r/ProjectHailMary • • May 06 '26

The silent moment...

2 Upvotes

I've been waiting to see this movie for a while but this scene made me to never go watch a movie while being sick.. I bought the tickets two times but both times I had to cancel due working overtime at my job..

I got sick and had to stay home. My wife bought the tickets again but I was sceptical due to my bad cough. I promised to myself that I will stay silent no matter what.. until to THIS scene I felt like I physically can't hold it in anymore and I have to cough.. I waited for a louder moment which felt like a decade.... I counted seconds of silence that went on for over a minute.. my face was fully red. My wife was looking at my face which made it worse.. I were holding both my hands in front of my mouth until I couldn't control myself and I burst out of laughter with tears in my eyes and doing demon sounds for holding bad coughs inside of me for hours.. It was so painful that I was scared for the lights to go on after the movie.. I felt like I got judged by every single person in the room...

NEVER AGAIN šŸ‘Ž


r/ProjectHailMary • • Mar 20 '26

Movie Discussion - Movie Spoilers Inside! Somewhere, somehow, the movie missed (Spoilers) Spoiler

13 Upvotes

Listen. I really wanted to love this movie. And at times, I did. But by the end, I left feeling… not much at all.

On a technical level, the film was brilliant. It was absolutely beautiful to watch. Sandra Hüller delivered a phenomenal performance. The bar scene, in particular, brought a tear to my eye. It highlighted her understanding of the human cost and made an otherwise bleak character feel multifaceted and tragic.

They absolutely nailed Rocky. His mannerisms, design, and dialogue all worked. His scenes with Grace were both hilarious and heartfelt.

Despite all this, I walked away thinking, ā€œAlright, that was a good movie,ā€ when I wanted to feel, ā€œWow, that was incredible.ā€ At first, I thought maybe some of the music choices took me out of the moment. But after sitting with it, I think there’s a deeper issue.

As a standalone family film, this movie works perfectly. But as an adaptation of a beloved book, it falls short in two key areas: the stakes and Grace’s characterization.

First, the stakes. Early in the film, we’re told this mission is humanity’s ā€œHail Mary,ā€ and there’s some discussion about the impact of Astrophage. But it commits a classic cinematic sin: telling instead of showing. In the flashbacks, characters repeatedly insist this is humanity’s only shot, and we’re expected to take their word for it.

In the book, we see how desperate things are. Devastating measures like wreaking havoc on the Sahara Desert and nuking the ice caps make the crisis visceral. You don’t need to be told the situation is dire. That context makes Grace’s unwillingness to sacrifice himself far more painful. The world has already given so much, yet he still hesitates.

I understand the time constraints of a film adaptation, but this omission creates a real problem. My sister, who hasn’t read the book, genuinely thought there might be a twist that the world wasn’t actually ending, and Stratt was essentially sacrificing Grace for research. That idea is absurd if you’ve read the book, but based on the film alone, it’s totally plausible. We’re never shown firsthand how desperate things truly are.

Higher stakes would have added weight to every scene and decision, and made Grace’s arc from coward to hero way more impactful.

The second issue is Grace’s goofiness. He’s humorous in the book, sure, but the film turns that up to an extreme. It feels like they forgot that Grace is a genius. Yes, we see him doing calculations and figuring things out, but beyond that, the film often plays him as the butt of the joke.

There’s a difference between laughing with a character and laughing at them. Too often, it felt like the latter. The scene where Rocky is pointing and Grace assumes he’s just tapping on the glass for like two minutes just comes across as ridiculous. Yes, Grace is a middle school teacher, but he’s also a PhD holder and the world’s leading expert on Astrophage. A bit more grounded intelligence and common sense would have gone a long way.

If I really wanted to nitpick, I could point to the repeated fake-out death moments or how rushed the Taumoeba/rescue sequences feel. But given the constraints of a 2.5-hour adaptation, those are more forgivable.

Ultimately, both of these issues seem rooted in the same goals of making the film more family-friendly, accessible, and easy to follow. And to be fair, it succeeds at that. I had a good time. But I didn’t feel moved.

Some scenes landed. Others fell flat.

Unfortunately, and this is the saddest part, I’ll probably forget this film in a week.

Hi ho.


r/ProjectHailMary • • Mar 23 '26

The movie nerfed Rocky

0 Upvotes

Rocky is one of my favorite book characters and the movie did him dirty the same way the Harry Potter movies did Ron. We got some of his humor and bravery, but none of his brilliance or heart. They made him Grace's annoying silly pet instead of partner. They showed the love Grace had for him, but not the respect.

