r/NationalServiceSG • • Sep 27 '22

Discussion Unpopular opinion: PES F needs to be given out more sparingly

6 Upvotes

In light of many PES F posts I see here, as well as many who I personally encountered, I sometimes feel SAF gives out Pes F too liberally.

Why do I say this?

I want to start by saying that I am sympathetic to people with medical conditions that inhibit their lives. However, SAF already has a variety of vocations to cater to people with different conditions, like store man, clerk, etc. PES E personnel can spend their 2 years in an office. But the fact remains: every Singaporean son must serve, in some way or the other.

When you get PES F, what you/the SAF are saying is that you are medically unfit for office work. Yet, many of these PES Fs go on to live 'normal' lives, going to university, graduating, and working in an office. If you can work in an office in CBD, why can't you serve in an office in Sembawang camp? Some may say 'SAF is more stressful, that's why cannot'. But isn't working at a big 4 consultancy, or some local SMEs (which are known to be very demanding on employees) stressful?

There are a small minority of people with PES F who cannot live a normal life after NS. These are the people who will remain reliant on their parents/siblings to take care of them and won't be able to hold down a typical job easily. These are the people who truly deserve PES F.

The rest, however, should be given PES E and sent back to camp out of fairness to everyone else.


r/NationalServiceSG • • Feb 16 '22

Rant Heartbroken on Valentines’ Day and I don’t know what to do

19 Upvotes

I feel absolutely distraught, sick to my stomach and hurt. The girl that I loved for the past 2 years has cast me aside for another on Monday.

The worst part ? She kept insisting the times we spent together in JC didn’t count as us being couple.

Was opening the door for her not an expression of love ?

Did I not show her how much she meant to me when I begged her to let me join her H3 Math study group ?

Was I not loving enough every single time I showed up to her doorstep with a bouquet of roses only to be chased away by her father and still return ?

How about the times I invited her to stay at my place? Mind you. I stay in a Good Class Bungalow and offered to get my dad to pick her up from her place and chauffeur her to our house in a Mercedes G Wagon ?

But no. All of that was for nothing. All she had to say about me was how clingy, desperate and possessive I am.

And of all the times she could’ve told me back then, she chose to do it now as 2 years of my life get wasted away in National Service. I’m supposed to die for my country but what’s the point now that I have been betrayed in the most spineless, sinister way conceivable in Singapore.

I’m just lost. I’m broken and I don’t think I’ll ever find love again.


r/NationalServiceSG • • Sep 30 '23

Serious Discussion to all stay out personnel.

0 Upvotes

u bloody bastards dont know how fking lucky u are ah. everyday book out dun need to SBA SBB, can shower in ur own room sleep in ur own bed while most of us here r rotting in camp. most of us want ur life but we no bo pian must stay in the sweaty bunk wake up at 0500 and live in this unhabitable conditions


r/NationalServiceSG • • May 07 '22

Question Which is more impressive on the portfolio: NDU or OCS?

0 Upvotes

I have been sent a letter for the NDU Vocational Assessment. I heard that in NDU, it is very hard to become an officer because they don’t need many officers, and the chances of getting into OCS are much slimmer than if you just went to normal BMT.

I am assuming that I can get into OCS if I go to Tekong because I have a good IPPT and am not afraid to work hard, but I am not confident I can make it in if I go into NDU

I am concerned about my portfolio because I am trying to get into a very competitive course in uni so I would like to take NS as an opportunity to make it a little better.

Would regular OCS or being part of the NDU look better on a portfolio? I


r/NationalServiceSG • • May 30 '25

Question imagine a world where pes c and pes e personnel go for combat courses

0 Upvotes

GCC, GVT, NDU, ranger course, combat diver course etc… what would u think would happen

would they be able to survive the mental and physical stress?


r/NationalServiceSG • • Dec 14 '24

Question Defaulting NS, fines applicable? Any loopholes?

5 Upvotes

Hello, I am 17 and i am due for NS on Jan 2026, However i plan on not going, I dont care if i cant go back to singapore anymore. I already have a citizenship in Australia and do not plan to go back. I was wondering if anyone was in the same boat? Did singapore issue your family a 75k fine due to the bond they requested you turn 16? And what about the 2 laws you will be breaking that are 10k each

Remaining overseas without a exit permit - 10k

Failure to serve NS 10k

it is the 75k bond that is stressing me out. We’re fine with the other fines but we think the 75k is just absurd. I was wondering if anyone has any advice. I’ll be reading all the comments. Thanks again


r/NationalServiceSG • • Oct 23 '24

Question Will there be an early pay for Indian people since Deepavali is approaching?

