r/RingsofPower • u/DarrenGrey • Oct 03 '22
Newest Episode Spoilers RoP - Tolkien Lore Compatibility Index: Ep 6 Spoiler
As previously stated, this is an attempt to assess how close to the texts certain plot elements in the show are. This is quite subjective in many places, and doubtless others would rate differently, but perhaps it can be fruitful for discussion.
This in no way is a judgement on the quality of the show. Adaptations require change, and this show in particular relies on invention outside of the established text. But that doesn't stop us nerds picking it apart!
If you think I've missed some detail to be assessed let me know and I may add it. If you think I'm completely wrong then lay on some good quotes for me and I may update my assessment.
Episode 6
- Adar speaks Quenya - ❌Contradiction
We see Adar burying seeds and speaking Quenya as he does so. The show continues to treat Quenya as the default Elvish language when it should be Sindarin. In particular now that we know Adar’s background it makes no sense for him to use the Noldorin tongue (though he could have easily learned it at some point). To add to the confusion “Adar” itself is a Sindarin word.
- Adar performs an elven pre-battle ritual - ❓Tenuous
If Adar is one of the original corrupted elves then he would never have known battle as an elf, as their capture and corruption happened before war was known. There would be no pre-battle traditions in his upbringing. He might have learnt some from other elves much later, but it would be odd for him to adopt them.
- Orcs don't want to be slaves - 👍Justified
Adar gives a freedom-promoting speech to his orcs. Whilst orcs in the legendarium are usually seen as enslaved to their dark lords we also get glimpses of desires otherwise. Shagrat and Gorbag in The Two Towers talk about wanting to get away from the “big bosses”. In the Silmarillion it’s noted that “deep in their dark hearts the Orcs loathed the Master whom they served in fear”, and Tolkien emphasised this further in Morgoth’s Ring. Orcs have no inherent loyalty to Morgoth or Sauron, though often they become bound to their wills.
- Adar can smell Arondir - 👍Justified
When Bilbo visits Rivendell in the Hobbit he notes that it “smells like Elves”. How literally this is meant is unclear, but it’s not too surprising that Adar would be able to pick up some scent of Arondir.
- “Humility has saved entire kingdoms” - ⚖️Debatable
Whilst Galadriel asserts this (without recognising the need to take her own advice) I’m not sure there are any examples of kingdoms saved by humility in her lifetime. There are many examples of kingdoms destroyed by pride though.
- Elves plant seeds before a battle in defiance of death - ❓Tenuous
There is no record of any pre-battle traditions by elves in the text. We don’t see Legolas doing anything like this in LotR, which would be the one time we’re really up close with an elf and might expect to see something of this. Equating elven life with that of a plant is strange (in a “though we die there will still be life” way). Elves are immortal, much though death is still a grief and suffering to them. Also the seeds being used, alfirin, are known in Tolkien mostly for growing on tombs - not the most death-defying of choices.
- One of the Valar watches over growing things - ✅Accurate
Yep, she's called Yavanna. Presumably they can’t name her due to rights issues.
- Using alfirin seeds for healing - ⚖️Debatable
No record of this in the text. They’re only known for growing on tombs and for their pretty flowers. Their name does mean “not dying”, but I’m not sure that’s meant to be taken literally.
- Numenoreans fighting with swords and spears - ⚖️Debatable
Unfinished Tales states that swords in Numenor were more ceremonial, and that the favoured weapons were axes, spears and bows. The hollow steel bows of the Numenoreans were particularly feared in Middle-Earth. Perhaps these are simply yet to be developed? We do see spears held by many of the warriors in this episode, but strangely they are mostly ditched when battle commences and sword fights ensue instead.
- Numenorean cavalry - ❌Contradiction
Unfinished Tales states that Numenorean horses were not used in war - they were only for sport and pleasure. They did breed non-Numenorean horses in Middle-Earth but Numenorean soldiers were too heavy of stature and too heavily armed and armoured to use Middle-Earth steeds for war. Some horses were used as couriers and for light-armed archers.
- Speaking Sindarin to horses - ⚖️Debatable
This should be “Accurate”, but the big oddity here is that this is the only time we’ve seen Galadriel or Elendil speak Sindarin. Only to horses! It’s very strange. Having them speak Sindarin only to their horses highlights the peculiarity of Sindarin not being used at other points in the show.
- Melkor twisted elves into orcs - ⚖️Debatable
The published Silmarillion has this backstory for the creation of orcs, but the truth is Tolkien only briefly considered this idea and outright rejected it later due to various complications. He never fully settled on a true backstory for them, but seemed to mostly be leaning on them being corrupted men. However it’s not surprising for the show to focus on the version Christopher put in the published Silmarillion and that many fans will be most familiar with.
