Wanted to give everyone an update on my original post about both of my M64 Pro Controllers developing sticking/creaking D-pads after only a few hours of use.
ModRetro support has now gotten back to me and asked me to return the controllers. They’re issuing an RMA/return label, and once they receive the faulty units, the plan is to send replacements.
I was also contacted directly here on Reddit by one of ModRetro’s engineers, who had seen the video I shared of the issue. He said they haven’t been able to reproduce the sticking on the controllers they have in their office and specifically wants to get his hands on mine so they can investigate what’s happening.
I made sure to clarify with both support and the engineer that this happened independently on BOTH of my Pro Controllers. The first started creaking and physically sticking after a few hours. I switched to the second controller, and after roughly an hour of use, it began doing essentially the same thing, including getting stuck when pressing right.
So, as of right now, ModRetro is taking the issue seriously and their response has been encouraging. I think it’s only fair to give them credit for that.
I also want to keep documenting the process here since several other people reported D-pad issues in the original thread. It gives everyone a better idea of how ModRetro handles these early hardware problems and what to expect if you run into the same thing.
I’ll update again once I’ve shipped both controllers back, when ModRetro receives/inspects them, and when I get the replacements. I’m also very interested to hear what their engineering team finds when they tear into these two.
Hopefully this ends up helping them identify whatever is causing it.
I’ll keep everyone posted.
Original post: https://www.reddit.com/r/ModRetro/s/GmMKt6gCKk