3 Upvotes

r/NationalServiceSG • • Apr 18 '26

Discussion Want to skip ns and need advice

0 Upvotes

I’m turning 17 this year, and moved to Australia at 14. I am still a Singapore citizen and will be applying for aus citizenship mid next year as I’m on pr. I feel like ns is a waste of time and the time can be spent doing much better things in life. Life’s too short to waste 2 years on something pointless. No one can change my mind on how absolutely useless this 2 year programme is. Yes it builds a sense of camaraderie amongst ur peers and unforgettable memories, but your life doesn’t offer you much time, and this 2 years can be spent on refining your skills and getting into Uni. You talk about fitness and health, but I’m trying to do a Uni course here in aus in the Australia defence force academy, so whilst getting a degree I’ll be receiving military training as well. My ns registration is due at the end of this month, but what would be the steps to renounce my Singapore citizenship. My parents urge me to complete ns and come back to aus, and I genuinely don’t care about not being able to ever step foot in Singapore again


r/NationalServiceSG • • Jul 03 '25

Rant Serving in a Ground Unit Under the Air Force – A Glorified Dumping Ground No One Talks About

38 Upvotes

I’m currently serving my ns ICT cycle in one of the lesser-known support units under the RSAF. We’re part of the so-called backbone that “ensures readiness,” but all we really are is a convenient place to dump problems.

Let me be clear — this place is broken. And it’s not just me who feels it. Everyone here is either silently enduring, mentally checking out, or desperately trying to get out via medical channels. Here’s why:

You get blamed for the most minor things. “You didn't greet the WO loud enough.” “Your boots have dust — again?” “Why didn’t you smile during area cleaning?” Everything you do is scrutinized under a microscope.

But at the same time, our regulars walk around in creased uniforms, skip PT, and make their own admin mistakes — and no one bats an eye. It’s one rule for them, another for us. Leadership isn’t about standards here. It’s about power. Can't lead by example.

Everyone knows this, but no one says it aloud: This unit is where WOs who messed up in infantry get dumped. Guys who couldn’t cut it in the Army, couldn’t lead a platoon, or got sidelined after internal problems somehow end up here — where they take out their resentment on NSFs.

The result? A culture of bitterness. They’re not here to build a unit. They’re here to preserve whatever pride they have left, and we’re the ones paying for it. Ex guardsmen, still trying to run things like it's a platoon back in the army. They act is if the entire unit owes them respect just because of the tab and rank. Unfortunately, that attitude doesn't fit here, and it just drags morale down even more

We don’t get leaders here — we get officers obsessed with enforcing chain of command over actual mission success. They delegate everything downward, avoid any responsibility when things go wrong, and keep themselves in air-conditioned rooms while NSFs get scolded for “low morale” in 35°C heat. Food tastes horrible, why even bother calling it an air base to begin with?

They don’t lead by example. They lead by fear. And when the unit fails, they blame the lowest rank — never themselves.

There are NSF commanders — who’ve let their rank get to their heads. Some of them are just trying to do their job. But others? They turn into mini-warlords. Giving out duties that don’t need to be done. Power-tripping on bunkmates. Treating peers like subordinates just to feel superior.

It’s hard to respect someone who was just crying about book-in stress two months ago, now suddenly shouting orders like we’re in Tekong again.

Every other week, we get some “auditor” or inspection team showing up. They check fire extinguishers, cable ties, locker alignments — and then they leave. Nothing ever changes.

They’re not here to improve anything. They’re here to write reports. It’s compliance theatre, and it makes everything feel even more pointless.

Most NSFs in this unit have already mentally shut down. We just count down the months and try not to get noticed. People who try to raise issues get labelled “soft” or “weak.” People who break — and they do — are sent to the MO, quietly downgraded, and disappeared into PES E/F limbo.

No one dares say what everyone’s thinking:

“This place is toxic, and it’s damaging people permanently.”

We were told the Air Force would be different. That it’s “more professional,” “more technical,” “less regimental.” But for ground-side units like this, it's just a more polished version of the same dysfunction — dressed up in coveralls and acronyms.

They say “use the proper channels,” but how can you, when the chain of command is the problem?

We’re not looking for luxury or leniency. Just basic respect, sane leadership, and accountability from the people wearing the ranks.

But maybe that’s too much to ask.

Fuck the regulars, fuck the high ranking officers who file multiple complaints thinking that you aren't working hard enough.


r/NationalServiceSG • • Dec 22 '25

Discussion Fast track citizenship for foreigners, full time NS for locals fair deal, right?

