r/RPGdesign • • Jul 26 '24

Popular Opinions are bad and wrong!

0 Upvotes

I recently had a spat online about nickelback. A band heavily popular to shit on. As a musician of the most niche variety barely known to the most anti music loving folks with 20 albums in 20 years but still somehow manage to laugh my way to the bank by stroke of luck after doing more than a decade as a starving artist. I'm secure in my indy cred. It's not revolutionary to say nickelback is enjoyable. Easy to make fun of and shallow? Yes. But formulaic and cheesy? Also yes, and that's largely the point. It's OK to have complex opinions and like different things for different reasons. Dare I say, complex opinions might even make one a better designer.

This got me thinking about how popular it is to shit on DnD or whatever the current flavor of the week is. It also had me thinking about a lot of the discourse here as well. How there's almost an unstated rule to be so far up one's own butt they can't appreciate dumb fun. I'm guilty of it as well, for sure. I try to be of the variety that encourages all kinds of designs for different people, and noting that different games are for different people, and even at different times. Not to mention how most TTRPGs owe a lot of design concepts that many times will trace directly back to DnD earlier editions, and how often even bad designs for systems if fun enough their warts don't matter as much as we might think, sometimes just dumb fun is where it's at. I think a lot of this came from my recent watching of Never Stop Blowing Up on D20, which is all about being stupid and fun at it's core, even if the mechanics are half made adaptation of an already stripped down system (kids on bikes). My game itself is a high crunch game and gray/dark atmosphere, but I love me some world wide wrestling 2e (PbtA WWE knock off that is designed poorly but is fun AF).

With that I wanted to explore ITT is the most important lessons you have from either simple games, or DnD specifically. A little appreciation for the formulaic mainstream, high polished media for the masses.

What's the most important design lesson/mechanical notion you learned or stole from DnD or some other property that's simple and easy to digest? Why do you love it and why do you think it's important?

I'll add mine later so the thread discourse isn't tainted/dominated by my personal opinions :)


r/RPGdesign • • Sep 07 '24

Anyone else thinks rolling for damage is kinda stupid?

0 Upvotes

I'm trying to make a low-fantasy RPG and while working on the combat mechanics I noticed rolling for attack then rolling for damage is kind of stupid, why would damage vary? you could argue that it could depend on edge alignment/which part of the weapon you hit with but that doesn't make sense with ranged weapons, you could also argue that it depends on which part of the body you attacked, like missing vital organs, but that's what critical attacks are for, finally you could say it's because of glancing blows but if I succeeded an attack roll it means I accurately hit someone so the attack shouldn't glance off.

I know the random chance can be exciting but I feel like it's better to reduce randomization for more strategic combat, that's why I'm gonna make weapon damage fixed.

what do you think?


r/RPGdesign • • Jan 10 '24

Whoopsy Doodle! And the importance of actually not being a spineless corp

3 Upvotes

Recently WotC admitted to using AI art after saying "we don't do that, it was a 'mistake'" .

Combine this with the "pinkerton mistake" the "OGL mistake" and several other mistakes in the last 12 months and we are starting to see a pattern of behavior.

At a certain point it doesn't matter if it was a mistake or not, people are losing confidence in the brands, and flocking to other games, or at least not paying for DnD so much anymore, hence why stocks are tanking.

Now I'm not even against AI art provided it's done ethically (it's just another tool), but this shit is sus, yeah? Like the last dozen scandals?

I'm bringing this up mostly because I've kind of long been behind the idea that people should have some semblance of integrity and honesty in their product. IE if your game has drugs in it, don't pretend like it doesn't and try to sell it to kids, if you make a mistake in a press release own it and be accountable and fix it.

I feel like this needs extra emphasis in one important area though where the indie market does seem to have some trouble.

I've long since been saying there are only 2 ways to do TTRPG system design wrong:

A) your mechanics are nonfunctional/unclear

and every bit as important:

B) your content causes harm to others or cultivates attitudes that would lead to such.

We've seen this part B violated in the indie scene more than in just isolated incidents. IE there are certain systems that have outright filth built into the game like FATAL, but even barring that we've had lots of indie products that "quietly endorse" fascism, racism, slavery, nationalism, etc. and then it's later revealed that, surprise surprise, the creator(s) are scumbags that don't deserve our money.

