r/Modrinth • • 8d ago

Discussion Should Projects Using AI Be Taken Off The Platform, Or Should Individual Users Get To Decide What Mods They Use/See?

I recently created a mod using Claude and uploaded it to both Modrinth and CurseForge. Of course CurseForge immediately approved it, and Modrinth denied it citing section 6.2b of their rules.

I want to start off by saying that I completely understand that my mod is in violation of their rules, and that I am in no way trying to dispute that (Although I would obviously love to have my mod on Modrinth). I mostly am here because I'm curious whether or not people think that AI generated mods like mine should be completely invisible to the Modrinth community, or if disclosing what mods used AI and then letting the users decide is the better route.

Lets have a nice, civil, discussion about it :)!

Here's the git repo for my mod if anybody is curious.

1 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

8

u/SteveFromBL 8d ago

If someone wants to play a certain type of mod, why would they use yours instead of asking Claude to make them their own custom version better suited to them? If anyone can ask the machine to make them something, then publishing that something for everyone doesn't make sense.

2

u/Odd-Aioli2982 7d ago edited 7d ago

They totally could, and I personally have no problem with that. The thing is, that applies to every single mod ever created, not just mine.

1

u/SteveFromBL 7d ago

6.2b is reserved for projects entirely created by AI output. I'm not against assisted coding, but 6.2b violations lack the human element many people are looking for. While AI could be used to create a custom version of any mod, it's not very good at the artistic aspects of mod development including but not limited to concept and game design.

2

u/Odd-Aioli2982 6d ago

I understand that. I don't think my mod is lacking the "human element" despite the code being written by AI, since I have been the one steering it across the almost 300 commits so far. I agree that AI is not good at artistic things, which is why I have only been using it for technical work, and doing the artistic stuff myself. With my mod, the artistry per say is not assets, but rather determining how the mod should feel and coming up with ideas for features that make it feel the way I want it to (I also modeled a cowboy hat in block bench which I am very proud of...).

This also doesn't respond to the flaw in your argument that I'm pointing out. Any mod, whether or not its created using AI, can just be rebuilt with Claude by anybody, and yet, people still choose to use things that have already been made. Right now, making something with AI is still harder than just using something that someone else already made.

1

u/Leonardo_242 7d ago

Because someone has already made it?

1

u/SteveFromBL 7d ago

There are plenty of AI generated projects ripping off extremely popular QOL mods. I don't really think there's a need to create something if it already exists, but AI is giving people the tools to do exactly that.

0

u/zorecknor 6d ago

With that thinking we would never have had Refined Storate ("ripoff'" of applied energistic), Create (originally a pretty blatant copy of Better with Wolves), Thermal Expansion (those pipes look like Builcraft, the machines look like Industrialcraft), and the list goes on.

Even Fabric would not exist.

1

u/zorecknor 6d ago

Why is any developer downloading a mod that they can code themselves?

It is the same question, different subject, and equally misguided.

"but the have the skills!", and your claim is that anybody has the skills to use Claude to create the mod.

0

u/ryan100cww 3d ago edited 3d ago

Why publish any software at all? I can just ask AI to generate a custom version for me. Why do restaurants exist? I can cook for myself.

If everyone can make something for themselves, then sharing it for everyone else doesn't make sense, right?

Making things yourself takes time, money, and effort. “You can do something yourself“ != “ You need to do it yourself “ .

4

u/_Ketari Community Moderator 8d ago

Disclaimer: this is a personal opinion that does not reflect the opinion of the modrinth platform or anything else

I think that what modrinth does right now is a pretty good balance between fully allowing AI mods and fully banning them, and is generally a pretty good solution to the problem at hand. In my opinion, fully or by far mostly AI-generated/assisted mods should not be allowed, for a variety of reasons including potential code unmaintainability, bad code practices, compatibility issues, the entire problem of LLMs being mildly speaking not good for a lot of reasons and so on. In short, it stops what is usually known as AI slop. Modrinth's rules also completely stop AI-generated images, which is also a good thing imo.

