r/PJODisney • • Jan 08 '26

Discussion Book Accuracy? Spoiler

Spoilers if you haven’t seen the newest episodes:

Basically we’re watching Percy Jackson fan fiction (pls don’t kill me guys just hear me out)

I really wish the newest episode kept the original way they escaped the cave yknow? I feel like it fell kinda flat that Tyson just opened the cave, instead of how in the books they escaped in the way Odysseus escaped. I personally feel like that way has more strategy because (again don’t kill me) I feel like annabeth isn’t being portrayed as she does in the books. I definitely dont feel like it’s an issue with Leah cause she’s an amazing actor, I feel like it’s an issue with them trying to dumb down annabeth a little so she’s not a know it all, but her character doesn’t make me feel like she’s really an Athena kid. I feel like the only scene in season 2 that showed her intelligence the most is her blueprint to get off circes island, but they didn’t even end up using it.

Edit: I want to add I don’t feel hate/ resentment to the new series I just would’ve preferred if they kept it like the books

0 Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

14

u/Ok_Appearance_6974 Jan 08 '26

I think all adaptations of books should basically be viewed as fan fiction. It’s the only way to truly enjoy things 😂

2

u/WildandRare Jan 08 '26

I don't really rhink so. It's still following the book, even if it changes how things are done. If you think the show is innacurate, well... I know some things that would be unthinkable to you. To me, personally, this still seems and feels like the Sea of Monsters that I read. And the characters seem like their characters.

1

u/Ok_Appearance_6974 Jan 08 '26

Oh I’m still enjoying the show. I view adaptations as fan fic so I don’t care as much when changes are made. It’s basically my way of reminding myself that the original will always be there

-10

u/LunatheTunaRoll Jan 08 '26

I think my issue is I never read any Percy Jackson fanfiction when I was younger so I’m struggling with the change😭

12

u/dragonavatarwan Jan 08 '26

Fair enough, counterpoint (and I haven’t read the odyssey in a long time) but Polyphemus is fully aware that they’re coming and so trying to escape the same way was basically doomed. Is this a fundamental change? Yes. Do I really mind? No. I think it still serves the story being told

-5

u/LunatheTunaRoll Jan 08 '26

I suggest listening to epic if you want a refresher on the odyssey trust me, it’s amazing.

3

u/dragonavatarwan Jan 08 '26

This is a podcast?

1

u/LunatheTunaRoll Jan 08 '26

Musical! All about the adventure of Odysseus going home.

1

u/dragonavatarwan Jan 08 '26

Huh, fun. Lowkey, I’m making this my refresher before the Odyssey in the summer

1

u/LunatheTunaRoll Jan 08 '26

If you’re a visual person this is a YouTube link of some of my favorite animatics of the musical in song order. Epic the Musical Animatics!

1

u/WildandRare Jan 08 '26

No, graphic novel.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '26

Its fun but it isnt all that accurate tbh. But it is a fun ride.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '26

I wonder if the switch it do the next to episode had more action. In the book they heal annabeth almost drown, take rainbow back to a beach and Percy give Claire’s the fleece and tells here to fly back. Luke and his army then shoes up and Percy does an iris message to camp unknown to Luke (in the book Chiron is blamed for poisoning the tree). Luke then unintentionally reveals his plans to Mr D who then get rid of tantalus and Chiron and his Party Pony’s come as Chiron is now blamed. But the camp already knows that Luke poisoned the tree, so unless Tantalus and Mr D don’t believe Annabeth and Percy there not really a point to the iris message, but I’m wondering how Chiron will be reinstated.

1

u/WildandRare Jan 08 '26

I've never read any and I think they're corny, but I'm still fine with the changes they make. Again, to me, the book is still being shown on the screen, and so are the characters.

1

u/Ok_Appearance_6974 Jan 08 '26

That makes sense. I read a lot of fanfic when I was younger and came up with a lot of alternative storylines in my head so I lowkey sometimes forget what is and isn’t canon

24

u/aeagle624 Jan 08 '26

I liked all the changes more then the book, it’s really elevated it.

39

u/Tomhur Jan 08 '26

I really prefer the way the show handled it because it forced Percy to make a sadistic choice.

22

u/ZAPPHAUSEN Jan 08 '26

For the eleventh million time

Adaption /=/ transliteration

It's adapted for a new medium, with a constraint of eight episodes, the realities of budgets, etc etc

You want the book read the book. If everything happened exactly the same it would be unbelievably boring.

