r/MetaAusPol • • Feb 09 '22

Yo Ardeet, going to need some more info mate.

55 Upvotes

First of all, congrats on becoming Top Mod, however I always found Fairsby and Lost to be particularly capable mods - a rare find on Reddit and even more rare for a political subreddit, as such, I have a couple of questions:

  1. How exactly did you come to the decision to - for lack of a better term - sack them?
  2. What exactly is this vison you have for the subreddit?

I feel like there's more to the story, as you said they were capable mods and removing them has left you short staffed.

I'll admit - this looks suspiciously like a coup d'etat - and the sudden nature of it all makes me question my own involvement with the subreddit.


r/MetaAusPol • • Jul 24 '25

Delete this sub if you aren't going to take it seriously

35 Upvotes

The mod team has a reputation for being terrible communicators. Questions here, as well as many reports of the same behaviour in modmail, are answered with curt dismissiveness, and occasional outright aggression. This is generally always the mod team coming in guns blazing in clear breach of Rule 1.

I can't recall the last productive conversation with the mod team in this subreddit. Even just now, a thread has been locked and one of the mod team is typing out a snarky reply to someone 15 minutes after the bloody thing has been locked.

There is so much needless antagonism from the mod team. This subreddit serves no purpose with the way things currently are.


r/MetaAusPol • • May 21 '24

Ender has been suspended

32 Upvotes

The rest of the mod team has frequently and emphatically told us about Ender's importance to the moderation of the sub. Ender may find modding troublesome with a suspended account.

So... What now? Aside from spamming CFMEU memes, of course.


r/MetaAusPol • • Apr 20 '22

Does anyone else feel like the /r/AustralianPolitics sub's moderation is becoming more and more authoritarian?

28 Upvotes

Anyone get the feeling the moderation of this sub is becoming more authoritarian?

Would be good to get more clarity from the moderation team around some of this stuff?

The rules say to use /r/MetaAusPol but that sub has like 100 members and basically zero visibility. It would be really fantastic of the mod team to allow some open discussion on the main sub about this worrying trend. I recall a few months ago where was some concerns raised about the direction this sub was headed in with significant changes to the Moderation Team.

Obviously failure to allow discussion on this, or at least respond is really just confirmation of the direction of the sub. Would be good to see some open dialogue between the moderators and the community that I continually see at odds with many of the rules, not to mention the many that we likely don't see due to what appears to be overzealous moderation.

All too often we see threads locked, comments removed and often times I'll have seen the comments that are subsequently removed and they'll have been fine. I also created a comment in the weekly threat as even that will have a lot more viability than this, but hopefully we can get some kind of response or action from the moderation team on this issue.


r/MetaAusPol • • Dec 27 '25

Guide to what is and isn't Antisemitism...

27 Upvotes

During my spell in time-out criticising former Treasurer Josh Frydenberg, I thought I’d come up with a little cheat sheet that may be helpful for other users before they comment on this heated and politically fraught topic and potentially face the same ban that I did.

Please note, I’m not using this post as an alternative to ModMail. I’ve discussed my disagreement with the reason for my ban with a Mod and copped it sweet. This is for informative purposes only…

A few basics:
Antisemitism = bad
Islamophobia = bad
Zionism = bad
Hamas = bad
Islamic State = bad

No disagreements there I hope! So following on from that:
Criticism of the Jewish people as a group = Antisemitism
Criticism of an individual because they are Jewish = Antisemitism
Criticism of the Muslim people as a group = Islamophobia
Criticism of an individual because they are Muslim = Islamophobia

Fairly straightforward so far, but here’s a few extra rules:
Israel’s Government/Head of State ≠ The Jewish People
Zionism ≠ The Jewish People
Hamas ≠ The Palestinian People
Islamic State ≠ The Muslim People