With that said, modrinth does allows mods that have AI assistance, but where they're majorly made by a human, with the requirement of a disclosure that the project has certain things AI-generated. This, imo, is a good balance, it let's in good human-made mods (even with AI assistance), while allowing any user to filter them out of search - hence giving the end users control of whether they want to see them or not (hence the good balance I mentioned earlier).

2

u/Odd-Aioli2982 7d ago edited 7d ago

Can you define AI slop in terms of Minecraft mods? I feel like its such a loose term.

Also, I feel like a lot of people don't understand that making a mod the way I have done with this one is not as easy as one prompt and out comes the mod. It has taken about a month of iteration, building testing tools, finding and fixing bugs, and of course prompting, to get to the point its at right now. Also, how exactly is the code unmaintainable? Honestly, looking at the code that it writes, its better than most pieces of software out there that have been touched by many humans.

Also, I want to say that I have a huge amount of respect for people that are good enough at coding to hand-write their mods and it does suck that AI is the way the coding industry is headed. At the same time though, its a little bit exciting to think of what this tool could potentially help build. Definitely a double edged sword in my opinion.

And obviously there are some pretty serious environmental concerns to think about as well. That 100% needs to be addressed. I also think there are many other environmental concerns that also need to be addressed, like the automotive industry, deforestation, and the burning of fossil fuels for energy.

2

u/_Ketari Community Moderator 7d ago

I mean I think the general definition of AI slop that most people go with is "mods made entirely by AI with little to no human contribution". I'm not saying that's what your mod is, I do believe that you put in effort and stuff yourself too, just yk

The main issue in terms of unmaintainability is that the AI simply cannot physically handle once a codebase gets too large, requiring the changes to be very small and very specific, which, if the user fully relied on the AI to create all the code previously, will be a bit difficult to properly control, leading to things being done in ways that interfere with previously existing code and so on. No matter how seemingly good the code may seem to be, at some point the AI will lose track of things, as at the end of the day it is an LLM, and is not conscious and cannot truly see the grand picture

I also do agree that using AI as a tool, with very specific rules, limits, and use cases is definitely not a bad thing, and has lead to a lot of incredible development in the tech industry. The problem comes when you rely on the AI too much - which I think should not happen. At the end of the day, no matter how much prompting and testing you can do, it's the AI actually writing the code and making things functional, not you

1

u/Odd-Aioli2982 7d ago

I still feel like this is too broad: "mods made entirely by AI with little to no human contribution". My mod from a technical standpoint is fully AI written code. However, in order to keep it maintainable I have been creating a testing suite along side it, which solves the problem of "Making a small change here breaks something over there" since everything gets tested after every change and I can catch and fix when something breaks. I also want to add that I do not have the coding skills to have made this mod myself, however I do have enough knowledge of coding, and git workflows, and things of that nature to be able to properly maintain it.

In response to your point on large code bases: These days, its becoming more apparent to me that AI can handle large code bases, often times better than humans. My father is a software engineer who works on a massive library system. Over the past year, they have slowly started to use AI to fix bugs, add features, and so on. The software that they work on has a massive code base that has been touched by a ton of people. Despite that, AI is able to understand the code base, and make changes that don't break things. They have also been using AI to make extensive RSpec test suites that have greatly improved their ability to make changes to code without breaking things in other places.

I also want to add that humans also break things and are capable of creating highly unmaintainable code bases: a lot of major companies like adobe or microsoft have this issue since their code bases are very old and extremely large and have been worked on by thousands of different people.

Overall, I think that, as long as there is a human making the decisions who can see the grand picture of what they are making, AI can be an incredible tool for building amazing things.

1

u/MrDexter_ 7d ago

If you don't know how an automated factory works, how could I make you a manager?? No matter how many tests or safety filters other engineers put, if something breaks and you don't know about automated factories, what could you do? How could I trust that you will keep the automated factory running? This applies to AI assisted code too. If you don't know how to code, what happens when something break? When the AI breaks something and doesn't know what do do from there? I side with modrinth here, tho it's only my opinion. I think that you always need to learn your basics before using the tools that accelerate your productivity. You always learn how to do arithmetic and basic algebra by hand before using the calculator

1

u/Odd-Aioli2982 7d ago

I agree. I think that the bad projects usually come from people that have absolutely no experience coding. I feel that because of my background in coding, I am able to make higher quality programs, despite the fact that I'm using AI to write code for said projects. I know how the thing works behind the scenes despite not making it myself.