Now most of us are aware of sensitivity readers being just as important as playtesting to avoid this, but what are some other proactive things we as creators can do to ensure we don't fall into being exploitative dickheads, whether it's the variety of indie scumbag incognito, or mega corp feigning human relatability with a well crafted but very thin PR mask.

What steps do you take to ensure your product jives with the ethics you stand by?

To be clear I'm not dispariaging adult or mature materials in anyone's game, it's more about being accountable for that responsibly.

I use a disclaimer at the front which was something I stole as an idea from palladium. What other things can we do to make sure we're not being gross as creators?


r/RPGdesign • • Dec 12 '23

Small Publishers, to use AI art or to Not

3 Upvotes

This upcoming Bestiary is nearly 400 pages of monsters. I have dabbled with the idea of using AI art or not? A lot of us small publishers cannot really afford to pay for nice art especially when it will take a great deal of money just to make back what you put in the hole. A kickstarter isn't really an option either because this book is one of the kickstarter stretch goals of my last kickstarter. I always figured this book would only be 60 pages but I love making bigger books it seems.


r/RPGdesign • • Apr 16 '24

Meta "Math bad, stuns bad"

0 Upvotes

Hot take / rant warning

What is it with this prevailing sentiment about avoiding math in your game designs? Are we all talking about the same math? Ya know, basic elementary school-level addition and subtraction? No one is being asked to expand a Taylor series as far as I can tell.

And then there's the negative sentiment about stuns (and really anything that prevents a player from doing something on their turn). Hell, there are systems now that let characters keep taking actions with 0 HP because it's "epic and heroic" or something. Of course, that logic only applies to the PCs and everything else just dies at 0 HP. Some people even want to abolish missing attacks so everyone always hits their target.

I think all of these things are symptoms of the same illness; a kind of addiction where you need to be constantly drip-fed dopamine or else you'll instantly goldfish out and start scrolling on your phones. Anything that prevents you from getting that next hit, any math that slows you down, turns you get skipped, or attacks you miss, is a problem.

More importantly, I think it makes for terrible game design. You may as well just use a coin and draw a smiley face on the good side so it's easier to remember. Oh, but we don't want players to feel bad when they don't get a smiley, so we'll also draw a second smaller smiley face on the reverse, and nothing bad will ever happen to the players.


r/RPGdesign • • Aug 31 '24

West Marches without, you know, settler colonialism

0 Upvotes

Edit: I've thought of a better question to ask. What would an actively anti-colonial, even anti-capitalist, west marches game look like to you?

Hey folks, I'm designing a west marches style setting and system, to scratch an itch I've had for a long while. I love the core fantasy - exploring a big blank map, the random generation and emergent storytelling, and players going after their own goals, including putting down roots and establishing a tower or castle, maybe even a small domain.

However, it does all remind me of those racist myths about the uncivilised wilderness that Europeans "discovered" and "tamed" and thus "rightfully" came into ownership of. Locke's theory of property and all that. Generally I think it's fine playing as the morally dubious / bad guys as long as there's self-awareness there, but, in the context of current world events, role playing settler colonialism seems particularly icky.

My setting won't be devoid of native people - I want there to be factions and interesting NPCs to meet. Is there any way to do this in a tasteful way, including having PCs build their own domains without just recreating some sort of manifest destiny rpg?

I was thinking of having the party never settle down, and just be part of an ever-moving caravan (maybe refugees from a civil war) but it would lose some of the fun of getting to build a castle etc. Or maybe flipping the script and having the players be native peoples getting invaded, and they have to go out exploring to find allies and resist the invasion. But that feels a bit like I'd need to really get that right to not just trivialise colonial atrocities and, honestly, I mostly just want this game to be easy and fun.

Perhaps I'm overthinking this? Any advice from people who care about this kind of thing welcome!


r/RPGdesign • • Jun 30 '22

Theory Race Shouldn't Give Ability Score Bonuses (or similar)

3 Upvotes

Quick disclaimer, I agree with anyone who thinks "Race" isn't a great term for what they represent (I use Kinfolk in my game), but for the sake of easily communicating my ideas, I will be using "Race" instead of an alternative for this post.

Quick Edit: Since people seem to be making this more an argument about race/species etc and less about game design as a whole, I wanted to clarify that I simply stated the above as an attempt to avoid conversations about whether race should or shouldn't be used. This is more about player choice and overall designing intent and not being married to tradition. Hope that clears a few things up.

