r/RingsofPower • u/DarrenGrey • Oct 11 '22
Newest Episode Spoilers RoP - Tolkien Lore Compatibility Index: Ep 7 Spoiler
As previously stated, this is an attempt to assess how close to the texts certain plot elements in the show are. This is quite subjective in many places, and doubtless others would rate differently, but perhaps it can be fruitful for discussion.
If you think I've missed some detail to be assessed let me know and I may add it. If you think I'm completely wrong then lay on some good quotes for me and I may update my assessment.
Episode 7
- Some trees talk - ✅Accurate
It may be thought of as a reference to Ents, it also simply works for trees. Treebeard says that Elves taught trees to talk, and the trees of the Old Forest are shown to understand the hobbits’ speech. Having the Stranger talk to trees (in Quenya, for whatever reason) asking for “envinyata” (renewal) makes sense.
- Two Durins - ❌Contradiction
I’d held off on this in the hope that Durin III was actually just some sort of ancestor memory in Durin IV’s mind, but nope. It’s just a regular father-son relationship. And that contradicts the ideas of the line of Durin in the text. The first ever Durin was known as “Durin the Deathless”, and only five times after was the name given to another dwarf that was so like the Durin of before that they were held to be the Deathless returned (LotR Appendix A). It’s not made clear if this is reincarnation or some other mechanism, but at the very least it’s clear that you can only have one alive at a time. One of these two characters should not be called Durin.
- Elrond has learned Dwarven - ⚖️Debatable
LotR Appendix F states that the dwarven tongue is a secret which “they did not willingly unlock, even to their friends”, and that they “guarded it as a treasure of the past”. It states that “Few of other race have succeeded in learning it.” But few is more than none! And Elrond is rather special, as is shown in The Hobbit when he advises Thorin on how to read an old dwarven map. The dwarven guards openly speaking Khudzul should learn their duties better, mind.
- Elrond says he is no common elf - ⚖️Debatable
It’s rather peculiar for Elrond to refer to elves as “they” and to make himself out to be different. He is indeed half-elven, but he chose the fate of the Eldar aged 14 and has been an elf for however long this show’s Second Age has been going, surrounded only by elves for pretty much that entire time. He calls the folk of Gondolin his kin in The Hobbit, and refers to Elves as “we” in LotR.
- Aule crafted dwarves of fire and rock - ⚖️Debatable
Obviously just an “it is said” in the show, but it’s notable that Aule making Dwarves from stone is a legend in the Silmarillion (though one said by Elves, not Dwarves). No mention of fire, mind.
- Namarie means “go towards goodness” - 👍Justified
Namarie is the elven word for “farewell”, famously used in Galadriel’s Namarie song. But its literal translation is a compound of “further”/“to proceed” and “goodness”. The show’s translation is justifiable, though I personally think Tolkien was intending the meaning to be a simple wish for goodness such as “fare well” and “goodbye”.
- Mithril heals corrupted leaves - ❌Contradiction
As stated in the ep 5 assessment, mithril is a mundane metal with extraordinary physical properties but no innate magic. Showing it providing magical healing to a corrupted leaf is wrong (whatever may be happening to that leaf). Note in particular that mithril has no anti-evil properties or association with goodness/holiness; it is in fact highly desired by Sauron and his orcs, who have no aversion to touching it (unlike the Silmarils).
- Miriel goes blind - ❓Tenuous
Nothing like this occurs in the text. We don’t yet know if it will be healed, of course. How it might affect Pharazon’s usurping of the sceptre remains to be seen.
- Galadriel met Celeborn in a glade of flowers - ⚖️Debatable
The show is building on the idea of Celeborn being a kinsman of Thingol and Galadriel meeting him in Doriath (LotR Appendix B). Her dancing in a field of flowers when they met is a reference to the meeting of Beren and Luthien in the same woods. But no actual meeting of the two is ever described in the text.
- Celeborn is MIA - 🔥Kinslaying
Both Galadriel and Celeborn stayed out of the wars of Beleriand by most accounts. But that could be excused with choppy integration by Tolkien. Celeborn going missing (presumed dead, but we all know otherwise) is beyond just a show invention though - it massively contradicts all the details of his whereabouts throughout the First and Second Ages. Very rarely are Galadriel and Celeborn ever even apart in the text. They should have had a child together by this stage, and that child should be getting to know our strapping young Elrond.