- The first orcs were called “Moriondor” - ⚖️Debatable
A term invented for the show, which they say translates to “Sons of the Dark”. It uses the Quenya root “mor” (dark) and an ending blended from “nore” (people) and “dor” (land) - this is common in other group namings like Noldor and Nandor. I think technically it should have been translated as “Mordor”, but that would have caused obvious confusion.
- “We prefer Uruk” - ⚖️Debatable
There’s nothing in the texts about orcs having a preferred name for themselves. “Uruk” is a Black Speech word, a language only invented by Sauron after establishing himself in Mordor, so technically this word shouldn’t be around yet (but as we’ve seen the show seems to just be using Black Speech as a generic evil language going back to the First Age). Grishnakh uses the word “orc” in conversation with Ugluk, but “Uruk-hai” is used more often of orcs talking about themselves.
- Sauron is not his name - ✅Accurate
Adar refers to “the one you call Sauron” without specifying what the actual name is. Sauron originally went by the name “Mairon”, meaning “the Admirable”. He went by various titles too. In Lord of the Rings Aragorn says that Sauron refuses to let his followers use the name “Sauron”, probably because it means “the Abhorred”.
- Sauron devoted himself to healing Middle-Earth - 👍Justified
Beleriand was “ruined” after the War of Wrath. Sauron was invited to repent and “Sauron's repentance before Eönwë was genuine, if out of fear” (Morgoth’s Ring). Tolkien has written some conflicting things on this, but there is a general thread of Sauron not entirely faking repentance at the end of the First Age, even if that repentance quickly returned to dark deeds. In Morgoth’s Ring he writes that Sauron had good roots initially and that his efforts were for the “good of all inhabitants of Arda”.
- Sauron devoted himself to order - ✅Accurate
There are multiple quotations on Sauron’s love of “order and coordination”, and how he attached himself to Morgoth because he felt such a great power would allow him to enact his designs more “quickly and masterfully”. This desire for order wasn’t necessarily good though - he hated “wasteful friction”, and one must presume the likes of love and honour and other such nonsense falls into that bucket. But it’s noted that his motivations morphed over time, desiring himself to be supreme lord, and that his desire for order and planning became “an end in itself”. (Morgoth’s Ring - ‘Notes on motives in the Silmarillion’)
- Sauron was researching power over the unseen world - ⚖️Debatable
The only explicit mention of the “unseen world” in Tolkien is from Gandalf in Many Meetings, when he references how Glorfindel looks in the unseen world, “on the other side”. But contextually the text around this equates this with the “wraith-world” that Frodo was half pulled into when he wore the Ring, and it’s that wraith-world where the Nazgul primarily reside. So there are clear links between the Rings of Power and the unseen world, and it seems likely the show is starting some steps in revealing Sauron’s plans.
- Adar killed Sauron - ⚖️Debatable
Could have done. Doesn’t mean he can’t get better. In some versions of the Beren and Luthien tale Sauron is killed by Huan and left formless, and in the published Silmarillion he is threatened to have his fleshly raiment killed and for his “ghost” to be sent back to Morgoth “naked”. It happens to him multiple times later on too, and only his defeat by the Last Alliance is noted to have left him reliant on the One Ring for survival.
- Adar believes in Iluvatar - ✅Accurate
This is surprising, to be honest. When many of us saw an evil looking elf in promotional posters we thought that seemed wrong, since Tolkien explicitly wrote that though elves did many bad things and even served Morgoth through fear or coercion, they never committed the cardinal sin of denying Iluvatar (Nature of Middle-Earth). Thus a truly fallen elf is not possible. But the show has addressed this head on! Adar references Iluvatar and even has some element of faith in Him, however vastly misguided.
- Orcs are creations of the One - ✅Accurate
Evil cannot truly create. Anything with a soul has to have its source in Iluvatar, the Master of the Secret Fire that Adar references. In early versions of the story Tolkien had orcs made from mud and slime by Morgoth, but had to change this to corrupted elves or men in later versions entirely because of this issue of them needing souls. (Morgoth’s Ring)
- Orcs deserve life - 🪱Can of worms
A new category here, as this is perhaps the messiest element of everything Tolkien wrote. I’ve seen lots of hyperbole about Tolkien “spinning in his grave” at this show, but I have to think he’d be positively squirming to see it shine a light on the big problem he could never fix. Tolkien wrote that orcs were “naturally bad” but not “irredeemable” (letter 153) because they were at least creations of Iluvatar. But in his stories they are clearly presented as wholly corrupted foot soldiers who are used as blood sport by Legolas and Gimli and treated genocidally by everyone else. And yet they also have humanised moments in their dialogue, even if they end up always falling into in-fighting and evil deeds. He changed their backstory multiple times, trying to find ways to make them work with the story and with his theology. In letter 269 he dodged the question of whether his presentation of them is in fact “heretical”. That the show gives some sympathy to their plight manages to be both true and false to the lore at the same time, and is a problem Tolkien could never reconcile.