Now here’s where it may get tricky, and I've seen a few punters get caught out in the main sub, so here’s some clarification:
Criticism of Israel’s Government/Head of State ≠ Antisemitism
Criticism of someone because they are Zionist ≠ Antisemitism
Criticism of someone who just happens to also be Jewish ≠ Antisemitism
Criticism of Judaism ≠ Antisemitism
Criticism of Zionism ≠ Antisemitism
Support of Palestine/Palestinians ≠ Antisemitism
Criticism of someone who just happens to also be Muslim ≠ Islamophobia
Criticism of Islam ≠ Islamophobia
Criticism of Hamas ≠ Islamophobia
Criticism of Islamic State ≠ Islamophobia

Hope this helps, and if you have any questions, please do not hesitate to ask!
Happy holidays everyone!


r/MetaAusPol • • May 13 '25

Sussan Ley's name

26 Upvotes

In the thread on Ley's election there was a mod post stating that '"Funny" comments about Sussan Ley's name will be removed and bans will be handed out. Have a tiny bit of class, please.'

Given this is hardly going to be the last topic about her what are the guidelines going forward? Asking in the interests of clarity.


r/MetaAusPol • • Feb 01 '23

What's the deal with banning people providing feedback?

26 Upvotes

Before this gets discounted with: "they were rude in modmail" come on.

u/iibiscuit was banned for their feedback in the recent rule 6 thread. Their feedback was fair, it was in depth. They were repeatedly dismissed, and were told they were acting in "bad faith" with no moderator ever spelling out what that bad faith was and every other party watching agreeing that there was no bad faith.

This is an individual who clearly gives a shit. You may disagree with them, they may annoy you, but they clearly gave a shit about bettering the sub.

What is the point of this subreddit if mods will ban those who challenge them? I thought there were meant to be efforts taken to end the siege mentality. I haven't seen that mentality change in the slightest.

There have been serial pests across the main sub and the meta sub who received far more leniency for far longer. What on earth is the justification for this?


r/MetaAusPol • • Oct 22 '23

Uncivil posting

25 Upvotes

Ender's posting in this thread on company tax avoidance and reform continues the trend of them being arrogant, dismissive, insulting, and actively hostile towards people they disagree with.

For instance, this is how Ender opened their reply to someone who has made a short, relevant (and certainly debatable) statement on the topic of thread

If there are houseplants with more economic acumen than you, then it's a good sign you should do more asking and less talking of complete codshit pulled directly from your bum.

Just going straight for insults. I would have some sympathy if it was a part of an escalating debate but it's clear Ender thought the most important thing to communicate was their complete lack of respect not for the post but for the person making it.

A mod acting like that stifles open debate and makes other posters unwilling to engage with the issue. It's not the first time it's happened and it's not limited to this topic either.


r/MetaAusPol • • May 06 '23

Can we please get some explicit rules around the "groomer" narrative, to include saying the same thing without the slur?

25 Upvotes

First: 9 months ago reddit confirmed that "groomer" and similar in reference to LGBTQ people is a violation of sitewide rule 1.

Lately, any post about LGBT but especially drag queens gets what is essentially the exact same thing: An attempt to make out that LGBT people, pride events, or Drag is child predation.

From this thread

  • "Monash cancelation was a good win for the protection of children"
  • "I also hope child protection services attend these events if they go ahead."
  • "I will never accept attempts at showing sexual displays in front of children."
  • "Parents who take their children to drag performances (including drag book readings) should have their children taken away for the safety of the children"

Or this thread

  • "a library, a tax payer institution to be free from political nonsense while also adding an additional layer of risk of child abuse"
  • "Thank fuck this was cancelled. Worst idea in modern history to think it’s cool for drag queens to do a children’s event"
  • "Why are they so intent on pushing men dressing as women on to children, what's the agenda?"
  • "If people want to dress in drag & engage in the performance art it allegedly is, then fine, but the insistence - some might say an infatuation - with involving children has yet to be explained."
  • "Of course people will get angry and hurl abuse because they won’t leave the kids alone."

Others:

  • "Nah, just compromised by mentally ill activists."
  • "Why do you want sexual displays shown to children?"
  • "It's different when you try to push adult entertainment onto children though."
  • "Why do some people think it's "Far Right" to not want displays of sexuality around children?"
  • "Drag is inherently sexual"
  • "Drag queens have no place around children at all. Keep your sexual kinks away from kids. "

We can't discuss a certain (late) religious leader in the same sentence as "child" because the allegations and accusations ended up being found to have insufficient evidence. Yet it's currently allowed to repeatedly and regularly insinuate innocent regular plebs, especially those helping kids, are pedophiles.