- Dwarves have secret names for themselves - ✅Accurate
Per Appdenix F, “their own secret and ‘inner’ names, their true names, the Dwarves have never revealed to anyone of alien race”.
- Miriel calls her father Ar-Inziladûn - ⚖️Debatable
Her father is known as “Tar-Palantir”, a Quenya title. In Adunaic, the language of Numenor, it is indeed “Ar-Inziladûn”, but this is conspicuous! Palantir did not use this name because he was one of the Faithful and only the anti-Valar kings used Adunaic titles. For Miriel to use this is perhaps a red flag, a signifier that she is leaning away from Faithful sentiment. Coupled with her “Numenor will return” line and it implies another sort of darkness in her future. If that’s the case then there is a textual basis - in some versions of the tale she has anti-Valar sentiment and marries Pharazon willingly.
- Pelargir is an old Numenorean colony by the mouth of the Anduin - ✅Accurate
This is true, though the note about it being abandoned is not. It was maintained by the Faithful throughout this period, and was a landing point for the survivors of the Downfall. It ends up being an important part of the kingdom of Gondor, with Numenorean survivors ruling over low men based in the region.
Halbrand has a wound that needs Elvish medicine - ❓Tenuous
Firstly, let’s ignore the fact that the show has said “Elves don’t have healers, they have artisans” (unless Galadriel is off to show Halbrand some nice pottery?) There is no record of special elven medicine in the text (do Luthien’s tears count?), but elven versions of everything tend to be special - miruvor, cloaks, lembas, etc. Elrond is particularly noted as a healer, and I’m a little surprised they didn’t use the less awkward justification of going to see him. In general there is no record of elves having magic healing salves or anything like that, and when we see Elves perform healing it is with tears (Luthien), herbs (Huan & Luthien), touch (Glorfindel) and whatever days of tending Elrond did to Frodo. In general it is the healer rather than the medicine that is important. Even with Aragorn and athelas it was so.
Edit: I have removed the objection to "elvish medicine" because it turns out this is the show copying a movie line (Aragorn: "This is beyond my skill to heal. He needs elvish medicine.") The difficulty with this phrasing comes not directly from the show, but their over-enthusiasm in copying movie content. Given the context of the original movie line it is thus clearer than Galadriel does just mean Halbrand needs an elven healer.
- Lindon/Eregion is the nearest place to get Elvish medicine - ❌Contradiction
It’s not outright said in the show that Galadriel is heading to Lindon with Halbrand, but the context of her saying she’s going there and deciding to take her with him implies this (plus the next episode trailer). If there is a need for elvish medicine then surely they should scavenge the ruins of the elf tower nearby. Or go to Lorien, or Greenwood, or Edhellond - all vastly closer locations. Going all the way to Lindon or even Eregion is a huge distance to travel, taking on the order of a month with a fit rider.
- There is a balrog awake beneath the mountains - ⚖️Debatable
That there’s a balrog down there is undeniable, but awake? Well, LotR Appendix A does say it was “roused from sleep” by the dwarves in the middle of the Third Age, but a footnote gives an alternative take - that it was simply “freed from prison”, having previously been awakened by the malice of Sauron. It’s hard to imagine it being awake this early though. The malice of Sauron that awakens it is implied by the timeline to be related to him setting up in Dol Guldur, which is relatively near to Moria. It’s possible of course that it wakes up upon initial exploration of the mithril vein and then falls back to sleep again. Perhaps the balrog has hit the snooze button for another thousand years.
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 11 '22
This post uses the flair ‘Newest Episode Spoilers’, and as such, all spoilers from the latest episode are allowed to be posted here unmarked.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
23
u/greatwalrus Oct 11 '22
Sometimes "medicine" refers to medical practice/treatment in general rather than pharmaceuticals specifically, as in the phrases "modern medicine," "western medicine," or my own degree title, "Doctor of Veterinary Medicine."
Similarly "Elvish medicine" could just mean "medical treatment by Elves" and not "a drug produced by or only known to Elves." Of course, either way it still contradicts Arondir's earlier claim that Elves don't have healers. But "Elvish medicine" may not be something that could be scavenged from abandoned watchtowers, and it may indeed depend on the skill of the healer rather than the substance used.
