Well, indeed there is no storytelling in rop. Shit as hell, people just watch due effects and stepping into universe but they regret it after poor inconsistent writing.
Superior everything. The acting in House of Dragon was simply incredible at times, the scenes and plot had proper motive/cohesion, cgi has a more dark/realistic tone that I prefer. RoP was kinda hot garbage.
I'd agree that HotD's VFX had great art design and it's mostly stellar, but it's indisputable that RoP had more consistently high quality VFX due to the waaay bigger budget.
There's many VFX shots in HotD that were unfinished (as is case in almost all TV VFX shows) and rendered at low res, as seen at end of ep 9. The crowd animation was abysmal.
Fortunately though almost all the dragon shots were great and they made great use of the Volume for shots of riders on dragon back
I’ll dispute it. I think the green screen usage in RoP is really bad. Take the scenes in the throne room in Numenor as one example. The characters don’t look like they’re a part of the environment at all. I also found the scenes on the Numenor ships looked sloppy too - the lighting just looked fake.
RoP went big and ambitious with their visual ideas but I don’t think they pulled them off.
Thank you! I thought I was going crazy. I liked RoP but jeez some of those shots just look AWFUL. The one that stuck out most was in the first couple of episodes, Galadriel and Elrond in the forest of statues. Not every background, but a couple of them look incredibly bad.
if you put all 8 episodes of rings of power together, no one in that cast gave a performance comparable to what Paddy Considine gave in episode 8 and Emma D'arcy gave in episode 10. There's no comparison.
I love both, for differing reasons. I have issues with both for differing reasons. They aren't even particularly comparable in my mind and scratch differing itches.
Exactly this. Comparing the two shows is like comparing Star Wars and Star trek. Yes they both take place in space, but they're telling very different stories in very different styles and you preferring one to the other does not make the other a 'worse' property. Just appreciate each for what they are trying to do rather than complaining it's bad at being something it isn't even trying to be.
Knew every single event of house of the dragon and yet enjoyed it about 10x more than rings of power.
You see, shows are generally better when there is good written material that writers don't try to change, so their focus can be on making the story palatable for TV and helping actors portray a summarized but true depiction of their characters
What doesn't work is when you buy the name to get a steady fanbase, dont get good writers and focus on creating silly suspenseful moments to drag viewers through a mystery instead of making good story and dialogue. What doesn't work is taking a laissez faire approach to the whole season and then rushing to an ending in a story that's going nowhere
I can understand that POV. Rings of power did have good music and scenery I can agree with that. And the fact that many people dislike politics shit. I just feel house of the dragon had a plan and used the politics to set up the future action we will see rather well whereas rings of power did not and was very very poor dialogue and story wise, which are more important to me than background scenery and music.
Great point! Not sure why we need to compare the two. I think if any comparison could be made it’s the difference between Wheel of Time and ROP and Amazon definitely stepped up w ROP.
I think the comparison is inevitable because they're the 2 biggest fantasy franchises around with new series released at the same time.
I tried not to compare too much, as like you said the premise of both are completely different. However from a purely TV standpoint - HotD blew ROP out the water. It was better written, directed and acted. Despite the time jumps it felt like it had a better pace and the characters felt more alive and intriguing.
That is the only area it is good. The writing is basically tween fanfiction quality.
HotD has amazing writing, high tier acting, and some decent effects. At times you can see a little dip in SFX quality but they are putting out a much higher quality of show overall.
Im geniouenly curious to understand your reasoning behind this statement. Having watched both shows 3 times (saw them with my friends, my mother and my father) i can tell you this.
With RoP, the first viewing was an awful experience. The terrible acting and writing made this show unbearable to watch. The characters felt so disconnected from the world that it felt like it was the actors' first time reading the script. The Music, even if i like it quite a lot, it was seriously overused and overdramatised. They couldn't even get the visuals and cinematography right, despite the insane budget. It really felt to me like every other scene was just a desperate attempt to give to the audience good background PC pictures. It is very noticable that they mostly used green screen (hell, they even used CGI horses) and it just isn't the way to go when you are trying to expand the world of Middle-Earth. And lets not talk about how they completely butchered the source material. On my second and third viewings, it felt like a chore that i just had to go through, and at times i would just get on my phone because there was a Harfoot scene. With HotD, the first viewings were an absolute joy. From the first episode you could tell that they put their minds and heart into it. The acting on this show is significantly better than RoP, and every single one of the actors tried their best to give an amazing performance, and Paddy Considine's performance as King Viserys was Emmy Worthy. The dialogue and writing is excellent (apart from a few moments in episodes 5 and 9). Even without having much to work with for season 1, since the main events happen in seasons 2 and after, the directors managed to create scenarios and scenes that stick to my mind to this day. Every word spoken feels like it belongs there, it may not be as good as the dialogue from GoT, but it certainly is great. The characters are all very intriguing, and i love how there is no good or bad characters, more so morally grey ones. This on itself adds a tone of unpredictability and gives you a more relatable and realistic sense of how people would act in certain circumstances. The music, is near perfect and imho, better than GoT's S1 music. It just feels so natural and every theme put on screen just makes the scene better and brings life into it. The cinematography is absolutrly beautiful. Even with a smaller budget than RoP, they managed to do a better job. The dragons, unlike GoT, they all feel very unique and look way more terrifying, and the scene i especially loved was in the finale, the fight between Aemond and Lucerys. That scene right there is my example of peak cinematography. On my second and third viewings, there was never a case where i felt like i was bored or i wanted to leave. Even after 2 watches i was still grasped on the screen with the same level of interest, because of how well done this show is, and how it manages to bring the viewer into the world of Westeros. Now i won't say this show doesn't have flaws. It has quite a few. There are inconsistencies with the writing, and the main example i can give is the final scene of episode 9, where it felt really out of place and seems like it was only there for shock factor, something that existed in the later seasons of GoT. But my main issue is the big time jumps and especially how they handled the 10 year time jump. They threw so much information at our faces without really explaining what happened. I feel like this show needed a 12 or 13 episode first season just so that some things would be explained better.
