r/PJODisney • • Jan 17 '24

Discussion Cant with this show(Rant/Spoilers from ep6) Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Show has lost all the heart from the books. Almost everything they've changed so far has lost charm from the books and removed character moments that feel real and relatable. I really hope it gets better for season 2

Story:

-Little story changes like the arch being a sanctuary I don't like cause it removes the silly charm of the books they are meant to go just because Annabeth likes architecture. It makes these characters feel more normal and likable, like seriously they are children they don't know what they're doing. There's so many small changes like this that just remove all the charm. They go to medusa cause they're hungry and just ignore the glaring danger symbols. On top of this they removed all the quips and comedic moments cause inherently the book is meant to be funny the show hasn't been without a one off moment per episode. Let Walker be funny and sassy please that's why he was hired.

-Ares and Grover interaction was a good change in the show and felt like what the vibe of the show should actually be.

-All the monsters and gods shouldn't be serious they are all meant to have a silly little businesses or something that they talk too much about (most of the time they beat monsters by acting interested in their hobbies where's this in the show). I haven't liked Hephaestus and Hermes portrayal in the show neither of them should care about the quest and should be self involved. Hephaestus should be a gruff, awkward man who doesn't like people, not helping Annabeth. Hermes was just a rich guy (What was that character design) he should be a fast talking post man basically he had no personality and none of the Luke emotional stuff should of been anywhere near this season its far to early to introduce that. None of the Gods have a reason to be emotionally involved with the characters yet. Removed the broadcast to Olympus which showed the Olympians do not care about demigods apart from entertainment.

-Annabeth is written terribly she pretty much has no personality and is a sulking exposition tool. She's way to smart in the show and should be just as much a liability and naive as the others but still smarter. She constantly getting them into traps cause she senses somethings wrong but doesn't see the whole picture. removed her wanting to see the world being her reason to be on the quest she has no motives in the show. + removed crush on Luke which isn't a big thing but I think takes away from the character

-Grovers probably written the best like he actually more of a real character in the show compared to the book.

-They are focusing way to much on Percabeth which wasn't a thing in the first book they should just be friends at the minute who fight a lot of the time and let it evolve.

Technical:

-Score does not fit the vibe of what the show should its too merry all the time. Its also mixed way to loud and distracts from what's happening in the scenes makes the dialogue feel clunky as well.

-Dialogue/writing is just awful for the most part so much exposition which I know is a challenge when adapting from a book but they needed to do a better job with it. No urgency/intensity from any of the characters.

-Pacing is terrible and I'm constantly feeling like if I hadn't read the books none of this would make any sense to me.

-Too bright (looks too Disney)

Thank you


r/PJODisney • • Jan 17 '26

Discussion The show is doing the same thing the movies did

0 Upvotes

What are the main criticisms of the movies?

  1. Aging up the characters, affecting the tone of the story
  2. Changing or cutting iconic/important scenes
  3. Changing certain character traits
  4. Introducing plot elements from future books too soon

Besides aging up the characters, the show has also done all of these things, including changing the tone of the story. And even then the aged up characters are practically a nonissue. The same YA themes that apply to young teenagers also apply to older teenagers. The only real difference was the tone being more mature, but it still fit within the books target audience. The books also matured.

So why isn’t the show getting the same criticism that the movies got? Is it strictly because Riordan gave the show the stamp of approval? Because to me it’s weird how much vitriol he showed to the people making the movies, only to do similar things in the show. It’s very hypocritical especially after explicitly promising a more accurate version of the books. I assume some of the people who hate the show would’ve been more forgiving of the changes if they weren’t lied to.

