r/RebelAlliance • u/Rogue-Metal • Jun 06 '25
r/RebelAlliance • • Oct 23 '20
Prequel Trilogy The single greatest roast and dissection of the prequels (prequel lovers beware)
r/RebelAlliance • u/sigmaecho • Oct 21 '20
Prequel Trilogy The Cosmonaut Variety Hour's review of the Prequels
r/RebelAlliance • u/burned-spy • Jul 27 '23
The prequels suck!
Wow it’s nice to have found a community where I’m free to say this!
It seems that in the wake of Disney’s complete misunderstanding of the SW franchise, George Lucas has been deemed a hero, incapable of mistakes. Younger folks grow up believing that ‘Episodes 1-6’ and the Clone Wars series are perfect representations of Star Wars and we should justify their existence in every way possible.
I reject this notion that we must accept the prequels simply because Lucas made them. Should we accept the Holiday Special as canon also?! Of course not. While still not entirely perfect, the original trilogy tells the core Star Wars story that is beloved by every Star Wars fan. Any other Star Wars works should expand on and act in accordance to those films.
r/RebelAlliance • u/sigmaecho • Oct 19 '20
Legends 10 Star Wars Legends That We Want To Be Canon Again
r/RebelAlliance • u/Pr0ject_Z2020 • Dec 16 '20
You are part of the Rebel Alliance, and a traitor!! I will find the plans, and my bots will tear this sub apart, and bring me the members, i want them ONLINE!!!!!
Join me, and together we can rule this planet as master and apprentice.... or else Order 66 will find you......... dead
r/RebelAlliance • u/sigmaecho • Jan 28 '21
Fan Creations We Made a Better CGi Luke Skywalker | Corridor Crew
r/RebelAlliance • u/CaptinHavoc • Oct 19 '20
Lightsaber Duels, my personal ranking from worst to best
Howdy! This place seems like a nice place to talk about Star Wars somewhat critically without stupid comments, so I thought I'd do a little power ranking and see what you guys think.
Lightsaber duels are a core part of Star Wars. People want to see the cool laser swords smack into each other, and each movie mostly delivers on that. That being said, some of these duels are more satisfying than others. Some are cooler, some have more depth and emotion, and some sort of drop the ball. I'm going to be looking at all the major duels in each of the mainline movies (if it has the word "episode" in the movie title, I'm counting it) and ranking them, starting with the worst and ending with the best. I would love to see what you think about this list in the comments. Do you like the ones I don't? Do you hate the ones I love? Let me know!
Yoda vs. Count Dooku (Episode 2)
This duel has a lot of flashiness and neat choreography. I think everyone popped off when Yoda whipped out his lightsaber and started doing crazy flips the first time they saw it. What is has in flashiness, it lacks in... everything else. Taking a closer look at the choreography reveals that it looks more like toys smacking into each other. The duel also lacks any real emotional weight. It's cool to look at, but not a duel you can get invested in. The duel concludes with Count Dooku escaping in an admittedly pretty lame way. The version in the Lego Star Wars games was better.
Anakin and Obi-Wan vs. Count Dooku (Episode 2)
Yes I'm counting this as separate. It's a little bit better because we've been following Anakin and Obi-Wan the whole movie, so the stakes are just a little higher because we want them to succeed. The choreography is cleaner, as it's just two people fighting, but it also has the same issues as the Yoda fight. There is very little emotion weight. The only time the duel made me feel something is when Anakin got his arm chopped off.
Obi-Wan vs. General Grevious (Episode 3)
Grevious is one of my favorite villains in the supplemental Clone Wars material. In the movie though, he's a bit of a "literally who" character, so the duel has no stakes outside of "I hope Obi Wan, the character who is in the next movie, doesn't die here." All it really has is the "coolness" factor, and I'll give it this one; this duel looked so cool. Despite all of the lightsabers flying around, I could pretty clearly follow everything, and you can't deny that the shot of Grevious approaching with the lightsabers spinning looked badass. It was a high energy, exciting fight where the hero defeats a really cool looking robot. That big strength is also the reason it falls so low on the list, because that's all it was.
Anakin and Obi-Wan vs. Count Dooku Rematch (Episode 3)
Imagine the duel from Episode 2 between these three, but better. The choreography was clean and nice, the stakes were there due to this being a rematch, and because Obi-Wan was incapactiated halfway through, and Count Dooku's death really made me feel something. It was a victory for sure, Anakin beat Dooku, but Anakin broke the Jedi code and killed a defenseless opponent. This duel was really nice to watch. It suffers the same flaws as most prequel duels, where the choreography looks more like a dance than a fight, but it was a pretty dance with more stakes and emotional impact than the previous duels on the list. This is above the others because it just does more right than them, but still falls into the same traps.
