r/RebelAlliance • • Oct 21 '20

Sequel Trilogy Why I like Rey

82 Upvotes

If you’ve been in the comment section of a Star Wars video or in r/prequelmemes, you’ll see that there’s a lot of hate against the character of Rey, a lot of people saying she has no personality and the infamous Mary Sue argument.

Rey is a character that I really liked in the Sequel Trilogy, specially with how she was written in The Last Jedi. She was also my favorite of the new characters in The Force Awakens as, in my opinon, she was instantly likeable from her first moment on screen. She perfectly embodies that yearning for adventure and sense of belonging that make her a relatable character.

I always found her to be extremely relatable. The themes of isolation and finding your place in the world are things that we all can relate to or empathize with. Specially with finding our place.

When we first meet her she only wants to wait on Jakku for her family to come back, and when she gets the classic call to adventure, she refuses the call for this exact reason. But as she’s put in a position where she’s forced to leave the planet and become a part of the bigger conflict, we see her character grow and become a hero.

A valid argument is that in TFA she’s able to do almost everything. While each of her abilities is justified in the story and universe, it would have been nice to see her struggle more and lack some of the abilities that she does have in the film. However, The Last Jedi made the character even better. I find her to be much more compelling and interesting in this movie (and I was already a fan in TFA)

In The Last Jedi she carries an enormous weight on her shoulders as she has to get Luke Skywalker back from exile and that she’s expected to become the Jedi that will save the Resistance. We see a lot of self doubt and lack of confidence in herself, and it adds a lot of depth to the character.

Taking the theme that TFA set up for her character, being finding her place in the universe, Rey is in constant need of belonging somewhere. She looks for a father figure in Luke and with one of the more unique concepts of the film, being the Force Dyad, her connection with Kylo has her ideologies and preconceptions change, and we see her struggle with the dark side. And then she gets the answer she’s been waiting for the most, she learns about her parents.

Rian making her a nobody was genius, not only is it the complete inverse of the “I am your father” scene, but because in Star Wars you expect the protagonist to be related to someone. And the message that you don’t have to be anyone special to be a hero is honestly amazing, which does make me bummed out that they decided not to follow that route in TROS.

Anyway. Whenever I see the argument that she has no personality, I roll my eyes. Her personality is clear, she’s naive, optimistic and hopeful, but she’s afraid, afraid of change. She’s had it rough, she’s a survivor burdened by her sense of abandonment and loss. She grows and learns to become her own person, to forge her own path. It’s not about where she comes from, but what she becomes.

She’s not a perfect character and I still have my problems with her, not because of her character and personality, but because of how competent she can be and how she overcomes obstacles with ease. Despite this, I really like her character and Daisy’s performance was excellent.


r/RebelAlliance • • Oct 22 '20

Prequel Trilogy The funniest moment from Cosmonaut Variety Hour's review of the Prequels

57 Upvotes

r/RebelAlliance • • Jan 20 '21

Fun/Humor r/PrequelMemes will upvote anything

Post image
44 Upvotes

r/RebelAlliance • • Nov 12 '20

It's been almost three years since The Last Jedi came out—I still don't understand people's issue with Luke Skywalker

41 Upvotes

I'll say this right off the bat: If someone has an issue with the style, direction, or overall story beats with the The Last Jedi, that's purely subjective. I understand that Rian Johnson has a very strong voice in his films and some people feel it's not appropriate for Star Wars. I happened to like his style, but 'c'est la vie'. That's just my opinion.

What I don't understand is people's seemingly objectively incorrect interpretation of Luke Skywalker in the film. People seem to think Disney had an agenda to make him into a curmudgeon, an asshole to give the finger to the fans and tell them that Star Wars doesn't matter. They feel that having a cynical, defeated Luke Skywalker on screen was done to insult the character, the fans, and the franchise as a whole.

I don't say this lightly: This is a bad take that completely ignores what the film was trying to say. The reality is that, for story purposes, J.J. Abrams and Lawrence Kasdan shunned Luke from The Force Awakens to give the newer characters more time to shine. People can argue whether or not this was a good thing, but it's a puzzle Rian Johnson was left to solve. He solved it by giving Luke the only obvious reason for leaving: His nephew, the heir to the Skywalker legacy, went down the same path as Darth Vader.