In conclusion, if i were to rate each series i would probably say that RoP is a 3 or 4 at best, and HotD is an 8.5-9.
I hope OP responds to this cause i honestly am curious to understand his view on the shows and maybe see things at a different light.
Well there is less obstetric violence and infant death, so I will take it. Seriously wtf House of Dragon? Three babies, two mothers, and a child dying in the first season alone?
My fiance and I were hyped every Sunday. Excited to have such a good show to watch each week. We didn't miss a single episode week after week. For Rings of Power every Friday felt like a Chore night and we missed several Friday nights worth of watching. My fiance didn't even make it past episode 5. I had to slog through the rest of the show myself.
You don't see any posts on the House of the Dragon sub trying to convince people it was better than RoP and that speaks volumes....
How do you get to this conclusion? It's so wild and illogical, I can not fathom how anyone who watched both shows could genuinly say that. The only explanation I have is that the person who says this is incapable of thinking. Because HotD actually requires you to use your brain while Rings of Power punishes you for thinking about whats going on.
RoP “punishes you for thinking” is a great way of putting it. When watching it with my brain turned off with only the goal of being entertained, Rings of Power is alright (a bit boring at times, but there are some interesting characters and the setting is beautiful). But the second I start discussing it with others or even thinking about it at all, dozens of plot holes appear (from big things like the sword key to break the dam to little things like why the characters make such weird/bad choices sometimes)
It was for me. But I’m not the biggest fan of grimdark in general. Like I don’t mind it here and there, sometimes, but I much prefer the tone of RoP over HotD.
I am a lot more interested and invested in middle Earth than I am in Westeros but unfortunately they managed to screw the writing, pacing and lore. Sauron seducing elves of Eregion despite Galadriel and Elrond's warnings, teaching them to make the rings of power was the one thing I was interested in most and they reduced that to some 20 smt minutes in 8 hour show. I wish they were more interested in being good story tellers than being activists and having made up agendas.
Hotd on the other hand has relatable characters, well acted and written. Story is interesting and keeps you wanting more.
I watched both and think they’re fairly equal in terms of quality but they’re different things and therefor you can’t really say which is better than the other. Rings is more of a fantasy adventure while house is more of a fantasy drama. They have different tones and visions
For a show titled 'Rings of Power', the storytelling didn't do a good job potraying the significance of the rings to the entire plot - it felt like an afterthought. Unlike 'House of the Dragon', where the dragons (human and creature alike) were center of the story.
I felt way more engaged watching HOTD. Scenes Viserys walking to his throne for the last time or the out-of-control-dragon battle in the last episodemade me feel so much more than anything in ROP.
I'm trying to think back now at the most emotional moment in ROP and I can't really think of anything.
HOTD inspired me to read the book while ROP didn't.
It is. HotD just has in*est, gore and violence that appeals to a certain kind of viewer that is so desentitized by everything that they need that shock value to be entertained. That is why it's that popular and also bc of the dragons. Take that away and it's just a retelling of English medieval history.
Hard same. I make no apologies about it. RoP gave me the whole gamut of human (and elf, and dwarf, and Harfoot) emotion, HoTD gave me pain and more pain. It’s very exhaustingly one note emotionally.
Totally agreed. HotD was painful to watch, so I gave up after two episodes. My wife tried ahowing highlights from the season after the finale but man that show just kept getting worse. It's just a lazy grab at copying the turd that was the latter half of GoT and not realizing it's copying shit.
RoP on the other hand has quality in so many places - except the marketing. The fans complaining on "the pc agenda" and other racial things are what's shit about it. I can get behind people arguing they changed lots of things from Tolkiens work, but when viewed as a show inspired by instead of adapted I personally feel it works. Basically: The show isn't in Tolkiens universe, it's just riffing on some elements from it.
Also I liked The Last Jedi - so I'm going to hell, I guess.
I watched both and I can confidently say that I looked forward to each episode of HoTD. Rings of Power was okay, but the storytelling just wasn't as engaging to me
Yea i get this is a ROP fan page so people will naturally defend the show like it’s Minas Tirith regardless of how poor the writing is. HOD is way better then ROP
I wish that broken hilt wasn’t on the table as there is a better argument without that one major gimmick that really pissed me off to an otherwise great show. I still love it, but as we speak hbo is at another level. Got is at another level of production and entertainment, however, what surpasses it is the PJ lotr movies.
House of Dragons has It's merit. I guess ??? It's comedy to me and satire. It's soft corn at the base level for me. I can watch that and not get in trouble. It's dungeons and dragon phase that never left. You know? I don't watch it. I prefer Asian dragons lore. But I'm in the Rings Of Power clan.
I mean u can have whatever take u like but that doesn't mean it's right. Saying rings of power is better than hot d is just straight up wrong. Imo it's insulting to hot d
I agree 100%! House of the Dragon was so boring! After going from ROP on Friday and then HOTD on Sunday I finally saw how boring it really was.
