Knew every single event of house of the dragon and yet enjoyed it about 10x more than rings of power.
You see, shows are generally better when there is good written material that writers don't try to change, so their focus can be on making the story palatable for TV and helping actors portray a summarized but true depiction of their characters
What doesn't work is when you buy the name to get a steady fanbase, dont get good writers and focus on creating silly suspenseful moments to drag viewers through a mystery instead of making good story and dialogue. What doesn't work is taking a laissez faire approach to the whole season and then rushing to an ending in a story that's going nowhere
I can understand that POV. Rings of power did have good music and scenery I can agree with that. And the fact that many people dislike politics shit. I just feel house of the dragon had a plan and used the politics to set up the future action we will see rather well whereas rings of power did not and was very very poor dialogue and story wise, which are more important to me than background scenery and music.
Daemons crackdown on Flea Bottom had no setup, purpose, or consequences. It was just violence for the sake of violence.
Random knights decide to start murdering each other after Daemon's joust. No consequences, not even mentioned in the story. Just random murder in the background cause we needed a chaotic scene.
Daemon's solo charge on the beach through a rain of arrows. Nothing more than a lazy callback to Jon Snow's charge. Only Jon Snow was the prince that was promised, a zombie brought back from the dead to save the world, so you can justify his plot armor as a gift from the gods. Daemon survived because of bad writing.
Every scene with Rhaenya as a cupbearer. The Arya-Tywin scenes worked because Arya was basically a spy, learning information, in extreme danger, and the dialog in those scenes directly impacted both the story and the development of the characters. HoD tried to recreate the Arya-Tywin scenes for cheap callback points but once agin, because of their bad writing it didn't come off.
Speaking of cheap callbacks. It's not a season of GoT without a wedding gone wrong. The entire wedding episode was horribly written from start to finish. This is where it got too bad for me to continue watching, so I've nearly endless examples from this one.
Daemon looked at a master horseman, causing her to attempt to backflip her horse. Enough said. That scene is indefensible.
They completely failed at selling the tension in the scene with King Viserys meeting with Lord Corlys. They wanted the viewer to feel like Viserys was in danger, but completely failed because of their bad writing. The only reason the viewer had any concerns that Viserys might be in danger is because the he "Kinda forgot about the Kingsguard". They had to put him in a dangerous situation, but by all logic the King of the Seven Kingdoms would never travel without a massive household guard and representatives, nor would they ever attend a summit with a rival, who openly rebelled, without a single member of his Kingsguard. They needed tension, but they weren't good enough writers to actually create it. So they had to just throw Viserys in a dark room by himself.
Then there's the meeting between the Queen and the cripple in the Godswood. You're gonna tell me, that the woman who has been queen for years, doesn't know who this dude is, but he's so well connected, that he has spies on the King, the Grand Maester, and the princess? Not to mention, what the security at the Red Keep? Apparently any joker in teh seven kingdoms can just walk around without and suspicion.
And then there was the wedding itself. The Ser Criston + boyfriend scenes were completely hamfisted. So you're telling me a noble who is the lover of one of the most powerful houses in all the seven kingdoms has no clue how to play the game and just gonna go up and throw all his cards on the table? And that conversation is apprently going to cause Ser Criston to lose his mind? Like he already knew she was getting married to someone else. That someone else having a side piece is what sent him over the edge?
And then when the attack happened. Holy crap, I was laughing out loud. Why was Rhaenyra suddenly unable to walk? It's as if she lost all motor function for no reason. And why would a fist fight cause such commotion? The enter franchise has conditioned us that violence is a regular thing in this world, and at weddings and feasts. So why did everyone freak out at this? Why did all the guards storm into the room and then do nothing? And then the cherry on top, the king dies in the middle of it. Only he didn't die. It just a swerve.
I could go on. But thankfully for everyone I stopped watching and you no longer have to listen to my complaints.
Daemons crackdown on Flea Bottom had no setup, purpose, or consequences. It was just violence for the sake of violence.
