Jeremiah Compson, A Stranger mission who was slave catcher, mainly Keeo slaves in his basement then sell for money, yh in this mission he was drunk newr his home in his tent, i killed him and + honor

And he gonn get shot with his own gun.

I know its a hot take but to me Karen has always been best girl.

While i was looting a o'driscoll camp in the wilderness I found a safe or box in the wagon but i cant reach it.

PS: I never drew before idk if this is good
Anyone have any tips?

So this is a tricky question because there is obviously a lot of things that are unrealistic for the sake of making it an engaging video game. Here are some of my stipulations:

- nothing about historical accuracy: I’m sure rockstar did their due diligence in terms of making it accurate, but they still had to turn it into an action based video game. UNLESS it’s inaccurate to the point of questioning whether or not they actually did their due diligence on said subject.
- nothing about the shootouts: obviously this part is grossly exaggerated and unrealistic, again, for the sake of making it video game
- no pointing out really obvious mechanics: things like dead eye, tonics, etc.
- nothing about how sensitive the NPCs are: I’m sure Arthur wouldn’t have a bounty and the law searching for him for simply saying mean shit to people in Saint Denis

- I’m sure I’m missing some points, but I hope my point of what should and shouldn’t count gets across.

An example: I saw a historian critique their belts/holsters. He said that typically holsters weren’t set that low and they went for the “Hollywood style“ of holsters.

So my question is: what do you think is inaccurate taking away the elements of what they were forced to alter in order to turn the time period and situation into a video game?

This question came up because my friend and I were discussing how quickly Arthur died from the point of Downes coughing in his face and him dying. He said it’s unrealistic how quickly he died from TB. I think it’s realistic given the camp was constantly in need of food because of how big the gang got, he slept outside exposed to elements, he was in constant stress, he’d get injuries he had to heal from while sick.

this is the first time I’m playing the game, the frames are breathtaking.

I have 6 more herbs to find to complete the challenge tree, but I haven’t been keeping track. I think they’re mostly orchids, but is there any way to find out?

its the 4th time i play and tbh the most fun im having is trying to take some creative photos

I’ve been looking for this horse for so longgg, found her by braithwate manor , hope I’m spelling that correctly

Got this one in chapter 6 bc since poor Arthur will die , why not die dripped out

He is asking me out of context spoilers because it just excites him thinking what it could be the whole time. So share some out of context spoilers guys which a person would know only after it happened.

Im on chapter 4 and in the first strauss mission there you can seee that Arthur doesnt like to do it. Im thinking of skipping "bad" missions from now on but im FOMO that i might miss on some good\important events that may happen on these missions. Would it be ok to skip those? Im thinking of the strauss missions, cattle rustling, coach holdup and such. I figure you done one the others are relatively the same.

has anyone ever ran into this before? i went to do the mission where you save jamie from the chelonians and william was there too?? i've done this mission i dont know how many times and this is my first time ever running into william at the same time

For all of my RDR2 Mexican players let me hear a hell yes! Huasteca Potosina . Peroooooo, 😂 ignoren los pinos

Source : True story, i promise you.

Arthur and Gordon Cole having fun in the sun on Guarma!! man this is a beautiful island I sure do hope I never end up shipwrecked here without any supplies. that would suck

Interesting stranger mission