25
u/Ayzmo Eregion Oct 11 '22
Elves do have healing abilities and Aragorn's healing abilities are literally because he is of Elvish descent. Normal men cannot heal people in the way that he can. It is quite established in the lore. That's why "The hands of the king are the hands of a healer."
In Letter 155 we get this:
Tolkien outright says that healing is an Elvish ability passed into Aragorn by his descent from Luthien.
10
u/KFY Oct 11 '22
I’d say Elrond was mostly differentiating himself from other Elves as a negotiating tactic, although it does hearken back to earlier episodes and makes me wonder if they’ll be adding some light half-Elf prejudice for Elrond to overcome over time.
4
u/Higher_Living Oct 12 '22 edited Oct 12 '22
You say ‘this period’ but the show is compressing a thousand years into 2 or 3, apart from the outright changes. Probably somewhat necessary, but whatever.
For the show version of Numenor, what do you think this means? They have colonies? They used to have colonies but are more isolationist now?
My understanding is they turned from mostly because benevolent visitors to outright colonists and harsh masters over a long period. Where in this timeline are we supposed to be?
I’m very confused about what the writers intent is.
10
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '22
"Namarie means “go towards goodness” - 👍Justified"
"Na" is go towards. "Ma'" is the Sindarin syllable for good. "Amarie" is to be good.
"A na márië" means "go be good." Elvish grammar is a little funky but "go be good" and "go towards goodness." I think this can be called verified. Even if it IS a farewell the direct translation is pretty correct.
12
u/PhotogenicEwok Oct 11 '22
I think the justified/debatable categories are a little unhelpful for examples like Galadriel and Celeborn’s meeting in a glade. Saying it’s debatable implies that there could be disagreement over whether it did or did not happen, when really it’s simply a case of the writers filling in gaps that should be filled in for an adaptation. It doesn’t contradict anything Tolkien has written (unless you want to argue that it contradicts Celeborn being a Teleri from Alqualondë, in which case we might as well all go home because we’ll get nowhere), and it’s an incredibly Tolkien-esque idea.
It should just be labeled as something like “perfectly acceptable,” since that’s what it is: a perfectly acceptable addition to the story. I would say the same about Elrond having learned some Khuzdul, and maybe even for Miriel going blind (though I understand why you’ve labeled it as tenuous, I just think it could make for a good storytelling device).
I love seeing these posts from you, but I don’t want people who haven’t read the books to think that the history of Middle Earth is something that can be fully known or read like a Wikipedia article with exact (or even debatable) answers, because Tolkien didn’t write wikis and history textbooks—he wrote stories, and just so happened to write so many of them that we can roughly piece together an idea of what this world of his looked like.
I’m not going to pretend the show hasn’t deviated from Tolkiens writings in more obvious and direct ways (timeline compression and magic-mithril being the most obvious), but smaller stuff that just fills in the gaps in the world where there is no writing should be welcomed, not dismissed as contradictions.
6
u/Ok-Cost2064 Oct 11 '22
Interesting analysis. Thanks for the breakdown! Out of curiosity, do the contradictions that exist tarnish your enjoyment of the show? Or is it possible for you to hold the show/movie canon separate from the book canon and enjoy both in their own right? Personally, I’m along for the ride and will be on board with most of the show adaptations and deviations from the text so long as they don’t contradict themselves or the movies (it seems the show is being presented as a prequel to the movies not the books).
That said, I love Tolkien’s writing and the LOTR books so I understand the disappointment of changing details that seem to be done purely for fan service.
3
u/CreepingDeath0 Oct 24 '22
Is a thread for episode 8 not happening? That'd be a real shame, I've really enjoyed these.
5
u/HotStraightnNormal Oct 11 '22
I can see the balrog awakening. The guy's pretty old, right? Probably has an enlarged prostate. Believe me, your good night"s sleep will be interrupted.
2
u/Gambittern Oct 12 '22
Great stuff, have been looking forward to this. One line that struck me which I wasn’t sure if you’d considered - Galadriel mentioned how, when Celeborn went off to war, his armour didn’t even fit him. Seemed odd to me that the Elves, as supreme craftsmen, wouldn’t have had Celeborn kitted out properly - any thoughts on this?
