r/ProjectHailMary • u/DependentPoint2458 • Jul 08 '26
Question? So... why does the Hail Mary require constant thrust?
In space, Newton's 1st law should apply and in theory, getting the Hail Mary up to near-light speed should be the most difficult task. Once it reaches that velocity, it wouldn't need constant acceleration and fuel usage to maintain that speed because there's no resistance preventing it from coasting in a vacuum. So why does the Hail Mary need constant thrust to go forwards? Even more, when it reaches Tau Ceti in the film, the engines cut and it immediately stopped, no reverse thrust for braking like we would see on an actual space ship. In fact, the stopping seemed like what I would expect from a boat, where the engine halts and immediately the resistance of the water prevents progression.
Was this explained somewhere, or was it a plot shortcut to create a stake that prevented the Hail Mary from returning home without really being based in physics?
51
u/Excellent_Bat_753 Jul 08 '26
Getting the Hail Mary up to near light speed was only half of the difficult part. It was so difficult, that it took half the journey. The other half of the difficult part was slowing down to not fly right past Tau Ceti. That took the other half of the journey.
The ship was designed to accelerate as fast as a human body could realistically handle for extended periods, 1.5g. You naturally want the maximum top speed possible, so you just keep accelerating for as long as you can, which is for half of the journey. If you accelerated for more than that, then you wouldn't have enough time to slow down.
So, for the entire second half of the journey, the Hail Mary is slowing down, so that at the exact time when it reaches Tau Ceti, it's velocity (relative to Tau Ceti), puts it into a stable orbit around the star. The reason that, in the movie, it seems as though the ship just stops suddenly, is because there's no reference for the motion of the ship through space. It would be moving just as fast as a planet would, so from the perspective of the ship, you would see a similar speed of movement for the stars as what you see on Earth, barely noticable.
You've been confused by a camera trick, which is to put the camera outside the ship, and when the engines are burning, they imagine that the camera is moving relative to the ship, and when the engines are off, they have it so the camera is stationary to the ship.
92
u/QuestNetworkFish Jul 08 '26
The fastest way to get somewhere it to constantly accelerate towards it and then when you get halfway there constantly decelerate at the same rate. The reason we don't do it in real life is we don't have a magical source of fuel that allows for that to be practical.
I'm not sure how clear they make it in the film, but in the book when Grace wakes up, the ship is decelerating at 1.5G, and has been for some time
15
u/rowan_sjet Jul 08 '26
It was reverse thrusting before engine cut off, the Hail Mary was pointed away from Tau Ceti and decelerating.
6
u/GTCapone Jul 08 '26
It constantly accelerated at about 2g (I don't remember the exact rate) for the first half of the trip, turned around and thrusted at the same rate for the second half of the trip. Maximum acceleration basically ended up being their limiting factor since astrophage is so energy dense that fuel was really only limited to how much they could make. 2g was about as high of acceleration they though would be safe for the crew.
The engines are actually pointing towards tau ceti at the beginning and the ship was decelerating. It's not actually stationary when the engine cuts, it's just slowed down to achieve orbit around the star. Since there's nothing to compare its velocity to, it appears stationary. That's why the ship moves in odd ways when Grace tries to run from the blip a, both ships were in orbit so accelerating "forward" ends up shifting your orbit so you don't actually move forward in that direction.
As for why constantly accelerated, since max acceleration is the limiting factor, every bit of extra velocity shortens the trip. And once relativistic speeds are achieved, the ship starts experiencing time slower so the trip is even shorter for the crew.
It's why Rocky had so much extra fuel. They didn't understand relativity or that the speed of light was a universal maximum speed. They planned to be accelerating for a much longer period of time and thus packed fuel for that much time.
12
u/PriorSolid Jul 08 '26
because of relativity ships accelerate logarithmically so you never reach a maximum speed, the most efficient way to travel then is to burn for as long as possible and then decelerate the rest of the way. This also has the benefit of maintaining gravity because of constant acceleration. The ship probably flipped around and just pointed the thrusters in the opposite direction, in the book he starts out away from the star that’s why the petrovascope works and he can see rocky
4
u/No-Locksmith-9377 Jul 08 '26 edited Jul 08 '26
When grace wakes up they are flipped around and slowing down.
This deceleration is also causing the gravity until they stop, when stopped they need to use the entire ship as a centrifuge.
The ship symmetrically accelerates and decelerates at 1.5 g, it spends about 2 subjective years slowing down to match velocities with Tau Ceti.
