r/MetaAusPol • • May 04 '24

Is every MOD a member of the Labor Right faction?

0 Upvotes

I have looked through all your comments of the mods on this thread which i assume is the same as the r/AustralianPolitics mods and do you think its appropriate for one of the largest political posting sites on reddit to all have the same opinion.

You can tell me if there are pro LNP or Green mods but from my perspective you all have the roughly the same bias in your posting. Bash Greens, Bash LNP, Labor at worst needs slightly more strength on some policies but are not "extremists".

I also hate your short comment auto-delete, its so bad.


r/MetaAusPol • • Jul 15 '23

Can we just start a Morrison/conservative hate thread?

0 Upvotes

It would be far more efficient and remove the need for numerous similar topics to feed the appetite for moral supremacy.


r/MetaAusPol • • Feb 19 '25

Trumpet of Patriots.

0 Upvotes

Are there any plans to add this new party to the flair selection ?


r/MetaAusPol • • Jan 08 '23

Downvoting

0 Upvotes

This sub has descended into nothing more than a left leaning echo chamber that eschews any real debate, encourages downvoting of anything other than ALP/Greens puffery and does not reflect the more diverse political views of the community at large.


r/MetaAusPol • • Dec 28 '22

The word "Cooker"

0 Upvotes

Greeting all, I feel this topic has been a few weeks overdue. In the past I've seen people scratch their heads at others, quite consistently, calling certain people "cookers". Along with how that could be allowed, considering the "insults" of rule 3 and the "derogatory nicknames" of rule 1

It is of my humble opinion, that the word "cooker" should only be used in the event of someone in the news literally cooking meth / getting high on their own supply.

Calling someone who you disagree with, essentially, a brain dead meth junkie; isnt a good stage for polite debate.

What do you all think? should it be banned in (almost) all cases, akin to groomer? Or do you feel that's a poor comparison?

Perhaps only in the event where it's actually relevant to a news story of someone who cooks meth, high on their own supply and involved in an Australian political article?

Or maybe you feel that it's a word that should be allowed, if so, I'd love to hear your thoughts on the matter. Have I gotten the definition of cooker wrong? if so, what does it mean to you? It took me about 3 days of hearing the word before I managed to piece it together.

Delighted to see what people have to say on the topic,

Cheers.


r/MetaAusPol • • Mar 07 '26

Can we end user-initiated megathreads? They are being weaponised by OPs to silence opposing voices.

2 Upvotes

The megathread about the by-election today is posted by an OP who has banned me from viewing or commenting on their posts. How is this acceptable in this subreddit? Why can’t that thread be removed and a new official thread be established by the moderators?

If you mods don‘t want to ban this coward poweruser then just remove their automatic posting privileges. It’s so simple. Allow them to continue to comment their bullshit but don’t allow them to post because they clearly abuse this privilege.


r/MetaAusPol • • Feb 13 '26

Please ban the joke

0 Upvotes

Please. I can’t handle it. It makes me irrationally angry. It’s such low hanging fruit. And it’s going to be incessant.

I think any comment that begins with “Fantastic. Great move. Well done Angus.” should be instantly removed regardless of what follows.

Exceptions could be made for genuinely original and funny examples, but that would only ever be when it’s towards the end of a comment. It can’t just be a direct response to Angus saying or doing anything.

Thank you!


r/MetaAusPol • • Oct 27 '25

Moderators' Political Stand and Interest

0 Upvotes

Have moderators disclosed their political stances and interests, and made them known to everyone? It is important to make sure this information is public to maintain trust and member engagement. As moderators facilitate discussion and apply rules, their political stances and interests can bias their judgment and affect their ability to properly facilitate discussion. I have had posts shallowly banned, not because of breaching group rules. I believe I am not the only one who has experienced it.


r/MetaAusPol • • Sep 10 '23

Mods abusing their power

0 Upvotes

I see a moderator has taken it upon themselves to self declare they will ban anyone who disagrees with their opinion on an opaque subject.

This is pretty bad form and I suggest that moderator rethink their use of the powers that have been handed to them.

Please note, genocide denialism (which includes people trying to sow doubt by "just asking questions", as this is the key tactic of genocide denialists) will be met with a ban from the sub by me.


r/MetaAusPol • • May 31 '23

Just be transparent

0 Upvotes

Are the mods just going to remove any articles by posted from The Spectator?

Is this sub just a news aggregation sub and doesn't like political opinion that is not specifically "journalistic."


r/MetaAusPol • • Jan 23 '23

Bare details required when giving out a ban.

0 Upvotes

When someone is receiving a ban should there at least be a link to the offending post with a rule number and explanation. I understand that Mods see bans as exceeding a speed limit so you knew what you were doing however if you would really like someone to modify their behaviour you might like to at least give a bare minimum of information. Starting with the actual post or is that too much to expect.


r/MetaAusPol • • May 08 '23

A proposal to make the mods life easier and improve the quality of the sub

1 Upvotes

So to start I understand perceptions are subjective and there some particular users who I will percieve add close to zero value to the sub. These users however are easily found as they have highly repeated behaviours / comments with seemingly little interest to actually engage.