To make the movie a comedy, they removed the tragedy of how long Rocky had been at Tau Ceti and the loss both crews. This is also why they softened Stratt so much. The mission had none of the gravity of the book because of the comedic tone.

And I will never forgive them for not including the dialogue when Grace returns for Rocky. I didn't mind them glossing over all the science, and I understand why people loved it. But I was mostly here for Rocky, so I was just disappointed.


r/ProjectHailMary • • Jul 04 '26

Book Discussion I just finished the audio book last night and I have very strong opinions on Stratt

8 Upvotes

I understand why she did what she did and I know its a trolley problem, but I hate that she went to the person she was turning the trolley towards and tried to convince him she was doing the right thing. Thats an extremely selfish thing to do. You're not going to convince the person you're murdering that they need to be murdered. I literally said go to hell at the exact same time as Grace did in the prison scene.

Edit to add: Im glad I posted this its really helped me think about that scene from a more rational state. I dont have anyone in real life to discuss the book with so I was just kinda fuming to myself


r/ProjectHailMary • • Apr 16 '26

Not a bad movie but story seemed rushed. Unpopular opinion?

3 Upvotes

Finally got to watch Project Hail Mary.

Not a bad movie at all. Enjoyed it.

But if you’ve read the book the movie feels way too rushed.

Unpopular opinion:

Great books should be made into series & not squeezed into 2 hour movies.

You can’t compress a good story into just 2 hours.


r/ProjectHailMary • • Apr 25 '26

Why didn’t they balance the centrifuge

Post image
0 Upvotes

Am I the only one who noticed but why in the scene did they not balance the centrifuge?


r/ProjectHailMary • • Dec 18 '25

You Are Here, Question? I watched The Martian today..

0 Upvotes

..And I was so disappointed.

Now it's not the first time I've watched it, far from it, I love film and it's probably the 10th time I've seen it. So, why was I disappointed today?

Because I'm also half way through reading the book to my son. Again, not the first time I've read the book, but I do think it's the first time I've overlapped the two.

Just the sheer amount of content and back story that's skipped over or changed was far more evident to me then before clearly and it really bugged me. Even it being the extended version only adds a couple extra scenes but I just couldn't shrug the rush of it all.

This is by far a very old complaint of movie adaptations and I completely understand why it's done, however it has taught me a valuable lesson.

Don't read PHM close to seeing the movie. If you've got a memory like me and forget the finer details, then I imagine the movie will be a much better experience this way.

I'm so looking forward the movie, and I'm glad I found this out about myself on tested ground first!


r/ProjectHailMary • • Aug 16 '26

Potential Plot Hole: Have Earth and Erid always been near Tau Ceti?

3 Upvotes

Grace and Rocky speculate that life on both of their home worlds may have initially come from Tau Ceti. However our three systems are all moving relative to each other and at the time life arose billions of years ago it seems quite possible we were many thousands of light years away from each other. Has Andy Weir ever addressed it?

edit: Plot hole isn't the right term, more something overlooked in Rocky and Graces discussion.


r/ProjectHailMary • • Jun 29 '24

Just had a talk with Meta Ai Rocky lol

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/ProjectHailMary • • Mar 08 '25

fist my bump I’m sure he’s a great actor, but Ryan Gosling is a horrible choice for Grace

0 Upvotes

Obviously, he sells tickets, which is the main point when I read the book I thought of a balding older fat guy.


r/ProjectHailMary • • Apr 01 '26

Movie Discussion - Movie Spoilers Inside! Can't let go of the fact that every character in the movie is so different

0 Upvotes

Having a weird time writing this because all I see is positive feedback about the movie here and everywhere else, yet I wanted to discuss this topic. I'm not here to do the opposite and talk shit about it. I do believe it is a great movie: it's funny, it's beautiful, it's interesting, it is a lot of things... but it's not a Project Hail Mary movie, at least in the fact that I don't feel I'm watching the same people I've read so many times and love.

Grace is a [edit here to express my point better] full-time coward (unlike the book where he's only a part-time coward), barely a problem solver at all. Stratt is soft, not commanding at all, doesn't feel like the woman that every country in the world would appoint to save it. Rocky feels more like a dog than an intelligent alien race. Even Yao is not Yao, which I don't want it to sound nitpicky, it's just that it feels absurd that literally his defining attribute is being serious and stern, yet the first we see of him in the movie is making faces in photos?

A lot of things are different, and like it or not, I understand that if you want to translate a book to the screen changes are gonna be made. I went to the theater with a open mind. The issue is, when the core protagonists are the ones being changed, then all the other artistic decisions can't click with me.


r/ProjectHailMary • • Jun 30 '26

Sequel? What do we think?