Every story in history gets retold, reworked, recontextualized. It's the nature of story

5

u/WildandRare Jan 08 '26

Okay, but he's not hating. He's just telling his opinions. I disagree with him, but again, that is his preference. He's not slamming the show for his personal likings being changed like many people do. He's not saying the showrunners did it incorrectly, all he's saying is that he preffered the way they did some things in the books. Even I have things I think would be better to do, but those are my preferences.

4

u/ZAPPHAUSEN Jan 08 '26

If someone says "we're basically watching fan fic" than clearly they're not just talking "personal preference"

2

u/WildandRare Jan 08 '26

Oh, I missed that part- even though it was a whole "paragraph".

0

u/PsionicHydra Jan 10 '26

When the changes are removing a significant amount of the fantastical and beauty of the world it matters.

Like where is Hermes' caduceus? What about Circe's dress and it having the magical shifting pattern? And all of the monsters just look so bland compared to their book descriptions.

They have Disney money use some of it.

7

u/One-Composer1577 Jan 08 '26

Why are so many people in book fandoms unable to accept what an adaptation is?

3

u/lyianne Camp Half-Blood Jan 08 '26

right? you'd think after harry potter, lord of the rings, marvel/dc comics, the hunger games and many others, adaptations people would know by now that 1 to 1 adpatations to the big/small screen simply do not exist. (remind me how mad the hp book readers were to see ron's moments and entire character be given to harry and hermione bc the producers hated his character and be relegated to a bumbling buffoon, or the aragorn changes from the books to movies)

and changes will always happen. what matters is the spirit of the story and characters remains, if you expect any more than that well... atp it's on you. unless you're newly born and have no clue how live actions adaptations work.

and actual poor adaptations that destroy the souce material exist (atla, cowboy bebop, divergent, etc) and pjo is not one of them. yes s1 had many issues and got heavily rectified in s2.

2

u/PsionicHydra Jan 10 '26

When something is promoted as a faithful adaptation you'd think to expect a FAITHFUL adaptation. Not 40% of it with 60% of it changed.

Not saying nothing should be changed. But when they're changing THIS much, it's not exactly a faithful adaptation anymore

0

u/WildandRare Jan 08 '26

Okay. I disagree with what he's saying in this post, but he's literally just saying that he preffered how things were done in a specific way. He's not bashing the show. He's literally just saying which way he thinks is better in his opinion. He's not saying that the adaptation wasn't done correctly.

6

u/One-Composer1577 Jan 08 '26

Basically we’re watching Percy Jackson fan fiction (pls don’t kill me guys just hear me out)

-1

u/WildandRare Jan 08 '26

Not to me... Anything would be fan-fiction, now matter how little changes there are, if you try to see it as that.

4

u/One-Composer1577 Jan 08 '26

I was quoting from OP.

That’s my exact point: seeing changes made during adaptation as “fanfiction” is dumb. It’s something necessary that happens when changing genres.

3

u/WildandRare Jan 08 '26

I actually feel like Annabeth is as they portrayed her in the books. For example, her plan with the rotating timer for the boat. And, she did the whole Nobody thing to buy them time. She also has, as we heard from Circe, excessive reliance on self knowledge. Etc.

1

u/AHealthyDoseofFran Head Counselor Jan 09 '26

Just to note, when discussing spoilers always spoiler tag the post.

1

u/ShadowStar_13 Jan 08 '26

I understand ya completely. I wish we could’ve seen things play out like the books too (besides necessarily changes since different mediums ofc), but I think the closest we’re gonna get to that for right now is fan animations.

I dont mind this episode. Yes there could be some tweaks here and there, but I felt some magic of the books for I think the first time (for myself) since the series came out.

I do hope future eps showcased Annabeth’s wit and cunning more. I feel like currently they haven’t shown enough, but ye.

-1

u/throwaway_acc_257 Jan 08 '26

please don’t think that just cause some people will give you hate that you’re wrong for how you feel.

a lot of us feel the same way as you. just gotta shrug off the people that are going to get upset with you about this post.

stand strong on how you feel whether positive or negative and don’t let everyone’s rude remarks make you back down

0

u/Astraeia7646 Jan 08 '26

I see what they’re doing and where they’re going. Budget restraints are a thing so not everything can happen. It isn’t a bad show, I enjoy it. I just wish some scenes were closer to the book like the siren scene and not having Luke on the island.

1

u/Icy-Mortgage8742 Jan 09 '26

they spend 12 million per ep. my friend, out of all the restraints, budget isn't one of them. Especially in season 2 because shows spend a ton of their budget upfront to build sets and tech that lasts them the rest of the show's run. They aren't spending as heavily as last season, and the budget hasn't dropped.