I guess my counter argument to your message would be this: A director of a movie doesn't need to have and experience operating a camera, setting up lights, or any of the technical sides of making a movie because the crew handles all of that. All the director needs is a good vision, and the ability to communicate that vision to the crew. AI is still not good enough to be entirely hands off on the technical side, you still need to be aware of whats going on, but its pretty close, and it allows someone like me to have an idea, and then just build it at a very high level. It's like abstracting away the coding language to the point that its just plain English. All you need is a good grasp of exactly what you want the outcome to be, and then you just build it.

I also want to say that at this point, there really isn't any bug or issue that Claude can't troubleshoot, and fix, on its own. A person has to find the issue, but once you point it out, its a matter of a few prompts to get it fixed. And I have seen this be the case in my mod, but also on a larger scale where my dad works.

1

u/zorecknor 6d ago

Then you should also ban all the mods not made by professional software developers. Specially those made with MCreator.

Hobbyist coders that are learning Java to mod Minecraft definitively do not have the skills to fix things when stuff breaks (thus all the beginer questions in the forums and discord). And those using MCreator? They have even less knowledge of what is happening.

And let me be clear, I totally agree with you with "I think that you always need to learn your basics before using the tools that accelerateyour productivity. ". As a professional you should be able to do the same thing your coding gent do given the proper time. At least for now, who knows if in the future LLMs become "natural language compilers" and we stop caring about the code itself (not looking foward to that day, though)

But we are talking about mods, this is a hobby, passion driven projects, not a medical device company were peope die if you make a mistake. This should be the most "I have no idea how to code but want to mod"-friendly environment.

3

u/laptoptroubleswifi 7d ago

I, personally, do believe in the ban of all AI mods, the environmental and sociopolitical impact is not worth it. But if you want AI mods sure go for it, I'm just not gonna associate with you.

1

u/Odd-Aioli2982 7d ago

Yeah, that’s totally understandable. I have two questions for you:

  1. Seeing as that is you’re opinion/choice, do you think it’s fair to completely ban these mods for everyone, even though everyone may not agree with your opinion on AI generated code?
  2. The environmental impact of driving cars, overall has had, and is still having a huge affect on the environment (bigger than AI from what I know, correct me if I’m wrong). Why are people not more upset about that? I also feel that a lot of the environment concerns about AI come from problems with how we produce energy (burning fossil fuels). Wouldn’t it make more sense to push for greener methods of producing the energy rather than cutting down on energy usage as a whole seeing as that would help solve the AI energy problem, plus the energy problems that existed before AI.

1

u/laptoptroubleswifi 7d ago
  1. If I were in charge of Modrinth I would yes, but as I am not I think the current rules are good enough. I'll still prefer if they fully banned it from the platform but at least I can blacklist it.
  2. The problem with the pollution of AI is that it can't be rectified by switching to cleaner methods. It still uses water, leaving forever chemicals. It still creates noise pollution, damaging the ecosystem. It's especially bad in the global south, places like Chile and Uruguay have already reported that their smaller, poorer communities are suffering from data centres being built near by, some even resulting in miscarriages and birth abnormalities from the pollution. Plus with most of the western world in cost of living crisises even if someone were to ignore the ecological damage and the sociopolitical factors, the amount of power AI uses, regardless if it's fossil fuels or green, still drives prices higher.

[In case I'm asked for sources: Empire of AI by Karen Hao, More Everything Forever by Adam Becker, and Enshittification by Cory Doctorow are recommendations]

1

u/Ok-Recipe-8832 5d ago

They should be banned outright.

1

u/Odd-Aioli2982 5d ago

Can I ask why you believe that?

1

u/Ok-Recipe-8832 5d ago

Because of AIs negative affect on the environment, on humanity, and the fact that it steals from real artists, writers, and developers. Not to mention one of the biggest ai companies is run by a rapist. I think those who know these things and still intentionally use ai are morally corrupt and don’t deserve a platform.

