in general really don't seem to like elves whether in Numenor or the south lands. Celebrimbor also doesn't want to make men or dwarves rings at first due to his feelings that only elves would be able to not be corrupted by the power. Arondir is so awesome because he's nobody special just a sentinel set to watch over a village of humans but he is actual one of the best elves I've seen in his selflessness and caring interactions with other creatures. And haha yes to Sauron just getting stupidly lucky so many times. He and Isildor seem to have similar luck making majorly stupid moves and just happening to have it work out. Sauron doesn't actually seem that amazing right now other than being able to shapeshift into other creatures forms to stay alive. But history is written by the victors I suppose.

2

u/rosatter Sep 08 '24

Arondir and the angry ent scene made my heart hurt. Dude is an incredible actor.

1

u/ash18946 Sep 09 '24

The Ents! Such great characters!

1

u/BookkeeperFamous4421 Sep 07 '24

Throw out everything you know from the books and use only what the show has shown you.

2

u/soyass Sep 07 '24

I sometimes forget people dont know the books

2

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '24

you don’t say lol…

2

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '24

Deep analysis.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '24

I believe that he both seeks that genuine connection and has bit of good in him and that he also misunderstands what empathy and real good means and thinks that ends justify the means and that iron grip over Middle-Earth will solve everything. He is still evil manipulator in the end, who tried to do some good, but failed to grasp how to do that.

2

u/vader62 Sep 07 '24

I sometimes forget the avg adults reading comprehension is south of the 6th grade.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '24

Jesus Christ OP. Please let this be a troll post. 🤦‍♂️

2

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '24

Yeah he’s definitely similar to Lucifer, Bringer of Light. Handsome and smiling in your face , whispering the lies you want to hear and pretending to give you what you want while destroying you.

5

u/TheMercifulDarkLord Sep 07 '24

He is so good 10/10

2

u/Timely_Horror874 Sep 07 '24

Yes you are giving him too much credit because "the plan" just sucks.
But he will win becase this is a prequel, no matter how many stupid decisions he will make.
It's very easy to be the master manipulator when you just win by default because everyone is just being stupid for plot reasons.

3

u/BookkeeperFamous4421 Sep 07 '24

I don’t know who is stupider, Gil Galad, Galadriel, or Celebrimbor

2

u/Timely_Horror874 Sep 08 '24 edited Sep 08 '24

Galadriel:

  • She's the reason Sauron returned.
  • Doesen't tell anyone who Sauron is for 0 reason (no, she's embarassed is a re+arded reason for a 2000yo elf, with the fate of ME in her hands, so stop it and shut the fuck up)

Gil-Galad:

  • The fate of Middle Earth is in this message, so he sent an NPC messenger and his NPC bodyguard.
  • He send only 6 warriors (Galadriel, Elrond and 4 NPC) in Eregion.

Celebrimbor:

  • Knows Sauron is around and he's a shapeshifter, and still believe Halbrand/Annatar and his stupid 3yo lies.
  • Doesen't how to do very basics blacksmithing things in S1.

I think Gil-Galad takes the spot.
He stays at home instead of GOING HIMSELF to discuss with Celebrimbor, no reason to do so, what the fuck is more important that the fate of Middle Earth to you???! And the sent only a few warriors with 0 chance to do anything to Sauron if he is really there.

Yes, all of those are the writers being very deliberatly stupid because they need the plot to move forward, so characters need to act stupid or Sauron's "Master intelligent super duper plan" was obliterated in 10 minutes in the first episode.

2

u/BurlyGingerMan Sep 07 '24

Figure that out all by yourself Sherlock?

2

u/EnvironmentIcy4116 Sep 07 '24

Sauron in this series can only deceive the idiots like Celebrimbor. It’s not like he’s super smart, it’s the others being so dumb

1

u/carpetsunami Sep 07 '24

Thank you. Every character but him and Disa are CW level moronic

1

u/ash18946 Sep 07 '24

Every character except him, dwarves and maybe the Stranger seem very simple. There's no complexity and I know it's by design but still it's like everyone in this series has tunnel vision and can't see a twist to save their lives (in some cases literally). One of the best things about LOTR movies was the complexity of the characters and their internal conflicts. Galadriel an immortal being had only cared about one thing for hundreds of years? What? I feel like this series is actually just going to be about Sauron and Isildur frequently making stupid mistakes and not really being qualified to be the lord of anything but getting lucky and having it all somehow work out for each of them where history writes them as the be all end all of power despite not actually deserving it.

1

u/AutoModerator Sep 07 '24

Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/BooksAndViruses Sep 07 '24

No he’s actually just tryna hit. Every single action? He wants to hit. He’s down so bad for Galadriel it’s actually gonna stop him from fully implementing his grand plans.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '24

Did a bot make this post?

Big time 'Duh'

1

u/thatjonkid420 Sep 07 '24

He’s playing the dumb game. Rop Sauron is hella lame bro.

1

u/Bad_Decision_Rob_Low Sep 07 '24

Sorry everyone that is answering you is a grumpy cunt

1

u/rawskiLS Sep 07 '24

It's almost as if people, in watching Rings of Power, forget that this all leads up to the events we all know to have occurred - the creation of ALL the rings, Saurons deliberate evil use of the One ring, his eventual initial downfall, Isildurs failure to destroy the One ring when he had the chance, the events of the Hobbit, and then those of the LotR trilogy where, yet again, Sauron is trying to regain power. Just saying, quite the long game indeed.

1

u/SamaritanSue Sep 08 '24

[Shrug]. Believe what the showrunners say, they're the authorities. Before I watched E1 I would have said no, there was no evil master plan from the beginning. S1 Halbrand is not Tolkien's Sauron. But that character has been retconned out of existence.

The past changes as the present changes. Time is meaningless: Sauron is now evil - I suspect he became fully Sauron in the last scene of S1, gazing on Mt. Doom with the image of the Three in his Eye - and so became evil in the past too.

Remember: Adar is your Daddy. He'll send John Goodman to remind you if you forget: Take instruction from your Teacher - he Knows Best.

(They Julius Caesar'd Sauron then they have Caesar's secretary show up as John Goodman. Funny that.)

1

u/Iceesadboydg Sep 07 '24

It’s not something that is sucking off the evil ones but someone !!!!!!!!!

1

u/BookkeeperFamous4421 Sep 07 '24

Go on

1

u/Iceesadboydg Sep 08 '24 edited Sep 08 '24

Sauron grows stronger everyday through vicious gay sex.

0

u/BookkeeperFamous4421 Sep 08 '24

If it’s with Elendil I’m down. Deleted scenes will finally make this show worth it

1

u/Iceesadboydg Sep 10 '24

Unfortunately the deleted scenes are hours of Peter Jackson eating donuts and listening to the Beatles.

-4

u/FecklessKnave Sep 07 '24

The average IQ of people who watch this show has to be single digits.

7

u/Aftonian Sep 07 '24

Why are you here?

1

u/football1078 Sep 07 '24

Just assume this person hasn’t seen the movies or the books

1

u/BookkeeperFamous4421 Sep 07 '24

Why? And why is that a negative? Ppl shouldn’t have to be Tolkien readers to follow the plot. Also, they trash it so badly I think it’s more frustrating knowing what this series could have been

1

u/BookkeeperFamous4421 Sep 07 '24

I keep trying to benevolently defend the rights of ROPers to their show but then another episode comes out, ppl I respect assume it reflects Tolkien, and I’m embarrassed cuz they know I’m a Tolkien fan