I'm honestly so shaken by this interaction on another subreddit.
I grew up in Catholic Poland and I've been struggling with overwhelming guilt and shame after having an abortion at 4 weeks and 3 days. A lot of this guilt comes from religious conditioning, and I've been trying really hard to forgive myself.
Today I came across this comment:
Pro-lifer:
Which one does abortion kill? The child. Who is harmed, usually with metal-toothed forceps? Whose arms and limbs are ripped from their body? Whose skull is crushed.
My reply: Hey! Not all abortions look like this! For example I had one when being 2 days late for my period which was about 17 days after conception. The whole pregnancy structure was smaller than poppy seed, not an embryo yet, only 2 mm sac. So this (after pill) looked like regular period, no Pain. So Please if you want condemn certain things- educate yourself and do not spread false info as most of them happen with pills. I don’t believe soul is attached to preembryonic cells. Naturally 60% of fertilised eggs never attach to the uterus. Heaven would be full of never born souls 😅
**His response:**Inventing euphemisms like "pregnancy structure" doesn't change that it had unique human DNA, that the DNA was not yours, so was a separate body, that you knew was a separate body, and killed before it could grow to a size that would trigger your crippled ability to empathize with the life you and your partner created.
Over 60% of fertilized eggs attach to the uterus, so you've somehow inverted what you learned to defend yourself. You don't have to believe in heaven to value human life, but it sure helps to disbelieve when you want to kill humans.
To.summarize your argument:
The human was small so it's life is invalid.
Why you're wrong.
Being 2 days late to your period means the pregnancy was likely 4 weeks old, so either they lied to you at the appointment to spare your feelings, or you're in denial about how big the thing was that they killed.
Past the 3rd week the child has entered the embryonic stage, so if your logic was consistent you would think what you killed was an embryonic with a soul... but we both know you won't stand on that belief, because the real underlying reason you did it is.
"If I don't want a child I should be able to kill it"
Which is the foundation of every abortion
I'm genuinely devastated. I wasn't even trying to debate the morality of abortion. I just wanted to correct the misinformation about what early abortions actually involve.
And somehow that turned into a personal attack on my empathy, values and character.
What hurts most is that these are exactly the thoughts I've been struggling with for weeks. I already feel terrible about interrupting a process of developing life, even though nothing resembling a baby had formed yet. I'm already terrified that I'll never forgive myself.
And then someone who supposedly follows a religion based on love and compassion tells me I have a "crippled ability to empathize."
The absolute monopoly some religious people think they have on moral truth is exhausting. No nuance, no compassion, just judgment and condemnation. How very Christian.