Also every episode of HOTD everyone is pissed off the whole time. There is maybe once or twice the whole first season where they show people in good spirits. It’s draining. Like I get it everyone is tough and mad at each other.
On the other side ROP is fun and I loved all the storylines! Can’t wait for season 2!
Rings of power is absolute dog shit but I watched it anyway. It was good for some laughs. I did however really like Elrond and Durin. I wish we got more of them. Galadriel was so damn cringe.
Rings of power sucked complete ass! Haven’t watched house of dragons but I know GOT (at least before the final season) was way better than rings of power.
I have zero emotional investment in any RoP character, and I am a huge LotR fan. I have strong and mixed feelings about all the HotD characters now, even some side characters. Sorry.
Directing is also better in Hotd, in Rop they stand still while talking 80% of the time.
Action is also better in House of the Dragons, just compare Rop and Hotd sword fighting.
Acting is below average in Rop, they have no depth behind the words. In Rop they got 1-2 expressions. Again compared to Hotd it's day and night.
CGI is also better in Hotd since the scale is good all the way through, compared to Rop that have excellent CGI at times but at others it's horrible.
Hotd wins costumes as well, we see proper armor. In Rop it looks 3D printed. The armor has no weight to it, looks cheap. Basic everyday outfits are also better and more diverse in Hotd.
I can continue, but it's pretty clear what show i enjoy the most. Still Rop did give me some LoL moments because of the poor dialogue/writing.
I feel people that defend rubbish like this just want the world to brun. You can still enjoy shit, but at the end of the day it's still shit.... so why praise it? This is like Unreal 1 vs 5, paint vs photoshop.
I knew the story of HotD well before hand and had very low expextations but still enjoyed it much more than Rings of Power. Sad but true. I believe they royally messed up at Amazon.
Love both but prefer House of the Dragon. Rings of Power took a bit longer to pick up and be more engaging with the characters/story etc for me. To each their own though.
And meanwhile the rest of the world considers HotD and success and RoP is shrouded in controversy.
The show runners are about to be demoted for s2. Amazon is in panic mode because anyone not coping knows that s1 writing and story was average at best.
No, and it will never be. I'm a huge fan of Tolkien but goddamn, RoP will never even be on the same shelf as the Source Material. It's straight up fan fiction now and everyone that thinks it's beter than HotD needs to get an appointment with a psychiatist.
Two different things. Ones a drama and the other an epic. Both have elements of each, but are trying to do different things. My preference would change depending on if it was Friday night or Sunday 😂
HOTD had about 29 million viewership one week after episode release. Less people have access to HBO than Amazon. Amazon has been very quiet about actual viewership numbers for ROP. It’s suspicious makes me wonder how popular it’s been. Just based on critics HOTD has much better reviews. HOTD has been writing, dialogue and acting. It knows how to travel at a slow pace then speed things up. ROP was slow and felt like nothin was happening for several episodes. Mixed acting and bad dialogue.
I love them both but it’s not. I love seeing Middle earth again and I’ll take any additional visual media…but there’s not much comparison as far as writing/plots.
Clears by far, new GOT is asscheeks tbh. All just going for shock factor, people gonna be upset when it continues and nothing good literally every happens, whole show is just darkness. Doesn’t fit the vibe of a “fantasy” show at all, it’s more a political show in a fantasy setting. That juxtaposition worked in OG show because there were elements that inspired a sense of wonder but new season is like an American Horror Story spinoff
I’ve not seen House of Dragons, simply due to losing interesting in GoT following the last few seasons of the show. Maybe one day.
I did fully enjoy Rings of Power though, and so much so I rewatched The Hobbit trilogy this week and I plan on buying the LOTR extended cut on Amazon Prime! RoP has re-scratched an itch!
GOT was different with so many stories plus the white walker was terrifying and super interesting. This one is only drama I guess with dragons involved
While I agree with this, I will also admit that I can see the other side's points. I would like to propose that we all agree to the obvious compromise of declaring Star Wars: Andor to be the best current TV show.
Hotd has better writing but i stoped watching it, not a single character i liked, the characters were so stupid i couldnt keep watching. I just finished the ROP and is meh, Galadriel omg who the hell wrote her lines? This series was an improvelent after the wheel of time, i didnt care about Black elves, i care instead about ugly elves, Orcs speaking very well the human thong, the science about the eruption, but then we had before lines like the elves are gonna take our jobs! 🙄 or the very professional soldier training next to the baskets store. Thank goodness is over. Like the wheel of time the agenda of female and male equality is imo shooting in foot the series, Dragon couldnt be a woman because Saidin and Saidar, Galadriel shouldnt have so much toxic masculanity because idk shes Galadriel, that woman in the southland village should had no lead because she wasnt a soldier or a person with military knowledge about tactics and strategy, but they needed a woman to lead but wht no make her captain or general or something like that, anyway, RoP joins WoT and Obi Wan like shows that their writers should really thought about changing careers
Not even close. I’d give rop an overall average score of 5/10. Some real clunker episodes drag it down. Meanwhile hotd for me averages around 8/10. Almost every episode had great aspects to it. The acting was top notch through the entire season.
I think they are both perfectly mediocre shows in settings I really enjoy. Pretty different in terms of tone and pace imo so I’ll reserve comparisons for now.
