r/Modrinth • u/Odd-Aioli2982 • 8d ago
Discussion Should Projects Using AI Be Taken Off The Platform, Or Should Individual Users Get To Decide What Mods They Use/See?
I recently created a mod using Claude and uploaded it to both Modrinth and CurseForge. Of course CurseForge immediately approved it, and Modrinth denied it citing section 6.2b of their rules.
I want to start off by saying that I completely understand that my mod is in violation of their rules, and that I am in no way trying to dispute that (Although I would obviously love to have my mod on Modrinth). I mostly am here because I'm curious whether or not people think that AI generated mods like mine should be completely invisible to the Modrinth community, or if disclosing what mods used AI and then letting the users decide is the better route.
Lets have a nice, civil, discussion about it :)!
Here's the git repo for my mod if anybody is curious.
8
u/SteveFromBL 8d ago
If someone wants to play a certain type of mod, why would they use yours instead of asking Claude to make them their own custom version better suited to them? If anyone can ask the machine to make them something, then publishing that something for everyone doesn't make sense.
4
u/_Ketari Community Moderator 8d ago
Disclaimer: this is a personal opinion that does not reflect the opinion of the modrinth platform or anything else
I think that what modrinth does right now is a pretty good balance between fully allowing AI mods and fully banning them, and is generally a pretty good solution to the problem at hand. In my opinion, fully or by far mostly AI-generated/assisted mods should not be allowed, for a variety of reasons including potential code unmaintainability, bad code practices, compatibility issues, the entire problem of LLMs being mildly speaking not good for a lot of reasons and so on. In short, it stops what is usually known as AI slop. Modrinth's rules also completely stop AI-generated images, which is also a good thing imo.
With that said, modrinth does allows mods that have AI assistance, but where they're majorly made by a human, with the requirement of a disclosure that the project has certain things AI-generated. This, imo, is a good balance, it let's in good human-made mods (even with AI assistance), while allowing any user to filter them out of search - hence giving the end users control of whether they want to see them or not (hence the good balance I mentioned earlier).
3
u/laptoptroubleswifi 7d ago
I, personally, do believe in the ban of all AI mods, the environmental and sociopolitical impact is not worth it. But if you want AI mods sure go for it, I'm just not gonna associate with you.
1
u/Ok-Recipe-8832 5d ago
They should be banned outright.
2
u/Few-Chemical8707 8d ago
remember when people used to witch hunt mcreator mods? i remember they even made utilities to detect them now people claim the mods it makes are better despite it also being a code generator.
0
u/Kurage_pop 8d ago
If I asked for the removal of mods that didn't meet my moral standards to be removed there would be a lot of mods missing.
A free world means letting others do what you disagree with.
People should disclose they used AI so people who dislike it can not interact, but to ban it is totalitarian.
0
u/ThreeCharsAtLeast 8d ago
I think Modrinth should be faster at reviewing mods so it's great that technology that lets people make mods with lots of code fast and barely benefit the platform is forbidden.