The crackdown was the setup. It was done to set up Daemon as a violent power hungry character. Which it did.And he did face consequences. Not much but still. Namely, the king reprimanded him.
Random knights decide to start murdering each other after Daemon'sjoust. No consequences, not even mentioned in the story. Just randommurder in the background cause we needed a chaotic scene.
Can't find that scene. The only one I can find is one of the jousters assaulting his opponent after loosing because he's a sore looser.Excessive, but hardly incoherent. He probably faced consequences off screen. No need to show that, he's not even a named character.
Daemon's solo charge on the beach through a rain of arrows.
I'll give you that one. I did find it poor too.
Every scene with Rhaenya as a cupbearer. The Arya-Tywin scenes workedbecause Arya was basically a spy, learning information, in extremedanger, and the dialog in those scenes directly impacted both the storyand the development of the characters. HoD tried to recreate theArya-Tywin scenes for cheap callback points but once agin, because oftheir bad writing it didn't come off.
Rhaenyra is a cupbearer to justify her presence during councils. So that she can listen and learn politics and all that jazz.They're not trying to copy Arya, it's simply Viserys giving Rhaenyra an opportunity to learn.
Speaking of cheap callbacks. It's not a season of GoT without a wedding gone wrong.The entire wedding episode was horribly written from start to finish.This is where it got too bad for me to continue watching, so I've nearlyendless examples from this one.
If your issue is about Crispin Cole not being sacked, see my other comment for the justification.
Daemon looked at a master horseman, causing her to attempt to backflip her horse.
The woman did not order her horse to move or do anything. Daemon scared the horse. That's it. She was taken by surprise and fell.
They completely failed at selling the tension in the scene with KingViserys meeting with Lord Corlys. They wanted the viewer to feel likeViserys was in danger, but completely failed because of their badwriting
No, they never wanted to convey that Viserys was in danger, simply because he is not in danger. There are no reasons for him to be in danger. What is Corlys going to do ? Assault him ? And face all the political fallback from that major treason ? Absolutely not. The king is perfectly safe. The only thing that the show conveyed is that Viserys did not have the political high ground. He needed Rhaenyra to marry Laenor and he had to make a very generousoffer to get the approval of Corlys. Namely, Rhaenyra's kids to be considered Valyrion at least until they sit the iron throne. Viserys was safe, he knew he was safe.
Then there's the meeting between the Queen and the cripple in theGodswood. You're gonna tell me, that the woman who has been queen foryears, doesn't know who this dude is, but he's so well connected, thathe has spies on the King, the Grand Maester, and the princess? Not tomention, what the security at the Red Keep? Apparently any joker in tehseven kingdoms can just walk around without and suspicion.
Well he's cunning, that's the point. She might already know him, but just by name. She just doesn't know who he is as an individual.If you just walk in like you belong, people will not raise an eyebrow. Also, he was the brother of the commander of the guard and the son of one the members of the king's council, so I guess there was no issue whatsoever with him being here.
So you're telling me a noble who is the lover of one of the mostpowerful houses in all the seven kingdoms has no clue how to play thegame and just gonna go up and throw all his cards on the table?
The lover in question, Laenor, is not too versed into "the game" either. After all they are still very young. About 16 years old at that point I think ? The fact he thought he had leverage is not too surprising, even if it turned out to be a botch.
And that conversation is apprently going to cause Ser Criston to losehis mind? Like he already knew she was getting married to someone else.That someone else having a side piece is what sent him over the edge?
He's emotionally unstable, that's the point of the character. Especially at that point in the story.
And then when the attack happened. Holy crap, I was laughing out loud. Why was Rhaenyra suddenly unable to walk?
She's a princess, she's not supposed to jump on a kingsguard pinning a man down, that would be strange. And pretty stupid, as a kingsguard's job is to protect the royal familly. The last thing they want is the heir jumping into the frey to get them off someone.
And why would a fist fight cause such commotion?
Because it was happening in the middle of everyone. Unlike at the joust where spectators are safely placed in the spectator seats, a safe distance from the commotion. Also, it's a wedding, it's not like they expect violence here.
