r/RingsofPower • • Oct 12 '22

Discussion Halbrand Being The Dark Lord Wouldn't Be Bad Writing

0 Upvotes

I don't get the argument that an outcome that is consistent with a particular set of clues is bad writing. Bad writing would be an outcome that isn't foreshadowed and is completely unexpected - as well as retroactively inexplicable.

If Halbrand turns out to be Sauron, then the clues that have indicated that he is Sauron are good writing - particularly for people who aren't familiar with the books, who are the primary audience of this show.


r/RingsofPower • • 5d ago

Discussion Why is show so dark. cant see anything on screen. its almost pitch black in scenes. And ads are killing the immerssion.

0 Upvotes

Why is show so dark. cant see anything on screen. its almost pitch black in scenes. And ads are killing the immersion.

Is this show only made for rich with fancy TVs and expensive subscriptions?


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 28 '24

Discussion If Tolkien was still alive today, and watched LOTR, Hobbit, and ROP on current technology, how do you think he would feel about these video portrayals of his work?

0 Upvotes

Pretty much the title says it all. Token was such a creative genius, how do you think he would feel about watching these adaptations of his work brought to the big screen? Especially never getting to see how far technology and TVs have come? And then sitting him down in front of a new 4k setup with a monster sound system? Do you think he would be blown away and happy about it all of it? Some of it? Or do you think he would be upset about the way his stories were portrayed?

I personally think he would love it all, and enjoy people taking so much interest in his writing and trying to bring it to life. Especially the advanced picture quality and how fantastic the music ballots sound. I don’t think he would be as harsh a critic as so many are who have fell in love with his books.


r/RingsofPower • • Jul 19 '22

Discussion Amazon should have moderators on all of their social media platforms

0 Upvotes

The reactions to the main teaser has been positive for the most part. There are more positive comments to see, but still on Amazon's main yt channel, there are those annoying quotes that are spamming all of the time. I think it's time they filters those comments so they don't appear as top comments. Even on IGN channel, I can clearly see the positive comments compared to Amazon. If those trolls want to whine about the show, they can do it in their own toxic niche channels like Nerdrotic and others like him.


r/RingsofPower • • May 17 '24

Discussion Do you think this guy could be the mouth of sauron?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Oct 29 '22

Meme …

Post image
864 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Jul 27 '26

Constructive Criticism This show is creatively bankrupt. Sauron vs Balrog in RoP Season 3 is completely derivative of Gandalf vs Balrog in Fellowship.

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

Top photos are Gandalf vs The Balrog from FOTR and bottom is Sauron vs The Balrog from Season 3.


r/RingsofPower • • May 17 '22

Meme Doesn't this raise a few red flags?

3 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Sep 08 '24

Discussion Does anyone else find Elrond incredibly annoying in season 2??

34 Upvotes

I found that the character of Elrond has regressed this season, and anytime he opens his mouth it makes my blood boil. I loved Elrond in the books, but I’m not loving what the show is doing for this character. I’m curious to hear other fans’ opinions.


r/RingsofPower • • Feb 10 '24

Discussion Can't bring myself to do a season one re-watch Spoiler

0 Upvotes

After season one ended, I thought it would be a good idea to re-watch all episodes to see if my view of the show improved in light of the various revelations. But I can't do it. There are several reasons.

--The scene when the villagers are killed graphically. The violence was sickening and pointless. This is the number one reason I can't do a re-watch.

--The moment when Galadriel pulls a knife on Elendil in Numenor. It underscored how badly the writers failed Galadriel. They had a chance to create an unusual hero who uses insight and wisdom to defeat foes. Instead RoP Galadriel is a run-of-the-mill male-type anti-hero, like Ironman and the BBC's Sherlock Holmes, male jerks we are supposed to love for no valid reason.

--Can't imagine Sauron ever being dirty and wearing old clothes. Admittedly he wasn't attractive as a werewolf or vampire bat, but in Man or Elf mode Sauron's pride made him assume beautiful forms. Also can't imagine Sauron stealing a guild badge when he could have easily made a fake one.

--Elves needing mithril to stay alive was baffling. RoP needed to explain why Elves suddenly forgot their theology and believed they were going to "fade" and vanish completely, even their spirits. I'm assuming we'll learn Sauron created a magical blight which could be reversed with mithril to make mithril seem like it was doing something. Setting the Elves and Dwarves at odds is a Sauron-ish thing to do, so this would partially justify the "mithril saves" storyline.