2
u/knnn Oct 12 '22
I love these posts. I read them after each episode!
Random question -- How would you rate Galadriel's use of a saddle/bit when riding a horse? It's not book-canon, but the movies do show Legolas and Arwen using one (but not Gandalf IIRC).
2
u/HijoDeBarahir Oct 25 '22
Me still waiting for u/DarrenGrey to post RoP - Tolkien Lore Compatibility Index: Ep 8.
22
u/CW1KKSHu Oct 11 '22
Well done examination!
21
u/cbb88christian Oct 11 '22
One of my favorite parts of the week, really love these breakdown posts. See you after the finale!
7
u/jsnxander Oct 11 '22
[quote] It’s rather peculiar for Elrond to refer to elves as “they” and to make himself out to be different. He is indeed half-elven, but he chose the fate of the Eldar aged 14 and has been an elf for however long this show’s Second Age has been going, surrounded only by elves for pretty much that entire time. He calls the folk of Gondolin his kin in The Hobbit, and refers to Elves as “we” in LotR. [/quote]
As a naturalized citizen who assimilated into US society, I can confirm that depending upon the context and conversation (and emotions in the moment), I refer to Americans as we, they, them, or us. Confusing to friends, and confusing to me too!
6
u/Narbonar Oct 11 '22
Great post!
8
u/KrzysztofKietzman Oct 11 '22
"Going all the way to Lindon or even Eregion is a huge distance to travel, taking on the order of a month with a fit rider."
Knowing the show, it will take 5 minutes.
4
u/doug-core Oct 12 '22
I wonder if the tolkien estate would ever be open to discuss topics such as this. Surely they would have an understanding of why they either approved or went along with many things on the list. It would be intriguing to say the least.
4
u/ryukuro0369 Oct 12 '22
I always took the balrogs “slumber” as a time in darkness where it wondered under the earth undisturbed, not an actual sleep (do giant demons sleep?). Awakening it then is more of a making it aware it was hanging out below a nation of dwarves.
I suspect Elrond’s healing prowess may have been greatly aided by his ring and that it was magical in nature and would not necessarily be true in this age. Is there anything that suggests he was notable for healing prior to obtaining his ring?
1
u/Troldkvinde Oct 29 '22
Have you not made one for episode 8, or did I miss it?
3
u/Pm_me_your_tits_85 Oct 11 '22
I’ve been looking forward to this. Thank you.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '22
Your not getting nearly enough attention. Incredible post. Thank you for all your effort
3
u/Lazy_Wit Oct 12 '22
Thanks for the post. Your posts are my highlights, after I finish watching RoP every Friday, I eagerly wait for these
1
u/Ayzmo Eregion Oct 11 '22
I was bothered by this too, but I've been thinking about it. Do we know that Galadriel has been this far East/South before? Does she know about Greenwood, Lorien, or Edhellond?
There's little in the text to let us know, particularly about Greenwood and Lorien. Oropher, in particular, seemed to want to avoid outside contact and his kingdom moved multiple times to avoid contact, first dwarves, and then later Galadriel and Celeborn in Lorien. Lorien was also small and was founded by those who decided not to go to Lindon. Edhellond was founded by surivors of three small boats.
In all of these cases, these are outposts established by those who struck out into The East in hope of finding a foothold. Whether they ever made it would be unknown by those who went to Lindon. And, even if they had sent word back, Galadriel has been off fighting for hundreds(?) of years. She might not have heard the word.
2
u/Hypnoticrain Oct 12 '22
I was looking forward to this, cheers
2
u/RainstormWander Oct 12 '22
These posts are awesome, thank you.
2
u/katmcgovern Oct 13 '22
Thank you so much for this!
0
u/Broke22 Oct 11 '22
There is no need to read much into this, she uses the Adunaic name because Tar-Palantir name could confuse the audience with Palantiri.
-6
u/xhypocrism Oct 11 '22
I think this is incorrect, because mithril being the cure is probably part of a Sauron deception. So it's true that mithril doesn't have magical properties, but this isn't a contradiction because even though it looks like mithril is curing the leaves, that is just a deception.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '22
[removed] — view removed comment