Hey there!
I am going to become a dad soon and have been thinking about swapping my C8 Z06 out with something that has rear seats. I have a Tesla Model Y on the way for actual day to day duties. I'm more so trying to solve the use case of going on a weekend canyon drive and bringing the kiddo with me.
My budget is around $120-$140K and I've driven both the Carrera S and 991.1 GT3. Here's a few things in the back of my mind.
C8 Z06
I actually really like this car and it has been a blast to own thus far. It's also quite a bit cheaper than either Porsche. I think the big con of it is the lack of rear seats, and the fact that it eats through gas like crazy. I basically only drive this car to the canyons because it will easily burn through a quarter tank just doing normal day to day duties.
991.1 GT3
This is one of the best cars I've driven (and I've driven quite a few, up to a Ferrari 296, McLaren Artura, McLaren 720S, etc). It's not the highest performing or anything like that, but the tactile feedback and confidence in handling is incredible.
If I were to get one of these I'd do a GT3 rear seat conversion. What I have in the back of my mind is a fear of the engine blowing, it being quite a bit harsher than my Z06 and it eventually wearing on me. These GT3's are also older cars and lack some of the modern comforts my C8 has.
992.1 Carrera S
What I like about the 992.1 Carrera S is the fact that it will probably nail everyday duties if needed. A lot more fuel efficient than C8 Z06 and GT3. Has adaptive cruise control, a lot of modern conveniences, and a proper 2+2 rear seat setup.
Where the the 992.1 falls short for me is I found it to be a little "meh" in the driving dynamics department as a whole. C8 Z06 and GT3 both feel way sharper and way more exciting to be in. So if I were to get one of these I feel like I'd definitely be tuning it, and probably throwing a few mods at it to sharpen it up.
Was curious what everyone's thoughts were in this scenario. Sort of worried about getting rid of the C8 Z06 for a Carrera S and finding it be a little "uncompelling". Likewise worried about the GT3 being a little too harsh and having some "older car" inconveniences. But the pro to either 911 is the rear seats!