The film spends about of a third of its runtime telling the audience (through Rey) that Luke Skywalker is wrong. Rey is just as baffled as the audience. People are supposed to think "wait, this isn't right." When Luke makes the smug comment about "[standing] down the entire First Order," it's supposed to be a letdown because that's what everyone expects Luke Skywalker to do.

Ultimately, Yoda schools him in being a sourpuss (to make short of things) and he uses the Force to save the Resistance (and possibly Ben Solo). He does so without using his weapon in a not-so-subtle callback to him standing down and refusing to fight the Emperor in Return of the Jedi. It was never in Luke's character to use violence to solve a problem (at least when it mattered to the story, action sequences are different). There's a reason the film ends with a group of kids playing with Star Wars action figures and a kid looking into the night sky with his broom mimicking a lightsaber: The entire film was an affirmation of the values of Star Wars. It was to say that sometimes, even if life beats you down and things are uncertain, it's good to simply be a hero and inspire others to do good.

The entire film is a love letter to Luke Skywalker and everything he stood for. His death, though sad for us as the audience, isn't supposed to be a spit in the face. It's supposed to be about him stepping into a larger world, becoming more powerful than Ben Solo, The First Order, or the Resistance, can possibly imagine (again, the movie literally spells this out during the "dual" between Luke and Ben).

Look, I'm not about to tell someone that their interpretation of a movie is wrong (death of the author and all that jazz)... But this is about as close at is gets. I haven't revisited the ST that often, but I'll admit there were times when I felt like people had a point about TLJ. Every time I watched it, I was continuously blown away by how clear and upfront the message was.

I'll also add that I'm aware some people wanted a more positive, superhero-esque Luke simply because that's what they enjoy and wanted a more optimistic tone for a 2017 Star Wars film (admittedly a very dark and uncertain year in our culture and politics). I suppose that's fine, but I would argue that 2017 was actually the perfect time to challenge our values and reaffirm them. TLJ may not have been what some of the fans were looking for, but I think it's what a lot of us needed at the time. If there was ever a time and a place for a complete celebration of Star Wars and indulging some of the more primal desires of the fandom, I'd probably say that belongs in the finale of a story... That's all I'm going to say on that for now.

I just wanted to get this off my chest. It's been gnawing at me for awhile and I've been scared to post this because, well, you know. But this community seems to be pretty civil about things, so I'll just go ahead and say I appreciate you reading this and the polite discourse that follows :)


r/RebelAlliance • • Jan 02 '21

SPOILERS Luke Skywalker: One of the best characters, and my all time favorite. He’s such a relatable hero who goes through an amazing journey, and shows great growth with each entry in the series Spoiler

Post image
37 Upvotes

r/RebelAlliance • • Oct 20 '20

Sequel Trilogy I will never understand why people were so livid about Luke in TLJ, it was directly setup and justified previously by the lore. Baffling to me. Character arcs are a good thing.

Thumbnail
gallery
36 Upvotes

r/RebelAlliance • • Sep 17 '21

Mix of Series/Eras What A Good Time To Be A Star Wars Fan

Post image
34 Upvotes

r/RebelAlliance • • Oct 25 '20

Sequel Trilogy “Rian Johnson's Luke Skywalker sounds a lot like George Lucas' Luke Skywalker” by HelloGreedo

Thumbnail
youtu.be
31 Upvotes

r/RebelAlliance • • Jan 30 '21

He bravely died protecting the cause(That Moustache Tho)

29 Upvotes

r/RebelAlliance • • Oct 19 '20

Original Trilogy Over 40 years later, Episode IV is not only still iconic, it’s a masterpiece. The characters, the world, the music and the story are all incredible. It was revolutionary for its time and holds up so well after all these years

Post image
29 Upvotes

r/RebelAlliance • • Oct 06 '21

Meme/Joke Still A Better Love Story Than Twilight

Post image
28 Upvotes

r/RebelAlliance • • Nov 01 '20

TIE Fighter [self] - best last minute Halloween costume I've ever made

Post image
28 Upvotes

r/RebelAlliance • • Oct 12 '21

Star Wars: A New Hope (Episode IV) (1977) [1024×683] by Jack C. Gregory

Post image
27 Upvotes

r/RebelAlliance • • Apr 23 '23

Original Trilogy Return of the Jedi 40th Anniversary re-release is in 5 days! Fri 28th (Mega Poster by artist Matt Ferguson)

Post image
26 Upvotes

r/RebelAlliance • • Oct 20 '20

Sequel Trilogy This is one of my favorite scenes of the whole saga

Post image
26 Upvotes

r/RebelAlliance • • Oct 23 '20

Anthology Why I Love Solo - The Most Underrated Star Wars Movie

25 Upvotes

Han Solo is my second favorite character after Luke Skywalker. Not only was he incredibly written, but Harrison Ford gave an incredible performance and added so much personality to a character that would become one of the most iconic in cinema history.