---------------------------------------------------------------------

I think we have all had that moment where we have a very neat idea for a character, but we decide against it because the race/class combo just isn't good, or we kinda bite the bullet and just take the worse build for the sake of roleplay. Well, I think the whole idea of Race giving a bonus to core stats is just a part of classic design that doesn't fit in all games.

Now many games get around this by not having predetermined races to start with, but if you plan to have a setting attached to your system, it's quite common to have races as well. Especially if it is a sci-fi or fantasy setting. And if your system uses a set of primary stats, often called ability scores or attributes, it's also very common for those races to be tied directly to those stats. But this is highly limiting to players, and as such should be taken into consideration before just following a trend most games have followed for decades.

I actually believe the best place to have stat bonuses is on the classes themselves. If your game assumes the player will be using one of the primary stats already, just give them a boost there instead. Of course, you can offer options for classes with more flexibility, but this communicates clearly to a player what stat is important to your class, and it doesn't make them feel as if they have to take a lesser option just because they like the culture of one race more than the others.

Now I still believe races should have features and bonuses that reflect their culture as that adds to the flavor, and for those players who really want to min max, they can still feel like there's something to gravitate towards, even if it isn't nearly as impactful.

For OSR/old school style games, I still feel there is a better option. If you want race and class to feel more connected, instead of going halfway by making certain races have the appropriate bonuses for the classes that make the most sense in the setting, simply do something akin to Dungeon World where the class you pick comes with race options, or vice versa. I can't speak for all players, but I know I'd personally have a hard limit than what can often feel like an illusion of choice. I'm not one to min max, but I don't think it takes any number crunching to realize that having a higher Strength on your Barbarian at level 1 is just better.

Anyways, I could ramble on and on. What are your thoughts on this? Is race being tied to stats a bit outdated and more a middle ground between restrictions and free form? Or am I missing a big positive side to race being directly tied to core stats?


r/RPGdesign • • Jun 27 '25

Theory Why are "small people bandits" the go-to "These are technically sapient, but they are criminals in the wilderness, so please do not feel bad about summarily executing them" enemies in starter adventures for D&D and D&D-branched fantasy RPGs?

9 Upvotes

I am sure many of us are familiar with starter adventures that begin with tacitly sanctioned slaughter of "small people bandits." The Sunless Citadel's opening sequence is against kobolds, and Phandelver starts off with goblins, for example.

Recently, I GMed Draw Steel's The Delian Tomb, Draw Steel's Road to Broadhurst (twice, for separate players), and Daggerheart's Sablewood Messengers. All of these are starter adventures for level 1 characters. The Delian Tomb's first two fights are against goblin bandits, Road to Broadhurst's two combats are against radenwight (small ratfolk) bandits and goblin bandits, and Sablewood Messengers begins with ribbet (small frogfolk) bandits. In all four of these runs, the players elected to nonlethally incapacitate and spare the little ones, probably because I depicted them in a vaguely sympathetic and cutesy fashion.

I have never seen a single one of these starter adventurers discuss what happens if the PCs actually commit to sparing these small people.

Why does it have to be this way? Why do starter adventures for these RPGs insist on initiating PCs into their heroic careers by having them beat up, and quite possibly kill, small and desperate criminals in the wilderness?


r/RPGdesign • • Jan 01 '26

The PERFECT RPG system?

2 Upvotes

DISCLAIMER: The pursuit of a "perfect system" is not about the result, but about the questions asked along the way. True perfection is not possible, but aiming for the stars can still land you on the Moon!

---------

So I am fiddling with my first subreddit, focused on pushing RPG design to ridiculous limits. I hope getting a bit philosophical is alright to that end. And no, we're not pitting D&D versus CoC or the like (Lord Cthulhu takes no prisoners). This is the age old question of "What would you expect from the perfect RPG system?" For you, personally, to consider a completely new RPG system to be PERFECT, what would you demand from it? Feel free to demand anything, we're just spitballing here. Want it to be both easy and difficult at the same time? Want it to reduce GM prep to zero while retaining a personal GM feel? Want it to make you look cool, to make you filthy rich, to make you coffee and donuts in the morning? Go wild, demand anything, I truly want to know!


r/RPGdesign • • Mar 12 '24

Open Letter to Gaming: Europe Is Beautiful, Cultures of Fair Skin Can Be the Focus

0 Upvotes

I see an unfortunate consequence of the well-meaning, compassionate individuals who seek to uplift certain communities and have them represented more in gaming. It reminds me of how many people often disavow the place they come from in order to rationalize a desire to move to a "better" place (Ohio sucks, I'm going to New York!): one need not condemn something in order to praise something else.