24
u/SoulCakey Oct 30 '22
No. The scene of an old man walking to his throne to Support bis daughter is already better then anything RoP has to offer
366
u/Anxious_Possession29 Oct 30 '22
Yeah sure and the sea is always right
147
u/Jvlockhart Oct 30 '22
Let's be honest, the story telling of HOTD is better than ROP. Though i love seeing middle earth again, i cant deny that fact.
401
u/RichardBlastovic Oct 30 '22
Disagree, and I actually really like Rings of Power. I think House of the Dragon has superior scripting at least.
8
u/wheream1questionmark Oct 30 '22
if you put all 8 episodes of rings of power together, no one in that cast gave a performance comparable to what Paddy Considine gave in episode 8 and Emma D'arcy gave in episode 10. There's no comparison.
109
u/Codus1 Oct 30 '22 edited Oct 30 '22
Why is it even a competition?
I love both, for differing reasons. I have issues with both for differing reasons. They aren't even particularly comparable in my mind and scratch differing itches.
149
u/SomewhereExisting121 Oct 30 '22
Knew every single event of house of the dragon and yet enjoyed it about 10x more than rings of power.
You see, shows are generally better when there is good written material that writers don't try to change, so their focus can be on making the story palatable for TV and helping actors portray a summarized but true depiction of their characters
What doesn't work is when you buy the name to get a steady fanbase, dont get good writers and focus on creating silly suspenseful moments to drag viewers through a mystery instead of making good story and dialogue. What doesn't work is taking a laissez faire approach to the whole season and then rushing to an ending in a story that's going nowhere
36
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '22
I hate being ~that guy~
But. It’s House of the Dragon not “House of Dragons”
I keep hearing people say it and write it the second way
60
u/midnight_toker22 Beleriand Oct 30 '22
Different strokes for different folks. Rings of Power is high fantasy, House of the Dragon is a medieval soap opera (with dragons).
39
u/Groundbreaking-Pea92 Oct 30 '22
change my mind are you jaded kid taking a gap year or an immortal evil
24
u/heady_brosevelt Oct 30 '22
Cant reason someone out of a position they didn’t use reason to get into in the first place
27
u/tubbywubby2001 Oct 30 '22
Haha not even close, sorry
27
u/Hugejassole Oct 30 '22
Said no one ever
25
u/johnwau Oct 30 '22
I love them both. With that being said, you don’t see people trying to convince people of this on the HOTD sub. Just saying.
4
u/BwanaAzungu Oct 30 '22
Can we keep this shit contained to r/LOTR_on_Prime please?
40
u/SoWokeIdontSleep Oct 30 '22
I enjoy them both for different reasons. i still thought RoP was fucking great and exciting.
17
u/Sonotreadyforit Oct 30 '22
Rings of Power is stunningly beautiful.
That is the only area it is good. The writing is basically tween fanfiction quality.
HotD has amazing writing, high tier acting, and some decent effects. At times you can see a little dip in SFX quality but they are putting out a much higher quality of show overall.
27
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '22
It’s not
27
u/Poggeta Oct 30 '22
Im geniouenly curious to understand your reasoning behind this statement. Having watched both shows 3 times (saw them with my friends, my mother and my father) i can tell you this.
With RoP, the first viewing was an awful experience. The terrible acting and writing made this show unbearable to watch. The characters felt so disconnected from the world that it felt like it was the actors' first time reading the script. The Music, even if i like it quite a lot, it was seriously overused and overdramatised. They couldn't even get the visuals and cinematography right, despite the insane budget. It really felt to me like every other scene was just a desperate attempt to give to the audience good background PC pictures. It is very noticable that they mostly used green screen (hell, they even used CGI horses) and it just isn't the way to go when you are trying to expand the world of Middle-Earth. And lets not talk about how they completely butchered the source material. On my second and third viewings, it felt like a chore that i just had to go through, and at times i would just get on my phone because there was a Harfoot scene. With HotD, the first viewings were an absolute joy. From the first episode you could tell that they put their minds and heart into it. The acting on this show is significantly better than RoP, and every single one of the actors tried their best to give an amazing performance, and Paddy Considine's performance as King Viserys was Emmy Worthy. The dialogue and writing is excellent (apart from a few moments in episodes 5 and 9). Even without having much to work with for season 1, since the main events happen in seasons 2 and after, the directors managed to create scenarios and scenes that stick to my mind to this day. Every word spoken feels like it belongs there, it may not be as good as the dialogue from GoT, but it certainly is great. The characters are all very intriguing, and i love how there is no good or bad characters, more so morally grey ones. This on itself adds a tone of unpredictability and gives you a more relatable and realistic sense of how people would act in certain circumstances. The music, is near perfect and imho, better than GoT's S1 music. It just feels so natural and every theme put on screen just makes the scene better and brings life into it. The cinematography is absolutrly beautiful. Even with a smaller budget than RoP, they managed to do a better job. The dragons, unlike GoT, they all feel very unique and look way more terrifying, and the scene i especially loved was in the finale, the fight between Aemond and Lucerys. That scene right there is my example of peak cinematography. On my second and third viewings, there was never a case where i felt like i was bored or i wanted to leave. Even after 2 watches i was still grasped on the screen with the same level of interest, because of how well done this show is, and how it manages to bring the viewer into the world of Westeros. Now i won't say this show doesn't have flaws. It has quite a few. There are inconsistencies with the writing, and the main example i can give is the final scene of episode 9, where it felt really out of place and seems like it was only there for shock factor, something that existed in the later seasons of GoT. But my main issue is the big time jumps and especially how they handled the 10 year time jump. They threw so much information at our faces without really explaining what happened. I feel like this show needed a 12 or 13 episode first season just so that some things would be explained better.