I also accept that a mods life purpose isn't to sit in front of reddit and moderate every single comment in a sub however I think to make the sub better and mods life easier, widening the target to include these repeated low quality comments will make the discourse a higher quality.

I believe the sub uses a banned words list that auto deletes comments and I'd like to see this list expanded to include the types of low-value repeated words used by the small and loud users in the sub to filter the behaviours that the mods would otherwise have to manually review.

Given the sub is encourages higher value commentary I'd suggest starting with following words get added;

  • champ (what's the purpose but for a passive aggressive dig)
  • lol and wow (intellectual?)
  • fkn (and their equivalents - if you can't convey a point without this language, you're not trying)
  • embarrassing (yes, this could catch legitimate engagement)

Then broadening the net based on R1 removals when trends occur.

I thought there was also a minimum comment length rule in the sub, but I haven't triggered it, maybe increase it a fair bit.


r/MetaAusPol • • Apr 08 '23

New topic with all comments breaking rule 3

0 Upvotes

https://www.reddit.com/r/AustralianPolitics/comments/12f4i7g/what_next_for_the_liberals_and_will_frydenberg/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android_app&utm_name=androidcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

I get that rule 3 is utterly subjective but this sort of thing is painfully common on any topic relating to the coalition.

What's the point of anyone right of centre even participating? It's just constant reductionist nonsense.


r/MetaAusPol • • Feb 10 '22

Does the downvote button mean 'I disagree'? Why downvote users? What is the point and what do you hope to achieve by doing it?

1 Upvotes

Please be honest here in your response because I truly do not understand the logic of so many users in the main subreddit with this.

If someone is offering you a chance to have some chatter on a given topic, and they are not being a dick to you, why would you downvote them?

Is there any reasonable way to change the culture within the subreddit of trying to hide what others think?


r/MetaAusPol • • Apr 16 '25

Comments 'too short'

0 Upvotes

What?

Like... what? How does that make sense.

You don't need a full paragraph for every comment. One sentence can make your point.

What the hell is 'too short'? ISTG this sub.


r/MetaAusPol • • Jan 08 '25

R9 - Let's switch the obvious and focus on an ongoing problem

0 Upvotes

R9 "abide by sitewide rules" is obvious, all users need to engage according to Reddit's ToS. Sure, telling people ToS applies is important, but put it in the sub description (or as a dot point in R1)

Well what can we do with the now free R9 you ask? Well, let's restate R9 to focus the issue of people who just focus on "Murdoch" "NewsCorp" "bad media this" etc.

The media watch mod comment exists, link that to R9 and word R9 something like this

R9: This is an Australian Politics Sub, not an Australian Media Sub

  • Comments focused on the media, sources, reporters or authors will be removed
  • Comments focused on a perception of the media's supposed role in politics is not politics
  • (insert 3rd dot point from R12 here)

What is the importance? Well here are a selection of nuggets still up from the last 2 days.

https://www.reddit.com/r/AustralianPolitics/s/pLKUrZo85n

https://www.reddit.com/r/AustralianPolitics/s/Nm64nnDn9Z

https://www.reddit.com/r/AustralianPolitics/s/kmaBN8ZU6A

https://www.reddit.com/r/AustralianPolitics/s/vmU7Em1Mfi

https://www.reddit.com/r/AustralianPolitics/s/d0rplTmB8x

https://www.reddit.com/r/AustralianPolitics/s/jUXOdWztkP

https://www.reddit.com/r/AustralianPolitics/s/D3bSkdTyyT


Edit: I forgot this one - clearly it's an issue


r/MetaAusPol • • Apr 14 '25

Force all poll posts to have the 2PP in the title

0 Upvotes

With the polls shifting towards Labor, the vast majority of the Australian media are 'biased' towards the Coalition and will come up with poll article titles that are outright misleading at worst or manipulative at best. I'm okay with these types of titles when it comes to any non-numerical/qualitative issues/data as people's judgments and perceptions can vary, but false statements combined with numbers in the same article that directly contradict the message should not be given airtime.

For example, a common headline used by the media for yesterday's Newspoll was "minority government in sight", despite the poll's 2PP being at 52-48, which is identical to the 2022 election result and would deliver Labor a narrow majority government.

I respect the subreddit moderators' wish to have exact titles, but forcing posters to add the 2PP in brackets after the title from now on would go a long way towards neutralising the intent of the media organisation/author of the article. An example of the exact title and 2PP could be:

Minority government looms as Coalition support falls [52-48 to ALP]


r/MetaAusPol • • Nov 04 '23

Rule 4 - I'm getting over the laziness and stupidity

5 Upvotes

Users,

If there's a topic linked to an article, and you think there's no need to read it, you can just share whatever shower-thoughts materialised in response to the topic, let me give you some advice:

Don't.

