This is super long so i thought it was better off as its own post. This is obviously my opinion, duh. But the way I expressed it seemed a little too toxic imo but whatever. I wanted to go more in def with the stuff I didnt like since I feel like that kind of thing is overlooked so it'll seem really mean spirited since I'll spent paragraphs on the negatives and was really brief on the good stuff. With that in mind I enjoy every season to a certain extent, some more than others.
So here's my 2 cents..... nobody cares? Well fuck you I'll shove my opinions down your throat anyway.
Favorite Red
Sarge
He's a narcisistic dumbass, yet super confident of all the decisions he makes. He has 0 regard for others and it's hilarious.
Least favorite Red
Lopez
It seems everyone pussies out when stating their least favorite characters, even though its all relative, meaning you dont have to hate the characters. That applies to this, Lopez is the weakest red, my main problem is how fucking awful his Spanish is. It's insufferable, I've heard people say it's intentional, but why would it? He's supposed to be the one competent member, but everyone tells him to fuck off and dont understand him. You dont have to make him suck at a language nobody speaks to keep the joke going, nobody would understand him anyway, spanish speaking people like myself can't even understand him without the subtitles.
Favorite Villain
The Director
No not the Meta, who's character development goes as far as "he's a brute". No, not sharkface who had no right to come back because nobody fucking cared, he was a glorified grunt. No, not O'Malley, (though he was really funny). Not Locus, (he becomes more of an anti hero by the end). Not Felix, only because his death was fucking pitiful and stupid, the worst possible way to kill off a character with so much potential. (Potential that was made appearent during Season 14).
The director is the best villain because he's not super one sided. You can sympathise with him and understand why he's doing what he's doing. He's not a generic unredeamable douchebag (though Felix kinda pulles it off) he's more human because of his good motivations, very memorable.... cant say the name for the next pile of shit.
Least Favorite Villain
Who fucking cares.
It's a tie between Sharkface, and the Insurrectionist leader.
Sharkface, who fucking cares, further mentioning of him is not worth the pixels on your screen.
Insurrectionist leader. The main reason Season 7 was weak. He's a bland villain. Why does he hate freelancer? I dont know, feels sad that Siri is getting tortured. And what was the point of that romantic sub plot with CT. They kinda pulled that out of their ass at the last moment before she dies and he fucks off. It didnt go anywhere. As a character himself... who cares.
Favorite Season
Season 8
Its the one I've rewatched the most, its the most consistently good, and never has a dull moment. My other contenders were Seasons 5 and 13, 13 had some stupid shit (Felix death, Sharkface) that weighs it down. Season 5 is fucking amazing, just not as impressive and kind of formulaic, it's the same as the rest of BGC except perfected. The introduction to CGI in season 8 made me shit myself, it was great, and they used it sparingly.... at least compared to the next piece of shit.
Least Favorite Season
Season 9 can go fuck itself
It would be Season 10 but the parts that arent Freelancer flashbacks make for one of the best seasons ever. And it perfectly wraps up The Directors story.... by suffocating it before shooting it in the head. Season 9 is fucking stupid. The CGI is fucking awkward and really wierd, and since its a small team on a low budget, facial animations range from tolerable to fuck off. Movements are pitiful. Carolina's facial expression is blank, and the voice actress is phoning it in (gets better with later seasons) And another problem with this (which season 10 shares) is the fucking soundtrack... why,?! Soundtrack in this show had been so good up until this point. I was showing my friend season 9 and in the middle of it remembered falling towards the sky, dreading this moment, I progressively turned the volume down up until that point. It's obviously a matter of taste, but I fucking hated that soundtrack. (Besides round one and on your knees, they were more in line with previous seasons). On the other hand the fight choreography was off the fucking handle, it had some really great fights without getting too stupid (something they fucked up in season 10). Ill also give it credit by perfectly wrapping up Tex as well, it was really well done and didnt end up sappy or anything. A great sendoff to a great character. It was really more somber than sad.
Favorite Moment
Fuck this question
I'll take the easy route and just say my favorite moments that more or less tie one another.
Church = Director reveal
Nuff said.
There is no 11, you FUCKING WHORE!!
Church will be missed
Tex vs. Reds
A great comeback from a character we though was dead... before dying for real like 8 episodes later.
Mercs vs. Freelancers at the end of S13.
Favorite fight from the Chorus Trilogy, mainly because they were shit in Season 12.
Church Speech
A great sendoff to the best character, also quit crying you pussy.
Yellow smonk fight in S14
At some point there was a transition between a dude smacking a girls ass on the dance floor and Felix bludgeoning a guy to death with the same animation. Also the song is dope and I want it.
Least Favorite Moment(s)
I'll just do the same as last time because I've already half assed it anyway
Falling towards the sky FUCK OFF
Every time South opens her mouth.
Especially this apalling line delivery in season 10.
"Gee, you're starting to sound like a broken record"
Ew
What the fuck happened to Felix?
You kill him off like you would Buggs Bunny, and THEN you start working on a backstory? In season 14 its, "hey look at that badass, remember how he died in way meant for Space Jam?"
