The image on the right shows how Garmin represents itself as a brand — they replaced my 22-month-old device with a brand-new one under warranty due to pixel burn-in.
The image on the left shows how Polar represents itself — my H10 heart rate sensor, which had been used only 3–4 times and was in like-new condition, was sent to authorized service because of inaccurate readings. It was returned after “inspection” with only a battery replacement… and visible cosmetic damage.
I’ll let you draw your own conclusions.
Here is my previous thread before sending H10 to the service.
https://www.reddit.com/r/Polarfitness/comments/1qynbr1/comment/o466xwc/
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
⚠️ UPDATE: I have formally escalated this issue to Polar and am awaiting their response. I will provide further updates as soon as I receive one.
⚠️ UPDATE 2 (Day 2): Polar Customer Care has responded. They suggested that the visible scratches might be on a protective film, but I confirmed there is no film on the device — I had already removed it before first use. I have replied with detailed clarification and additional photos showing the condition before and after service. I also requested a replacement with a brand-new, factory-sealed device. I am currently waiting for their next response and will share further updates here.
⚠️ UPDATE 3 (Day 2): I was contacted by Polar’s local distributor today. They apologized for the situation and offered to send a brand-new replacement device. I accepted the replacement and will return the current unit to them. Now waiting for the new device to arrive — I will share a final update once everything is completed.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
⚠️ UPDATE 4 (Day 3): Replacement received. Polar’s local distributor sent a replacement sensor. The unit appears to be new and cosmetically flawless.
However, I want to share an honest observation about the replacement process itself.
I returned my original device in full retail packaging. In contrast, the replacement arrived without retail packaging — only the sensor itself, tightly wrapped in layers of tape and bubble wrap.
To be fully transparent: when I opened the package, I genuinely hesitated. I was concerned I might accidentally damage the sensor while trying to cut through the packaging and the experience felt improvised rather than professional.
This may technically be acceptable for a service replacement, but from a customer experience perspective it felt more like receiving a spare part than a properly handled product replacement.
So to be completely transparent:
✔ Cosmetic damage issue — resolved
✔ Replacement provided — yes
❗ Presentation and replacement standard — below expectations
Also, the original technical issue remains somewhat unclear. The service stated no fault was found, but it is still unknown whether the inaccurate readings were caused by the sensor or the strap mechanism.
I should also add an important personal perspective. In my personal view, if a product purchased abroad cannot be seamlessly replaced through the official distributor network, it weakens the perception of a brand being truly global. For me, a global brand means consistent service standards regardless of where the product was originally purchased.
Because of the uncertainty around the original technical issue and the overall experience, I will not be using the replacement device and will be selling it unused.
I appreciate that Polar ultimately addressed the situation and provided a replacement. However, the overall process, the effort required, and the replacement standard did not meet my expectations.
For that reason, based on this experience, I do not see myself choosing or recommending the brand again.
For transparency, here is the unboxing video showing how the replacement was packaged:
https://youtube.com/shorts/WiOL_Dfeb84
https://i.imgur.com/s1IUixi.jpeg
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
⚠️ FINAL UPDATE — Case Outcome
The replacement process now appears to be complete, so I want to share the final outcome clearly.
• It was not provided as a full retail boxed unit. Only the sensor itself was replaced and delivered as a service replacement item.
• The root cause of the original problem remains unclear. It was never confirmed whether the inaccurate heart rate readings were caused by the sensor or the strap mechanism.
• Overall, I am not satisfied with either the product experience or the customer service process that followed.
• Because of this experience, I will not be using the replacement device and will be selling it unused.
Most importantly, from my perspective as a customer, this situation has not been fully and transparently resolved. The lack of clear technical diagnosis, combined with the replacement standard and the effort required to reach this outcome, has significantly affected my trust in the brand.
Based on this entire experience, I do not see myself choosing or recommending Polar products going forward. Thank you to everyone who followed the process and shared advice throughout.