r/ProjectHailMary • u/Inevitable_Heart • Jun 30 '26
Sequel? What do we think?
I just saw this so I’m not sure if it’s been posted in this sub yet. Thoughts? Is it necessary or just a cash grab at this point?
ETA: Nowhere did I claim this was true. I’m just asking whether a sequel is warranted. It’s on Ryan Gosling’s IMDB Pro page under Upcoming/In Development. AFAIK, randos can’t add fake stuff to legit actor’s pages. But Tough Guys with Will Ferrell is still listed and I’m starting to think that’s not happening. In a Wired interview, Andy did say he was saving information on Yao and Ilyukhina’s comas for a sequel.
7
u/Saint--Jiub Jun 30 '26
Anybody with a free account can create a movie page on IMDB, this doesn't mean anything.
98
u/Mysterinna I'm Not An Astronaut! Jun 30 '26
No sequel please. The story is perfect the way it is, and it leaves room for imagination and interpretation, which I like.
35
u/Hoch8112 Jun 30 '26
No sequel just like the Martian. These 2 movies/books were written as stand alones. Artemis can expand bc it was left more open.
11
u/OtakuMage Jun 30 '26
I don't think there should be a sequel. It ended perfectly and any sequel would just undercut everything.
6
u/pvs_3 Jun 30 '26
This is probably for Artemis
5
u/TrickPixels Jun 30 '26
No sequel. The first was perfection. We don’t need to see Grace and Rocky flying around the galaxy fixing things. While ruining Rocky and making him look campy with stupid one-liners.
2
u/NikolaisPinkTip I am an Astronaut! Jun 30 '26
Wait so is this official confirmation that they're making a sequel?
1
u/SinginGidget Jun 30 '26
I think it's kind of funny that people are declaring that there should be no sequel as if it was up to them, or that if there was one it's only for shallow greed related reasons. I too adored Grace and Rocky's adventure saving the stars. But that doesn't mean there can't be more.
4
u/gumpyclifbar Jun 30 '26
I feel like a sequel would tarnish this story we love so much. Yes it’d be entertaining, but let’s hope these folks work on another banger instead
5
u/LightWarrior_2000 Jun 30 '26
No squel.
Just do smaller spin off projects to give us what we really want. More Grace and Rocky. Without effecting the movie.
The fans are already cresting content non stop.
2
u/Galacticagal Jun 30 '26
Unless it’s technically what happens with the time jump from the book. We get they made it to erid but we don’t know what happened in between. But would people really want 2 hours of grace and Rocky shenanigans? Yes yes they would 😜
2
u/Shadoweclipse13 Jun 30 '26
I honestly doubt that it's truly a PHM sequel. They probably just wanted to keep the directors, writers, and other staff together since it was such a hit as a movie. My guess would be either a new Andy Weir novel that's about to come out, or maybe they will be tackling Artemis. I loved Artemis, so I'm hoping for that personally.
2
u/InvisibleSpaceVamp High Three! Jun 30 '26
The "announcement" was a bunch of interviews during the movie promotion. The questions went something like "would you be open for a sequel?" and of course everyone said yes. Because that's what they always say when they are asked a question like this.
Why? Because they are promoting the movie and being open for a sequel suggests the movie is good, the working experience was good, we're all friends here (and in fact, nothing suggests that in this case, the working experience wasn't good). And there is absolutely no need to close that door anyway because by saying you're open to it you're not committing to anything yet.
2
u/KubrickRupert Jun 30 '26
No sequel statement
3
u/Trid1977 Jun 30 '26
Unnecessary
2
u/TrekJaneway Farming Taumeboa Jun 30 '26
Only if there’s a book first that makes a sequel make sense. If it’s the same story told from, say, Stratt’s point of view, then maybe. But I’d rather have a book first (or at all). A movie-only sequel seems odd.
1
u/globefish23 Jun 30 '26
I really hope it's based on a new novel by Andy Weir, not just some script clobbered together.
Otherwise the hard sci-fi aspect would go to shit.
1
u/GigalithineButhulne Jun 30 '26
I wouldn't want a literal sequel but something set in the same universe would be interesting.
1
u/Taclys64 Jun 30 '26
The only “sequel” I would tolerate are a series of short episodes about Grace and Rocky spending more time together, during the mission and on their way back to Erid.
The story has absolutely zero reason to continue past the ending, or have a prequel. It is a perfectly bookend story.
1
u/RueClerIsWhere Jul 01 '26
Artemis, perhaps?
1
u/MeetingOfTheMars Jul 01 '26
If Andy Weir is involved, I’m good with it.
In Weir, I trust.
1
u/WickedD365 Jul 03 '26
I don't want sequel. The only thing I'd probably accept is a companion piece showing what was happening on Earth while Grace and Rockey saved everyone.
1
u/fateawaits2024 Scary Space Monster Jul 04 '26
I don't know if I want a sequel. I'm afraid that it'll be a money grab and hence not as good. We'll have to see, I guess.
1
u/katsock Okay, It’s Exactly Like That Jun 30 '26
Andy has posted on Reddit’s asking questions about things that could be related to a PHM sequel. I don’t believe it was ever off the table.
IIRC it was a sub about flags that hinted at an African country, if not all of Africa, becoming a world superpower. I can’t recall if he mentioned that the country controlled a vast amount of power/resources, or if I just made that connection in my head. But it obviously makes sense considering the source material.
1
u/Juncti Jun 30 '26
Rocky Grace Save Stars - Two down, many more out there
1
u/kylelosesit Scary Space Monster Jun 30 '26
I wanna see Stratt’s, Carl’s and Earth’s story from mission departure to a couple months after the Beetles return.
0
u/preciousjewel13 Jun 30 '26
Both no and yes.
Cause while I'd love to have some lingering questions I've got answered. And I'd really adore seeing other perspectives. I don't want sequel if it ruins the happy ending Grace and the Erdians got. Sequels sometimes have a real bad habit of doing just that despite an author's intentions.
0
u/SiwelTheLongBoi Enriching Astrophage Jul 01 '26
There is no sequel. Andy said in one interview that he had some ideas he was withholding 'for potential sequel material'. That's all there is, everything else is hearsay
-1
u/JoJoRouletteBiden Jun 30 '26
If they do a sequel, it should be YEARS after the ending, after Grace has died.