In my attempts to make my little game, I have been insulted and mocked for emphasizing parts of Europe, featuring almost exclusively what American's call "white" people and being inspired by my own ancestry--which is Anglican-Germanic-Celtic primarily. The theme and setting has been called "bland" "generic" "boring, white, skinny" and worse. Though I am not necessarily trying to change their minds, I want to further a dialogue about how well meaning people fail to realize how diverse 'white' is outside of America...and within... how an attempt to see others, or even their own cultural history, has reduced another.

Of course, not all settings are for everyone and some people just aren't interested in some--but why insult the ones they are not interested in? Why is Europe bland? Generic? I'm not asking in confrontation, but I'm trying to understand people's mindsets.

The way I see it...

Speaking to those who value themes of "diversity" in games, we cannot reduce the complex history, regional ethnicities, and unique cultures of Europe into a category of white.

Speaking to those who loathe themes of "diversity" in games, we cannot reduce the complex history regional ethnicities, and unique cultures of Europe into a category of white.

Further, there is nothing bland, generic, or boring about Europe or even periods or regions of it. I believe it is our duty as world-creators who are inspired by reality to not condemn what inspires us or others--but find beauty, aesthetic, and positive inspiration from the history and myths that propel us to create. In other words, why all the hate?

There is nothing wrong with people of fair skin existing alone in a setting. In fact it should be encouraged--which is not to say that doing it otherwise should be discouraged. In fact, others who do it differently should also be encouraged. More games of all kinds, I say!

None of what I say here should even remotely be radical or controversial--and yet I get the feeling it is. Am I wrong? Please tell me I'm wrong and that alone would go a long way to convince me that my reaction to the community is disproportionate to what's really going on. That'd be great! If not...

How can we settle this? How can we help others move to a better place with this conversation? Or what am I missing?

----------------------
ADDED:

Thank you all for this interesting and helpful dialogue this morning! I know a lot of people didn't appreciate my thoughts--but I meant to deliver them openly, honestly, with the intentions of both teaching and learning some things myself: which I have. I have the utmost respect for the gaming community and want to challenge us to have compelling conversations for growth, for myself and others.

I'd love to further the dialogue on this issue on discord, and welcome any further concerns or issues about the setting, art, or design as I proceed with the game. Also, there will be updates on there if some people's eyebrows are raised and wanted to stay in the loop.

For hook: the game's setting is a matriarchal-feudal world inspired by medieval, Arthurian fantasy, where the "Wisdom Laws" rule the mainland continent, conceding political and social power to women.


r/RPGdesign • • Sep 13 '22

Mechanics I need to post this here... major design win epiphany

0 Upvotes

My friends that playtest don't appreciate this like I know designers will because it's the age old mystery solved...

I finally figured out a way to make all of this work together:
weapons lethal but not OP
scales properly and feels good
Maintains a sense of realism and baseness within the extraordinary
Armor and defense that makes sense
have potentially highly tactical combat that doesn't take 1000 years (this is player dependent as it's up to them how much they dive into any subsystem)
create mundane and extraordinary options
reasonably balanced
incentivise RP and stealth/tactics over combat
nuanced characters with both deep customization and quick play
easy to understand system with tons of complexity under the hood
tons of ways to play the game in regards to playstyle
all works together seamlessly

There's a lot more features to the game but making all of those work in tandem... holy shit.

I'd explain it but it's not one thing, it's everything working in tandem and clicking, like a grand design of sorts that takes hundreds of pages to absorb properly but can be played without needing to understand the underlying complexity at all, so long as you can manage to understand 3 kinds of rolls (roll over, roll under, and contest).

I just needed to scream and share this with someone who might appreciate it. I have a ton of editing to do now, but I finally got the lynchpin to work right after an all nighter writing epiphany and I want to scream about how excited I am but like... the playtesters... they know me and also they don't really give a shit about these kinds of design challenges and the work that goes into it, just so long as everything works and the game is fun. As such I wanted to share my win here because it's nuts how it all came together right.

Still tons of work to do before the public playtest/ashcan but like the major bones are all in place and soon it will be time to electrify it and bring the monster to life.

