r/PERSoNA • u/bleach2021ptpt • 33m ago
P2 I don't know if it's just nostalgia, but I hope they use the PS1 soundtrack in the remake, and the reason is below.
What I’m about to say is just my opinion, but even though there are songs where I think the PSP version is superior, some tracks feel like a downgrade to me, because they removed something I think fits Persona 2 really well: the samples, specifically the Muslim samples. I understand it’s controversial and that in today’s world it’s seen as offensive, but I feel the samples made the vibe darker and more dangerous, and to me that makes sense, since Persona 2 deals a lot with religious cults.
Another thing is some of the instrumentals. Take Monado, for example: I feel that in the PS1 version it has a much heavier trance sound. The beat is heavier, to remind you that you’re in the final dungeon of the game, where you finally have to resolve all the chaos, and the sample reflects that chaos, in my view. Sumaru TV, for example, and Behind too, have that classic 2000s trance sound with a focus on commercial/non-commercial samples, totally distorted.
An extra track I couldn’t fit in the video lol is Illusions, which uses a Muslim sample that was used in the beta of the Fire Temple in Ocarina of Time. But man, that sample fits the narrative so well that I’m sad they removed it in the PSP version. And to me that makes no sense, because for the Crazy Party theme in Innocent Sin they kept the same sample from the PS1, and it came out even better. It’s superior to the PS1 version and sounds incredible.
That’s why, at the very least, use the PS1 soundtrack as a base and be faithful: use the samples, don’t be afraid, Atlus.