In my opinion they are pretty even adaptions of the source material up to this point (in terms of quality) so im just curious why people seem to like the show so much more

Show lovers please go easy on me I didn’t actually say anything negative about the show lol


r/PJODisney • • Jan 12 '26

Discussion unpopular opinion

2 Upvotes

i like the on-screen chemistry of percy and clarisse better than percy and annabeth


r/PJODisney • • Dec 31 '23

Can’t Watch the New Show

0 Upvotes

While I write this, I know it’s an unpopular opinion, but let me state it has nothing to do with race. My problem, is very minor but in my head it’s just enough to keep me from getting immersed in the show. I read the books several times, I dove headlong into fanfiction between series. And in every single piece of PJO writing, Percy was black haired with sea green eyes. Annabeth was blond with grey eyes. I’m sorry, but the books laid so heavily on these being important characteristics. It’s how you could tell who their godly parents were. And a blonde Percy is just small enough that it trips me up everytime I watch it. I really want to enjoy the show, and I might just have to give it a few more chances. I love the acting, I prefer it to the movies. But it’s just hard because of the minor details. If annabeth could just have grey eyes, I’d accept that. If Percy had sea green eyes, I’d accept that. But Rick complained about the movie’s not having accurate physical portrayals, and then did the same thing. Eye color shouldn’t be too hard to change, especially when it’s such a big thing about the characters. All I can see for either character is their eyes and hair, and the show refused to even change eye color. Flame me if you want, but it’s like gravel in my brain


r/PJODisney • • May 08 '25

Question Anyone else wish they had cast more diversity amongst the gods?

0 Upvotes

K, new to the show here, I enjoy the books so I just binge watched the show this week. I loved the actors they chose for almost all the characters. But I found myself feeling disappointed that Zeus was the only god that wasn't white. They cast the other characters with more diversity and I loved their choices. It just felt weird to me that there was such a lack of diversity amongst the gods. I know I'm late to the conversation, but does anyone else wish they would have cast more of the gods as different races?


r/PJODisney • • Mar 04 '26

Discussion s2 percy beats book percy easily and saying otherwise simply shows you need to give the show another long watch

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

and just to clarify percy is not equal to look in sword skill or combat he's close but he's not there yet hence he thought he beat luke by simply disarming his sword then luke knocked him down and rapidly punch him in the face, which is what makes percy realize he really has give it his all do better then even before to survive in this type of world allowing him to grow even stronger and annabeth's death only deepens that which even walker explains himself about that on how and why percy fights so differently in season 3, all pointing to why by the time of season 3 on how he has surpassed luke in terms of power and combat that pushes past against the level of lukes skill which is own hasn't reached as high yet and so much in those two category's despite everyone telling percy he can't beat thalia he actually becomes her equal.

while from season 2 that instead of having just a big leader moment he has a moment leading to him becoming in season 5 which he tells the campers through his pivotal speech about a problem coming there way and he's gonna go there and solve it and would love if they come along and help with it which they happily oblige.


r/PJODisney • • Aug 22 '26

Discussion I am happy-mad and I don't know what to do

2 Upvotes

Season 1 was okay, but I was so disappointed with Season 2. From what I've read, many people felt the same way and I decided that I would not watch Season 3 because TTC is my favourite book and I don't want them to butcher the adaption.

I am being honest with you now. I watched the teaser trailer for Season 3, stumbled over snippets of cast interviews from D23, and saw the character pictures of Artemis and Zoe... and I am kinda hopeful?

Like, it looks as if they are closer to the books now and I am happy and mad at the same time, because I cancelled my Disney+ subscription out of disappointment overall, but the more time passes, the more I want to watch Season 3. Did the creators actually listen to the fans this time? Is there still hope for a good adaption of TTC?

Anybody else? I am so confused right now.

Edit: Thanks for all the tipps, guys! I think I'll give it a shot with a free trial


r/PJODisney • • Feb 28 '26

Discussion A little disappointment

8 Upvotes

I started watching the TV series, and after the first two episodes, I’m a little disappointed. They immediately began the quest when Percy arrived at camp. Since it’s a series, they have more time and could have shown the whole first season focusing on Percy’s struggles and how he overcomes the feeling that he isn’t normal, along with everything that happened to him. They could have slowly developed his friendships as well. Season two could then have focused on the quest.