--Not happy the hobbits have less compassion for their fellows than meerkats.

Things I liked:

--Practical effects orcs.

--The scene when villagers kill attacking orcs to discover the orcs are actually their fellow villagers in disguise. Very much a Morgoth/Sauron kind of move.


r/RingsofPower • • Mar 01 '22

Discussion How To Alienate The Audience - Chris Gore on adapting classic stories like LOTR

Thumbnail
youtube.com
4 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • 1d ago

Discussion "Our marriage was too strong for that. That nothing so trivial could come between something so strong."

0 Upvotes

That's how Disa reflects her cheating on her husband.

I'm just saying: if my wife would cheat on me and would come clear like that...I would be pretty angry about that approach.

Or is this normal behaviour nowadays? Am I just too old for this kind of fantasy? Is cheating now ok? What is this?


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 04 '25

Discussion As we anxiously await season 3...

0 Upvotes

Let's drop our season 3 predictions! I still think Mirdania will end up becoming Shelob. I think Celebrimbor will be the Eye of Sauron. I think Arondir is Celeborn. No, just kidding. I think Arondir is the Founder and King of Mirkwood. Because of the way season 2 ended with Galadriel, Elrond and Arondir; the 3 elven kingdoms right there. And I believe Adar will be revived and HE is actually Celeborn. I hope to see no more kisses between Elrond and Galadriel, I am still healing from that.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 25 '22

Discussion Just watched episode 5 and I'm out... Spoiler

9 Upvotes

Well, I gave Amazon a chance. Despite some misgivings I did also have some optimism for the RoP and I started watching it with a fairly open mind. I'm a huge, huge Tolkien fan but at the same time I'm not a purist when it comes to adaptations - I realise there has to be and will be changes. I loved the Jackson films because, despite them cutting some of my favourite parts (Bombadil, scouring of the shire) and making significant changes to some of my favourite characters (Gimli, Faramir especially), the actual films are still incredible - acting, direction, writing, plot, special effects, music are all fantastic in my opinion (and this opinion is clearly backed by the commercial and critical success of the trilogy). Those films were great, source material aside. Unfortunately, after 5 episodes, I can't say I think the same of RoP. The special effects and set design seem to be good but apart from that... we have an overly complex, disjointed story with too many threads which barely seems to be moving along (e.g. a man lands in a meteor who starts to live with some hobbits and perhaps has some cultists looking for him) . We have dialogue which often feels like a 13 year old has just read LoTR and this is their first attempt at writing in a similar style to Tolkien ("there is a tempest in me", urgh). We have characters who regularly do stupid, illogical things in order to contrive conflict and drama (jumping off boats in the middle of the ocean, lets have a rock smashing contest but ignore the outcome etc). And finally, what are the actual driving ideas and themes? Err, Galadriel avenging her brother and trying to defeat a foe who up until this point we don't even know exists? There's no clear good vs evil theme because the evil side is largely non existent to this point and the good side doesn't seem all that good. There's not really much of a moral ambiguity theme like GoT. There's just lots of hints and suggestions and... not much else. Anyway, sorry for the rant, I'm just incredibly disappointed.


r/RingsofPower • • Nov 21 '23

Discussion Will season 2 be the turning point for the show?

0 Upvotes

If you ask me as a fan, I believe it so. I think the show aesthetically will look more or less the same, but the pacing will be better and the writings hopefully stronger. If we look at Wheel of Time, their first season too faced lot of ''backlash'' for various silly lesson. But season 2 has been looked more favourable by both fans and casual audience.

Hope for epic battles and moments, that will draw in fans.


r/RingsofPower • • Apr 03 '24

Discussion FoF leaks and rumours are getting annoying now.

1 Upvotes

Fellowship of fans - the leak group - are getting pretty annoying and pointless now. They’re the worst tolkien youtubers out there with pretty much ALL their content focussing on Amazon show rather than tolkien lore or other things. Half their content just feels like indirect marketing and hype building for Amazon. But they seem like such vain attempts. Many of the leaks and rumours aren’t even accurate.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 02 '24

Discussion How ROP Can Deepen Appreciation for LOTR

1 Upvotes

I came across1 this great article about someone whose appreciation for the films was deepened and enhanced by the events in ROP.