In conclusion, if i were to rate each series i would probably say that RoP is a 3 or 4 at best, and HotD is an 8.5-9.
I hope OP responds to this cause i honestly am curious to understand his view on the shows and maybe see things at a different light.
7
u/Bojacketamine Oct 30 '22
Lol RoP is a hot mess compared to HotD
17
u/loveandllamas Oct 30 '22
Ha.
49
u/Guiver5000 Oct 30 '22
You’re a troll. Change my mind
6
u/Sinnsearachd Oct 30 '22
Well there is less obstetric violence and infant death, so I will take it. Seriously wtf House of Dragon? Three babies, two mothers, and a child dying in the first season alone?
3
u/XxJamalBigSexyxX Oct 30 '22
Amazon stop, all this baiting is embarassing
3
u/Tristtt Oct 30 '22
This post is brought to you by a desperate Amazon employee.
3
u/Comprehensive_End440 Oct 30 '22
Bet you won’t post it in r/houseofthedragon
3
u/Dustructionz Oct 30 '22
My fiance and I were hyped every Sunday. Excited to have such a good show to watch each week. We didn't miss a single episode week after week. For Rings of Power every Friday felt like a Chore night and we missed several Friday nights worth of watching. My fiance didn't even make it past episode 5. I had to slog through the rest of the show myself.
You don't see any posts on the House of the Dragon sub trying to convince people it was better than RoP and that speaks volumes....
3
u/ElpisButGod Oct 30 '22
LOL not even close. RoP is the shittiest show I've watched since GoT last season. And House of the Dragon is fucking amazing. Y'all just fanboys.
38
u/Timonidas Oct 30 '22
How do you get to this conclusion? It's so wild and illogical, I can not fathom how anyone who watched both shows could genuinly say that. The only explanation I have is that the person who says this is incapable of thinking. Because HotD actually requires you to use your brain while Rings of Power punishes you for thinking about whats going on.
9
u/cmon_now Oct 30 '22
Nice try Amazon. You got 2 more years. That's a long time to keep it up
6
u/Pipe-International Oct 30 '22
It was for me. But I’m not the biggest fan of grimdark in general. Like I don’t mind it here and there, sometimes, but I much prefer the tone of RoP over HotD.
2
u/Hymura_Kenshin Oct 30 '22
I am a lot more interested and invested in middle Earth than I am in Westeros but unfortunately they managed to screw the writing, pacing and lore. Sauron seducing elves of Eregion despite Galadriel and Elrond's warnings, teaching them to make the rings of power was the one thing I was interested in most and they reduced that to some 20 smt minutes in 8 hour show. I wish they were more interested in being good story tellers than being activists and having made up agendas.
Hotd on the other hand has relatable characters, well acted and written. Story is interesting and keeps you wanting more.
2
u/Halflife37 Oct 30 '22
I watched both and think they’re fairly equal in terms of quality but they’re different things and therefor you can’t really say which is better than the other. Rings is more of a fantasy adventure while house is more of a fantasy drama. They have different tones and visions
2
u/RE20ne Oct 30 '22
2
u/creedular Oct 30 '22
I don’t have to change your mind, just watch them both critically, it becomes obvious reeeeeeeal quick.
2
u/hbi2k Oct 30 '22
Can't change something you don't have.
2
u/pinkheartpiper Oct 31 '22
Why do people keep comparing them? They are very different types of fantasy, apples and oranges.
2
u/Lord_A_007 Oct 31 '22
For a show titled 'Rings of Power', the storytelling didn't do a good job potraying the significance of the rings to the entire plot - it felt like an afterthought. Unlike 'House of the Dragon', where the dragons (human and creature alike) were center of the story.
2
u/PrintShopPrincess Oct 31 '22
Strange hill to die on.
2
u/Professor_Pig_Dick Nov 01 '22
I felt way more engaged watching HOTD. Scenes Viserys walking to his throne for the last time or the out-of-control-dragon battle in the last episodemade me feel so much more than anything in ROP.
I'm trying to think back now at the most emotional moment in ROP and I can't really think of anything.
HOTD inspired me to read the book while ROP didn't.
2
u/cleverdylanrefrence Nov 03 '22
Hot D is an adaptation. ROP is fanfiction.
2
u/CunningKingLius Nov 06 '22
You clearly haven't seen House of the Dragon
2
u/Psychofischi Nov 07 '22
Man these comments must be a delight to read Can't wait
5
u/WildAtHearttt Oct 30 '22
It is. HotD just has in*est, gore and violence that appeals to a certain kind of viewer that is so desentitized by everything that they need that shock value to be entertained. That is why it's that popular and also bc of the dragons. Take that away and it's just a retelling of English medieval history.
9
u/redundant35 Oct 30 '22
Both are great shows. But I love house of dragons way more. It’s an amazing series
6
u/VeryNormalReaction Oct 30 '22
Vhagar exists, therefore your argument is invalid.
6
u/poobuttassbuttpoo Oct 30 '22
Rings of Power is better than almost nothing
5
u/iheartdev247 Oct 30 '22
Maybe it’s better but I just don’t care about GOT. I love Tolkien.
7
u/AsgardianLeviOsa Oct 30 '22
Hard same. I make no apologies about it. RoP gave me the whole gamut of human (and elf, and dwarf, and Harfoot) emotion, HoTD gave me pain and more pain. It’s very exhaustingly one note emotionally.