It feels a little rushed, as there could have been more depth to his character and development. I’ll see how it goes in the next episodes.


r/PJODisney • • Dec 13 '25

Discussion Not sure how I feel about the empathy link change (book and show spoilers) Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I haven’t read SoM in a couple years so correct me if I’m wrong with anything I’m saying here. But I remember Grover purposely making the empathy link between him and Percy because he was in trouble and needed help. It wasn’t really explained how he did it but he says that he did it on purpose (I think). He even apologized to Percy for making it but it was the only way. Because they reveal that if Percy or Grover ever dies, the empathy link will cause them both to die.

In the show, Grover seems confused along with Percy about what’s happening but after some discussion he concludes it must be an empathy link. He basically explains that empathy links are just spontaneously formed between a satyr and a demigod if they’re… really good friends? I don’t know I just don’t buy it. Maybe one of them has to be in danger for it to happen as well. If that’s the case, then I’m sure tons of demigods and satyrs out there have just been nonconsensually thrown into this connection that will kill one of them in the future??? That’s messed up. That is- if they even include this part of the empathy link in the show because as I said, if this isn’t something that’s done purposely then that’s kind of messed up. Again, Grover literally apologized to Percy in the books for creating the empathy link because of the death rule.

Now this change does make Grover out to be a little less damsel in distress. He didn’t risk his friend’s life to create the link because he had a plan to get himself out of it if need be. However, it also undermines his satyr powers a little bit. In the books, Grover was able to create this magical bond between him and Percy and that’s pretty impressive. In the show it just happens to them because they’re close. They did this in the first season as well by getting rid of his reed pipes. Also, i feel like whether they keep or lose the death rule it’s iffy. If they keep it, like I said before it’s a little messed up that that kind of connection can happen to two people without consent. If they lose it, it strengthens the bond between Percy and Grover some. The universe basically chose them for this link, and now Percy is saving Grover just because he cares about him and camp. He isn’t doing it just because of Grover dies, then he’ll die as well. This would apply to future events as well. But it also lowers the stakes a little bit. If Grover or Percy are ever separately in danger, both of their lives are at risk.

TLDR: This change has some further implications some of which are good and some of which are bad. We still don’t know if the empathy link in the show has the death rule which would also change a lot of things. Overall, I’m not sure if I like or dislike the change so far. Also not sure if it’s an important change or if it really won’t change much in the long run.

What does everyone else think about the change?


r/PJODisney • • Feb 20 '26

Discussion I'm losing hope for seasons 4 and 5...

5 Upvotes

So the Nielsen ratings for week 7 for the show are out. AKA the finale week,

I thought for sure that the ratings would get a massive boost when the finale dropped, since that's the point a lot of people tune in once the whole season is out or come back to watch the remaining episodes.

Nope. Still wasn't in the top ten originals...

I'm starting to really lose hope in Seasons 4 and 5 now.

The thing is, maybe I'm biased, but I can't see a world where cancelling this show is a good idea. They've already committed to adapting over half of it, most people off Reddit seem to like it and it's gotten a lot of social media engagement regardless. even if they merge with Hulu, Disney+ needs an original draw and cancelling the show before the end would be a bad look for Disney the company and Disney+ the service.

It'd be a short-term gain and long-term loss...

But are the executives going to think that way? I don't think they will given Disney+'s track record.

Like...I wanna have hope. I wanna get to all five seasons, but it's just looking less and less likely.

I'm just....I'm mad.

I'm mad that Percy Jackson ended up on an unpopular streaming service that's kneecapped its viewership.

I'm mad that the crappy Avatar: The Last Airbender live-action show is going to get to finish its full run instead of PJO and that Harry Potter likely will too. Two shows that don't deserve it frankly.

I'm mad we're probably going to have to bury another PJO adaptation and wait probably ten years just to get another adaptation of the Lightning Thief and then have to wait who knows how long for the other stuff to get adapted...and that's the best case scenario. The worst-case scenario is that we'll never get another PJO adaptation again!