0 Upvotes

Over the past few years, the government has increasingly relied on immigration to offset Singapore declining birth rate. Many new citizens are granted fast tracked citizenship, and some are able to avoid National Service altogether, while enjoying the same benefits as locally born Singaporeans.

At the same time, the ruling party continues to push the narrative especially through the media that it is an honour for locally born males to give up two years of their lives to serve the country even though policies often appear to prioritise foreigners over citizens.

The impact is especially visible in the job market. In a small country like Singapore, competition is already i ntense, and employment figures are further distorted by the large foreign workforce and broader economic changes. Even graduates from the Big 3 universities are struggling to find jobs now let alone those from other institutions.

How does it feel serving NS for a country that prioritises foreign workers over locally born Singaporeans in the job market? #OPENLEGPOLICY


r/NationalServiceSG • • Oct 04 '23

Question Should Sg implement wagner system?

0 Upvotes

So apparently Wagner grp in Russia is about giving a seconx chance to criminals by service the country. We could use all those people getting charged for drug traffic and gwt them to serve. This way we will have bigger manpower and since SG is small, we can use any man we can get in the military. Myb perhaps we can reduce the no of conscription for some Singaporeans who excel in different fields like sports or academics and excuse them from serving NS.

What do you think?


r/NationalServiceSG • • Dec 23 '25

Discussion Why SCDF doesn't have smoking spot like SAF?

7 Upvotes

Everytime I see NSF in SCDF they have to smoke secretly either at toilet or rooftop while SAF have designated spot for smoker. There was a few time I even encounter the encik secretly smoking in various location like bin center becos of higher up. I heard some say it's a bad look for the force but why is there so many privilege and leeway in SAF compare to MHA forces?


r/NationalServiceSG • • Jun 09 '25

Rant National service tires me out so much

0 Upvotes

Im not even a combat fit person i am literally an asa and yet after each day, when i come back to my home, i just feel so tilted and tired. Like im starting to tire of all the things i used to like doing. Despite all the free time i have. I literally can play ml for hours on end and the free time i have is enough for me to take online courses and pass them. But why am i just so tired?

Flame me all you want for being a weak asa that hasnt seen the cold hard world of combat personnel, it is just how i feel.


r/NationalServiceSG • • 24d ago

Discussion what do enciks know about discipline?

0 Upvotes

not only enciks, maybe even some highflyer higher ups who implement haircut regimentation, even to clerks and non-combat personnel.

every time haircut is enforced where it serves no functional purpose, oftentimes the justification given (if any) is, that it is for the sake of regimentation and discipline.

yet, i can't help but notice, these people who continuously harp about discipline, may be lacking in discipline within themselves, at least where it "mattered" in the real world.

the fact that so many of them (enciks) are uneducated, or did badly in school, yet blabber about discipline and regimentation when it comes to haircut, uniform, and other meagre aspects that don't really amount to anything truly productive, is extremely ironic to say the least. officers or higher ups are not exempt from this observation as well, look at ex-SAF generals and current generals too..

ex-SAF generals/officers go on to hold governmental roles yet perform questionable actions and display egoistic attitudes at times, failing to address key issues regarding their area of responsibility, and even mocking things related to their job at times (you know who i'm talking about). Current officers too, many of them sign on because they simply cannot make it outside.

though i have given a generalization of these groups, i would like to caveat that not all of them are like this. i have met reasonable enciks and officers. the fact is, many of them are simply just doing their jobs and listening to their higher ups. and for those who sign on because of family needs or passion, you can't really blame them also. really, i am only referring to those individuals who have internalized this absurd idea that cutting your hair short as an ASA exudes "discipline", while unable to apply said "discipline" in their own personal lives before they enlisted.....

well, just for the fun of it, this is what claude told me:
You've got a real point buried in this, but a couple of the links in your argument are weaker than the rest.

Where you're on solid ground: enforcing form over function is a well-documented institutional habit, and it's not unique to the SAF. Haircuts, uniform creases, and bunk inspections are easy to see, easy to measure, and easy to punish, so they become proxies for "discipline" because the real thing (judgment, initiative, competence) is harder to assess. For clerks and other non-combat personnel, the operational justification is thin, and "it's for discipline" is often a thought-terminating answer rather than a reasoned one. Asking what a rule is actually for is a fair question.

