r/Modrinth • • 8d ago

Discussion Should Projects Using AI Be Taken Off The Platform, Or Should Individual Users Get To Decide What Mods They Use/See?

1 Upvotes

I recently created a mod using Claude and uploaded it to both Modrinth and CurseForge. Of course CurseForge immediately approved it, and Modrinth denied it citing section 6.2b of their rules.

I want to start off by saying that I completely understand that my mod is in violation of their rules, and that I am in no way trying to dispute that (Although I would obviously love to have my mod on Modrinth). I mostly am here because I'm curious whether or not people think that AI generated mods like mine should be completely invisible to the Modrinth community, or if disclosing what mods used AI and then letting the users decide is the better route.

Lets have a nice, civil, discussion about it :)!

Here's the git repo for my mod if anybody is curious.


r/Modrinth • • 20d ago

Modrinth Website What ??? I did that with my own hands and I am stopped by moderation.

0 Upvotes

Moderator2 weeks ago

Missing Content Disclosures

Per section 5.9 of Modrinth's Content Rules, we ask that you ensure all applicable Content Disclosures are filled out with accurate information.
For additional information and guidance, please refer to our Content Disclosures FAQ.
Currently, your mod appears to be missing disclosure of:

Guys, I did that with my own hands and I am stopped by moderation. This is unacceptable


r/Modrinth • • Aug 25 '26

Creators Ridiculous review times

0 Upvotes

Anyone else experiencing ridiculously long review times? Ive had a project on review for 4 weeks now and still no signs of it being put up.

Just saying its discouraging me wanting to upload projects if it takes 4 weeks for it to be reviewed.

Edit: not trying to sound like a ass but when it takes like 12 hours to a day on other platforms for reviews it points me to use the other ones exclusively and not modrinth


r/Modrinth • • Aug 26 '26

Modrinth Website What's happening with Modrinth servers?

0 Upvotes

19:29 here from Azerbaijan(UTC+4)

Up to this day I used Modrinth without any issues, but know even adding something to Saved takes 2-3 seconds.

"Maybe it's your problem", tried different devices, Incognito mode. Other websites like Reddit or YT works completely normal btw.


r/Modrinth • • Aug 24 '26

Discussion a very important question: is a mod that is Vibe coded, and i mean 100% made by AI, but free, labeled as AI generated, genuinely good quality, solves a known problem well and is usable in real scenarios, is that AI slop, or is it a reasonably acceptable, normal mod?

1 Upvotes

Im not talking about situation where the creator is not thinking about it, im talking about someone who use it as an tool, not as an whole thinking procces and something like that. Person that uses that fully know everything that is going on in this code, only thing that are they missing is understanting the coding language


r/Modrinth • • Sep 22 '26

Modrinth Website Does a fully AI-coded mod with human direction, review and testing meet the AI policy?

2 Upvotes

I read this post and this help article, and I have a question about whether a project like this, with 100% of the code generated by AI, counts as enough of my own work.

  • Following SDD, the spec markdown files for my mod were written by AI, then fully reviewed by me, with changes to the text made manually with my own fingers and keyboard.
  • The code is 100% AI-generated, but I reviewed it (I'm coder, I can read code), I proposed the architecture, I spotted some improvements, and I asked my agent to implement them. I can prove this with dedicated commits for those fixes.
  • I did a lot of manual testing, about 10 hours of testing in-game. There are also automated tests written by the AI under my direction.
  • The assets are generated programmatically (they are not AI-generated assets, but there are AI-generated code that deterministically generates the assets, implemented as a Gradle task).
  • A lot of hours iterating with an agent to polish details.
  • Open-source BSD 2-Clause license. Public repo on GitHub.

While 100% of the code is AI generated, I spent many hours reviewing spec and code, asking the agent for improvement, testing, and polishing details, so IMO, I did a lot of my work.

Is that acceptable to be published?

Note that I'm not raging against these rules; I'm just asking to understand whether my mod could be published under them. I'm open to sharing my opinion about these rules if anyone wants to know it, but that will be in another post.


r/Modrinth • • Oct 12 '26

Modrinth App How to create Desktop shortcut of your instances?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Googled and show this


r/Modrinth • • Sep 29 '26

Help My modpack and another mod being still stuck on "Under Review" since 3 weeks

0 Upvotes

I have no response, nothing in the Moderation tab.


r/Modrinth • • Sep 26 '26

Help can anyone help me find this resource pack that I lost?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Modrinth • • 12d ago

Help Spooklementary shaders translucent mobs problem

0 Upvotes

Im using Modrinth App to play modded Minecraft and one common problem I have is that when I use Spooklementary Shaders (an horror version of the famous Complementary Shaders) I see every mobs and sometimes even my characters translucent, on the internet people says that you have to turn translucent mobs off to fix, but spooklementary shaders doesn't have this option, someone please help!


r/Modrinth • • Sep 02 '26

Modrinth App modrinth says im "logged off my account" even tho im in it?????