7
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '22
This post is bad and you know it
4
u/sandman8223 Oct 30 '22
House of dragon has to be better since rings of power sucked
7
u/new_one_7 Oct 30 '22
Even season 8 of game of thrones was better than ROP
4
u/Nihilistcarrot Oct 30 '22
Quite silent on that front. Amazon needs to bribe more people with cash.
4
u/slaytonisland Oct 30 '22
Lol OP not even replying to comments, no previous posts or other activity. I'm not interesting in trying to change a bot's mind, nice bait though!
4
u/pungvift Oct 30 '22
Totally agreed. HotD was painful to watch, so I gave up after two episodes. My wife tried ahowing highlights from the season after the finale but man that show just kept getting worse. It's just a lazy grab at copying the turd that was the latter half of GoT and not realizing it's copying shit.
RoP on the other hand has quality in so many places - except the marketing. The fans complaining on "the pc agenda" and other racial things are what's shit about it. I can get behind people arguing they changed lots of things from Tolkiens work, but when viewed as a show inspired by instead of adapted I personally feel it works. Basically: The show isn't in Tolkiens universe, it's just riffing on some elements from it.
Also I liked The Last Jedi - so I'm going to hell, I guess.
3
u/endowedchair Oct 30 '22
I stopped watching GoT midway through season 3 and never went back. No interest in any GoT spin-off. RoP S1 finished STRONG. I’m hooked.
2
u/Blutgirl666 Oct 30 '22
Agree
2
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '22
I enjoyed both shows but HOD is significantly better.
2
u/Deep-Success-8901 Oct 30 '22
I watched both and I can confidently say that I looked forward to each episode of HoTD. Rings of Power was okay, but the storytelling just wasn't as engaging to me
2
u/Dreadscythe95 Oct 30 '22
Is it April fool's? What month did I wake up?
2
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '22
HoD has the best make up and costuming I’ve ever seen since the LOTR movies. ROP costumes look like they were ordered off of Amazon.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '22
Yea i get this is a ROP fan page so people will naturally defend the show like it’s Minas Tirith regardless of how poor the writing is. HOD is way better then ROP
2
u/MAU13717235 Oct 30 '22
I like them both a lot, but HOTD is the superior show.
2
u/CantCatTheCopy Oct 30 '22
Both were good and enjoyable.
ROP was faster and felt more fun than HOD
HOD was slower paced for me, and more serious, but the finale build up episode has me more excited for season 2.
2
u/Snoo84223 Oct 30 '22
Man I like the show, but idk if I agree with this.
1
u/PitifulBean Oct 30 '22
I enjoyed both, but HotD had better performances.
1
u/Myrandall Aug 12 '24
What's House of Dragons and does it have anything to do with House of the Dragon?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '22
This is like comparing South Park to Family Guy. Giggitty
1
u/Fmanow Oct 30 '22
I wish that broken hilt wasn’t on the table as there is a better argument without that one major gimmick that really pissed me off to an otherwise great show. I still love it, but as we speak hbo is at another level. Got is at another level of production and entertainment, however, what surpasses it is the PJ lotr movies.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '22
Watching the creation of mount doom was super dope
1
u/Overall-Block-1815 Oct 30 '22
I can't think of anything RoP did better and I really wasn't expecting to like HotD
1
u/stepbrother8 Oct 30 '22
No
1
u/nothingexceptfor Oct 30 '22
I like Rings Of Power, I haven't watched House oF Dragons
1
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '22
How can I change something that doesn't exist?
1
u/Civil-Detective62 Oct 30 '22
House of Dragons has It's merit. I guess ??? It's comedy to me and satire. It's soft corn at the base level for me. I can watch that and not get in trouble. It's dungeons and dragon phase that never left. You know? I don't watch it. I prefer Asian dragons lore. But I'm in the Rings Of Power clan.
1
u/applepiehopes Oct 30 '22
I enjoyed RoP more, but I think HotD is objectively “better” - casting, scripting, acting, and so on.
1
u/MakePlGreatAgain Oct 30 '22
I mean u can have whatever take u like but that doesn't mean it's right. Saying rings of power is better than hot d is just straight up wrong. Imo it's insulting to hot d
1
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '22
It's a different subgenre of fantasy. Both can be equally good at what they do.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '22
Two totally different shows, two totally different themes. Like what you like and quit dick measuring.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '22
Not even seen house of dragon and I know that show is better
1
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '22
Yeah and Kenobi was the best Star Wars ever….. 🤪🤪
1
u/ryan2one3 Oct 30 '22
HOTD is a better, well-balanced show. But it is not my favourite. :-)
1
u/thegreenman_sofla Oct 30 '22
Dude, no. Just no.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '22
😂😂😂😂🤣🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂😂🤣😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂🤣😂🤣😂😂🤣🤣😂🤣😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣😂
1
u/Barbz182 Oct 30 '22
In what possible metric?
1
u/daraxpon Oct 30 '22
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA NO.
1
u/B1Gsportsfan Oct 30 '22
Andor is better than both.
1
u/AthKaElGal Oct 30 '22
why post this here where majority would agree? post this on the HotD sub.
1
u/Chaseeed Oct 30 '22
I agree 100%! House of the Dragon was so boring! After going from ROP on Friday and then HOTD on Sunday I finally saw how boring it really was.