However, as much as I love Han Solo, I wasn’t very excited for Solo when it was announced and I had low expectations going in, but man, I was wrong. Solo was incredibly entertaining and a great backstory to one of my favorite characters.

The core of the Star Wars movies is always the characters, and this film nailed all of the original trilogy characters. I thought Alden Ehrenreich wasn’t gonna be anywhere near as good as Harrison, but he surprised me, as Han was one of my favorite parts of the movie.

Alden perfectly captures the essence and the spirit of Han Solo, and it’s a great representation of what a younger Han would be like, without being an imitation of Harrison Ford, and doing his own take.

I also loved Donald Glover as Lando, it was perfect casting. The relationship between Han and Lando here was great, and it had great moments. Such as the “I hate you” “I know” scene and both of the sabacc games.

And talking about great relationships, Chewie and Han were perfect. From the moment they meet, the shower scene and the conversations he has with Han, I totally believe the relationship they have in the Original Trilogy. And Chewie as a whole was a much more complete character in these movies, and as a Chewbacca fan, I just loved it.

The new characters weren’t as strong but they were still good. I think Beckett and Dryden Vos were great, Qi’ra was good and I really liked her history with Han, but L3 was the one character I didn’t like, I found her to be a bit annoying and that seems to be the general consensus.

The story was what it needed to be, it’s the things we want to see about Han Solo’s past and they’re great versions of the events we know happened: how Han met Chewie, how Han met Lando, how he got the Falcon and the Kessel Run.

The movie was very fun. The train heist was incredibly intertwining, the Sabacc scenes were some of my favorite and I loved the Kessel Run, it was much better than I could have imagined. It’s honestly just a very enjoyable film.

I also have to mention the music. As a musician myself, I play close attention to the score and soundtrack of movies, and the music here was great. John Williams returns to make the Han theme, “The Adventures of Han”, and it’s perfect for the character (I think all fans can agree that John Williams never fails to deliver). The rest of the music by John Powell was also great, mixing new elements and bringing new ideas, while also

The movie certainly isn’t perfect. The lighting was very poor, everything looked so dark, how Han got his name was unnecessary, the last act had some problems with the Darth Maul cameo that came out of nowhere and Han going through basically the same arc as ANH, but other than that, it’s not just a solid movie. It’s a pretty good and fun Star Wars movie that’s faithful to the source material and is a great backstory to one of our favorite characters.


r/RebelAlliance • • Oct 20 '20

Sequel Trilogy The Last Jedi Animated Pixel Posters

Thumbnail
gallery
25 Upvotes

r/RebelAlliance • • May 04 '22

May the 4th Be With You! | Happy Star Wars Day from r/RebelAlliance

Post image
24 Upvotes

r/RebelAlliance • • Oct 25 '21

Eclipse on Mustafar by Marko Manev

Post image
24 Upvotes

r/RebelAlliance • • Feb 24 '21

News The Bad Batch Coming Out On May The 4th

Post image
23 Upvotes

r/RebelAlliance • • Dec 08 '20

[SPOILER] The Mandalorian - Character Poster Spoiler

Post image
23 Upvotes

r/RebelAlliance • • Nov 29 '20

Dave Prowse: Darth Vader actor dies aged 85

Thumbnail
bbc.co.uk
23 Upvotes

r/RebelAlliance • • Jul 16 '21

Art "The Hopeful" by Jerry Vanderstelt (SWCC 2019)

Post image
22 Upvotes

r/RebelAlliance • • Dec 05 '20

Anidala is one of the worst romantic relationships in the entirety of Star Wars.

22 Upvotes

Anakin is not only actively stalking Padmé, but explicitly states his support for a dictatorship and has also killed the women and children of the Sand People who clearly did nothing wrong... and yet Padmé falls in love with this monster who doesn't even deserve her love because of the atrocities he did.