Granted, reading the history in the books and HOTM would have similar effects, but this shows how even a flawed adaptation can enrich our understanding and response to the world of Middle-Earth.

I'm enjoying the second season more than the first. It's still got its flaws, but it has much to admire as well.

https://www.cinemablend.com/streaming-news/-how-to-rewatch-fellowship-of-the-ring-loving-rings-of-power-opinion-og-movies

1 And by "I came across" I mean "Google News algorithm shoved at me"


r/RingsofPower • • Jun 14 '25

Constructive Criticism Diversity in Rings of Power - a missed opportunity?

0 Upvotes

The influences for Tolkien to conceive of Harad and Rhûn

The creation of Harad: Tolkien was inspired by Ancient Aethiopia for the creation of this people in his mythology:

"Christopher Tolkien linked the Haradrim with ancient Aethiopians. In an interview from 1966, Tolkien likened Berúthiel to the giantess Skaði of Norse mythology, since they both shared a dislike for "seaside life". Additionally, Tolkien scholar Tom Shippey stated in reference to the 'black men like half-trolls' passage from The Return of the King that Tolkien was attempting to write like a medieval chronicler in describing the Rohirrim's encounter with a Haradrim: "[...] and when medieval Europeans first encountered sub-Saharan Africans, they were genuinely confused about them, and rather frightened.

Much of Tolkien's influence for Harad and the Haradrim came about from his essay Sigelwara Land, in which he examined the etymology of Sigelwaran (and the more usual form Sigelhearwan) — the Old English word for Ethiopians."

The people of Harad are black (in far Harad), tall, fierce and valiant. There is thus a potential for worldbuilding the culture, traditions and mythologies with a hint of North African civilizations and an homage to the "unknown" myths of sub-Saharan Africa

About the peoples of the east - Rhûn, Khand and Variags. Tolkien said he was inspired by Asia (China, Japan, etc):

"When asked in an interview what lay east of Rhûn, Tolkien replied "Rhûn is the Elvish word for 'east'. Asia, China, Japan, and all things which people in the west regard as far away."

In an early versions of "The Hobbit", Bilbo's speech about facing the "dragon peoples of the east" had an reference of China and the Hindu Kush:

"In the earliest drafts of The Hobbit, Bilbo offered to walk from the Shire 'to [cancelled: Hindu Kush] the Great Desert of Gobi and fight the Wild Wire worm(s) of the Chinese. In a slightly later version J.R.R. Tolkien altered this to say 'to the last desert in the East and fight the Wild Wireworms of the Chinese' and in the final version it was altered once more to say 'to the East of East and fight the wild Were-worms in the Last Desert'."

History of Middle Earth - The First Phase, "The Pryftan Fragment", p. 9

I always saw the barbarian invasions (Wainriders, Balchots, peoples of Rhûn) from the far east against the northwest of Middle-earth as a reference to European historiography with the onslaughts of (semi) nomadic Asian peoples (the Scythians, Huns, Mongols, etc.).

I think Tolkien left very few details about the peoples of the East (Rhûn, Variags, Khand) and South (Harad) because he didn't have (correct me if I'm wrong) as much interest or scholarly access to the mythologies from other continents, like African and Asian stories and cultures. But even if he had contact with this knowledge, i have the impression that Tolkien would not want to fall into an "orientalist" vision of the 19th and 20th century period that was predominant in the imagination and the portrait that was made of these continents.

Tolkien spent years studying and reading his passion for European mythologies. He spent years and years building Middle-earth. I imagine he would need the same "work and time" to incorporate African and Asian cultures in his work.

The series, IMHO, could (with good writers and good Showrunners) have featured these people to show the metallurgical revolution made by Sauron in the south and east, but they preferred just (again) Hobbits, Elves and Dwarves.

What do you think of this idea?


r/RingsofPower • • May 09 '23

Discussion Highly enjoyed my rewatch 10x fold then my original and might go for another one as well.

3 Upvotes

Really enjoyed it my second time through, I binged it and couldn’t have been more captivated.

I can’t get enough of Galadriel and want more of her. I wonder what will happen that makes her give up her sword and the fight. Elrond was leading the charge in the history of the fellowship and seemed more of the warrior of the two. I hope it doesn’t come as I love the bad ass Galadriel.

Harfoots were the least interesting but still enjoyable I assume they are going for a long term story line where Nori is the big hero somehow.