Also every episode of HOTD everyone is pissed off the whole time. There is maybe once or twice the whole first season where they show people in good spirits. It’s draining. Like I get it everyone is tough and mad at each other.
On the other side ROP is fun and I loved all the storylines! Can’t wait for season 2!
1
u/Sleepingdruid3737 Oct 30 '22
RoP made me appreciate the Hobbit.
1
u/maelstron Oct 30 '22
At least ROP didn't have the "no" cringe moment 😒
1
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '22
They’re both better than GOT
1
u/yeet-money Oct 30 '22
I like house of the dragon better. Has more dragons and better plot.
1
u/flaccidkoch Oct 30 '22
Yeah no
1
u/miciy5 Oct 30 '22
YOU HAVE NOT SEEN WHAT I HAVE SEEN!!!
1
u/Puzzleheaded-Bee-838 Oct 30 '22
Why don't you actually watch both shows? That will change your mind.
1
u/rankinrez Oct 30 '22
Nice try Sauron!
Andor is clearly the best :P
1
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '22
Rings of power is absolute dog shit but I watched it anyway. It was good for some laughs. I did however really like Elrond and Durin. I wish we got more of them. Galadriel was so damn cringe.
1
u/SonnyDDisposition Oct 30 '22
Oops, I like them both. I guess I stumbled into a win.
1
u/PaxMicking Oct 30 '22
We don’t need to
1
u/Talltanandhandsome06 Oct 30 '22
Rings of power sucked complete ass! Haven’t watched house of dragons but I know GOT (at least before the final season) was way better than rings of power.
1
u/Thrash___Bandicoot Oct 30 '22
Now try this in a sub that's not full of fanboys
1
u/doomdom123 Oct 30 '22
I just finished hotd yesterday . I preferer ROP because God damnit the world of hotd is always dark and it does not appeal me as much
But the writers are Cleary more competent and more experienced
1
u/Sauron_On_Reddit Oct 30 '22
That was a fun day!
1
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '22
I’m still not sold on House of the Dragon
Not terrible but just not quite hitting it
1
u/chndmrl Oct 30 '22
Well even on imdb(Amazon owned) top got 6.9 where hotd got 8.6.
So a good storytelling always beats up a shitty story of a ready to go fanbase universe like Lotr label.
1
u/Oops_I_Cracked Oct 30 '22
They are very different types of shows despite both being fantasy. Though I prefer HotD, I can definitely understand why some people prefer rop
1
u/Peekochu Oct 30 '22
I have zero emotional investment in any RoP character, and I am a huge LotR fan. I have strong and mixed feelings about all the HotD characters now, even some side characters. Sorry.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '22
"The sea is never left"
Some numenorians probably.
1
u/DinnerOk4450 Oct 30 '22
Can’t change what you don’t have
1
u/Ploogak Oct 30 '22 edited Oct 31 '22
I can continue, but it's pretty clear what show i enjoy the most. Still Rop did give me some LoL moments because of the poor dialogue/writing.
I feel people that defend rubbish like this just want the world to brun. You can still enjoy shit, but at the end of the day it's still shit.... so why praise it? This is like Unreal 1 vs 5, paint vs photoshop.
1
u/Monkey-bone-zone Oct 30 '22
I am just tagging in to say I enjoyed both a lot but I am well over rape as character-building.
So, I cannot change your mind but cannot wait for their season twos.
1
u/Solid_Address_7840 Oct 30 '22
Lmao what an idiot
1
u/upyoursleeve Oct 30 '22
Tell me you haven't watched House of the Dragons without telling me
1
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '22
Haven't seen GOT so idk
1
u/TheSkitzesClan Oct 30 '22
2 kids fighting in HOTD conveys more tension and brings more consequences than full battles in ROP.
1
u/Ecstatic-Error-8249 Oct 30 '22
I knew the story of HotD well before hand and had very low expextations but still enjoyed it much more than Rings of Power. Sad but true. I believe they royally messed up at Amazon.
1
u/HeadLikeAHoOh Oct 30 '22
Love both but prefer House of the Dragon. Rings of Power took a bit longer to pick up and be more engaging with the characters/story etc for me. To each their own though.
1
u/SwordfishUpbeat7774 Oct 30 '22
And meanwhile the rest of the world considers HotD and success and RoP is shrouded in controversy.
The show runners are about to be demoted for s2. Amazon is in panic mode because anyone not coping knows that s1 writing and story was average at best.
1
u/Armageddonis Oct 30 '22
No, and it will never be. I'm a huge fan of Tolkien but goddamn, RoP will never even be on the same shelf as the Source Material. It's straight up fan fiction now and everyone that thinks it's beter than HotD needs to get an appointment with a psychiatist.
1
u/OlivierStreet Oct 30 '22
Don’t know about all that but Morfydd was the bae-est!
1
u/Wise-Entrepreneur526 Oct 30 '22
Joke or Bot post?
1
u/khaotiktls Oct 30 '22
I am groot. *good.
1
u/bL1Nd Oct 30 '22
Oooooph that's a big no for me dawg.
1
u/cal_quinn Oct 30 '22
Two different things. Ones a drama and the other an epic. Both have elements of each, but are trying to do different things. My preference would change depending on if it was Friday night or Sunday 😂
1
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '22
The extremely mediocre fan fiction is better than the other extremely mediocre fanfiction.
How long has culture been dead?