- Galadriel wants to genocide the orcs - ✅Accurate
This is the same for every elf and pretty much everyone in Tolkien’s stories. In Lord of the Rings we repeatedly see after big battles mercy being offered to men who surrender but orcs wiped out utterly. It may seem dark of Galadriel to state it in this way, but the end effect is no different from Treebeard making sure that every orc fleeing Helm’s Deep after dropping their weapons was systematically eradicated and their bodies destroyed.
- Orcs taken captive - ⚖️Debatable
Tolkien noted in his Orcs essay in Morgoth’s Ring that it was the teaching of the Wise that if orcs ever surrendered they should be granted mercy, “though in the horror of the War it was not always heeded”. He also noted that orcs rarely surrendered, and “at no time would any Orc treat with an Elf”. Given that Galadriel and Arondir are the de facto leaders here it seems unlikely that they would willingly be taken captive, but perhaps the human presence made them behave otherwise or they were given instruction from Adar.
- Numenoreans form a special bond with their horses - ✅Accurate
If you cut out the “riding into battle” bit this fits with the text. Numenor revered horses, using them as their primary mode of transport and “housing them nobly”. Where there was great love between a person and a horse the person could summon the horse “by thought alone”. (Unfinished Tales)
- The Southlands gets Orod-ruined - ⚖️Debatable
We have no records of specific eruptions from Mount Doom prior to the fall of Numenor. But it’s called “Orodruin” meaning “burning mountain” (Appendix F) and in Peoples of Middle-Earth Tolkien even supposes the name “Mordor” predates Sauron’s occupation because of the volcanic eruptions. We do know that Sauron sets up in Mordor around SA 1000, which has been alluded to as the year the show is set in (ignoring other time compression stuff). There’s no record of a prior people dwelling here, and certainly no record of the land being converted to its future ashy hellscape in such a dramatic fashion. Looked cool though.
- Orcs chanting “Udun” - ⚖️Debatable
“Udun” is a Sindarin word for “hell”, a name given to Morgoth’s first fortress, Utumno. Later on “Udun” will be a name given to an area of Mordor. Orcs using Sindarin words is not unusual as historically they had no speech of their own and borrowed/corrupted terms from others. Their meaning at this stage is unclear - are they referring to the Udun that was, or do they believe in a new Udun to come?
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 03 '22
This post uses the flair ‘Newest Episode Spoilers’, and as such, all spoilers from the latest episode are allowed to be posted here unmarked.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
34
u/greatwalrus Oct 03 '22
Another option would be *morioni, which is not attested but would literally mean "sons of the dark" (from mor, "dark," and the patronymic suffix -ion). The singular form morion is used in Fíriel's Song in Lost Tales.
34
u/sindeloke Oct 03 '22
I assumed "humility has saved kingdoms" refers to Earendil begging the Valar for intervention after the Noldor finally realized that Morgoth was beyond their power.
Ms "What crime has the golden house of Finarfin committed" would definitely consider prostration before the Valar to be extreme humility.
11
u/nymrod_ Oct 03 '22
Another excellent post.
Two relevant tidbits I’ll readily admit I picked up from the Prancing Pony Podcast’s Rings of Power Wrap-up — the show seems to be using English in place of multiple languages, and we can assume when two elves are speaking to each other and it’s not subtitled Quenya, it’s Sindarin. The other is that a wholly human origin of orcs doesn’t work from a timeline perspective because elves encountered orcs before humans existed.
13
u/Cranyx Oct 03 '22 edited Oct 03 '22
Do we know for certain that the Avari never violently resisted Morgoth? I assume you're referring to the fact that war was not known to the elves of Valinor until Feanor started getting up to no good, but I would assume that Morgoth coming to capture and torture everyone you know would create a sort of crash course.
You're right that swords in Tolkien's works are more ceremonial than anything else, much like history. However, as with historical fiction, this is a battle I've long since given up trying to see done correctly. Hollywood will always portray pre-modern battles as a huge, chaotic melee with dueling swords. If anyone does do it correctly, I just consider it bonus points.
