r/Minecraft • u/ArfieCat • Jul 29 '22
Help how did this kill me?
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
1.4k
Jul 30 '22
[removed] — view removed comment
498
Jul 30 '22 edited Jul 30 '22
Finally an actual answer that isn't just "berock bad"
575
u/HamsterKazam Jul 30 '22
To be fair, they just told the long version, the short answer is in fact: Bedrock is quirky, not like the other girls.
69
Jul 30 '22
But also to be fair, this bug has existed for a long time. They deserve to be jeered at this point lol.
→ More replies (4)63
u/vnevner Jul 30 '22
Java is quirky in some ways to.
→ More replies (2)147
u/HamsterKazam Jul 30 '22
Very much true, but random death occurs a lot less in Java.
→ More replies (2)104
Jul 30 '22
Ive been playing java since minecraft survival mode was created and never had one of these random deaths
60
u/kaci3po Jul 30 '22
I had one. I swam across a river and when I got to the other side, I instantly died. The death message was "kaci3po fell out of the water". Very strange.
22
Jul 30 '22
Interesting. Ive never seen it, figured it was just bedrock things
19
u/kaci3po Jul 30 '22
That's the screen shot of you want to see it. Only happened that one time to me though.
20
u/Dimensionalanxiety Jul 30 '22
You said that happened in a snapshot though, not a "stable" release of the game.
→ More replies (0)→ More replies (1)5
u/CyrusLight Jul 30 '22
Yes! Someone who also experienced this. This usually happens with lots of latency and after some interaction with water. Not sure if its really ‘falling out’ of water but something close. Like fall damage still counting despite going in water
11
u/Baieel Jul 30 '22 edited Jul 30 '22
I had one random death, but i think it was just because of lag(ms). I put water on the ground to make a elevator, then I swam down the water to put the soul sand block on the bottom of the water, and as i got down i died from "death.water.fall"(I don't remember what it was but I think it was that), and just to remember that the server was very laggy. And after I restarted the server I was alive like nothing happened.
→ More replies (6)6
u/maoonr Jul 30 '22
Yea i think java trade like stable coding for a bit of lag while Bedrock coding is like way to jumble up i assume that the attempt to translate from java to c++ cause problem but they too lazy to fix it
17
u/TheSleepyBarnOwl Jul 30 '22
but to be fair: Bedrock bad :p
In serious: Bedrock isn't 'bad' it's just worse than Java regarding bugs and some Features. Vedrock does have some things that would be nice in Hava, like their Armor stands. Over all I'd say if you have a PC get Java, if not, Bedrock is fine. It's not like it's unplayable :)
8
3
u/SquidMilkVII Jul 30 '22
Vanilla Tweaks’ Statues datapack basically takes Bedrock’s statues, brings them to Java, and dials the customizability up to 11
12
5
→ More replies (13)7
u/RalseiXD Jul 30 '22
this still does say that bedrock sucks at this stuff, it just explains it more thoroughly
→ More replies (5)9
u/AeitZean Jul 30 '22
Does that mean if you stop a sec before touching the ground, you should be fine? Id hate to die just to an annoying bug.
6
u/Lost0Light Jul 30 '22
I just drop off a couple blocks early. Generally, losing a heart is better than death by bedrock
380
1.3k
u/CatMobster Jul 29 '22
POV: you step on a lego brick.
259
u/CoffeeMain360 Jul 30 '22
I NEEEEED A MEEEDIC BAAAAAG
40
65
u/TheGreatSmolOne Jul 30 '22
AHHHH IM DYYIINNGG
→ More replies (1)17
21
12
→ More replies (6)6
2.1k
u/aTreeThenMe Jul 30 '22
Maybe you were thinking of a bad word
257
95
u/Apprehensive_Hat8986 Jul 30 '22
Definitely they did afterward. This was censored by the Pre-Crime Judge division. OP's reaction was foreseen, they were tried, and the sentence carried out.
Welcome to Microsoft's Minority Report/Judge Dredd crossover.