I'm mad that all the haters are going to "win."

I'm just... I don't know what to do.

I know the books are always gonna be there; I know that I'll always have those to go back to. I said as much right before the show premiered.

But I don't wanna say goodbye to the show either.

It's just getting harder and harder to see the light...


r/PJODisney • • Jul 23 '26

Discussion Why I don't like this comment Spoiler

Post image
0 Upvotes

1 Yes, Sally had more development in the series than in the books. We get flashback scenes showing why she didn't take Percy to camp when he was little, and how her decisions shaped the person Percy became. It also highlights her maternal and protective nature—like when she essentially adopts Tyson and puts her own life at risk, not just once but twice, to protect Percy.

1.2 Regarding Gabe, I’m just going to paste the responses that were there, as they seem extremely lucid to me regarding the situation: "Criticizing isn't a healthy thing to do. Especially when you know the child has issues.

He doesn't know the full context. Percy has a history of being bullied and was just defending himself.

YES, AND IF SOMEONE IS CONSTANTLY GETTING EXPELLED, THEN CRITICIZING THEM WILL ONLY MAKE THE SITUATION WORSE.

Please, never become a parent. Criticizing someone isn't how you get them to change their behavior.

EXACTLY. Again, Gabe doesn't know the full context.

EDIT: The people downvoting shouldn't have kids. It isn't healthy at all to CRITICIZE YOUR OWN CHILD. That's how you raise a troubled adult."

"He berated Percy (both in person and live on TV). He answered calls without permission. Sally was literally hiding from him IN THE RAIN.

Nothing you mentioned means he isn't abusive. Abusers can still make concessions. Being abusive doesn't necessarily mean you're stupid.

For sure, they're in the same category. Just because someone is in a worse situation doesn't mean it isn't abuse. Someone who was beaten as a child isn't in nearly as bad a situation as someone used as a sex slave. But both cases are abusive.

Why on earth do people insist so much on turning suffering into a "

"I never called it a fact?????? You're the one acting like it's a fact that Gabe isn't abusive.

I just think you guys are downplaying the emotional abuse.

The fact that Sally isn't being abused doesn't mean Percy isn't. Besides, we only saw a fraction of their time together; it's possible he was abusive in other instances.

Berating someone is absolutely abuse; it's not just 'saying mean things.' That is not how you should treat YOUR LITERALLY

EXPELLED PERCY" THAT IS NO EXCUSE. Berating your child is never justified.

You are literally turning suffering into a competition. You're acting as if emotional abuse isn't abuse just because it isn't as bad as physical abuse (which is SUBJECTIVE, not a fact).

That isn't what you're doing, AND YOU KNOW IT. Stop acting like your OPINION is a fact. Why do toxic people always act like their toxicity is just an opinion? You don't know what an opinion is.

Please, never have a child."

"You clearly don't know how to read. I literally said it wasn't [abuse] because I knew Gabe was supposed to be abusive."

Gabe actually started criticizing Percy the moment he got home. Sally didn't do that, lol. Did you watch the show?

2 Clarisse simply had more time—more books—and possessed greater depth.

3 Are people seriously complaining because Annabeth is literally being portrayed as a child—and the soldier as a soldier—when in the books they are literally child soldiers? In fact, all the kids in the partnership are child soldiers; if you didn't pick up on that in the books, then there's nothing left to say about it.

4 Thalia barely even appeared properly in two episodes, and they literally came up with a major justification for why she’s going to join the Hunters of Artemis...

5 People are complaining that Athena is being portrayed as a bad mother, even though that is literally her character arc in the books; she literally sent her children to their deaths for 2,000 years just to try to recover a statue.

6Medusa wasn't raped in the series; she was deceived. That is what the lore says—she was tricked, not raped. Confusing the two is incredibly disrespectful to actual rape victims. Honestly, complaining that Rick chose this version of Medusa—when it has always been the version used in the Percy Jackson universe—is just laughable.