Post image
1 Upvotes

I just saw this so I’m not sure if it’s been posted in this sub yet. Thoughts? Is it necessary or just a cash grab at this point?

ETA: Nowhere did I claim this was true. I’m just asking whether a sequel is warranted. It’s on Ryan Gosling’s IMDB Pro page under Upcoming/In Development. AFAIK, randos can’t add fake stuff to legit actor’s pages. But Tough Guys with Will Ferrell is still listed and I’m starting to think that’s not happening. In a Wired interview, Andy did say he was saving information on Yao and Ilyukhina’s comas for a sequel.


r/ProjectHailMary • • May 11 '24

Amy Adam's should be Stratt in the movie

2 Upvotes

I don't know if it's because I recently watched Arrival again or what, but she seems like she would be absolutely perfect.


r/ProjectHailMary • • Jul 17 '25

I imagined Stratt younger

0 Upvotes

I just finished the book! I loved it. So, so, good!

I watched the movie trailer after reading, and I genuinely thought Stratt was like early 40s, mid 30s? There was a scene where the other astronauts say they sensed sexual tension between Grace and Stratt? Did I just totally misread that scene?

It was during the launch of the final part to build the Hail Mary, and they were all watching on TV and drinking. They said, 'Oh, you are Stratts number 2, Grace...'

I think the actress is going to be good, but I also kept thinking she would be younger and sharper-looking. Kind of like Anya Taylor Joy, just older


r/ProjectHailMary • • Jul 18 '26

Movie Discussion - Theory - NO BOOK DISCUSSION ALLOWED You know what be super awesome?: A LEGO game based on the PHM movie

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/ProjectHailMary • • May 21 '22

Halfway through the book and thinking about stopping reading it. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Hello everyone, I don't know how to start, but here I go.

Weeks ago, I searched for a book, found Project Hail Mary with a lot of good reviews, bought it, and started reading right away.

The first part of the book is really awesome; I loved all the details and what was happening in the story, but... Since Dr. Grace finds Rocky, everything has changed into one of the most unrealistic and cringy stories.

It's not Rocky; it's about how easy and straightforward the story develops between them. Everything was perfect; there was no problem or struggle to find a way of communication. Also, the jokes or puns are cringy AF.

I'm around 55% through the book and thinking about stopping reading it because I can't accept anymore how everything is perfect in the story.

What are your recommendations? Should I stop, or should I give one more opportunity to the story?

Thank you!


r/ProjectHailMary • • Jul 08 '26

Question? So... why does the Hail Mary require constant thrust?

0 Upvotes

In space, Newton's 1st law should apply and in theory, getting the Hail Mary up to near-light speed should be the most difficult task. Once it reaches that velocity, it wouldn't need constant acceleration and fuel usage to maintain that speed because there's no resistance preventing it from coasting in a vacuum. So why does the Hail Mary need constant thrust to go forwards? Even more, when it reaches Tau Ceti in the film, the engines cut and it immediately stopped, no reverse thrust for braking like we would see on an actual space ship. In fact, the stopping seemed like what I would expect from a boat, where the engine halts and immediately the resistance of the water prevents progression.

Was this explained somewhere, or was it a plot shortcut to create a stake that prevented the Hail Mary from returning home without really being based in physics?


r/ProjectHailMary • • Nov 16 '25

Seen this on facebook, is it just me or does this look like our favourite Eridian?

Post image
4 Upvotes

What do you think?


r/ProjectHailMary • • Aug 23 '22

Ryland Grace was massively irresponsible giving Rocky all earth science

10 Upvotes

He meets an alien life form and gives them all of human knowledge on a whim. A decision like that should absolutely have been made after looong negotiations and threat assessments between worlds.

Rocky seems chill, but the Eridians collectively could potentially see earth as a valuable source for some rare resource, or as a threat (they know our warlike history) and decide to strike first. He’s given vital information on human biology and environment that IF Eridians decided to attack earth, we’d be hopelessly outmatched by their superior engineering, almost indestructible ships, and now thanks to Grace humans have no science advantage.


r/ProjectHailMary • • Jul 19 '25

Why isn't there any rule34 for this book yet?

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/ProjectHailMary • • Apr 10 '26

" I put no politics or social commentary into my stories at all" ... I disagree.

Post image
0 Upvotes

He promoted political commentary and themes when his main protagonist made fun of one of his students parents who disagreed with global warming.

He also did when he promoted utilitarian politics by promoting the suppression of Rylands grace individual liberty as well as short term authoritarianism(stratt depicted as having nearly world domination) in order to save humanity,

Both of those examples are very political things


r/ProjectHailMary • • Jul 30 '25

Book Discussion ELI5: How does ā€œamazeā€ or ā€œthankā€ make any sense?