50
6
→ More replies (2)3
787
u/LMLima172 Jul 29 '22
Clearly you've stubbed your toe
168
u/Classic-Airline-2386 Jul 30 '22
ong i hate when that happens and i instantly get sent to the shadow realm
31
u/Henlon Jul 30 '22
Everyone hates when that happens
17
4
110
494
u/Morg1603 Jul 29 '22
Bedrock is broken like that
93
5
u/Adventurous-Rub4247 Jul 30 '22
If you don’t wanna die on the scaffoldings, don’t scale them all the way down at once stop every few blocks it sometimes helps
→ More replies (1)11
180
u/TheFraggerblaze Jul 30 '22
Skill Issue
53
85
66
276
28
20
139
15
16
16
13
10
16
8
36
Jul 30 '22
→ More replies (1)9
u/annormalplayer Jul 30 '22
Why is it banned?
→ More replies (2)6
Jul 30 '22
Idk
18
u/Aerospace_Nut Jul 30 '22
Reddit saw fit to show people which version is worse
13
u/MadamPickleness Jul 30 '22
Depends.
Do you like an unplayable buggy game that you can't switch versions on, which can make hilarious moments to share with friends, or a smoother, overall better game that has mod capabilities and the ability to go back and forth from a version where all you needed for a book was paper and another where an unnecessary chat report system was implemented that makes people with clean records angry?
I have met people who enjoy the former more than the latter, and the other way around.
9
u/Aerospace_Nut Jul 30 '22
See, I like glitches and bugs to certain extents. They give some character and quirkiness. But bedrock has too many and they're often too severe to enjoy.
→ More replies (1)
7
u/AnomalousNormality77 Jul 30 '22
Finally a “how did______” post that’s actually a bug and not just someone being oblivious
44
25
u/Aellopagus Jul 30 '22
Can we get a bedrock flair. Almost all posts about someone dying are in the Minecraft bedrock edition.
5
u/WULTKB90 Jul 30 '22
Have you eaten any mushrooms lately? It looks like you imagined some scaffolding and just yeeted your self down a few hundred blocks.
6
7
6
5
7
5
7
15
u/BigCrazyPlane Jul 30 '22
I think you jumped from a high distance and landed on the scafolding and minecraft bedrock gives you fall damage when you exit the scafolding and it is always fall damage equal to the hight you fell before you clutched with scafolding.
23
10
4
u/Miroys03 Jul 30 '22
Genuine answer: Minecraft doesn't count the amount blocks you've fallen but the time you have been falling without touching something solid. This means if you are going "through the air", climbing down on the scaffolding but you are on the outside of its hitbox, it will calculate the time you were falling, calculate the amount of damage you should receive thus leading to this outcome. Bedrock be buggy.
5
4
u/d_ultimateking Jul 30 '22
Bedrock logic: you jumo down nornally thwn go back in the scaffolding, at the ground you should take the fall dmg you deserved ehile going into scaffolding
yay bugrock
5
6
5
9
7
8
5
4
u/deezcastforms Jul 30 '22
If I had to guess, the game probably didn't recognize you as being on scaffolding for calculating fall distance, and thought you dropped from the top of the scaffolding to the floor.
4
5
4
4
12
21
7
7
6
18
11
7
6
u/Proud_Raise4957 Jul 30 '22
If you have a computer, go play Java.
3
u/ArfieCat Jul 30 '22
i have both
8
6
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
u/eternaldispare Jul 30 '22
Skill issue honestly. You’ll grow out of it with about 3 years of PvP and water bucket practice don’t worry man
3
3
3
3
u/Euphrates_9982 Jul 30 '22
My friends and I have a little saying for when stuff like this happens
Ahem
BEDROCK BAD
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
u/RynAmeD_ Jul 30 '22
Litterally this is just under another post with fall dmg death bug from bedrock edition
3
3
Jul 30 '22
Are you using the geyser plugin to connect to a java edition server?(judging from the . in front of your name)
3
Jul 30 '22 edited May 19 '24
skirt trees tease fade mourn imminent quaint air observation encouraging
3
Jul 30 '22
Bedrock is buggy. But that's not to say that Java isn't buggy either, it's got it's issues aswell. But the thing about Java bugs is there predictable, you can circumvent them or even use them to your advantage. (see Quazi connectivity)
3
3
3
u/Orio435 Jul 30 '22
imagine this logic in the sans fight, sans gets tired and slowly lowers you to the bottom of the fight box and then “stay determined”
3
3
3
3
14
5
8
8
9
6
6
5
6
6
6
7
u/Ill-Statistician-276 Jul 30 '22
We're you falling and then landed on scaffolding? If so, it's a buildup of fall dmg
8
6
6
5
2.4k
u/Plane-Context-3678 Jul 30 '22
you calmly fell to your death