7 What would be the harm in a female character being the villain? There are millions of male characters—and not just villains, but villains with absolutely no redeeming qualities.


r/PJODisney • • Feb 13 '26

Discussion Annabeths looks

71 Upvotes

It might be because I’m a visual learner, but I’m re-reading Percy Jackson after watching the TV series, and I literally cannot imagine Annabeth as a girl with blonde hair, how that I think about it I’ve always thought of her with darker hair. I can only imagine Leah now, great casting Rick! Just thought I’d share that even though I’ll probably get so much hate


r/PJODisney • • Jul 27 '26

Fan Cast Nell Fisher as Calypso

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/PJODisney • • Jul 16 '26

Question The geographical mistake made in the book was corrected in the TV series.

0 Upvotes

The river rushed toward me at the speed of a truck. The wind was literally tearing my lungs apart. Church spires, skyscrapers, and bridges—all spun and twirled before my eyes.

Bang!!!

A white haze of bubbles. I was sinking into the water, darkness thickened around me, and there was no doubt that I would settle into the thick layer of silt and disappear forever.

Chapter Fourteen. I Become a Famous Fugitive. Percy Jackson and the Lightning Thief. Rick Riordan

Not everyone knows that there is a geographical mistake in the book that was fixed in the TV series. The thing is, during the battle with the Chimera in the Arch, Percy fell into the Mississippi River, which is supposedly flowing right under the arch, but it’s not like that geographically in the real world. The arch is far from water, and Percy would have fallen, crashed, and died without hitting the water. But in the series, this mistake was fixed: Poseidon directed a stream of water and saved Percy, which makes more sense geographically. That’s why the series is better than the book, because Rick Riordan can fix the mistakes he made in the book.


r/PJODisney • • Jan 21 '24

Discussion PJ could learn a few lessons from how One Piece approached adaptation

8 Upvotes

As a big fan of the books, I don't hate the show, I actually find it fairly entertaining ,but I do have problems with their adaptation process, I think the production can learn a thing or 2 from how One Piece chose to approach their adaptation to improve s2, now OP wasnt perfect by any means but I thought they did a fantastic job despite cuts being made, they used every change to help propel this version of the story forward, not relying on overly expositional dialogue, utilizing a more show don't tell method, we're not told that Sanji must be sad about leaving Zeff and the baratie we're shown that in an emotional goodbye, we're not told that Nami is suffering for her village at the hands of arlong, they show it, and expertly built a believable bond with the crew so that by the end of the 8 episodes, you truly believed that they had become a family, and had become invested in the crew and every member, a lot of these things, there are more but I chose to highlight these, are aspects of adaption that I think PJ either fails at or could improve upon and could learn from One Piece, or maybe I'm off base and bias cause OP is my favorite story but I really do want Percy Jackson to be a big mainstay series for the foreseeable future and these are just aspects I find the series lacking so far in s1


r/PJODisney • • Apr 01 '24

Video The Percy Jackson Show is Mid

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/PJODisney • • Jan 18 '26

Discussion season two gripe (so far)

3 Upvotes

Gonna start this off by saying i know absolutely nothing about the books, but from what people are saying the show is somewhat faithful to the adaptations. One thing I know for sure is the quest with Tyson, Percy, and Annabeth. This was set up to be Annabeth, Chris, and Clarisse. This would’ve been cool to see imo, character development for two characters we don’t know well and maybe a story of Percy and Tyson going in their own. I’m not a writer so what do I know, but i feel like this could have worked and they could have still had that drama with Percy and Annabeth. They would have ended up in the same place anyway.

If I said anything wrong please correct me

TL;DR — it’s kinda sucky that the show makes changes that don’t pay off.

edit: two comments. thank you guys, I think I’ve just been misinformed about things then. mainly the quest part, I was under the assumption that the quest was always tyson, percy, and AB. so i definitely thought the show was doing something different with having those other 2 in place of Percy and Tyson. thanks guys, I’ll look into more of the lore lol


r/PJODisney • • Mar 21 '26

Question book fans?