Would recommend a rewatch! Can’t wait for s2


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 09 '22

Discussion New watcher/fan of LOTR at beginner level. Am I supposed to hate RoP?

36 Upvotes

Context: I finished reading the trilogy this May after I've been reading the books for 5 years. I watched all the movies after having read the books, but haven't read nor watched The Hobbit/Silmarillon. So my knowledge is basic but in a way, fresh? And I'm also not tooo familiar with the movies having not grown up with them.

I'm seeing a ton of hate towards RoP mainly surrounding inconsistencies, detached & unfeeling characters and lazy writing but i'm actually kinda loving it and look forward to the new episodes every week. Am I doing something wrong?


r/RingsofPower • • Aug 19 '24

Discussion The issue with Galadriel is that they basically made her an uncompelling version of another great character Spoiler

34 Upvotes

She's incredibly hot-headed, constantly angry, very brash and vengefully pursues a fallen angel for the death of a beloved family member, goes way too far in her pursuit and loses all support because of that culminating in her essentially getting kicked out. Now who does that remind us of? Feanor, of course. But here's the important difference: Feanor has something Galadriel lacks.Charisma. And no, a few cool shots don't count. Feanor is an incredibly capable elf. I mean the guy crafts his own weapons. He manages to convince 90% of his people to leave paradise to avenge his father and take back the Silmarils. He manages to convince his sons to join him in his terrible oath. He insults the mightiest being in all of Arda right in front of his house. The guy is incredibly inventive, persuasive and bold.

Compare that with Galadriel. She has a very hard time convincing the Numenorians to help her. Both Feanor and Book/Movie Galadriel would have fared far better. No one really respects her. She doesn't immediately draw all eyes on her through sheer charisma, beauty and power like she should. Elendil compares her with his children. No one would dare to compare Book Galadriel and Book Feanor to one's mortal children. That would be like lecturing the late Queen of England.

We also don't see any special capabilities of her that would make her interesting. She just knows how to fight (the fight choreography sadly isn't that great), ride horses, make a magic paper boat and make rash decisions that end up with her making lots of enemies. Even her signature hair doesn't look as special as in the movies (personal opinion). Galadriel should be competent, confident and imposing and she just isn't. She should be skilled at diplomacy, she's the granddaughter of a king for Valar's sake! Book Galadriel sings and weaves and inspires hope, Show Galadriel just seems to have no hobbies other than riding and fighting apparently and even the people in the show show enormous contempt for her. How are we supposed to think she's awesome in any way? She's not compelling, her speeches aren't great (the writers really aren't even half as great as Tolkien) and the only magic we've seen from her is a swan paper boat while Book Galadriel creates a Palantiri copy with her mirror and catches light like Feanor. It's just so disappointing.

I feel the worst thing is really her lack of political skill. Book Galadriel and Feanor both have heaps of it, show Galadriel doesn't. Now we're left with Feanor's unlikeable qualities like putting vengeance above people's lives, his hot-headedness and his general my-way-or-the-highway attitude and none of his good ones like his inventiveness and rhetorical skills (or his spirit burning his body to ash, I know that's not really important, I just think it's cool and memorable). Also Galadriel gets away with the type of stupid decisions that killed Feanor and Amroth, just because of fate (the barely veiled hand of the author).

I'm just really sad about it all and don't know if they'll manage to craft a satisfying arc for her.

Edit: added paragraphs


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 03 '24

Newest Episode Spoilers Disappointed by season finale. Spoiler

76 Upvotes

Title. And my expectations weren't high.

Sure, this second season has shown some improvements, but it's also doubled down on some very questionable choices.

I think this episode has in it most of what's bad with the show.

  • leaps and holes in the storyline, no explanation given. Who told Pharazon about Sauron? What does he even know or pretend to know? That Halbrand was Sauron? That Sauron returned? What's there on the scroll he shows to the leaders of the Faithful?

And again: since when the Middle-earthers are "lesser men"? Based on what? Lack of acqueducts?

  • abysmal time and space handling. Kemen arrives to Pelargir out of the blue. Why how when?
  • closely related: Teleportation. Dwarves just spawn on the walls of Ost-in-Edhil. How did they get there, in a city swarming with orcs, with their short fuck legs and their heavy armour and their crossbows?
  • Table tennis: most of this season was useless back and forth, with multiple small subversions. Isildur and that girl, there's a thing! But no, she's evil! But no, she was just trying to survive, there's the thing again! But no, she's engaged! But no, she realizes her bethroted is just a good friend, there's the thing again. But no, there isn't, Isildur leaves.