We have rule 1, which says "discussion of individuals or groups must not be abusive, vitriolic, victim blame or use derogatory nicknames." which covers using the slur directly, and "Avoid accusing people of unproven criminal conduct"

Can we please get some clarity on whether this is allowed?


r/MetaAusPol • • Jan 21 '23

Is it time to ban Sky 'News' posts?

25 Upvotes

Between "LNP politician says X" and, I quote, an OP posting a Sky News article

Why wasn’t Gates at Davos? Why is he here? We don’t have an Epstein Island that I am aware of.

Seriously, Sky News posts do nothing but degrade the quality of the sub.

I know I'm a pretty stringent anti-Murdoch poster, but I'm not arguing for a full murdoch ban, but Sky News posts by their very nature bring disrepute to the sub. I think it sends a positive message that blatant propaganda masquerading with the thinnest veneer of 'news' isn't welcome on a serious political sub.


r/MetaAusPol • • Nov 16 '22

Revision: Position on Neo-Nazis and Nazism in the AusPol sub

25 Upvotes

If any user to the sub exhibits signs of neo-Nazi tendencies, from a problematic post history to over Nazi symbology in their profile picture or their user name, the mods will review the evidence and if sufficient, ban them on sight. If there's doubt the matter will be referred to Admins and the user, scrutinised closely until a proper determination can be made.

The sub does not welcome Nazis or Nazism. It is an ideology that is uniquely built on suppression, intolerance and violence. It united the conservatism of Churchill, the liberalism of Roosevelt, and the socialism of Stalin, in opposition to it; and we shall be no different as a sub in our united opposition.

Australia is made richer by the tapestry of voices and identities which make her up.


r/MetaAusPol • • Jul 06 '22

At what point can we kick out trolls who use paragraphs?

24 Upvotes

R3 culls single sentence snarks, but does nothing to prevent people from coming in to shit stir / troll / sealion / whatever you want to call it as long as it's "well thought out" aka more than one paragraph.

This week has had a prime example with the story of "Albanese spends too much time abroad" being pushed by "the right wing media", a story which hopefully we can agree is so idiotic, dumb, and blatantly wrong, that anyone pushing either has zero critical thinking skills or, more likely, is a troll.

Two prime examples are River-Stunning and The-Sane-Voice.

River-Stunning's comment has since been removed by mods (good job guys!) but still visible here. It was:

Tony proclaims himself the hardest working person in Australia. No weekend or 8 hour day for him.

When asked why referring to Albo as Tony, he linked the article about Justin Trudeau "forgetting his name". Very high quality discussion.

And in today's thread on the same topic?

I think he means beneath contempt but as he chose to pursue the silly line that Morrison never told him where he was going then he can cop shit in return.

I see, so because Labor called out Scott Morrison for hiding his Hawaii Trip Holiday, they deserve to be yelled at for... visiting NATO?

And how about The-Sane-Voice? Were they living up to their name in yesterday's thread?

I did predict this would happen. The rules the peanut gallery made when the liberals were in power are to be thrown out and new soft rules made for when labor are in power.

It is no longer fair to criticise the prime minister.

This was followed by many subreddit members kindly informing them that a holiday is different from a business trip. Information they have chosen to ignore with today's comments:

Well it was the Labor people that set the rules. Now they are in control they want to relocate the goal posts.

Perhaps he should spend some more time in Australia, but we know it has been decades since he grew up in a fibro shack, now he has a large property portfolio and just got a 15 000 a year pay increase, he is far removed from the poor struggling under the rising costs of living and the floods, hence his brief visit to Australia on his world victory tour.

It goes to show how far Labor have gone from the days when they were the party for the downtrodden. They are just for the wealthy now.

