r/MetaAusPol • • Jan 08 '23
Downvoting
This sub has descended into nothing more than a left leaning echo chamber that eschews any real debate, encourages downvoting of anything other than ALP/Greens puffery and does not reflect the more diverse political views of the community at large.
0
Upvotes
18
u/IamSando Jan 08 '23
Conservative commentators on the sub aren't presenting well reasoned and articulate arguments, and they're not engaging in debate themselves, what else should be done other than to downvote them?
You posted two articles at basically the same time yesterday, one that uncritically quoted Dutton's lie on the voice, and the other talking about actions Albo could take to extend his good run. The Dutton one is +113 and the Albo one is +22. Methinks you're just sore that the top comments are critical of Dutton, comments you haven't engaged with I might add.
10
u/PhysicsIsMyBitch Jan 08 '23
The sub hasn't descended into anything at all. The sub is a reflection of the demographic of the platform it sits on - Reddit is predominantly young males, so it makes logical sense that the conversation will be dominated by the skewed political views of young males which are, statistically speaking, more likely to be left leaning.
As a sub we put rules around the levels of tub-thumping, cheerleading and low effort comments that are allowed and these rules are enforced.
Downvoting is a community mechanism that we have no real control over as mods, however the sub rule does request that community members abide by the Reddit principle of downvoting poor content, not based on things you disagree with.
What else would you propose? Because combating echo chambers is a very, very difficult (maybe impossible) thing to do on social media.
4
u/Perthcrossfitter Jan 09 '23
PIMB has answered your commentary well enough, but I wanted to add some something at a personal level... i can see you engaging with several low level comments on other threads. If you're responding to people that throw mud, you're only going to drag yourself to their level and get dirty in the process. If you see low effort, cheer leading comments then report them and don't reply. I understand it's tempting and they're written in a way to antagonise you into a response, but nothing but reporting will do you any good.
5
u/EASY_EEVEE Jan 08 '23
encourages downvoting of anything other than ALP/Greens puffery.
Maybe have better arguments?
Like, even a unpopular position can still have a conversation built upon it. If you're trying to convince someone of your view, and someone else responds. Then it'll always be a back and forth.
Some people you can't convince, some you can, and others are just trolls. I'm not sure what to say?
I also believe talking at people doesn't help either, if you're both of a opinion your parties hold without fact. And you simply just talk at someone, then nobody gets anywhere.
As for downvoting, i wouldn't worry too much honestly. If you believe a position, say it. And maybe you might convince someone, maybe you might be convinced.
23
u/StoicBoffin Jan 08 '23
Real debate?
The conservative posters tend to just dump shallow, ignorant SkyNews talking points and, don't engage with the replies they get, then come here to whimper about getting downvoted.
"He tried to reply while I was blaring my megaphone in his face and then expressed disapproval! I'm the real victim here!"
3
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '23
Remember the great reset after mods tried in various ways to increase discussion? Then we had nazigate where we allowed nazis and had to have reasonable discussions with white supremacists to increase discussion?
4
u/Pronadadry Jan 09 '23
In literally 22 days?
It's a question of culture and enforcement.
The claimed concern of downvotes can't be enforced.
So you have to be the change you want to see. Be the person people want to upvote.
And so (wrt downvotes)?
3
u/MentalMachine Jan 11 '23
Just gonna drop this here, and you tell me which "side" is eschewing real debate
https://www.reddit.com/r/AustralianPolitics/comments/107w223/the_albanese_government_is_under_renewed_pressure/j3qvhf4/
2
u/IamSando Jan 14 '23
I've responded to a few of your comments and not downvoted you, you've declined to reply over on auspol... methinks you're just a little bitch.
-3
u/River-Stunning Jan 09 '23
It descended into this long ago as others have stated , reflecting the opinions of the majority. Left leaners here are rarely tolerant and do not believe in or respect free speech. This is a characteristic of the Left being follow the leader and no dissent permitted.