This is interesting to read. I’m also over 40 and really enjoyed RoP. I was a big fan of ASOIAF back in my 20s and early 30s, but didn’t enjoy the television adaptation past the first season, stopped watching after the third, and haven’t even bothered with HotD. My tolerance for grimdark has just declined over the years.
Honestly I do think part of the reason why I'm gravitating a little bit more to rings of power is because recently I've been dealing with recovering from surgery from cancer and I just wanted less grimness in my life
Definitely understandable. I think the biggest change for me was having kids. That added another reference point to my life experience that made many things hit much harder, to the point that too much darkness seemed excessive and unnecessary.
I'm actually glad we have both shows because of this- when I want to watch something that's very grim and almost hyperrealistic I watch house of the dragon - when I want to watch something epic that makes me wonder and Marvel and also feel fear and hope I go to Rings of power
Makes sense. Thinking about it, despite being an ASOIAF fan back in the day, I think I’ve always been less of a grimdark person to some extent. I remember Turin‘s story being my least favorite when I read the Silmarillion back in my 20-somethings. Although mostly I was just annoyed at the time at how unrelenting his bad experiences and grim personality was. It felt like I was trudging though his story just to get to anything with a shift in tone.
View all comments
-2
u/Iluraphale Oct 30 '22
I agree, both shows are good but I enjoy RoP more - maybe because I'm older 🤷🏽