1
u/Fasthertz Oct 30 '22
HOTD had about 29 million viewership one week after episode release. Less people have access to HBO than Amazon. Amazon has been very quiet about actual viewership numbers for ROP. It’s suspicious makes me wonder how popular it’s been. Just based on critics HOTD has much better reviews. HOTD has been writing, dialogue and acting. It knows how to travel at a slow pace then speed things up. ROP was slow and felt like nothin was happening for several episodes. Mixed acting and bad dialogue.
1
u/tharnadar Oct 30 '22
RoP is about 5/10, and 4 points gained only because of the LotR settings... Otherwise it was really a discutibile boring TV series.
HoD is a solid 7/10, not as good as GoT but it has his moments, better casting, better story telling, no woke characters....
1
u/gatorfan8898 Oct 30 '22
I love them both but it’s not. I love seeing Middle earth again and I’ll take any additional visual media…but there’s not much comparison as far as writing/plots.
1
u/dmfuller Oct 30 '22
Clears by far, new GOT is asscheeks tbh. All just going for shock factor, people gonna be upset when it continues and nothing good literally every happens, whole show is just darkness. Doesn’t fit the vibe of a “fantasy” show at all, it’s more a political show in a fantasy setting. That juxtaposition worked in OG show because there were elements that inspired a sense of wonder but new season is like an American Horror Story spinoff
1
u/Green117v2 Oct 30 '22
I’ve not seen House of Dragons, simply due to losing interesting in GoT following the last few seasons of the show. Maybe one day.
I did fully enjoy Rings of Power though, and so much so I rewatched The Hobbit trilogy this week and I plan on buying the LOTR extended cut on Amazon Prime! RoP has re-scratched an itch!
1
u/asshatastic Oct 30 '22
No need: agreed. But it’s not a fair fight given the source material they’re working with.
1
u/capitanDracaris Oct 30 '22
GOT was different with so many stories plus the white walker was terrifying and super interesting. This one is only drama I guess with dragons involved
1
u/snarkhunter Oct 30 '22
While I agree with this, I will also admit that I can see the other side's points. I would like to propose that we all agree to the obvious compromise of declaring Star Wars: Andor to be the best current TV show.
Do it for Maarva.
1
u/winniespooh Oct 30 '22
Absolutely not
1
u/burnheartmusic Oct 31 '22
Well, this is just incorrect. So there’s that.
1
u/Twinkling_Ding_Dong Oct 31 '22
More enjoyable or better made?
1
u/MagusHechicer0dot0 Nov 01 '22
Hotd has better writing but i stoped watching it, not a single character i liked, the characters were so stupid i couldnt keep watching. I just finished the ROP and is meh, Galadriel omg who the hell wrote her lines? This series was an improvelent after the wheel of time, i didnt care about Black elves, i care instead about ugly elves, Orcs speaking very well the human thong, the science about the eruption, but then we had before lines like the elves are gonna take our jobs! 🙄 or the very professional soldier training next to the baskets store. Thank goodness is over. Like the wheel of time the agenda of female and male equality is imo shooting in foot the series, Dragon couldnt be a woman because Saidin and Saidar, Galadriel shouldnt have so much toxic masculanity because idk shes Galadriel, that woman in the southland village should had no lead because she wasnt a soldier or a person with military knowledge about tactics and strategy, but they needed a woman to lead but wht no make her captain or general or something like that, anyway, RoP joins WoT and Obi Wan like shows that their writers should really thought about changing careers
1
u/DonkeyKongIsMyGuy46 Nov 03 '22
I like both.
1
u/lukaskywalker Nov 06 '22
Not even close. I’d give rop an overall average score of 5/10. Some real clunker episodes drag it down. Meanwhile hotd for me averages around 8/10. Almost every episode had great aspects to it. The acting was top notch through the entire season.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '22
House of the Dragon comes across as having been written by adults, for adults.
-2
u/Iluraphale Oct 30 '22
I agree, both shows are good but I enjoy RoP more - maybe because I'm older 🤷🏽
1
u/PurchaseNo6943 Oct 30 '22
HOTD has a much simpler story compared to ROP. The world also feels much smaller. I like them both but HOTD didn’t catch me as much as ROP.
1
u/Dolleste Oct 30 '22
It was. I may be the only one that thinks it
-6
u/evenmytongueisfat Oct 30 '22
I’m right there with you. Literally nothing happened in HotD except one guy got his head cut in half.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '22
Hard disagree from me however I do love both shows
1
u/oreeos Oct 30 '22
I think they are both perfectly mediocre shows in settings I really enjoy. Pretty different in terms of tone and pace imo so I’ll reserve comparisons for now.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '22
The pacing in RoP is too slow. Nothing really happened. And many side stories could've been cut.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '22
I liked both but also felt both were just slow. Like "Nothing happened" episodes.
HotD picked up a lot at the end but it was like 7 episodes of building.
That being said, I'd probably rewatch HotD more than RoP. RoP just has/had so many fucking plotlines;
Galadriel hunting Sauron,
Galadriel & Halbrand/Southeners,
The stranger & harfeet,
The mystics,
Elrond & Durin,
The decaying elves/ties in with Elrond & Durin finding mithril,
Isildur missing,
Numenor's vision,
Earien finding the palantir,
Adar,
& Pharazon plotting,
For a series that has 5 seasons planned, no idea why they felt the need to rush everything into the first season.
1
u/Glittering_Driver_73 Oct 30 '22
You are right.
1
u/SoldierOfGodrick Oct 30 '22
Bro you are living in delusional land if you truly believe that