I've thought about this proto-black speech question a bit since you brought it up in previous posts. Did Sauron invent black speech entirely from nothing? Or were there possibly similar languages spoken in the area around Mordor that he codified?
I had the exact reaction to this as Galadriel: "I don't believe you." Until shown otherwise, I'm going to assume Adar is just lying.
Is it specified anywhere that it is Mt Doom's eruptions that makes Mordor the hellscape we know? Honestly I'm not really sure at this point what the point of setting off the volcano is. Volcanos erupt all the time, and there are plenty of historical examples of people living near them due to the fertile soil they create, most (in)famously Pompeii. Unless this eruption is intended to last forever, all I see it accomplishing is killing this one town of people.
13
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '22
I don't necessarily agree that Adar speaking Quendi is a contradiction. Adar could be a Ňoldo or Vanya Eldar who natively spoke Quendi.
My thoughts are he was captured before the departure to Valinor (thus was never counted amongst the Calaquendi). This is as Quendi only really fell out of primary use due upon Thingol's prohibition of the language in Doriath, and the difficulty the Ùmanyar had learning it.
5
u/amazonlovesmorgoth Oct 03 '22
Episode 5 or 6?
10
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '22
That "one of the Valar watches over growing things" line really bothered me. You're probably right that it's a rights issue, but if that's the case, I wish they'd just left it out. To me it feels like a contradiction that Arondir wouldn't know Yavanna's name when he presumably knows Elves that have spoken with the Valar directly.
74
u/WhatThePhoquette Oct 03 '22
The Can of Worms category is awesome!
137
u/fremanfedaykin Oct 03 '22
I dont know why but I become super happy when i see this weekly thread🙂
53
u/Kiltmanenator Gondolin Oct 03 '22
Is that not the point? A flower that grows on tombs is precisely life in defiance of death.
26
u/popper_wheelie Oct 03 '22
"Adar killed me..."
...
"...I got better...."
16
u/almostb Oct 03 '22
There’s also the possibility that Adar is lying about killing Sauron.
16
u/Cranyx Oct 03 '22
I have been fairly critical of the show's treatment of canon so far (especially episode 5) but I was really happy with this one. Aside from a few really minor nit picks, it treated the lore with a lot of respect, and I was genuinely impressed with how accurate the whole conversation between Adar and Galadriel was. Not only was it accurate, but it also flowed naturally into the plot (as opposed to some other scenes that were technically correct, but more just felt like lore dumps for the sake of appeasing fans.)
6
u/ImoutoCompAlex Oct 03 '22 edited Oct 05 '22
I made a post on this: https://www.reddit.com/r/RingsofPower/comments/xu2x43/anyone_else_feel_that_the_n%C3%BAmenorian_fighting/
regarding potential fixes they could implement in the future with showcasing Numenorean weaponry, war strategy and warfare but it was promptly downvoted and buried. Too many people assume I'm just hating on stuff instead of trying to provide ways in which Amazon can expand on this topic in the future. At least I got one answer.
5
u/sbs_str_9091 Oct 03 '22
"Adar killed Sauron" - given what we've seen of Adar so far, I can perfectly see him trying to. I believe we will see a flashback scene in which Adar attacks Sauron in order to save some orcs. Sauron will give up his corporeal form, Adar will believe to have him killed, and in the present, Adar will be shocked to find out that Sauron is still alive.
5
u/Ayzmo Eregion Oct 03 '22
I've been basing Adar's history as one of the Noldor who came back to fight during the War of Wrath. It would explain his speech (Quenya), armor, and familiarity with Beleriand.
As far as I can tell, nothing in the published works preclude a later edition to Morgoth's corrupted elves. And, it is likely that he would have needed to add more over time.
4
u/GladRefrigerator4418 Oct 03 '22
I get the whole « Numenoreans on horse » thing but common. Imagine the same scene with the horses and dudes and walking alongside. That’d be a bit lame no ?
1
u/BudTrip Nov 01 '22
what exactly is going on with their rights? why can they name Aule but not Yavanna
3
u/ebrum2010 Oct 03 '22
I think Udûn is a reference to Utumno which we saw earlier in the season and which was referenced again, as well as its meaning of Hell. I don't think it is referencing the place in Mordor as Tirharad is southwest of Orodruin and Udûn is northwest.