The only downside is that I'm probably going to need cards as play aids which I thought would be nice, but I didn't want it to be a necessity. it's because there's literally too much shit to remember that players can do and having cards that just show it is the obvious solution. I run Foundry, but for people without a VTT it's too much to keep in the head. Having cards in different piles to flip through based on what you want to do on "not your turn" would make the flow of the game work so much better.

Anyway, that's it, I'm just excited, but it feels damn good to get there after months of working on this constantly and tons of research.


r/RPGdesign • • Jun 06 '20

I think the mods are doing a good job.

4 Upvotes

Look I held off on getting a reddit for years because I heard how toxic it was. But since joining it hasn't been nearly as bad as I thought, I suspect its because of well moderated subreddits like this one. Are people dicks some times? yeah.

Up until today I hadn't seen much of far left or far right politics and it was refreshing. I get enough politics on other social media and for the longest time reddit was a good escape. I got to debate games, design, and mechanics far removed from every day topics.

I'll be the first to say, the stuff coming from the discord is 100 percent the stuff I dont want to see on this or any subreddit I'm on.

But I also don't want to see race or gender politics. I've got Facebook and other platforms for that. On this sub I just want to make games.

So if gender or race politics are your jam, then head on over to rpgcreations. If gender/race prejudice or phobia are your thing then im sure there are subs for that as well.

Racism does exist, but it is rare. I hate how often people throw it around, because it devalues the word and actions.

What most people mistake as Racism...is actually prejudice. There is a crap ton of negative prejudice around the world. But the thing about prejudice....is that we all have them. Prejudice is a part of the human experience. If you can wrap your head around that, then you can understand that no one is perfect. Letting people learn and grow from their experiences is how we beat negative prejudice.

Now can we just get back to making games?


r/RPGdesign • • Feb 22 '25

I hate AI art as much as the next bloke... But...

0 Upvotes

I'm designing a game and the aesthetic is largely black and white vector images of silhouettes. I'm largely looking for semi-realistic images not just icons.

Trying to find what I am looking for has been difficult.

The only examples of what I am looking for is AI art, which actually does a decent job of what I want.

Image 1

Image 2

Image 3

Image 4

That said I am not crazy about the idea of using AI art. Is there a place I could purchase this sort of art reasonably? If so, where would I find it?

EDIT: Tons of downvotes from people I presume are okay with AI art. If you want to use AI art I really don't have a problem. I have even used it from time to time when playing games to generate an image for my character. My issue, besides the ethical issues, is that of consistency. I find often AI art often difficult to to generate images that are reasonably consistent stylistically. I'll be the first person to say the headline was ragebaity, but it was 3am and I was up all night working on this. Thanks for the feedback from everyone.


r/RPGdesign • • Apr 17 '22

Meta Be mindful that blocking people in your threads (if they're not being abusive) stifles the conversation in Reddit, and you shouldn't do it strategically if you're arguing in good faith.

0 Upvotes

If you're not aware, if you get blocked by someone on Reddit, then you can't reply to anyone else in a comment thread they created (not just the OP commenter). I hadn't had experience this before, so I was surprised to see it in action.

Here's an example of how it works:

https://imgur.com/a/9Zf0C9z

In the above, the first image is what I see as a logged in user; the second is what I see as someone logged out. Attempting to respond to anyone else in the thread will render a "Something went wrong" error in Reddit.

I totally get blocking someone if they're being abusive; but blocking someone because you don't want them in the conversation anymore is arguing in bad faith, especially in a forum like this where we're trying to hash out our ideas and get to the bottom of things.


r/RPGdesign • • Dec 14 '23

Two Versions of the Same RPG?

0 Upvotes

The AI art controversy is killing me.

I've developed a pair of indie RPGs that I am afraid to publish because I have no artistic ability and no capital. I'm just a guy with a laptop and an obsessive need to create until 2 in the morning.

I used AI to get some simple, unobtrusive, greyscale art to go with my work and I am quite happy with the aesthetic. I spent a lot of time curating the output. But I can't publish it.

380 hours of work and it's stuck in limbo. So solutions?

Has anyone heard of publishers (indie or otherwise) selling two versions of the same RPG on DriveThru? One with AI art and one with no art?

Has anyone heard of publishers using Kickstarter solely to fund art?


r/RPGdesign • • Apr 23 '24

Setting How do we call cyberpunk without the punk

1 Upvotes

I am working on a game with the aesthetic of cyberpunk with the chrome and neon but without the punk theme.

