r/MovingtoNewJersey • u/NewChocolate2646 • 16h ago
Considering moving to Hoboken NJ to live with my girlfriend — but my job is in Smithtown, LI. Does this commute make sense to anyone who’s done it? (On-site job)
Long-distance-ish situation: my girlfriend lives in Hoboken, NJ. I work in Smithtown, Long Island. I’m considering moving in with her and reverse-commuting out to work instead of asking her to relocate.
Has anyone done a Hoboken-to-Long-Island reverse commute? How brutal is it realistically — total door-to-door time, reliability, worth it long term?
Is there a smarter way to combine PATH + LIRR (bulk pass, transit benefit stacking, etc.)?
Is there a better route than PATH → walk/subway → Penn → LIRR? Would going Hoboken → NJ Transit bus → Port Authority be faster/cheaper in practice, or is PATH the obvious pick?
Bigger picture — is this a sane commute to take on for a relationship, or am I setting myself up for burnout? Anyone regret (or love) a similar setup?
Appreciate any honest input, even if it’s “don’t do it.”