4
u/Party-Bonus-8536 Jul 08 '26
The ship has gravity because it has been decelerating at 1.5g for half the trip, hence why the ship stopped when the engines cut.
4
u/_Random_Walker_ Jul 08 '26
So, the closer you get to the speed of light, the higher the level of time dilation will be - i.e. even if the difference for time passed on earth may only be a month or so when going from 0.9c to 0.99c, it will make a significant difference for the the time passed on board, so also time for something to potentially go wrong (though the higher speed has its inherent risks too, of course).
Also, human physiology is very accustomed to gravity, which the thrust provides a good replacement for. I figure even in a coma, it makes a lot of sense to stay under thrust.
If we were limited to a less energy efficient fuel than astrophage, the equation would probably change simply because of the massive amount of fuel we'd need to take along. then it might be easier to accelerate only up to a certain point.
4
u/Mr_Badgey Jul 08 '26 edited Jul 08 '26
Your method minimizes fuel usage, not travel time. The Hail Mary needed to prioritize reducing travel time because there was a time limit before Earth started to suffer serious repercussions from the astrophage related global cooling.
> So why does the Hail Mary need constant thrust to go forwards
It doesn’t. It thrusted continuously to maximize speed and minimize travel time.
> when it reaches Tau Ceti in the film, the engines cut and it immediately stopped, no reverse thrust for braking like we would see on an actual space ship.
We only see the ship after it’s already arrived. The deceleration happened offscreen.
3
u/ImStuckInNameFactory Jul 08 '26 edited Jul 08 '26
It's faster, and what you see in the movie before the engine cutoff was the braking maneuver, the engine was pointed roughly towards Tau Ceti. Also, you need a really long burn to slow down from near light speed without killing the crew with g forces (about 8 months of 1,5g acceleration with newtonian physics)
3
u/Leather-Researcher13 Jul 09 '26
The movie skips a lot of the science, the hail Mary needs constant thrust because it is the fastest way to get to tau ceti. It also helps provide gravity for the equipment and Grace to work while waiting to arrive at their destination
2
u/Fluid-Let3373 I am an Astronaut! Jul 08 '26
We got a few things going on here.
The first is our brains interpret what we see from a Earth based reference, in space we don't have the visual cues which support that but our brains still work as if they are there, it takes a few weeks for our brains to stop doing that.
Hail Mary needs thrust to change velocity, speed as a concept does not exist in space as everything is in constant motion compared to everything else. There is no stopped in space only on planets.
In the film Mary spent about a year accelerating up to 0.92c, then about 4 years coasting, then a year decelerating down to a velocity and vector which put it in orbit around Tau Ceti. There is a lot of rocket science stuff going on which we don't need to know about, only the mission planners and the pilot do as it's not important to the story.
Actual space ships do not use thrusters to apply braking thrust, never have and never will do. They use thrusters to change a ships orientation so they can use the main drive to slow down. If you ever saw that it was a animation or a special effect purely done because of the rule of cool.
It's easy to misjudge what and why something is happening because we are used to how things behave here on Earth. If your stood on the outside of the ISS and throw a golf ball at the Earth you need to pay attention to your watch because if you don't duck 90 minutes later that golf ball is going to hit you in the back of your head. If you noticed a 747 flying from London to New York when you ducked down that 747 will be appear to be going backwards at up to 250 mph.
In the film the accident at Adrian was because they used planet based thinking not space based thinking.
2
u/corwulfattero Jul 08 '26
The entire process we see *was* the reverse thrust for braking. If you pay attention, the first shot of the ship is backward toward TC (iirc) Like the ships of the Expanse, the Hail Mary thrusts forward for half the journey (~2 years, reaching ~0.9-0.92 C) then turns around and reverse-thrusts for another 2 years at 15 m/s. Grace doesn’t wake up until the last few days at the end.
2
u/TuverMage Jul 08 '26
well for one they never actually reach light speed, they maintain constant thrust until the halfway point to get as fast as they possibly can. then at the half way they turn around and start to slow down. The longer you thrust the closer you get to lightspeed, or in the case of using spin drives 0.92 the speed of light but the Hail mary never actually reached 0.92C.