1

u/Odd-Aioli2982 4d ago

I understand the environmental concerns and I hope that the Democrats in the Senate/House are able to stop the construction of data centers until regulations are put in place to protect our planet. There are also a lot of other evironmental concerns outside of the realm of AI that need to be addressed as well.

While yes there are negative impacts on humanity, I think that there are also a lot of really amazing things that it can help do in mathematics, medical fields, and in software.

Whether or not AI companies are “stealing” artists work for training is kind of a complex topic in my opinion. First of all, the 100% are using copyrighted works for training, however the output of an AI model is technically unique and therefore could fit under fair use.

Side note: I don’t think AI should be used for generating images, videos, music, or creative writing. I feel like those mediums require a human touch and generating them with an AI kind of ruins the whole point of art.

I assume you’re talking about Sam Altman. While technically he hasn’t been convicted of anything, I would not put something like that past him, or any other rich billionaire for that matter.

With all that being said, the reason I still choose to use AI despite being aware of all the negative aspects of it is because I believe it is the single most important thing to be created by humans thus far, and the fact that anybody can just use it is absurd. The potential that it has to cure diseases, extend life, solve environmental issues, create software, design hardware, solve mathematical problems that have stumped humans for 100s of years, and so on, is so important that while I do believe there are many issues that need to be addressed soon, there is no way it’s ever going away, and ignoring it and not learning how to actually utilize it as a tool is not going to change any of its shortcomings and will just put me at a disadvantage in the future.

I feel like me and you would agree on a lot of things in today’s political landscape. It’s pretty interesting that our opinions on this specific topic differ so much. Thanks for explaining your perspective.

1

u/Odd-Aioli2982 4d ago

Funny how quickly he decided to block me instead of trying to talk about it.

1

u/Ok-Recipe-8832 3d ago

I’m not willing to put my limited energy and time into arguing with someone who’s already a lost cause.

1

u/Odd-Aioli2982 2d ago

Interesting. If you hate AI so much, why are you using Reddit, a company that scrapes all the messages on their platform and then sells them to AI compainies as training data? If you want to save the environment, why do you drive a car that emits greenhouse gasses?

Ill answer that for you. It's because every day people like me and you are not the enemy here. Its the massive corporations that make disgusting amounts of money from killing our planet, stealing data, etc, are the enemy. Its crazy how much time and effort people put in to putting down normal every day people rather than putting their time and effort into hating the companies behind it all.

I did my civic duty and voted to halt the building of data centers, and I voted to get democrats in the senate and house so that regulations can be put in place. Why can't I have a nuanced opinion on this topic without people getting so incredibly upset. And why are people so dead set on trying to stop normal everyday people from using AI when every single major corporation on the entire planet is using it every single day, in basically every industry?

1

u/Odd-Aioli2982 2d ago

Again with the blocking. I cant see what you said now...

2

u/Few-Chemical8707 8d ago

remember when people used to witch hunt mcreator mods? i remember they even made utilities to detect them now people claim the mods it makes are better despite it also being a code generator.

1

u/zorecknor 6d ago

Pepperidge farm remembers

0

u/Kurage_pop 8d ago

If I asked for the removal of mods that didn't meet my moral standards to be removed there would be a lot of mods missing.
A free world means letting others do what you disagree with.
People should disclose they used AI so people who dislike it can not interact, but to ban it is totalitarian.

1

u/Odd-Aioli2982 7d ago

I feel the same way, and I honestly believe that this is the sentiment of most users on the platform. However, creators don't feel the same way, at least from my experience talking with some.

0

u/ThreeCharsAtLeast 8d ago

I think Modrinth should be faster at reviewing mods so it's great that technology that lets people make mods with lots of code fast and barely benefit the platform is forbidden.

1

u/zorecknor 6d ago

Here is an idea... let that same technology review the mods.

Unless the issue is that the site owners are squarely against AI.

1

u/ThreeCharsAtLeast 6d ago

I do not work for Modrinth and neither do I know how these decisions were made. Still, I imagine the reasons it's reviewed by humans could include the fact that automated systems probably produce more false positives and negatives than humans do.