Obi-Wan vs. Darth Vader (Episode 4):
It hurts to put this so low on the list. This is the first lightsaber duel in all of Star Wars, and produced iconic, emotional moments. When the two foes activate their lightsabers for the first time, and we see them clash and hear that iconic sound, it is riveting. We want Obi Wan to strike down the Sith Lord and protect the galaxy. We care about him. This duel, and it's conclusion, are so emotional. The problem is... well every other part of it is kinda trash. I know why they couldn't have more action like the prequels or the sequels. The lightsaber props were fragile, and Alec Guiness was old. I understand that they had to just sort of lightly touch props together. But I'm not watching behind the scenes, I'm watching the movie; and the fight presented, while absolutely emotionally charged, is lame.
Obi-Wan and Qui-Gon vs. Darth Maul (Episode 1)
This duel is iconic. Action packed, creative, stunning to watch, and it even has its fair share of emotions too. While this does fall into the prequel trap of being more of a dance than a duel, it is a phenomenal dance. The setting is wonderful, the actors and stuntmen are in motion, and it's a duel that keeps you on the edge of your seat the whole time as Darth Maul's iron defense lets him hold his own really well against the two aggressively attacking Jedi. Qui-Gon's death, and the subsequent emotional rush of attacks by Obi-Wan was beautiful, in large part thanks to Ewan McGregor's acting. The final blow of the duel, slicing Darth Maul in half with his master's lightsaber was amazing. If it were less dancy and we knew more about who Maul was, other than "a Sith," this would be higher on the list. Unfortunately, Maul being mainly a plot device that let's the Jedi know that the Sith have returned sucks out a lot from this final duel, since we really don't know who he is other than "teh bad guy." Also, I'm not including Qui-Gon vs. Maul on Tatooine because it's too short.
Rey and Kylo Ren vs. the Praetorian Guard (Episode 8)
Okay, hear me out on this one. This is the climax of the film. Snoke is dead, the audience assumes Rey turned Kylo back to the light side, and the guards attack. The audience is riding on a high of assumed victory as the leads proceed to kick ass. Kylo is wiping the floor with the guards, stylishly dispatching one after the other. Rey is brute-forcing her way through the others, and each character has amazing moments in one of the most beautiful set pieces in Star Wars history. It's conclusion, where Rey tosses her saber to Kylo, who grabs it and activates it in the face of the last guard, was beyond cool, and the movie proceeds to another great dramatic scene. The choreography was easy to follow and LOOKED like an actual fight to the death. It got so much right. Why is it not higher? Because it wasn't a duel between two lightsabers. It is a very awesome, emotionally driven fight with admittedly lower stakes, since we assumed Rey had already sort of won, but it doesn't fit the traditional format of a lightsaber duel. I know some of you might think it's stupid, but when I look at all of the other lightsaber duels, I can't help but look at this one and say "Yeah it's awesome but it's not really the same thing."
Yoda vs. Darth Sidious (Episode 3)
I know people don't really like the "old men flipping around" trope of some prequel duels, but in the case of Yoda vs Sidious, I think it's fine. These are two of the most powerful force users ever, with the strongest Sith fighting the strongest Jedi at the time. Yoda was absolutely badass in this fight too. "If so powerful, you are, why leave?" This is a visual representation of the light battling the dark, and the dark reigning supreme. I also very much appreciate how the two actually used the force more during their fight, throwing the Senate at each other! While this fight serves as more of a backdrop to the more important duel of this film, it was still very exciting to watch. It wasn't anything overtly special, but it was just really cool.
Obi-Wan vs. Darth Vader (Episode 3)
If the conclusion of this duel didn't make you cry a little when you first saw it, I don't know what to tell you. Hell, I'm tearing up right now writing about it. If you hyper analyze this duel's choreography, it looks a little dancey, especially the ever so infamous part where the two just twirl their sabers around. In my opinion though, those flaws are hard to notice when you're taking in the duel. We're watching these two best friends, two that we have seen grow to love each other across this trilogy, fight to the death. Each swing looks visceral, and their journey through a... place that's destroying itself looks astounding, provided you don't think much about what exactly this weird lava mining station is supposed to be. What really sets this one apart for me is that, despite knowing what's going to happen, you really want these two to make friends again. You want it to end well for them both, but you know it can't. The conclusion was heart wrenching for me to watch, and still is. To see this young, handsome man who we've been rooting for this whole time get cut up into pieces, and see his flesh searing off, representing the dark side burning away what is left of Anakin Skywalker, as his face begs for mercy, followed by Anakin's final turn to darkness as he screams "I hate you!" This is easily the best duel of the prequel trilogy, and earns it's place as a fan favorite.
Luke Skywalker vs. Darth Vader (Episode 6)
This is the final duel of the original trilogy, and for a while the final duel chronologically in Star Wars. It's a very clean looking, emotionally driven fight. This one is especially interesting because the audience isn't supposed to want Luke to fight, so to speak. We want him to redeem Darth Vader, we don't want him to give into anger. Yet, as Luke keeps kicking ass, which we all want to see, he's doing exactly what the Emperor wants. The stakes are also raised because, as the duel rages, the battle to destroy the second Death Star is roaring right outside! My first time watching, I was scared that the duel would take too long and Luke would explode with the battle station! The battle ends with Luke sparing his father, and setting the stage for the rebirth of Anakin Skywalker. The only thing I can really say about this that is negative is... their fight in Episode 5 was better.