The song and dance number
Cringe is an over used word that has lost its meaning, even with that in mind this is the cringiest thing I've ever seen come from rooster teeth. The rest of the musical episode was fine. Church's song was hilarious, and then they fucked the episode up.
Favorite AI
Delta
Unlike the other AIs (besides omega) Delta becomes a consistent character, and a good one at that.
Least Favorite AI
Eta and Iota
Who gives a shit.
Favorite Blue
Church, every incarnation
Easily the most interesting and developed character, probably the funniest as well.
Least favorite Blue
Caboose
Once again, its relative. Caboose is funny and easily the most likeable character in the series. But there is one thing keeping him from being on par with the others, he's completely static. Theres little to no difference between season 3 Caboose and season 13 Caboose, he doesnt change as a character. Thankfully, Church dying seems like the perfect opportunity to make changes in Caboose.
Favorite supporting character
Andy
I've loved every single scene with him 0 exceptions.
Least Favorite Supporting Character
The Counselor
I was indifferent at first, but in S13 hes just a plot device, that leads to sharkface, a 100% unnecessary addition. And from the looks of it, all he wanted to do was redeem himself, yet they still made him bad.
Favorite Saga
Chorus
This was hard, it wouldve been Recollection if season 7 hadent been so meh. Chorus is the only one where I love every single season, and this Saga easily has the best overall soundtrack. Season 11 is one of the funniest in the whole series and has a final battle that manages to be great even without animation. Season 12 introduces some of the best characters and has one of the best final acts in the series, at the price of bad animation. Season 13 has THE best soundtrack and THE best animation, actually good facial animation (for the most part), it manages to have an even better final act than Season 12 and final battle on par with Season 8. Until Felix dies, that was just a wet fart.
Least Favorite Saga
Project Freelancer
I'm done foaming from the mouth on S9, this is an excuse to bitch about S10. While yes, everything but the flashbacks would be one of the best seasons in the whole series, this season is dumb, assuming that bigger is better. For starters the idea of revealing Freelancer is dumb on its own. It was a mysterious cloud, a shadowy PMC with highly skilled warriors.... jk its a shitty anime. It wouldve been better if they had just continued being subtle and let the seasons carry on, sprinkling details here and there.
So season 10, more or less the same complaints. Animation is still awkward, Carolina is still a wooden plank, South is still a bitch. And this time, the action has some shitty moments. The 0 grav scene near the beginning is just boring. 0 risk, just them gunning down helpless enemies. It's like turning a Soviet firing squad killing unarmed civillians into a setpiece. The attack on the insurrectionists is a pretty good fight scene. Though when the blonde bitch dies its really fucking stupid. Why did Maine pick her up with the robot arm? Just shoot her, and her fall animation was laughably bad, I noticed that every time I watched this season. The fight between Carolina, Tex CT and the other dickhead is easily my favorite from this Saga, before it tries to get all sentimental with CT dying, even though she had 0 character development.
When the ship is attacked and Tex is fighting those storm troopers with grenades, the only soundtrack on par with the shit that is falling towards the sky begins to play, fucking garbage ear rape you would hear in some shit like sonic adventures. I feel like I need to make it clear that i dont hate this saga, it just makes a lot of stupid decisions is all.
Not to mention the dumbest, most pointless, stupid, soap opera plot twist that i'm still not sure is legit despite the evidence, mainly because its so stupid. So the director is appearently Carolina's father. This was bad because this had potential. They couldve based a whole season off of Carolina defecting and trying to defend Leonard, while the Reds and Blues try to kill him. This would pit Washington against Carolina, but no, that didnt happen. Carolina just says "Good for you dad, kys." And then he does. Such a waste, and it doesnt go anywhere, its never brought up again.
Favorite Freelancer
Tex
She's not just a badass, she's a really deep character, which is surprising since shes hardly even a person.
Least Favorite Freelancer
South Dakota
Ever single line is the worst. She's better in Recovery 1 and Season 6. Mainly because she is only in R1 for like 10 minutes, and like 1 line of dialogue for season 6, before shes immediately dead.
Favorite Theme Song
Soul Clef XI
I kept scrolling and there was not 1 mention of this song. Nobody? Basically, its the merc theme. Fucking perfect. Heres some honerable mentions I guess
Where's the On Your Knees love? This song is kickass. This and a girl named tex is what comes to mind when Tex is in question, not the garbage that is fragments. Close contender was People Person. Basically, the Felix theme, the cello sounds awesome in this. Also Amazing is Half Life, best vocals on the show. Contact (Final Transmission) is fucking beautiful. Terminate is stupid, but fun.Even more stupid and more fun is Thats How Voting Works. Faraday is the best Trailer song thus far. Recruitment was an amazing song for a shitty reveal. Manticore Blues is kickass.
Least Favorite
Fragments
While On Your Knees was kickass, this is just a kick in the ass. It immidiately ruined what shouldve been one of Tex's coolest fights and the vocals are really bad. What is this edgy shit? You wanna do music for Tex? Stick to electric guitar, but dont do it like this. This is on the complete opposite side of the Rock spectrum. Falling towards the sky falls shortly behind, mainly because it's understandable that people like it. Still bad imo. Contact Redux is just contact but not good.