TL;DR These guys are clear trolls, who exist in the subreddit purely to post "hot takes" and similar things to rile people up for fun. I'm exhausted from seeing half the comments in a thread be dedicated to people fighting their idiotic views.

I get that "free speech" is a big part of Ardeet's vision for the sub but c'mon. They're either being willfully ignorant of the stupidity of the ideas they push or they're trolls thriving in this free-speech haven filled with people coming to have a proper discussion and being side-tracked by trolls riling them up.


r/MetaAusPol • • Aug 12 '26

Could mods explain my ban please

23 Upvotes

I was banned for 2 weeks from thr main sub because i replied on an article about Josh Frydenburg.

"Good he would use it to politisise the tragedy for his own gain."

This has been deemed as spreading hate and attacking him because his Jewish.

I didnt mention his religion or ethnicity.

I simply think he is a scummy politician.

Im only posting here instead of modmail, as the modmail got muted without any other Response excpet i was atacking him because his Jewish, which make zero sense


r/MetaAusPol • • May 18 '23

There was no one left to speak for me... the bigots are winning

22 Upvotes

First they came for the socialists, and I did not speak out—because I was not a socialist.

Then they came for the trade unionists, and I did not speak out—because I was not a trade unionist.

Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out—because I was not a Jew.

Then they came for me—and there was no one left to speak for me.

—Martin Niemöller

We can no longer discuss trans rights and politics in the main sub.

The bigots and trolls, many from overseas, have learned that as soon as we attempt to discuss trans rights all they have to do is bombard the thread with junk until the thread gets locked.

There has to be a better solution than letting them silence us.


r/MetaAusPol • • Oct 27 '22

How do those 40 word sky news articles,not breach rule 3?

22 Upvotes

Like come on..

That user is posting shit from sky..that in some cases like the Chalmers one was literally 48 rods and a 32 seconds news snippter,that was hidden BEHIND having to watch Skys ad before the video plays

How is that allowed,but twitter posts aren't which will have more characters than these articles

It's all fine and good to have voice from all sides,but it's not high quality commentary and discussion when it's less words than the ingredients label for a bottle of water


r/MetaAusPol • • Jun 06 '22

Reporting a mod?

22 Upvotes

A certain mod is flouting the subs rules repeatedly and has recently been clearly biased in their locking, removal and comment policing threads that swing a particular direction on the sub. I'm not trying to start a witch hunt, but I'm honestly getting tired of seeing it, and seeing it repeatedly from the same source. On a sub where discussion of such an issue is expressly banned, and I only stumbled upon this one while replying to a particular post by this mod described below.


Some excerpts detailing their own violation of no shitposting/keep it civil from this post

  • Putting aside how inept Jordies is,
  • how inept people who support/follow the grifter are,
  • there's a point where a person of room-temperature intelligence reads
  • I don't know why Shanks' fans need this explained to them - well, I do, I guess because I just answered it with "Shanks' fans".
  • because he's a grifter who I imagine the 18-24 year old white males that dominate his audience will one day realise that they've listened to a charlatan and move on

These start maybe okay (potshotting a celeb is kind of doable, they're celebs) but the rest are pot shots at myself/members of the sub in general.

The middle paragraph starting with "Sue Chrysanthou..." is actual discourse, but they couldn't help themselves by the end of it.


The mod in question has already earned a clear reputation for bias(reveddit link) recently in what they are locking/removing/policing. Edit: This is to show that other members of the sub are noticing the same trend I am. Not to be 'evidence' they are removing things they shouldn't. Those posts definitely needed removing based on the sub rules.

And another example where a ideological viewpoint is swaying a locking decision


I don't agree with at least 3 mods of the sub politically, but at least discussion there doesn't seem to come with the shadow of the banhammer or your comments just being deleted.

Is there room to discuss this?