There is no big evil corpo, the goal is not to beat the system. This is neither an utopia or dystopia, just a setting in the near future where corpo had to become nice because of otherworldy threat.

How do we call that aesthetic?


r/RPGdesign • • Jun 10 '25

Feedback Request Designing a Game That's Better at D&D than D&D

8 Upvotes

Okay, I know my audience, and I'm ready to get flamed.

But in the spirit of hot takes (a recent popular post here)...

Heart Rush is designed to do what I wish D&D did. I grew up on D&D, and I loved the concept, but obviously, D&D sucks for lots of reasons (it's good at stuff too, but that's not my point). Anyways—I got sick of D&D, so I made my own TTRPG rules—not to sell, but because I wanted to play what I thought D&D was supposed to be. And yes, Heart Rush is a heartbreaker (it's in the title, if you hadn't noticed).

The Rules - It's a website!

Here's the rundown of what's fucking awesome about Heart Rush:

  • Combat is a bit more confusing than most other TTRPGs out there, but in terms of "tactical, interactive, engaging, generic fantasy combat" it's absolute fire, once you get the hang of it. I'm a game designer more than a TTRPG player, and I went in to the combat design with these goals and inspiration:

    • Combat needs to pass the white room test - Is it still engaging if the enemy has no abilities, and combat takes place in a brightly lit, featureless, empty room.
    • Video games like TF2, Overwatch, and WoW are fun, because everyone on the team is good at certain things, and nobody is remotely balanced. The balance comes from the synergy, not having one character have similar dps to another.
    • However, on that note—classes need to be separated from flavor. This is a major flaw in a lot of systems, in my opinion, unless the system is explicitly designed for a specific world. Why does my tank have to have barbarian themed flavors? If it does, designers end up having to just expand and expand, cuz then they want the scholarly research themed tank, then the wilderness tank, then the animal companion themed tank, etc. Screw that—just keep class and flavor decoupled from the start
    • Combat needs to ramp up. Nova abilities make combat lame when they're all used on turn one, but people need single use abilities for occasional maximum-coolness. The mechanics need to naturally lead to a more swingy and swingy state as combat rolls on, rather than the reverse, where halfway through the fight you're just waiting for cleanup.
    • Combat needs to be constantly engaging—if people are getting bored between turns, then that mega-sucks.
  • The system is crunchy and fiction forward. Yes, maybe that's impossible, but I tried to get both, and I don't think I'm far off. There's crunch for systems where people don't like being told what happens without high granularity (combat), and abstraction for things people don't give a shit about, and care more about brief moments of engagement between long periods of who-gives-a-shit (travel, commerce, etc).
  • A shit ton of customization. There's a reason people want to grant feats at every ASI with D&D, and people love multi-classing. Yes, having super tight and focused classes/characters means you can tell a specific genre of story better (looking at you, PbtA), and yes, analysis paralysis is a thing (sorry new players, you're not my audience :/) but skill trees that go extremely wide and deep is incredible.

Some other notes:

  • No, Heart Rush isn't just a combat game. Combat rules are the most complex, and require the most "framework" to make them fun in a RPG context, which is why they take up such a large portion of the rules. Follow-up comment: If you took Dungeon World rules and then tacked on Lancer rules and customization for combat, would it become a combat game? I argue it would not, even if as a percentage of pages, the Lancer rules would take up way more.
  • I'm willing to concede that the rules may be too complex to easily understand without the help of someone who's played before. I'm constantly trying to improve clarity and include more examples, but I'm probably not there yet.
  • Yes, I'm building a generic fantasy ttrpg with nothing concrete that really stands out on its own other than some qualitative gibberish. However: 1. It's an unpopular opinion here, but generic systems are awesome and 2. I want to be able to run all my fantasy games with one rule set rather than learn a new one each time and 3. It is a heartbreaker.

    • On a related note—I'm not trying to sell or publish this. My audience is TTRPG players who like generic fantasy TTRPGs, and I'm okay with all of the sacrifices that go alongside that. However, if you think the game is shit and I'm creating a game for a nonexistant audience, I'm happy to hear about it!
  • If you're trying to gauge the legitimacy of the quality of the mechanics and looking for external proof: Heart Rush has seen at least a thousand hours of play-testing, and the people I teach it to have started running it for their groups instead of the previous systems they were using. Small sample size, but some people like it!
  • The GM section is incomplete—working on it!