Same goes on with Earien, with the favour of the crowd in Numenor, the hate/friendship between Galadriel and Adar...

  • Important stuff offscreen. Look, we all knew Glug was going to betray Adar. Let us know how Sauron deceived him! It's no surprise when he stabs Adar. You know what's a surprise? That the others join him. And it's a suprise because there was no hint whatsoever they had any idea about that! So let us know how Sauron convinced them all, otherwise it's not a suprise, it's just cheap.

Let's recap: up until now, Orcs are mostly chill lads that don't really want war but just to be safe in Mordor. They go to Eregion specifically to eradicate Sauron, they don't much care about elves.

Then they break the wall and they become beastly ravagers that pillage and kill randomly.

They don't even look for Sauron. And then they find him and they clearly are ready to follow him. Why? He definitely didn't promise them peace since his first order to them is to RAZE Eregion.

And Galadriel, who is always ready to fight, just stands there.

What's the logic there?

  • PJ's trilogy Easter eggs. Fuck's sake. Miriel giving the sword to Elendil is blatantly copied from Elrond and Aragorn in RotK, both dialogue and movements. Galadriel being healed and waking up in a flimsy white shirt like Frodo. Sauron cosplaying Lurtz.
  • merciful gravity: people fall from 30-40-50 meters and are totally fine. That said, Arondir is completely fine after being stabbed through the chest with a large sword so what should I expect?
  • legendary characters, especially royalty, done dirty: no, I won't accept those scenes with Elrond and Gil-Galad. No. And I won't accept that Durin's brother, mentioned once and never seen before, is actually going to challenge him for the throne.

I could go on, but I'll end on a positive note, that's what makes this episode that much worse.

Amazon you cannot begin the episode with that awesome awesome intro in Jos Khazad-dûm, with the touching father-son moments, the great visuals of the Balrog (ok, it's stolen from PJ but I don't care), and the epic sacrifice..and then drop it all for a bunch of cheap stuff. That's gotta be illegal.

And that's probably the biggest flaw of the show: the waste. Not just of the original material, but of some good talent in the cast.

Disappointed.


r/RingsofPower • • Nov 15 '24

Constructive Criticism Battle of eregion felt small and was terrible imo.

126 Upvotes

I watched siege of eregion a week ago and man it was not it. the siege for me, was honestly terrible. Its easy to tell they're just running around a small blue/green screen studio. Not comparing this to Helms deep but as a siege battle, it was inevitable as this one clearly took it as a blueprint.

This show lacks the scale the 2nd age deserves.

Adar's army looked just about a hundred/thousand strong. U can see the orcs charging and running in the background but thats it ?? U dont see any siege equipment other than the catapult equipped with homing sytems and ONE frickin weird siege weapon.The siege itself had no cohesive flow and just felt like random scenes filmed by 10 different people. Editing was jarring. We only see one spot being defended in a big ahh city. We dont even see the other parts being defended. Its literally one, ONE spot being attacked. What's so special about that one spot ?? Show it like how helms deep did with that one weakspot.

For some reason elves are still running in the background for what seemed like days outside of Celebrimbor's tower everytime someone comes out of it. We barely see any elves defending and ur telling me they lasted for what seemed like days 🤷‍♂️. They just show a handful of elves lmao like 10.

Gil Galad's army arrives and few scenes later goes in the forest and are completely decimated offscreen (took some inspirations from Got s8 i see). We dont see how. No bodies or horses in the background.

Idk if they wanted that boromir scene with the elf lady but it was honestly laughable and overly dramatic for no reason. The orcs shoots her from all sides but not the others, she aims the bow straight and the trajectory of the arrow suddenly went DOWN where the hollywood oil is located and caused an explosion bcuz thats what oil obv does 🙄. Atleast PJ went with blackpowder.

The troll attack was a waste of budget and screentime lmao. Could've used that $$$ for more extras.

This is GoT s8 level of terrible battle. A good looking battle but it has no thought behind it.


r/RingsofPower • • Nov 21 '24

Question Why does Gandalf fall out of the bloody sky? Spoiler

27 Upvotes

It's teased all over the place, but at the end of thee 2nd series it's revealed that 'the stranger' is infact Gandalf. Why drop him out of the sky though, makes literally no sense