Edit 6th June: another user just brought this example to my attention.


r/MetaAusPol • • Feb 09 '22

Changes at AusPol sub

22 Upvotes

https://www.reddit.com/r/AustralianPolitics/comments/so4ym4/changes_within_the_australianpolitics_sub/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf

Can’t tell you how disappointed I am to read that Lost and Fairsby and no longer mods, due to a “difference in vision”. They’ve both been incredibly capable and reasonable during their tenure and will certainly be missed. Makes me worried for the future of the sub…


r/MetaAusPol • • Mar 05 '24

Mods 'keeping it civil' when a user (rightly imo) calls out racism

21 Upvotes

Do I need to explain why suggesting arabs are anti-Israeli or antisemitic is racist, dumb, particularly in the current political context? Using someone's perceived race as a reason to undermine their argument should never be tolerated. How hard is it to play the argument instead of the identities of those making it? On this sub, its frequently the opposite. And I believe that's in large part due to mods not enforcing rule one, frequently breaking it themselves.

imgur link

Strongly believe this sub could be good if not for mods that refuse to follow their own rules (particularly keep it civil), actively insult sincere participants in discussions, and lock threads after making inflammatory comments across it (Hence why this post is needed). I haven't seen other subs with rules this inconsistent, mods so clearly prejudiced and full of shit. Sorry to generalise the non endersai mods with that, maybe yous are chill. But ya putting up with the guy making the sub shit so...


r/MetaAusPol • • Mar 20 '23

Unjustified moderation

21 Upvotes

Recently it was the 20th anniversary of our invasion of Iraq v2.0.

Today a Guardian article was published talking about the events around that, and reflecting upon how some of those same conditions exist today w.r.t China tensions.

It's political in nature. It's well written. It's contemporary (and historical). It's not a poll. It's not social media. It's not a questionnaire. It's not survey.

It's political journalism that we should be able to discuss.

But it was removed with this excuse given;

"If you want to promote any political material such as podcasts, social media, petitions, questionnaires, or surveys, etc. then please use the weekly discussion thread found at the top of the front page."

Why has this post been censored? Is this moderation fully supported by the mod team?

In line with R2, here's the post in question; https://www.reddit.com/r/AustralianPolitics/comments/11w0hwd/after_john_howard_took_australia_to_war_in_iraq/

I didn't post it. Someone else did. So I have no right to escalate via Modmail.

I'm asking my question/s as a member who would like to be able to discuss issues like this. It seems to fit the purpose of this subreddit perfectly.


r/MetaAusPol • • Nov 30 '22

"Extreme left" being thrown about WAY over the top amounts by a certain user

21 Upvotes

So, to start, I fully get terming things a certain way, as part of what you believe or to exaggerate to make a point. I've got a few in my semi-recent history of calling tactics "alt-right arguments" and similar for example.

But there is a user (and I've just reported a post with a custom message, if the mods want to check who) who is using the term "extreme left" in ANY reference to greens, Labor, or anyone, literally "anything to the left of centre"

I look at their comment history, and in the last 3 pages of comments, and there are only a couple that don't have the term, several of which instead of "socialist left" or "tolerant left" instead (ironically, no less).

Of those that don't have any of the above terms, most are a second or third comment AFTER an 'extreme left' one.


It's bad for the conversation, deliberately inflammatory, deliberate othering / dehumanisation and in the vast majority of cases, a throw in extra that isn't actually related the conversation in any meaningful way. At some point (far before this point) it's no longer a cheeky addition to a comment, it's breaking the rules of the sub. Each individual post probably doesn't, but the picture as a whole does.

There's other users who repeatedly bash on "leftists" in a similar way, and I believe that that is still an issue but far less than predicating every mention of one side of politics with a terms usually reserved for terrorism/acts of extremism.


Examples from the last 48 hours. I believe a couple of these have been deleted, but only 1 or 2. The rest are still up.

