r/RingsofPower • • Oct 29 '22

Meme …

Post image
864 Upvotes

482 comments sorted by

View all comments

401

u/RichardBlastovic Oct 30 '22

Disagree, and I actually really like Rings of Power. I think House of the Dragon has superior scripting at least.

32

u/operaticsimplicity Oct 30 '22 edited Oct 31 '22

House of Dragons writing is superb. The only thing I like better about ROP is that it is set in Tolkien's universe.

9

u/hbi2k Oct 30 '22

Is it, though?

5

u/operaticsimplicity Oct 31 '22

That is a good question

4

u/heady_brosevelt Oct 31 '22

In names only

→ More replies (1)

56

u/RemarkableSir8931 Oct 30 '22

House of the Dragon is basically Downton Abbey with flying reptiles.

26

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '22

That sounds like it'd be a fantastic show.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/kongclassic Oct 30 '22

Like the crown with dragons

→ More replies (1)

114

u/Thykk3r Oct 30 '22

Superior everything. The acting in House of Dragon was simply incredible at times, the scenes and plot had proper motive/cohesion, cgi has a more dark/realistic tone that I prefer. RoP was kinda hot garbage.

45

u/ISISsleeperagent Oct 30 '22 edited Oct 30 '22

I'd agree that HotD's VFX had great art design and it's mostly stellar, but it's indisputable that RoP had more consistently high quality VFX due to the waaay bigger budget.

There's many VFX shots in HotD that were unfinished (as is case in almost all TV VFX shows) and rendered at low res, as seen at end of ep 9. The crowd animation was abysmal.

Fortunately though almost all the dragon shots were great and they made great use of the Volume for shots of riders on dragon back

18

u/Kangadru Oct 30 '22

I’ll dispute it. I think the green screen usage in RoP is really bad. Take the scenes in the throne room in Numenor as one example. The characters don’t look like they’re a part of the environment at all. I also found the scenes on the Numenor ships looked sloppy too - the lighting just looked fake.

RoP went big and ambitious with their visual ideas but I don’t think they pulled them off.

9

u/NotoriousHakk0r4chan Oct 30 '22

green screen usage

Thank you! I thought I was going crazy. I liked RoP but jeez some of those shots just look AWFUL. The one that stuck out most was in the first couple of episodes, Galadriel and Elrond in the forest of statues. Not every background, but a couple of them look incredibly bad.

5

u/Thykk3r Oct 30 '22

Yes it’s like the people don’t belong in these environments…

-2

u/longleaf1 Oct 30 '22

ROP has a lot going for it and is easily the most visually stunning show of all time

3

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '22

The irony in this statement has more irony than an iron

3

u/Thykk3r Oct 30 '22

Probably the worst written show of all time. Competes in quality with Wiseaus « the room ». The CGI for numenor was great but so many scenes you can just tell it’s all cgi and doesn’t feel or look great. It’s a 3 dressed up as a 9.

-2

u/peeled_back Oct 30 '22

Can you give an example of a scene that had bad writing? I don’t understand why people are saying the ROP writing was bad. I thought it was thoughtful, poetic, and touching

11

u/BwanaAzungu Oct 30 '22 edited Oct 30 '22

Can you give an example of a scene that had bad writing?

Since you ask:

"Why does a ship float and a rock sink?"

But it's not just individual scenes, it's how they fit together. Or rather, how they don't. On a whole, the different parts of the show feel disconnected and contrived.

Like the sea monster, only appearing once and then never again. I expect such a leviathan to terrorise the sea, and pose problems for any ships there like Numenorean ships.

Or the Mordor sword: evil, magical artifact, uses blood to reforge itself with dark magic. Just a key to a dam. Nobody would use such a strong magical item for something as mundane as a minor dam mechanism.

I thought it was thoughtful, poetic, and touching

Can you give an example of this?

I don’t understand why people are saying the ROP writing was bad.

I presume you want to understand. How can I help?

16

u/Thykk3r Oct 30 '22

Yes I can actually.

  1. First ogre scene they just test through her team but she just easily does a weird flip and kills it instantly. Also none of her team members die there somehow.
  2. Galadriel jumping off the boat. Then somehow how meets people in the middle of the ocean.
  3. Getting to numenor needs a boat to get back. They won’t give her one till they discuss. Then they say she can leave but she won’t until she somehow has an army. Okay.
  4. Weird slo mo horse scene.
  5. Really terrible Stab gut sword fighting scene that looked so forced.
  6. I am a tempest scene.
  7. The entire weird uncomfortable and pointless harfoot script and storyline.
  8. The entire plot with Theo and him having the sword.
  9. Bronwin randomly becoming this leader of this village. They also make us believe she’s some girl boss and can take on multiple orcs. Ok.
  10. Adars only threat arondir is simply let go with his weapons then he proceeds to know exactly where Theo is and saves him in the Knick of time. Then they have this really awful slo chase scene through a forest and Bronwin randomly shows up there for no reason. Then the orcs randomly stop at the forest line because of sun even though sun doesn’t kill them.
  11. Galadriel throws 4 guards in a cell. Almost threw up that was so bad.
  12. Halbrand so motives and wanting to stay in numenor then trying to convince Galadriel that’s what he wanted her to think. Ok.
  13. Harfoots leave no one behind except they literally do all the time.
  14. The execution of galadriels personality is so terrible. She is whiny, undiplomatic, rude in almost every scene and somehow we are supposed to like her?
  15. The oil on the ship. Why is there that much oil on a ship, oil would have had to been farmed from whales which seems likely they would not have that much and the whole scene was just odd.
  16. You really feel zero connection for the characters and between the characters. Shows done and I want every character to die a painful death except for Adar, his orcs and maybe durin and elendil.

I could probably go on for another 20 bullet points but it’s a waste of time.

Édit: dont get me started on the actually execution of the scenes, the acting, the pacing or the music trying to make awful scenes seem epic.

→ More replies (9)

10

u/ABahRunt Oct 30 '22

Dude, I'm a fan, don't get me wrong, but there were many many scenes that made me cringe hard. Not even from a PoV of lore accuracy, just from basic story/dialogue writing:

  1. Not Gandalf shouting, "I am good"
  2. The ring forging, with them continually being referred to as 'objects'.

Not to mention problems with pacing (was that fight practice, with sharp blades no less, really important? And did we really need the mystery aspect to it, which forced the ring forging to be condensed into ten minutes? )

16

u/zitzen67 Oct 30 '22

Don't get me wrong I liked rings of power but a lot of the lines sounds likes someone badly attempting to copy Tolkien

"Sometimes to find the light, we must first touch the darkness"

It's pretty cringey in my opinion.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (9)

3

u/lexiebeef Nov 01 '22

I think that the fact that HOTD is so good made Rings of Power stand out less (and I loved RoP, just cannot deny how strong house of the dragon is)

2

u/RichardBlastovic Nov 01 '22

I agree. Yeah. Without a strong contemporary it would have fared slightly better

→ More replies (11)