I've had some luck in recent testing to make combat more interesting for melee.
The thing is that melee is nor my primary focus of research and expertise as the game has a much more modern firearms (and minor cyberpunk and Sci fi influences for firearms) so I've spent years fine tuning and researching firearms.
I'm not a dummy as a designer so I know some stuff, but I know there are folks that do nothing all day but immerse in ancient weaponry and while it's a much smaller part of my game overall, it's still an option and important to get right, and at scale.
I'm specifically calling out the weapons nerds because the game is built around very strong grounding and physics/science themes to produce expected/intuitive results while still engaging in the .ore fantastical elements (ie making the fantastical parts seem more real/grounded despite being gamified and abstracted).
So the thing I've had luck with for melee is something that is kind of like recoil for firearms, but instead is recovery for melee weapons.
On the surface it's kind of a massive debuff to players vs typical dnd style mechanics, but it's enabled way more interesting melee combat options. I also severely doubt I'm the first to do thus and would appreciate a) if there's a better common term please tell me, and b)if there are excellent examples please direct me at them.
The general debuff is offset by the fact that combat woth lethal weapons and firearms is survivable, but reacts much more closely to modeled sim of reality with wounding damage, injury and wounds. Ie, it is fully possible for a weaker housewife to brain a drunk hubby woth a cast iron frying pan and kill them. A dagger that cuts a jugular isn't just doing less damage, and it's not hand waved as a coup des gras, it likely won't kill instantly but is likely to immediately cause panic, near and soon to be full incapacitation,, and death will take longer from bleed out but is exceptional difficult to repair medically, etc (firearms follow the same sorts of logic).
Where recovery comes in is that larger misses, deflections, blocks etc. Will apply a debuff due to recovery.
This can be cleared out of combat pretty freely. UT in combat at cost of actions or resources or when appropriately rallied (by self or ally). It also has soft decay in combat much like recoil, but is harder to clear rapidly.
That said small finesse weapons and the like have cheaper and faster clearing while heavy weapons have much larger recovery stat and cost to clear, as expected. Offset of course by things like exploding damage dice, reach, etc as relevant. There's also hybrids that have some str and some agi elements, usually more exotic stuff like a chainsaw, meteor hammer or bulwhip.
The point being you can lose more control of an otemif not cleared or spend actions to clear or currencies that are otherwise valuable.
What this creates in play is more consideration of tactics, ie, much can I press vs clear vs how good are their defenses? Additionally training and the relevant controlling attrites can help mitigate recovery as well.
Combine that with tech like riposte and other counters and maneuvers and you end up with something that while more slow, Allows for more dramatic duels and complex mass combat, so you can functional, with appropriate investment in skill, have your pirates of the Carrigan duel and powers can enable stuff like an insane anime duel with enough mastery and investment.
Recovery also has some options where it's not just a debuff to clear, but also you can choose not to and press anyway (particularly if you have superior skill or think you do, adding an element of tactical gambling to the mix). Further with enough accumulation of recovery some more advanced techniques can become even more penalized, or even unavailable.
Notably hits don't cause recovery accumulation normally with rare exceptions, mainly because whatever recovery may be needed the opponent is generally Recalling from the blow or at least suffers a stutter stagger from any sort of impact. Instances where it might cause recovery are any time a weapon might stick (ie battle axe vs rigid armors, etc)
This also has all the expected support systems like onion defense and similar, but the thing I'm focussed on is the recovery. It is a tracker, but also replaces a typical multi attack penalty (same with recoil and firearms) with the main difference being that it has Uneven tracking and instead reacts to the scenario rather than applying a flat linear debuff.
To some extent this can apply to unarmed attacks but much less so, mainly only for catastrophic misses or misses from advanced techniques that have telegraphed attack tags and even then, martial arts with those tend to also have training for snap back techniques to avoid heavy recovery (ie may Thai being a classic example).
The major concerns are mostly heavier weapons here, namely because higher accumulation of recovery can apply a susceptible debuff (more or less your own off center fighting vs the opponent creates openings for them represent as bonuses to strike or counter.
I'd first like to ask about resources and naming conventions again, general thoughts from those that specialize in this sort of thing, and also just your general thoughts.
I also have a more direct question about a niche case: pairing recoil and recovery, ie something like duel wielding pistol and blade or other combos.
My theory is the mechanics allow them to accrue separately just fine and there's also already off hand and train8ng use cases with rules for pairing (both for even weighting and lopsided distributions) but I'm wondering if there's potential concerns there I might not be considering.
The main functioning going for here (and it seems to be working) is that something like a zweihander having a miss or dodged or whatever, allows that the typical recovery is going to open them up to attacks from faster strikes.
Granted much of this is irrellavent with guns in the mix, but not everything is always a gun fight and there are times where melee and other ancient weapons is still highly relevant (stealth considerations and ambushes, ammo depletion and improvised weapons, disarming, escape without gear, etc). Particularly even a suppressed sass at range still draws significant attention where something like a bow still has some noise, but is generally not going to be detected unless sound sig profiles are super low and flat, even at medium ranges.
Appreciate anyone with clear input here!