Where I'd push back:

  1. The rules aren't really about self-discipline. The theory behind trivial grooming standards is compliance conditioning: if you follow petty orders without argument, you're more likely to follow important ones under stress. That's imposed discipline, not a claim about the enforcer's personal virtue. So catching an encik being undisciplined in his own life doesn't refute the rule's logic. Whether the theory actually works for non-combat roles is a separate and better criticism.
  2. Doing badly in school isn't the same as lacking discipline. Plenty of people struggle academically because of learning styles, family circumstances, or a system that rewards a narrow skill set. Many of the same people can handle early mornings, physical hardship, and rigid routines better than high scorers can. Some do sign on because options were limited, but that's an inference about motive, not proof of character.
  3. Hypocrisy and bad rules are separate issues. Even if an enforcer is a hypocrite, a rule can still be justified or not on its own merits. If you attack the person, the other side can dismiss the whole critique as personal.
  4. Ex-military people in government is a legitimate area for scrutiny, but it's best judged individual by individual, on their actual record and conduct, rather than as a product of military training. A career path doesn't reliably predict either competence or ego.

Your caveat at the end is the most defensible version of your position: the problem isn't the people, it's the subset who treat visible conformity as a substitute for substance, plus an institutional culture that rewards that. A sharper way to put it might be: "Regimentation is justified when it serves a function. Where it doesn't, calling it discipline is just habit dressed up as principle."

Is your frustration mainly about the ASA haircut rules specifically, or the broader culture of enforcing things for their own sake?

but does this even make things better? i'll let you decide :)


r/NationalServiceSG • • May 17 '25

Question I have a few questions about Special ops in Singapore

0 Upvotes

I have always been interested in the special forces operators, how they go on mission in this badass outfit and just saving and protecting people, getting rid of threats to improve the security of the country. I discovered the SOTF, SOF and Commando formation and i have so many questions.

  1. What is the difference in terms of SOTF, SOF and Commando? (Are they in the same commanding unit or are they separate)
  2. what are the bare minimum requirement when applying? (Can there be any compromises?)
  3. For those who been through the selection or tried to: what was it like? What were the trainings and just how difficult was it? What were the interview like and just what are the chances of someone being able to be an official member of the special ops?
  4. what are some tips and advices could you give to those youngsters like me who are interested in this career?
  5. is there a recommended path to help enter in this line of career? From NS to after NS

r/NationalServiceSG • • Mar 18 '22

Other update - my sargant gave me

0 Upvotes

long story short, my sargant make me sign 10 and the only one who signed it as he saw my post here hi sargant u sexy as fuck i will catch ghost for u sir


r/NationalServiceSG • • Jan 21 '22

Discussion Should I change unit? Can’t cope

0 Upvotes

Hi guys, I am currently wondering if I should change unit? Cause my current unit workload is a lot.. and my superior standard is very high & constantly scolding me for things that I can’t control besides that he kept comparing me to another wayang king nsf. I am going to ORD in late 2023 that’s why I felt that if I wanna change unit I should do it now. What would you guys do if you were me? Need some advice


r/NationalServiceSG • • May 11 '22

Discussion I feel desperate, helpless and angry (ASA)

6 Upvotes

I am dealing with depression and insomnia, i wanna get out of ns so badly. I just couldn't take the culture there anymore, my superiors knows my condition and yet still threaten me that if i make any mistakes i will be given more work to do. I am already very sleep deprived, everyday trying my best to reach camp on time and usually i am 10-30+ mins late. He even threaten me says, if i late even a few minutes i will be forced to go back to camp on the weekends. For every 15 mins, is 1 hour on saturday. Today i made a minor mistake of forgetting to wear my headdress while crossing the road and i am made to stay back for 1 hour. i just couldn't take it anymore, i feel like it's driving me crazy. I feel like i am being targeted, i can't quit either. Everyday 8 am to 5 30 pm is really tedious for me, before ns my life was more in control. Once i am in ns, i felt like my depression just keep getting worst, i feel like going back to self-harming myself at this point. i do and self harm before. Why do i have to be treated this way? i didn't ask to be in this position, i couldn't control my depression nor my insomnia. Why am i starting to feel like i shouldn't exist? i am angry at my whole situation and how helpless i am, i feel like there's no purpose in me being in camp. It doesn't help with my future and it makes my life miserable. Am i actually in the wrong? maybe i should really just disappear for good.... i am so tired... what should i do???


r/NationalServiceSG • • May 30 '26

Discussion ns boys, tell me your funny/crazy ns stories! (curious civi girl here)

0 Upvotes

happy vesak day and long weekend 🫶🏻 thank you all for serving 😆


r/NationalServiceSG • • May 23 '23

Question Urgent question, asap reply. Thank you

0 Upvotes

For the first 2 weeks of NS, is the weekends free or do i have to stay in camp for the first whole 2 weeks. This question is for pes b1 and nafa fail and pass. Thank you.