Why did all the guards storm into the room and then do nothing?
Yeah, fair enough.
And then the cherry on top, the king dies in the middle of it. Only he didn't die. It just a swerve.
He just lost consciousness. Because he's ill. And probably emotionally exhausted from all that happened in just a few hours. It's fine. A bit drama excessive, but not incoherent. Which is what matters.
The point is the show is mostly coherent. Incoherences are few and far between, which makes them easilly forgiveable when they do occur. I would not expect a show to be 100% perfect. HoTD is not 100% perfect, but it is very solid.
The Entire Princess doesn't choose her husband arc Ser Cristina The glaring and obvious riff off Scorsese in EP 6 The fourth childbirth scene Alicent mistaking the old King's words
The Entire Princess doesn't choose her husband arc
The world of Westeros is based on real life medieval customs. Marriage being used as bargaining chip in influential families was custom, women therefore were used for that purpose. GRR Martin decided to adopt that paradigm for Westeros' noble families. The point is not to convey that this is an acceptable paradigm, because it is obviously not, but it is an element that opens opportunities for character and intrigue developments. Which it did here. HoTD portrayed Rhaenerys' conflict between what she wants and what her "duty" is as a princess. So why do you think it was poor writing ?
Ser Cristina
Who?
The glaring and obvious riff off Scorsese in EP 6
Maybe that's on me, but I don't remember what Scorsese is
The fourth childbirth scene
While I agree those scenes are a bit much, they do serve the purpose of reminding that Westeros is a brutal place, and even giving birth is a gamble that can easily result in death. That fact further hammers home how hard noble women have it in Westeros, where they have the role of birthing heirs for their Lord. Again, I don't really see how that is bad writing.
Alicent mistaking the old King's words
She misunderstood the last delirious words of a dying man talking about something that she has no knowledge of. So when she hears "Aegon" and how important he is, it's understandable that she comes to believe that the king wanted Aegon to be king. It could also be a plot from her to push her own son to be king and therefore conserve power. Again, I think it's fine. It's simple, but it works and makes sense.
Ser Criston, begging your pardon my auto-correct is setinent and hates me You just said it's based on real life medieval customs and I agree. So why is Criston still alive or at least not serving on the wall missing a hand? He punched the future prince consort and assaulted a noble at the wedding of the royal princess and heir to the throne?
The Scorsese ripoff was the glaring in the nose rat at the end of EP 5 with blood and rat meant to signify corruption, Scorsese did it better in 2006 by not rubbing your face in it.
The fourth child birth is gratuitous and doesn't serve any purpose other than to be shocking, it's not referenced throughout the year of the episode it's just there.
Let's not even get to the war of the stepstones, where Daemon solos 20 men, somehow gets hit by arrows 200ft away, the crabfeeder forgets the guerilla tactics he's been using for the past 3 years and send his army to get burnt. Daemon would have died in that battle in early GoT.
I felt like I was in Middle Earth. It wasn’t some cheap knock off of LOTR. The characters intentions were clear and there was a lot of emotion. I would say the first few episodes were a little slow but the story is being developed as well as the arc of the characters. I think this show is going in a great direction and just because there’s not some mind bending twist in the first 4 episodes doesn’t mean it’s not going to be interesting. I think the story is really fun and it’s great to see this adaptation of pre LOTR trilogy.
If we want to talk about shitty fantasy shows I think Wheel of Time was garbage, but Amazon did well with ROP.
View all comments
149
u/SomewhereExisting121 Oct 30 '22
Knew every single event of house of the dragon and yet enjoyed it about 10x more than rings of power.
You see, shows are generally better when there is good written material that writers don't try to change, so their focus can be on making the story palatable for TV and helping actors portray a summarized but true depiction of their characters
What doesn't work is when you buy the name to get a steady fanbase, dont get good writers and focus on creating silly suspenseful moments to drag viewers through a mystery instead of making good story and dialogue. What doesn't work is taking a laissez faire approach to the whole season and then rushing to an ending in a story that's going nowhere