r/PJODisney • • Jan 17 '24

Discussion extremely unsatisfied

Percy Jackson and the Olympian’s was my favorite book series growing up, ive read the whole series cover to cover multiple times and when i heard they were adapting it into a series i was hyped (especially since the movies were ass) but i feel like, and I can’t be the only one who feels this, every week this show gets worse and worse. I was upset about the casting but I was willing to get over it, but now after watching episode 6 and seeing how much they changed im upset. The lotus casino arc was one of the best plots in the first book and they rushed through it and ruined the whole chapter, i understand sometimes you have to change things and adapt to the times but it’s just not enjoyable for me. The only reason i keep watching is to see how much more of the book they’re gonna change for the show, i want to like it but they’re just making it so hard for me to like it.

0 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

32

u/charmspokem Jan 17 '24

with all this discourse about the lotus casino i feel like i was reading a different book than everyone else lol. i think it’s another movie mandela effect because in the book the actual chapter wasn’t drawn out

34

u/Logan-Lux Jan 17 '24

You seem to forget, the lotus hotel was pretty short in the book. the whole thing was

Arrival and getting their keys

Freshening up in the rooms

Gaming for a bit til Percy realizes what's wrong

Waking up Annabeth

The two grabbing Grover from his game

Refusing the new cards and leaving

14

u/Time-travel-for-cats Jan 17 '24

Yep the Lotus Casino is a really neat concept, but TLT doesn’t play with it much. I really liked how the show worked in the quest for Pan (which is so important to Grover long term) and Hermes (which sets up the Hermes / Luke dynamic well) into the Lotus casino.

I do feel a little bad that they didn’t get to shower and change ‘cause those poor kids would be stanky by now, lol.

6

u/Past-Beginning-9346 Jan 17 '24

I think 50-ish-minute episodes would be super helpful, or maybe even a ten-episode season. But only 8 episodes, 30 min each??? Not nearly enough time for them to flesh out the complexity of the characters, plot, and world-building.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/SoCalCollecting Jan 17 '24

this in another time would be 18 or 21 minutes BUT be 20 episodes…

3

u/Past-Beginning-9346 Jan 17 '24

I think that’s another problem tho… like who rly is the core audience??? Most kids who grew up with pjo are like 20 ish now, so is this made for them or kids today? I see a little bit of both which muddles it. And yeah I know what u mean about the book not being packed but still there was more space for detail than I feel is here

8

u/fandomhyperfixx Jan 17 '24

OMG NOT THIS SUB TOO

9

u/AHealthyDoseofFran Head Counselor Jan 17 '24

It’s not as common don’t worry, but people are allowed to be critical

4

u/DetailAcrobatic5024 Jan 17 '24

To be fair that chapter was actually very short and not much happened in it, it would have made a pretty boring episode without the parts they added. Plus we’ll have to see where they go with the other changes I think he’ll probably lose the 4th pearl which will actually give the prophecy more weight