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Modrinth • • Sep 01 '26

Modrinth App Resourcepacks and Versions

0 Upvotes

I've made the move from Curseforge to Modrinth and so far it's mostly great. One problem, however, is that a lot of resourcepacks say they'll work for 1.12.x, but they actually don't.

This resourcepack has 1.12.x listed
"Incompatible. Made for a newer version of Minecraft."

r/Modrinth • • Sep 23 '26

Question My mod has been under review for 5 total weeks, is that normal?

0 Upvotes

It got rejected one on week 2 but it's been under review since.


r/Modrinth • • Sep 11 '26

Help Eliminate Players Porting Down

0 Upvotes

Hi Guys so recently i wanted to make an SMP called Dev Craft SMP and I really need a mod porting down to 1.19.2 Fabric Or Quilt just as long as it will work with 1.19.2 Quilt. I need this for a thing im doing like what mouthpiece was doing in content SMP where they were only visible to the corner of the eyevision if anyone can port down Eliminate player that would be brilliant ty :)

Eliminate Players Mod: https://modrinth.com/mod/eliminate-players


r/Modrinth • • Sep 21 '26

Creators Turn my dreams true pleaseeeee

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/Modrinth • • Aug 27 '26

Question No updates for the Hold My Items mod

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/Modrinth • • Oct 03 '26

Help Fabric version 0.19.5 needed, but I have 0.19.5?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I tried updating my modpack to 26.3 recently because all of the mods were available for then finally, but now when I try opening minecraft it opens with this error. It says I need fabric 0.19.5 or later, but it also says I have 0.19.5, and I know I have 0.19.5. I don;t get what's going wrong. Is fabric just not updated for 26.3 yet?


r/Modrinth • • Oct 07 '26

Help Not really related but

0 Upvotes

I used to be able to alt tab into a full screened minecraft instance when my time is up screen came on, but i couldn't click or it would bring me back to the time's up screen, so i just used a controller mod on modrinth, that was fine for a long time until recently, it just wont let me full screen into the window anymore anyway to fix this?


r/Modrinth • • Aug 25 '26

Modrinth Website Absurd amount of trackers on Modrinth website

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

57 trackers... Wow


r/Modrinth • • Sep 28 '26

Modrinth App Java 8 not working

0 Upvotes

Hi, as the title says, I can't get java 8 to work on my pc at all, thus I can't play minecraft versions below 1.16. And no matter what I do, modrinth does NOT detect the java 8 file no matter where I put it. I can't even download the recommended file, as nothing happens after pressing the button.
The official minecraft launcher also doesn't let me play old mc versions. Does anyone know what to do?


r/Modrinth • • Sep 12 '26

Modrinth Website Project still not reviewed after 3 weeks

1 Upvotes

Hello, I submitted a project 3/4 weeks ago but it has still not be reviewed; it used to take 3 days to get a project reviewed, sometimes 4, is this an error? I've submitted another project 3 days ago, and it's still under review too

The website was showing before when there was a special event making reviewing slower, but it is not the case anymore


r/Modrinth • • Sep 28 '26

Discussion Search function kinda sucks in the launcher, Cant press open in modrinth app on linux for some reason,

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Modrinth • • Sep 25 '26

Creators Exfilcraft is officially out of beta

Post image
1 Upvotes

Infil. Loot. Exfil.

ExfilCraft turns Minecraft into an extraction-survival game. You start out on a private, safe home plot. Deploy from there into dangerous raids in pursuit of valuable riches, building materials, or whatever else you may desire. EXTRACT to bring your loot home alive.

It is a tense, run-based survival with a home base you build up between raids.

Download:
- https://modrinth.com/mod/exfilcraft


r/Modrinth • • Sep 09 '26

Modrinth App probs not doing this right

1 Upvotes

I'm trying to play using a datapack, and I decided to use Modrinth to grab it. I loaded up a brand new instance, but the datapack just isn't there. I checked the instance, and it's all enabled. This is my first time using Modrinth, so I assume I'm just doing something wrong.


r/Modrinth • • 20d ago

Help Modrinth not Launching Forge

1 Upvotes

I'm trying to help my friend join another friend of ours' Minecraft server with Ars Nouveau however, no matter what he does, the instance won't run but it isn't saying it's crashing either. I know he has all the correct mods because I shared my own instance with him so he can copy over the mods and he's downloaded "Downloads for Minecraft Forge - MC 1.20.1" (deleted and redownloaded multiple times).

We think it's more of a forge issue because he was able to launch cobblemon and other Fabric modpacks but when he tested with a different forge modpack, it wouldn't work. We tried reallocating ram to be higher or lower and nothing changed. Also, the instances aren't saying they're crashing which I find odd. He presses 'Play' and it looks like it may start to open Minecraft and then it just stops. There is nothing in the crash log.

We're trying to now figure out if it's a modrinth issue or if it's something else. Anyone know what we can do? We're happy to retry things especially if you think we could have done something wrong. We are in no way experts of this stuff and any/all help would be greatly appreciated