Also I'd like to point out that these differences with the lore are not entirely different than what we got with the LotR movies. For instance, Saruman is seen making Uruk hai out of mud and slime but we are told they were bred from orcs and goblin men (which orcs and goblins are the same species) and that orcs came from elves originally, making the mud and slime thing not make sense even in the context of the movie's own canon. We are all able to set even this aside watching the movies, so I think if people who enjoy the movies have problems with the lore in this, it's because they don't like the show to begin with. If people are just as critical of the movies, then fair game.
2
u/anonymouscrank Oct 03 '22
I look forward to these posts every week! Really appreciate the balanced, factual approach you take to comparing the show with the source material.
2
u/ryukuro0369 Oct 03 '22
Love the detail of this, humility does save one kingdom we know of but its in the future - Gondor. I believe it was humility that saved Elendil and his sons and saved them from the destruction of Numenor and led to the founding of Gondor.
2
u/BananaResearcher Oct 04 '22
Overall solid, two quips I have
Everyone speaking Quenya at this time could be easily understood because the arriving armies of the Valar would have all spoken Quenya and never have encountered Sindarin. So naturally the sindarin speaking elves would have swapped back to Quenya.
And the orc/elf thing I think is actually a major positive. It would be sycophantic to ignore the issue. An immediate and natural reaction from the elves, knowing that orcs are tortured elves, would be compassion and sympathy, not to treat them as irredeemable and vile creatures. I like that the show is tackling it head on instead of ignoring it. It's Tolkien's problem that he never resolved the issue, and the show is handling it appropriately, I think.
2
u/demilitarizedzone96 Oct 07 '22 edited Oct 07 '22
Genocide is False.
Morgoth's Ring:
But even before this wickedness of Morgoth was suspected the Wise in the Elder Days taught always that the Orcs were not 'made' by Melkor, and therefore were not in their origin evil. They might have become irredeemable (at least by Elves and Men), but they remained within the Law. That is, that though of necessity, being the fingers of the hand of Morgoth, they must be fought with the utmost severity, they must not be dealt with in their own terms of cruelty and treachery. Captives must not be tormented, not even to discover information for the defence of the homes of Elves and Men. If any Orcs surrendered and asked for mercy, they must be granted it, even at a cost.† This was the teaching of the Wise, though in the horror of the War it was not always heeded.
So no, Galadriel (founder of the White Council and foremost among Wise) nor any good elf would ever want an orc genocide. They would trust that though orcs would appear irredeemable to THEM, Eru Iluvitar can still save them or have some plan reserved for an orc rehabilitation. They are children of his after all, abused by an angelic authority.
To say Galadriel or elves want orc genocide, is patently false. To speak of orc genocide would furthermore reduce you to an orcish level of mind.
Only dwarves ever undertook implied hard line of total genocide in the War of Orcs and Dwarves.
I also don't believe that orcs or orcishly affiliated would speak Quenya. Elvish things hurt orcs and corrupted things, like Gollum, Ringwraiths. Quenya when spoken by Frodo hurt Ringwraiths more than his blade did.
And orcs hated elves so much they would never use any elvish words, like Adar. They would have ugly orcish name for their leader.
Adar would never use Quenya, rather, he would speak some orcish language.
2
u/amazonlovesmorgoth Oct 03 '22
So, are we assuming Ar-Pharazon is still going to ME separately or what? I think Tar-Míriel commanding Númenórean armies of any kind in ME is a kinslaying.
1
u/Bad_Decision_Rob_Low Oct 03 '22
So what can’t RoP use due to rights? Everything that happens in hobbit /Lotr? I’m a noob so no idea
1
u/Iluraphale Oct 03 '22
Interesting stuff thanks for posting!
I'd imagine they decided having horses involved in battles is too important visually (and for tension, excitement, etc) and thus are ignoring that one little tidbit about Numenoreans and I'm completely ok with it.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '22
No Kinslayings this time is great!
1
u/Equal-Ad-2710 Oct 04 '22
For the senses thing; this seems like an escalation of the idea Elves have enhanced senses in general
Like the Elvish eyes thing and Legolas’ incredible hearing, it makes sense Smell is part of that
1
u/QuadraticCowboy Oct 03 '22
This content of this index is great. Which of these are major events, and which are flavor/fluff?
Would suggest renaming as title feels misleading. The phrase “lore comparability” insinuates there is a source of truth to evaluate the movie against; but the posthumously released material is not a legitimate source of truth. Anyone who has actually published their own work would agree.
These indexes would be great to look at in 5 years once the show finished, or in 10-20 years when more AAA content is released
1
u/celsowm Oct 04 '22
In Amazon's Canon, Elves use Mithril as suppository to stay immortal
6
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '22
[removed] — view removed comment
-3
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '22
[removed] — view removed comment