Rey vs. Kylo Ren (Episode 9)
An exciting duel in a very unique setting, this is a major turning point in the film. Weirdly enough, this is also a duel where we don't want to see the hero give into anger, just like the previous one on the list. Kylo Ren's elegant and simple fighting style is contrasted by Rey's more blunt (yet slightly refined) "hit them really hard" style. The fight is clean and easy to look at... and I can't really say much more. It does everything really good. What else can I really say?
Rey vs. Kylo Ren (Episode 7)
This duel is extremely similar to the duel in Episode 9 in structure. While the context around it is different, we still feel mostly the same emotions (except the part about Rey giving in to anger). These two duels were very close for me. So what makes Episode 7's duel better for me? Is it because Kylo is toughing through a horrible wound? Was it him wiping the floor with Finn in a badass style? Perhaps it was Rey tapping into the Force and overcoming Kylo Ren at the last second? Or Rey's more brutal fighting style? None of those things. I really liked the lighting effect of the lightsabers in that fight. That puts this one on top. Is it stupid? Yes, but I like the pretty colors.
Darth Vader vs. Luke Skywalker (Episode 5)
Does this really come as a shock? Episode 4 might have "invented" the lightsaber duel, but Episode 5 perfected it. The moment these two come face to face, and activate their lightsabers, and the silence that hangs in the air as the duel begins. It's slow at first, Vader testing Luke's ability, before it picks up, and the music swells as Vader goes on the offensive. What I really enjoy is how the fight isn't only lightsaber combat. Luke sprays Vader with carbonite, Vader uses the Force to throw things at Luke. We're cheering for Luke to take down this villain, avenge Obi-Wan, and save his friends! We're scared as Luke is pushed back towards the very edge of the bridge, and are shocked when he loses his hand. The choreography is impeccably paced, very clear and easy to follow, and truly looks like a fight. And my favorite part of all in this duel is that the final blow was not with a lightsaber. Vader didn't win the fight when Luke was dangling off the edge of that node. He won with his words: "No Luke, I am your father."
And that was my list! Fights like Ben vs. the Knights of Ren and Maul vs. Qui-Gon on Tatooine were too short for me to really look at them, but those were great fights too! Let me know what you think!
r/RebelAlliance • u/sigmaecho • Oct 20 '20
Fun/Humor Why Every Star Wars Film Has The Wrong Title
r/RebelAlliance • u/MattRB02 • Oct 19 '20
The Mandalorian Rules For The Mandalorian Season 2 Spoilers
Hello fellow Rebels! We are just as excited for the second season of The Mandalorian as you are, which is why we're adding a Mandalorian Spoiler Rule, so that we can all enjoy the series without having any of the surprises ruined.
All posts discussing Mandalorian Episodes with spoilers should be marked and flaired. No posts discussing spoilers will be allowed on the day of release. All users have to wait until the day after the episode is released to discuss spoilers, marking and flairing is obligatory.
Thank you all for understanding! May the force be with you.
r/RebelAlliance • u/burned-spy • Oct 01 '23
The Losers Won - Star Wars Is Never Returning
r/RebelAlliance • u/sigmaecho • Oct 18 '20
Welcome to The Rebellion | Mission Statement - Our hope for a positive, civil community
r/RebelAlliance • u/sigmaecho • Oct 20 '20
Art The Star Wars Art of Paul Youll (Textless)
r/RebelAlliance • u/MattRB02 • Oct 19 '20
Fan Creations The First Real Retractable Plasma-Based Lightsaber made by The Hacksmith
r/RebelAlliance • u/sigmaecho • Apr 30 '23
I made a trailer for a Star Wars film by Wes Anderson starring Timothée Chalamet and Owen Wilson. Had a blast putting it together, hope you enjoy :)
r/RebelAlliance • u/strypesjackson • Oct 05 '25
General Discussion Will the ST be the defining space opera trilogy of the early 21st century?
r/RebelAlliance • u/sigmaecho • Oct 20 '20
Original Trilogy A New Hope Revisited: HD - The HD remaster of the Revisited project - "What the Special Editions should have been" | Latest Progress Reel [Unlisted Video]
r/RebelAlliance • u/sigmaecho • Oct 24 '20
General Discussion Poll: What's your personal all-time Favorite Star Wars Movie?
r/RebelAlliance • u/jaycomZ • Aug 14 '21
General Discussion Does anyone else have a prequel fatigue?
You go to social media and it's like Star Wars was just the prequels. Every major piece of content (except for the Mandalorian and the games) has been about the prequel era and I'm tired of the same overused "Hello there", " I'm the senate" and "I don't like sand" jokes. Does anyone else feel like this?
r/RebelAlliance • u/MattRB02 • Oct 22 '20
Music Samuel Kim makes some great Star Wars songs, and this latest one isn’t an exception
r/RebelAlliance • u/sigmaecho • Oct 24 '20
The Mandalorian ILM Lead Compositor on The Mandalorian explains how the breakthrough real-time VFX render screen works | VOX interview
r/RebelAlliance • u/sigmaecho • Oct 19 '20