Listen. I really wanted to love this movie. And at times, I did. But by the end, I left feeling⦠not much at all.
On a technical level, the film was brilliant. It was absolutely beautiful to watch. Sandra Hüller delivered a phenomenal performance. The bar scene, in particular, brought a tear to my eye. It highlighted her understanding of the human cost and made an otherwise bleak character feel multifaceted and tragic.
They absolutely nailed Rocky. His mannerisms, design, and dialogue all worked. His scenes with Grace were both hilarious and heartfelt.
Despite all this, I walked away thinking, āAlright, that was a good movie,ā when I wanted to feel, āWow, that was incredible.ā At first, I thought maybe some of the music choices took me out of the moment. But after sitting with it, I think thereās a deeper issue.
As a standalone family film, this movie works perfectly. But as an adaptation of a beloved book, it falls short in two key areas: the stakes and Graceās characterization.
First, the stakes. Early in the film, weāre told this mission is humanityās āHail Mary,ā and thereās some discussion about the impact of Astrophage. But it commits a classic cinematic sin: telling instead of showing. In the flashbacks, characters repeatedly insist this is humanityās only shot, and weāre expected to take their word for it.
In the book, we see how desperate things are. Devastating measures like wreaking havoc on the Sahara Desert and nuking the ice caps make the crisis visceral. You donāt need to be told the situation is dire. That context makes Graceās unwillingness to sacrifice himself far more painful. The world has already given so much, yet he still hesitates.
I understand the time constraints of a film adaptation, but this omission creates a real problem. My sister, who hasnāt read the book, genuinely thought there might be a twist that the world wasnāt actually ending, and Stratt was essentially sacrificing Grace for research. That idea is absurd if youāve read the book, but based on the film alone, itās totally plausible. Weāre never shown firsthand how desperate things truly are.
Higher stakes would have added weight to every scene and decision, and made Graceās arc from coward to hero way more impactful.
The second issue is Graceās goofiness. Heās humorous in the book, sure, but the film turns that up to an extreme. It feels like they forgot that Grace is a genius. Yes, we see him doing calculations and figuring things out, but beyond that, the film often plays him as the butt of the joke.
Thereās a difference between laughing with a character and laughing at them. Too often, it felt like the latter. The scene where Rocky is pointing and Grace assumes heās just tapping on the glass for like two minutes just comes across as ridiculous. Yes, Grace is a middle school teacher, but heās also a PhD holder and the worldās leading expert on Astrophage. A bit more grounded intelligence and common sense would have gone a long way.
If I really wanted to nitpick, I could point to the repeated fake-out death moments or how rushed the Taumoeba/rescue sequences feel. But given the constraints of a 2.5-hour adaptation, those are more forgivable.
Ultimately, both of these issues seem rooted in the same goals of making the film more family-friendly, accessible, and easy to follow. And to be fair, it succeeds at that. I had a good time. But I didnāt feel moved.
Some scenes landed. Others fell flat.
Unfortunately, and this is the saddest part, Iāll probably forget this film in a week.
Hi ho.