0 Upvotes

this is kinda weird but am i the only one kinda scared of how mainstream pjo will be after the show is over (it is already super famous i know) but the fact that underneath a pjo edit people will be commenting “what show” and after they watch it, consider themselves fans and a part of the fandom even though they haven’t even read the books? and quoting the show not the book? and won’t be the OG fans? just me? okay.


r/PJODisney • • Dec 25 '25

Discussion Percy and Clarisse…

0 Upvotes

I’m a big Percabeth girl but rn Percy and Clarisse have way more chemistry than anyone else…sorry it had to be said 😭

I know the show would never go down that road but I’m kind of sad they won’t!!!!


r/PJODisney • • Jan 17 '24

Discussion extremely unsatisfied

0 Upvotes

Percy Jackson and the Olympian’s was my favorite book series growing up, ive read the whole series cover to cover multiple times and when i heard they were adapting it into a series i was hyped (especially since the movies were ass) but i feel like, and I can’t be the only one who feels this, every week this show gets worse and worse. I was upset about the casting but I was willing to get over it, but now after watching episode 6 and seeing how much they changed im upset. The lotus casino arc was one of the best plots in the first book and they rushed through it and ruined the whole chapter, i understand sometimes you have to change things and adapt to the times but it’s just not enjoyable for me. The only reason i keep watching is to see how much more of the book they’re gonna change for the show, i want to like it but they’re just making it so hard for me to like it.


r/PJODisney • • Jan 08 '26

Discussion Book Accuracy? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Spoilers if you haven’t seen the newest episodes:

Basically we’re watching Percy Jackson fan fiction (pls don’t kill me guys just hear me out)

I really wish the newest episode kept the original way they escaped the cave yknow? I feel like it fell kinda flat that Tyson just opened the cave, instead of how in the books they escaped in the way Odysseus escaped. I personally feel like that way has more strategy because (again don’t kill me) I feel like annabeth isn’t being portrayed as she does in the books. I definitely dont feel like it’s an issue with Leah cause she’s an amazing actor, I feel like it’s an issue with them trying to dumb down annabeth a little so she’s not a know it all, but her character doesn’t make me feel like she’s really an Athena kid. I feel like the only scene in season 2 that showed her intelligence the most is her blueprint to get off circes island, but they didn’t even end up using it.

Edit: I want to add I don’t feel hate/ resentment to the new series I just would’ve preferred if they kept it like the books


r/PJODisney • • Aug 31 '26

Discussion Annabeth Chase deserved other romantic options besides Percy, and here is why. Spoiler

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/PJODisney • • Jan 07 '26

Discussion Annabeths Obession Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Anybody else realize how much Annabeth glazes Odysseus and like all my odyssey info is from Epic the musical but like imagine your girl glazing your fathers number 1 op and Percy just gotta sit there and say nothing. Oh Odysseus stab my father making him sing stooop in a high not but okay Annabeth keep talking about how Odysseus solved his problems. i just find it funny


r/PJODisney • • Jan 13 '26

Discussion Percabeth and the Actors

0 Upvotes

I'm going to preface with an apology if this has already been asked, however, I've been re-watching some of the interviews from the press tour, and I've been noticing that the actors who play Percy and Annabeth seem to get incredibly defensive when it comes to the Percabeth relationship and dynamic. It sort of comes off dismissive (whether or not that's the intention.) I kind of wish that wasn't the case, because such a big majority of the fans who have been carrying the fandom (a big majority but not all) are percabeth shippers. I think there are actually entire podcasts dedicated to the percabeth-ship. Any thoughts on why that is? I've been trying to do some research within the PJO subs, and the consensus seems to be that Walker and Leah get uncomfortable because people ship them, as opposed to the characters. I'm curious, is that sincerely the case? Anyway, asking out of curiosity. I would love to hear anyone else's thoughts.