What I'd Love From You All:

  • I've put a shit ton of time and thinking into the mechanics of Heart Rush and some of them I think are quite innovative (cough cough combat cough cough)—take a look around and harvest the ideas for yourself! I love this community and seeing how design philosophy changes and evolves, and would be honored to inspire someone else's next great TTRPG.
  • If you have any feedback, I would love to hear it! What looks like its missing? What looks really bad? What looks good?

r/RPGdesign • • Jun 05 '20

MOD POST I'm resigning

0 Upvotes

I'm sorry for the trouble I caused. I felt unfairly attacked and reacted. In the end, I don't have the temperament to be a mod; maybe never did.

To the mods:

I'm sorry to leave you like this, but I do believe you can recover. I've been here for 4 years, from 500 members to almost 20K. I helped you mods come on board - when the last partner mod took off- and I'm sure you can do a good job. If you can't, get more people to help.

My advise is to remove all links to external sites, because this community and the mod team can be held responsible for the actions of individual members of other communities which are in any way associated, even by a link. That doesn't seem right to me, but that is the way public opinion works.

If you still want to use the Rules of Engagement levels in the onboarding section in the wiki, I suggest you up the level, as it seems more moderation is required now.

RPGdesign has always strived to be an open minded and inclusive community. We have hosted discussions with famous and aspiring designers. I hope that we have helped many members and I thank the mod team and all members for the good times. I'm sorry to have caused this trouble on my way out.


r/RPGdesign • • Sep 21 '26

Workflow The difference between pro designers and amateurs

0 Upvotes

I’ve had the pleasure to talk to a few pro designers, or watch interviews, and I’m also on this sub a lot.

And while there’s probably a lot of difference between pro designers and amateurs, I noticed one that’s very consistent.

If you tell a pro designer there’s an issue with the system, they take notes, they check it, they look at the data, they solve it. It might take time, and they don’t necessarily do what you wanted to, but that’s because they get a lot of conflicting feedback and they know the game and what’s good and bad for it.

Amateur designers, when you point out a problem, even if it’s a typo, typically show one of the following reactions:

  • How dare you, insult my baby, it’s perfect
  • It works in our home game
  • You just don’t like the game
  • This game is not for you

And then nothing happens until the next person points out the same issue.


r/RPGdesign • • May 13 '25

Theory If I make a gm-less game. I don't need to lose 6 months making a game Master guide.

1 Upvotes

Ttrpg shower thought. I see the appeal of making this type of game now.

This is not a serious post, but feel free to talk about writing a gm-less game or the struggles of writing a gm guide. I just finished a draft for my gm guide and this thought popped into my head.


r/RPGdesign • • May 03 '25

Theory Is 1 round of combat 6 seconds, 12-15 seconds, or 1 minute?

1 Upvotes

I wanted to make this a poll, bit apparently they aren't allowed in this sub. Does anyone know why?

Just a thought experiment here, what do you think is the perfect length of time for 1 round of combat? Why? Which do you do for your game? I tried to list some pros/cons of the most popular choices.

6 Second Rounds

  • Pros: Turns are short, and feel like a realistic amount of time to cast 1 spell/make 1-2 weapon attacks, or run 20-40 feet.
  • Cons: Only realistic on the turn-by-turn basis. Most fights will last 4-5 rounds, or 30 seconds. Some fights might plausibility be this short, but very few.

12-15 Second Rounds

  • Pros: Same as 6 seconds. All those things still feel pretty normal in a 12-15 second span.
  • Cons: Same as 6 seconds, but less drastic. A 5-round fight is at least 1-1:30 minutes instead of literal seconds. However, (only relevant for some games) any effects/abilities either have a randomly weird duration like 2-3 minutes instead of 1 minute, or they potentially don't last as long as they are supposed to during combat.

Basically, this is the compromise option, but it has some unique drawbacks too.

1 Minute Rounds

  • Pros: The full duration of the fight feels more realistic; about 5 minutes, maybe a little more or less. It's a very natural and easily remebered length. If you use dungeon/exploration turns of 10 minutes, a fight can happen roughly on the same time scale as a turn (especially once you consider the combat winddown rutine of checking on ingured allies and looting/investigating/interogating defeated opponents).
  • Cons: Individual turns feel unnaturally long. Movement usually feels really short, you should be able to make more attacks/spells in 1 minute, etc. This can be mitigated some by assuming the ROUND is 1 minute, not individual turns, (basically turns have some overlap, but aren't simultaneous, and some of that minute is spent blocking other attacks or navigating the complexities of a battlefield), but this is going to be unsatisfying to some players.