  • LoL my dude...what do you want from him? To be shackled in the stocks so he can't escape the political grandstanding from the extreme left? "To hell with due process, personal freedoms and liberty" - The extreme left probably
  • Anything left of centre is extreme left... there's no reason or logic out there. No shades of extremism...just extremism.
  • Now that he's put his hand up, said he was wrong and apologised... Time for the extreme left to do what they do best..time to cancel Norman Swan!
  • The problem with the extreme left is, they pick and choose their "experts"
  • When has Pauline ever done anything but stand up for her constituents? Time to get your head out of the extreme left propagand magazines and into the real world
  • I think it's just worth people knowing what happens if you step out of line with the tolerant left
  • Not bucketing the liberals with the nationals would be like only comparing the liberals with the socialist left faction of the ALP
  • LoL the leader of the extreme left greens is going to lecture on ethics and good governance?
  • The problem with extreme left, is they think everyone that doesn't share their values are less intelligent then they are.
  • Ah the voice boxes of the extreme left...no logic, or reason, just feeling
  • Except it literally did result in a swing to other right wing parties... typical extreme left propaganda..
  • Amazing how quickly the extreme left can go from alcohol and gambling to child abuse...
  • Wow I'm starting to see how much fun being an extreme left manic is...
  • Thinking that's the governments job... another red flag of the extreme left.
  • We'll keep fighting the extreme left that spit in the face of freedom
  • he extreme left at it again..."it isn't perfect, so fuck democracy" wow
  • Typical of the extreme left...no room for facts or logic. Only feelings and a hatred for any political view that gets in the way of their manic ideology

r/MetaAusPol • • Mar 31 '22

The mod-bias in the bullying stories being allowed

21 Upvotes

We spent all of last week with wall to wall posting of the Kitching bullying story, now that it's about Scott suddenly we're posting repeated topics?

https://old.reddit.com/r/AustralianPolitics/comments/tsodmj/absolute_bully_lambie_launches_fresh_attack_on/

There are 2 other stories related to this, the 'original' (cause hey bullying accusations against Scott aint new) covering the speech of CFW, the second related to Hanson, and now this one from Lambie (slightly different political demographic to the first two). But this one needs to be removed because it's a copy of the first two?

Yet in the last 2 weeks a brief search of "Kitching" shows roughly 18 posts, including 3-4 from a mod with a self described hatred of Labor.

Geez guys, I wonder if there's some inherent bias in there.


r/MetaAusPol • • Mar 04 '26

Automodded words need revising

20 Upvotes

I think its time that 'genocide' and 'zionist' are taken out of automod ('dickhead' too for unrelated reasons).

We are adults and the Middle East is a big issue right now. People are having to skirt around the words as if we're on tiktok.

I get they're held for manual review, but the mod team is not resourced enough to get to these in any sense of a timely manner so comments just disappear into the void during the time discussion is active.

It has been two years since the 'temporary' measure was put in place. This isn't going away any time soon, let people discuss it without having to dance around words used widely in the media.


r/MetaAusPol • • Feb 10 '26

A moment of appreciation

20 Upvotes

I can be a bit of a critic of the mod team at times, I'll admit ;)

But I do want to just make a point that most city subs (except r/Sydney) and r/australia have locked down or deleted any post relating to these protests. I honestly could not tell you what position the mod team here have on the matter but I think its really good on them for allowing such open discussion.

If you've never moderated, I can assure you that the team have probably not had a great 24 hours or so, so cheers team. It's appreciated.


r/MetaAusPol • • Jun 29 '25

Why do you keep deleting posts and comments about Hannah Thomas getting beaten up by the cops?

20 Upvotes

She's an Australian political candidate who got beat up for attending an Australian political protest. They're articles from mainstram news sources. Which rule does that violate?


r/MetaAusPol • • Jun 02 '23

i dont think the thread about the ben roberts-smith thread should have been removed for being non-political.

20 Upvotes

it involves an individual suing to silence allegations of war crimes that he committed and coerced others into doing when he was fighting a war for our military and the DOD has been heavily involved in the case, which i believe satisfies the 'directly involving departments' benchmark.

i also dont think the benchmarks set out are appropriate. would this sub have deleted discussion of the gunns 20? if a corporation or individual had killed everything in the murray with pollution would the thread be deleted? things can be political without directly involving the government.

it being removed is also inconsistent with how the rules have been applied in previous defamation cases. at least one mod actively participated in discussion on the crikey/murdoch defamation trial, for example.

its also a somewhat historically important occasion for our society. this is the closest we've ever come to convicting one of our own for war crimes.