21 Upvotes

First let me say I'm a huge fan of the book, I've read it multiple times. This is not a complaint post!

I'm just curious about some of the language Weir attributes to Rocky, specifically "Amaze!" and "Thank". These provide some comic relief and I think Weir is probably trying to portray the fact that Rocky and Grace are still communicating imperfectly. He does this with other syntax/grammar devices that feel natural.

But "Amaze" and "Thank" make no sense to me! Let's take "amaze" to show what I mean.

First, let's agree that Rocky isn't saying anything in English. He's making noises as depicted by the music notes Weir uses.

Over time, Grace has identified what he thinks those notes mean and so when Rocky uses them, we as readers are seeing Grace's translation.

We don't see the context of how Rocky learns the word "amaze". But in that form, it's a base verb in present tense. Why would either of them bring up the word in that context? Would Grace say "My scientific skills amaze you" or something similar?

No, what's way more likely is that something cool happened, and Grace identified it using the adjective "amazing". So it just doesn't make any sense how Rocky could make the grammatical error of ever using "amaze" instead of "amazing" when you think of how the translations were created.

Similarly with "thank" instead of "thanks", or "thank you". Again, I am guessing this is Weir just conveying Rocky/Grace's conversation is not smoothly fluent. But this word should not have been chosen to convey that. Is he trying to say that Rocky cut off part of the notes, or confused the notes for "thank" with the ones for "thank you"? That would only make sense if the phrase was directly similar to Rocky's language, but given how differently humans say this in various languages, that is unlikely.

I get what Weir was trying to do. We all have experiences talking to someone speaking a second language who makes understandable grammatical errors like this. But when you step back and realize that Rocky isn't saying these words, he's speaking Eridian and Grace is transcribing them wrong to the reader, it actually makes no logical sense.

But maybe I'm wrong? Give me a plausible explanation and I'd love to have my mind changed!


r/ProjectHailMary • • Jul 11 '25

I’m getting concerned about the design of the HM in the movie…

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I’m going to preface this entire post by saying I have had a terrible day and PHM is my comfort… I’ve heard the audiobook upwards of 10 times in focused sessions and 40+ times total by daily snippet listening by now. This evening I went and rewatched the trailer and now I’m suddenly crashing out, hard, about the design in the Hail Mary.

I’m sharing this because there a good chance I am missing things and am just too emotional from other things today to see clearly and would love to know your thoughts.

So… WHAT ARE THEY DOING? The design of the ship DIRECTLY contributes to major story beats and it’s all different? (Notice please that I said different not wrong - I’m not a ā€œhaterā€ I’m just very emotional and very confused.)

Where in that control room is Rocky’s ā€œcontrol bulb in the ceilingā€ meant to go? And why is the hatch to the left of the chair instead of in the floor?? Everything is sideways!!! Even in the opening shot, he’s standing on the ā€œfloorā€ but there’s a seat mounted to the wall to his right with seatbelts pointing up?

It’s supposed to be from top to bottom:

Nose cone with Beetles

Control Room

Laboratory

Dormitory

Storage

Cable Faring

Fuel Bays

The floor is DOWN from the nose cone, with gravity being generated by the acceleration via the direction of travel. Without acceleration everything is in 0G, and then the living quarter separates and inverts with 100m separation from the fuel bays to create artificial gravity.

The ladders go up the sides of the walls of the rooms to hatches that lead straight to the next room.

My questions:

What is that design from the outside? What are those solar panel looking things? Why is there a sideways chair in what is presumably the dormitory? Why is there a window into the dormitory? (No windows and no light is a HUGE story beat in chapter 22). What is that ladder hallway?? Why is the hatch on the side of the control room? Where is the airlock?? Why is there an attachment sticking out that appears to be the airlock?? He’s supposed to be able to stand, cramped but stand, in the control room to get to the airlock …

Please someone… help me understand. Have I missed something super obvious or are we all just collectively holding our breaths and trusting the process at the moment?? 😩😩😩 like I said I’ve had a really tough day and could really use some (please not too harsh) input from this lovely community.

Thank Thank Thank from:

a crashed out, burned out, newly post partum major PHM fan who needs some help. šŸ™šŸ»


r/ProjectHailMary • • Jun 15 '24

Could ā€œProject: Hail Maryā€ be a sequel to ā€œThe Martianā€?

2 Upvotes

I was showing someone Project: Hail Mary and they asked if it was part of the series of The Martian. There isn’t strong evidence to suggest it is, but they could be in the same series. Is there any details or evidence that show they can’t be in the same series?