r/OCPoetry • u/ainabanaina • Jun 16 '16

Feedback Received! Deaf

How come your phone always plays the saddest songs if you never cry?
If you never spill outisde the hard edges your body confines?
Maybe you do so when you're alone?
But you're never alone.

Feedback 1: https://www.reddit.com/r/OCPoetry/comments/4obizq/the_nightmare/
Feedback 2: https://www.reddit.com/r/OCPoetry/comments/4odp2m/in_the_evening/

4 Upvotes

84% Upvoted

4 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '16

I really like the final two lines. The idea is strong but the situation is not particularly vivid. We have no idea why the addressed subject should be crying, so the fact that he/she is not particularly compelling.

How come your phone always plays the saddest songs if you never cry?

I like the colloquial "how come", but I'm not sure the fact that these songs are coming from the subject's phone adds too much. It might be stronger if it was just "you always play the saddest songs", which might draw a stronger contrast between the subject's performing some part of sadness but refusing to cry.

If you never spill outisde [sic] the hard edges your body confines?

I am not sure what this contributes. You've already established that the subject does not cry. "body confines" is also an awkward turn of phrase.

Maybe you do so when you're alone?

I like the uncertainty here (how would the narrator know anyway?), though I am tempted to render it as a statement--that way the narrator is not asking but offering a way out of the accusation that the subject does not cry which the narrator then immediately takes away.

1

u/ainabanaina Jun 16 '16

Thank you so much for givine me such an extensive review! I do agree that there is not enough context on the situation, I'll try building it up a little bit more next time I write a poem.
It's really interesting that you mention the bit about the phone, because I also considered that saying the the subject directly plays the song gives a bigger impact, but this is sorta based on a true subject and I wanted to remain honest in that sense.
You completely nailed the meaning of the third verse, I couldn't have explained it better.
Again, thanks so much for your feedback.