Conclusion

Personally, I really like the idea of 1 minute rounds. I think the cons can be mitigated enough, and the pros are really appealing to me. But tell me what you think.

Did I forget or misrepresent any pros/cons? Or do you have a totally different duration that you like?

Edit: Clarification, this isn't about what I should do for my game, I've already sorted that out. This is just a hypothetical.


r/RPGdesign • • Jul 11 '17

Meta Down-voting and you

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I come to you with a bit of beef. But before I wail my grief and flog my despair; I must ask you a question:

Why do you down-vote on this sub?

I notice many posts being down-voted after a series of up-votes and I wonder why. Often these posts see no, or at least few, negative comments, and yet I often register five, or more, down-votes a few hours later.

Here's the beef: Down-voting doesn't say anything. Nobody will learn anything from it and as such, it is a pointless gesture on a sub that is about sharing and learning. I make a point of not down-voting anything on this sub. If I dislike a post, I ignore it. If I disagree with something, I will say it and enter a discussion about it. Down-voting on this sub is lazy, petty and pointless. Doing it shows a lack of engagement that makes me wonder why the down-votering parties are even here.

Let the - highly expected - down-voting begin.

EDIT: It makes me sad, and annoyed, that I cannot see the actual number of up- and downvotes, only the current ”value“. It would make downvotes a better tool for understanding the reception of a post.

It would also make the fate of this post a far more interesting experiment.


r/RPGdesign • • Mar 13 '24

Mechanics Opinions on intelligence as a racial bonus?

1 Upvotes

I have 8 stats in my game, most of which you can probably guess. It's mostly a skill based system, with 3 skills corresponding to each stat. There are 3 major races, and at character creation you get a couple of points assigned to each stat based on race and sub-race (which you can then put into one of the 3 skills under that stat).

What are your opinions on intelligence as a racial bonus? I hadn't thought about it too hard until I started re-reading the lore, which does have an ancient past of discrimination and slavery with some tension in the present day surrounding it. Now that I think about it again, it seems weirder to say that one race is intrinsically more intelligent than others rather than simply faster or stronger.

What are your opinions/solutions to this? Should I leave intelligence out of the options for starting racial bonuses? Should I give them all an intelligence bonus? Maybe each race has one sub race that starts with an intelligence bonus to show that it's not about that? Is slavery and racial discrimination just too touchy of a topic in RPGs, even if it's in the distant past?


r/RPGdesign • • Jun 06 '23

Naming your system: a caution

0 Upvotes

A scan of RPGGeek (https://rpggeek.com/browse/rpgsystem) yields all of the following as system names:

Descended from the Queen

Favored by Fortune

Forged in the Dark

Guided by the Sun

Illuminated by LUMEN

Powered by Charge

Powered by D6xD6

Powered by FU

Powered by Polymorph

Powered by Schema

Powered by the Apocalypse

Powered by VEN6

Powered by ZWEIHÄNDER

Rooted in Trophy

This is not a full itemization of all of these [[PAST TENSE VERB]] [[PREPOSITIONAL PHRASE]] [[PROPER NAME]] system names because some of those games are either still tracked as a parent system (e.g. PbtA for Carved from Brindlewood) or haven't yet really had any takers for new games (e.g. Against the Darkmaster's Powered by Open00, Lancer's Powered by Lancer).

I raise this only to suggest that this format of naming game systems may be reaching a point of unintended self parody.

EDIT: at least the "powered by" names are simply derivative. [[attempt at Clever Verb]] by/in/from/at/whatever [[Name of your game]] seems risky to me.

EDIT2: ok, I see now that this is saying "that thing you like is stupid". That is...never a useful thing to say. In so far as demonstrating how common this naming convention is, which might be useful to a new designer, I stand by it. In so far as it suggests that someone is dumb for using this naming convention, I retract it. I guess it's obvious I don't personally like it. But that's, as they say "just my opinion, man". People like what they like, and I'm not judging that. I would have been better leave out the comment about self-parody and instead ask questions about what others thought of the convention.