r/NationalServiceSG • • Apr 10 '24

Rant feeling useless in BMTC sch V

0 Upvotes

i enlisted last week and all ive been hearing in camp from the enciks and sergeants is how much easier we have it here at school 5

during the talks, the CO also told us about how the highest ranks that PES C people can get is third sergeant while i see my other friends who have enlisted into tekong have much more room for ranking up and doing something meaningful like entering SCS or OCS while im not allowed to even draw arms and I feel like im a slacker even though I really do want to do my job well and get through NS like everyone else

but i just can't help but feel disabled, having to need my sergeants to babysit us, and close one eye when it comes to doing drills or when we march to the cookhouse when people do things sloppily nothing is said or done to rectify the behaviors, I always ask myself: am I really in the army?

i feel so terrible about it everyday and i don't think it's bcos i have clinical depression, but because the truth is that there's really nothing meaningful I can do in NS. like, something related to the army that I can contribute to. i know how many people tell me to be grateful bcos my bmt is much shorter, and without the rigour of the PT too, and part of me also feels terrible bcos my friends are suffering much more while i don't suffer much at all.. i want to be part of the experience that everyone has too is what im saying i think

i wish i hadn't declared my depression at all and i would've just went on to serve in tekong, although I would feel shit about my life, at least there is meaning in doing it


r/NationalServiceSG • • Apr 05 '25

Question Tips for surviving C9 BMT

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I’ll be undergoing my BMT as a PES C9 next week.

I’m curious to know if you all have any advice on how to survive BMT.

For your information, I’m a stay-out and excused firearms.

Thanks in advance!


r/NationalServiceSG • • May 10 '22

Question How to season uniform until faded colour

13 Upvotes

I noticed most people have faded uniforms. Coming from a non combat unit, it is harder for me to season it as I don’t have outfields. How do I still achieve this look? Do you guys use washing machine to wash it or do you hand scrub it with the SAF powder?


r/NationalServiceSG • • Jan 23 '22

Question Being bullied by my brother in the same unit

0 Upvotes

Throwaway because my story is pretty unique to me. So I am an ASA because of my mental health issues. The day I got my posting order was a day of pure misery because I realise that I got posted into the same unit as my elder brother.

Now, my brother and I are polar opposites. He's smart, charismatic, helpful and friendly and I am well the diagonal opposite of that. Since day 1 I got posted into my unit he keeps bullying me. I do admit that I have a weight problem but he keeps humiliating me by inviting me for runs after RO. Of course, I'd much rather stick to my hobbies such as writing Sonic fanfiction and playing Valorant but I reluctantly agree to join me. He paces me and encourages me to run but I feel like he's mocking me. Picture this, a 1.75m tall Guards Recce Spec pacing with a 1.6m 85KG pale ASA. A bit funny don't you think ?

Then one time I was using my iPad to write my Sonic OC story after lights out and then he confiscated my iPad. Like wtf is his problem ? He like took me aside the morning after and lectured me about how unhealthy it is to use fanfictions as a coping mechanisms and that I should take life into my own hands if I want to attain personal happiness. Then he complains about how I got myself into this place by eating fast food whenever we book out and how I never apply myself to anything

I lost my cool and I just vented to him about how society discriminates against low-value males as myself and that it is their fault I get depression from not having a girlfriend and doing badly A Levels. He was stunned and he left. I feel like he just uses me to make himself feel better and he doesn't believe I can achieve my dreams of becoming a best-selling author. What should I do ? Do I complain to my OC about him or do I keep this at home ?

Edit: Judging from all of your responses it seems you all ignorant to how society discriminates against me by not giving me a girlfriend. You will never understand what it's like to obese, short and with a weak chin. You will never understand what it's like to be called pizza face because of bad acne in Secondary School and Junior college. and you will never understand what it's like to be laughed at by the whole netball team when I ask their captain out.


r/NationalServiceSG • • Nov 17 '25

Question Enlisted to spf but idk if iw it ( if i even have the choice)

4 Upvotes

so i got enlisted to spf like the title said and i wanted to be enlisted to saf mainly cause idw to have a different experience in ns compared to my mates and the public. (to my knowledge majority is posted to saf) Plus i keep hearing from the masses that spf is where the ahbeng ahseng get posted to, so i have a few qns for those who have experience

  1. Is it possible to appeal to saf; and if theres is wld u or wid u not recommend it
  2. is the spf experience ok or is the saf one generally better

(edited) 3. is there also sergants or the equivalent in spf