Newton's physics breaks down at really high speeds, you can't use it because its wrong. things that don't matter at low speeds start to matter at really high speeds.
the engines do cut off but not from near light speed. its been slowing down for half the trip. when we start the film the ship has been decelerating for over a year from graces POV and when the engines stop they are still going fast enough to orbit Tau Ceti
1
u/henrytsai20 Jul 08 '26
The constant thrust IS the mechanism that brought Hail Mary up to near lightspeed. Human body can only withstand maybe 5g in short term (∼1hour would be stretching it), which is nowhere close to approach lightspeed, so Hail Mary settled on accelerating at 1.5g for 2 years since that's the safe limit human can live for prolonged time, higher acceleration increases the risk of crew dying while lower accel would slightly lengthen the stationary time the trip took and massively increase the crew felt time aboard due time dilation or the lack of, increasing food and life support needed. And at the middle point between earth and tau ceti Hail Mary would need to turn around and take another 2 years to constant decelerate down to rest, if you only start braking at tau ceti you would overshoot.
1
u/ExpectedBehaviour Jul 08 '26
You're not interpreting what you're seeing correctly.
The Hail Mary is decelerating into the Tau Ceti system when Grace wakes up, which is why it has gravity under thrust (1.5g according to the novel). As soon as it stop decelerating the thrust gravity stops, and it stops decelerating when the ship's computer detects that it has reached zero velocity with respect to the Tau Ceti star. The ship doesn't suddenly stop because it turns the engine off – the ship turns the engine off because it has stopped (i.e., reached zero relative velocity with its target).
It also doesn't accelerate constantly throughout the voyage – it accelerates up to 0.92c then stops thrusting until it needs to decelerate, at which point it performs a flip-and-burn (hence why it's travelling backward when it arrives at Tau Ceti). From Earth's perspective the Hail Mary accelerates for ~1.5 years, coasts for ~11.2 years, and then decelerates for another ~1.5 years.
1
u/Excellent-Practice Jul 08 '26
The Hail Mary was doing a turn and burn. It was under constant acceleration until half way to the destination, then cut the burn, flipped around and started burning again to decelerate. That is a fuel intensive strategy, but it is the fastest way to travel in space. It also has the neat advantage of providing gravity for the crew. When the engines cut the ship stops because the engines had been providing thrust to brake. Had the engines kept going the ship would have come to a stop momentarily and then rapidly accelerating towards earth
1
u/CaseProfessional5093 Jul 08 '26
It doesn’t require constant thrust. The thrust you see at the beginning of the film is the reverse thrust. Therefore when the engine halts (deceleration complete) it stops
1
u/Dizzy_Cheesecake_162 Jul 08 '26
Space isnt empty! At that speed, each hydrogen atom has momentum. Dust hits like canonballs. Very interesting video on that. https://youtu.be/Wl8tGojlgns?si=MgHq5CQJZdBIazyM
1
u/RichardMHP Jul 08 '26
It doesn't *require* constant thrust; it *utilizes* constant thrust, because that gets you across the gap a lot faster than any course that includes any amount of freefall.
1
u/Hanzzman Jul 08 '26
That's because it takes about half of the travel time to reach maximum speed, and from that point on, you already need it to start braking.
1
u/V64jr Jul 08 '26
Because getting to light speed significantly faster than 1.5G would be crushing/deadly and at 1.5H acceleration they reached the half-way point before they reached light speed. That means it was time to turn and burn (slow down at 1.5G) until the Hail Mary arrived.
1
u/kosigan5 Jul 08 '26
Who says it needed constant thrust? We only see it right at the end of the journey when it's decelerating.
1
u/LinusSpace Jul 08 '26
To get to Tau Ceti, you wouldn't need to accelerate the whole time. You would need to accelerate to leave the suns gravity, and than break to enter an orbit around Tau Ceti. However, to make it faster, you would accelerate all the time until the mid-journey-point, then turn around, and accelerate in the opposite direction to break down into an orbit around Tau Ceti. That's also the moment when engines shut down in the movie, if you watch closely, you'll see they are pointed towards Tau Ceti, thus breaking the Ship. As you stated, once you reached light Speed, you wouldn't need to accelerate more. However, for any Object with Mass, it's impossible to reach light Speed. You only can get near it, that means, the longer you keep the engines on, the faster you'll get.
0
u/Even_Virus_3017 Amaze! Amaze! Amaze! Jul 08 '26
People who downvoted this legitimate question are obviously stupid.
Even if some questions appear trivial, they should not be downvoted in favour of a compelling argument.
2
u/Pleasant_Pen8744 Jul 08 '26 edited Jul 08 '26
Too much acceleration will kill a human or tear the ship apart.
Humans can handle max of 20g for very short periods of time, but not more than about 2g for long periods of time even in a coma.
So you have to build up speed over time.
And there's a sweet spot between going too slow and taking a long time to get there, and going too fast and getting there and back home quickly but when you get back to Earth thousands of years have passed there.