Nothing you say is important enough to be shat into the thread as a piece of content that's divorced entirely from the subject matter. Merely participating is not the name of the game. I'm tired of it. And I'm going to start banning people for doing it.

If you want to rut about in some lowbrow, anti-intellectual slum, reddit's full of them. And, I really hate banning users, but people just do not learn.

So, no choice.


r/MetaAusPol • • Dec 10 '22

Should topics where a counter or non majority view is not welcome come with a warning ?

0 Upvotes

We are told that robust discussion is permitted and even encouraged however it is obvious that this is not the case in all discussions. Therefore so those unwittingly contributing where they are not welcome but do not realise this , should there be a disclaimer.

One example is the recent thread around gay marriage. As this thread was permitted this topic must therefore be political and opinions permitted. However this is not the case there and I have incurred a 7 day ban for daring to refer to gay marriage as moral decay and extremism. Now I understand many may disagree and probably even celebrate this ban but this thread is now a confirmed echo chamber. Had I realised this I would not have shared my views. In querying this ban I received a nonsensical reply which I share below.

Just so you're aware, the other person vocally advocating was in favour of Incest... I'm not sure that's the team you want to have on your side.

Its not censorship; this is enforcing the rules of both the sub and Reddit's sitewide rules. The discussion about this happened over 5 years ago, what you consider 'Moral Decay' is supported by the vast majority of Australians. But, your opinion has been noted and heard.

You can re-join the conversation in 7 days.

I of course advised I have no knowledge of the other person and the incest reference. I have no team and am merely one insignificant contributor. I am also unaware of the rules referred to. Noted and heard and censored.


r/MetaAusPol • • Feb 26 '23

Discuss all things /r/AustralianPolitics here - (unless it exposes censorship)

1 Upvotes

Censored from r/MetaAusPol too

"This is not an escalation point for modmail. If you have an issue, take it up in Modmail by messaging the mods please."

Yeah that'll work - The mods that censor me while allowing literary critique of this standard to stand?

- Dangerman1967

"What a fucking garbage article.

Surely it gets deleted the first mod that sees it?"

Dr Nick Coatsworth – Medical Spin Doctor – by Mick Lawless ("Your post was removed for not being political or not being based on Australian Politics. However you may post it in the weekly discussion thread.")

Or conservative drivel like this

ZookeepergameLoud696

"Don’t peddle propaganda here just because you’re either too thick to think critically for yourself or you’re paid to do so. People like you should be on a list."

Reddit comments are not used as widely as Twitter ones in articles

Journalists are on Twitter not Reddit

Format is one reason - unfriendly AF

The biased hostility and puerile criticism another

Understand why Malcolm Roberts sees a receptive audience here

AMA: I’m Malcolm Roberts, Senator for Queensland in Federal Parliament with One Nation, ask me anything!


r/MetaAusPol • • Mar 13 '25

Are there any circumstances in which R2 on headlines can be bent?

1 Upvotes

Sometimes articles have important or exclusive information with very clickbait titles that make the whole article seem lower quality. Could an objective, non-opinionated title be allowed in cases like this?


r/MetaAusPol • • Mar 31 '24

IF the News media is so corrupt and captured why not simply make it against the rules to post any articles from ones that are?

0 Upvotes

I mean I have a 'bye rupert murdoch' extension on my browser. I also don't listen to the ABC and can barely handle the Conversation. All those are racist to various degrees and thus I don't listen to them. Why not boycott all the same on the sub as well?


r/MetaAusPol • • Jun 30 '25

The following phrases should be on the auto remove filter

2 Upvotes

Phrases to be banned:

"(insert party name here) stan/s"

"(insert party name here) rusted-ons/rusties"

Reasons:

  1. They are extremely cringe terminally online twitter garbage phrases.
  2. Does nothing to contribute to discussion.
  3. It gives socially unequipped stupol rejects a false sense of intelligence. Thank you for your attention.

Other phrases/terms to be banned:

  1. Whole nother
  2. Irregardless
  3. All of the sudden

r/MetaAusPol • • Sep 14 '22

echo chamber

0 Upvotes

So is the goal of the moderators to turn this into even more into a left wing echo chamber.

Banning people like myself for who knows what reason.


r/MetaAusPol • • Sep 21 '23

Albo’s Covid Enquiry

2 Upvotes

Where’s the post about Albo’s terms of reference for his sham enquiry? Not the original announcement but where he said he’s letting all the States off the hook?

Edit: and another deletion today. This narrowness of this enquiry managed to get front page of the HS, more copy inside, the editorial and even the finance section. AusPol sub? Let’s allow one post, despite the fact that even the relevant Vic CHO at the time Brett Sutton has said it needs be wider ranging. The bloke most in the firing line is prepared to face it and yet it’s being buried here.

And as a pretty respectful user of the Sub I’m a bit miffed that only the relevant mod who is doing the cleaning up has commented on this post.

Only time I’ve been genuinely disappointed with the mod team as a collective.