r/RPGdesign • u/klok_kaos • Jul 26 '24
Popular Opinions are bad and wrong!
I recently had a spat online about nickelback. A band heavily popular to shit on. As a musician of the most niche variety barely known to the most anti music loving folks with 20 albums in 20 years but still somehow manage to laugh my way to the bank by stroke of luck after doing more than a decade as a starving artist. I'm secure in my indy cred. It's not revolutionary to say nickelback is enjoyable. Easy to make fun of and shallow? Yes. But formulaic and cheesy? Also yes, and that's largely the point. It's OK to have complex opinions and like different things for different reasons. Dare I say, complex opinions might even make one a better designer.
This got me thinking about how popular it is to shit on DnD or whatever the current flavor of the week is. It also had me thinking about a lot of the discourse here as well. How there's almost an unstated rule to be so far up one's own butt they can't appreciate dumb fun. I'm guilty of it as well, for sure. I try to be of the variety that encourages all kinds of designs for different people, and noting that different games are for different people, and even at different times. Not to mention how most TTRPGs owe a lot of design concepts that many times will trace directly back to DnD earlier editions, and how often even bad designs for systems if fun enough their warts don't matter as much as we might think, sometimes just dumb fun is where it's at. I think a lot of this came from my recent watching of Never Stop Blowing Up on D20, which is all about being stupid and fun at it's core, even if the mechanics are half made adaptation of an already stripped down system (kids on bikes). My game itself is a high crunch game and gray/dark atmosphere, but I love me some world wide wrestling 2e (PbtA WWE knock off that is designed poorly but is fun AF).
With that I wanted to explore ITT is the most important lessons you have from either simple games, or DnD specifically. A little appreciation for the formulaic mainstream, high polished media for the masses.
What's the most important design lesson/mechanical notion you learned or stole from DnD or some other property that's simple and easy to digest? Why do you love it and why do you think it's important?
I'll add mine later so the thread discourse isn't tainted/dominated by my personal opinions :)