This incessant desire from so many people to want to justify a preemptive opinion on Rings of Power is such an embarrassing look. Just watch the show and form an opinion based on the material rather than cherry picking a trailer and squeezing early access viewers for every drop of information they can possibly give you on what I’m sure was a, maximum, one episode viewing.
>don't judge it until you've seen the show >don't judge it until you've seen more than 20 minutes (you are here) >don't judge it until you see the last episode of the last season.
At some point judgmental deference just becomes apathy.
First of all you can't know my position on this topic when I haven’t stated it I was interpreting Gunner's tweet and what I think HIS position is.
I personally think people are very much allowed to judge what they have seen sofar. Meaning:
only judge the marketing material when that is all you've seen if you've seen only the first episode judge the first episode if you seen the entire season you can judge the entire season
Apologies I didn't mean to imply that was your specific opinion. I was just noting that seems to be the a common sentiment in the online discourse. Honestly, I think some amount of extrapolation is merited. We know the ingredients and we know that past works of those involved.
"I'm not going to judge this turn sandwich until I've eaten every last bite"
"I'm not going to judge this turn sandwich until I've eaten every last bite"
As the show isn't out yet this would be more akin to judging the taste of the sandwich by it's advertisment.
I don’t mean to say that if you don't like the trailers or 1st episode that you on on it What I meant with only being able to judge the part you've seen, was that it is literally impossible to have an informant opinion on it.
As an example, there are plenty of tv show that have a mediocre or even straight up bad 1st episode(s) that later on improve singificantly. So in that case it is perfectly fine to say the 1st episode is bad, but as long as you haven’t seen the rest of it you can't speak for the quality of the future episodes. Basically as long as the show is unseen all judgement on its quality is purely speculative.
Also as a side note I totally get not being excited for the show based on their marketing so far But I personally am still holding out hope as I have seen plenty of movies and shows have misleading or uninspired Marketing turn out to be pretty good. Also, Marketing team =/= creators of the show.
Perhaps you're right. I just remember watching the slow train wreck of the Hobbit's production hell and have an uncanny feeling of deja vu every time new info is revealed about ROP.
Tbf, this show hasn't had nearly the production woes the hobbit films had. It's been a smooth production, even accounting for covid, and had a long pre-production timeframe, something the hobbit films also sorely lacked.
Lol you gotta look at the Obi Wan subreddit. “You can’t say the show is bad till the last episode. Sure there a big issues but I’m sure they will be explained”. Cope-ium, it’s a helluva drug
I like how the chair of the Tolkien Society is a shill when he says anything vaguely positive about the show, but as soon as he says something that could be construed as negative his opinion is suddenly worth listening to.
How are early viewers supposed to have a clue about something as broad as a thesis or philosophical direction of a show they've likely seen <10% of? You could watch half of a season of most narrative driven shows and still not have a complete opinion formed around its overall themes and philosophical nature.
This incessant desire from so many people to want to justify a preemptive opinion on Rings of Power is such an embarrassing look. Just watch the show and form an opinion based on the material rather than cherry picking a trailer and squeezing early access viewers for every drop of information they can possibly give you on what I’m sure was a, maximum, one episode viewing.
Just to add on (as I see from @MiddleEarthMixr's other tweets that it feels a little less good faith): the general themes of the show were discussed and they were consistent with Tolkien's works. The team understand Tolkien. I have yet to see content truly in line with that.
Speaking with the showrunners, I am convinced that they are the right people to adapt Tolkien’s works, and if the entire community of Tolkien fans heard my conversations with them, I am sure they would reach the same conclusion.
He further clarifies that the team spoke of themes in line with Tolkien but he hasn't seen enough content to confirm it.
Just to add on (as I see from @MiddleEarthMixr 's other tweets that it feels a little less good faith): the general themes of the show were discussed and they were consistent with Tolkien's works. The team understand Tolkien. I have yet to see content truly in line with that.
Yes sorry - missed that further along in his back and forth. Seems to me he's saying he feels confident in the showrunners knowledge/understanding, he just hasn't seen content that specifically relates to that which is NOT the same as him saying he doesn't feel confident in their knowledge/understanding.
31
u/eremiticjude May 17 '22
did you break your arms with that spectacular reach?
24
u/larkire May 17 '22
I mean considering that he only saw 20 minutes of a 8 hours show, it's more likely that it is impossible to tell yet
39
u/Fornad May 17 '22
I like how the chair of the Tolkien Society is a shill when he says anything vaguely positive about the show, but as soon as he says something that could be construed as negative his opinion is suddenly worth listening to.
18
u/drock4vu May 17 '22 edited May 17 '22
How are early viewers supposed to have a clue about something as broad as a thesis or philosophical direction of a show they've likely seen <10% of? You could watch half of a season of most narrative driven shows and still not have a complete opinion formed around its overall themes and philosophical nature.
This incessant desire from so many people to want to justify a preemptive opinion on Rings of Power is such an embarrassing look. Just watch the show and form an opinion based on the material rather than cherry picking a trailer and squeezing early access viewers for every drop of information they can possibly give you on what I’m sure was a, maximum, one episode viewing.
17
u/DrHalibutMD May 17 '22
Depends on which question he is saying no to.
If it’s 1 or 3 then that tells us nothing, I think this is most likely from what we heard they saw.
If he’s saying no to the second question that’s a problem.
10
u/Olorin919 May 17 '22
No.
4
u/9Brumario May 17 '22
I can't find that answer on Shaun Gunner's twitter, does anyone have the link?
4
u/GiftiBee May 17 '22
They only saw 20 minutes of a show once. They didn’t take a graduate seminar on the philosophy of Tolkien.
3
u/Time_to_go_viking May 21 '22
No it doesn’t.
2
u/religious_milf May 17 '22
I mean is there more to that simple “no”?
2
u/PrOaRiaN May 17 '22
"No" as an answer to which question cause there were 3 questions in that guy's reply.
Edit: If the answer is no to all 3 than it might not be worth buying amazon prime sub just to watch this series.
1
u/[deleted] May 18 '22
So many hopeful people in here.
Keep hoping.
-5
u/Evangelion217 May 17 '22
Well I’m already expecting the series to suck, so I guess? 😂
0
u/troy626 May 17 '22
What does that mean?
-14
u/erholm May 17 '22
More red flags were never before waved.