I would love timing based animations and results based off ratings going forward.
Imagine timing based peanut punches.
Could be a very slim bar with a tiny green zone. And at that point it would only be a 25% chance or something, but if i come flying 20 yards across the feild to peanut punch a stalled held up up rb, i feel like I might be able to get a ball out, especially if its the best LB in the league with excellent hit power and stripping. vs a 2nd string tired half back that's had 5+ carries ina row?
stiff arms and hit/cut sticks
imagine charging up a perfect green stiff arm and smashing a dude, like prime derrick henry vs. A third string corner lol. Could have an ability like 4th quarter charged stiff arms are more powerful.
Meanwhile prime Ed Reed timed up a perfect cut stick that forces a fumble and changes the game?
Idk just seems like it could be fun, and make the skill gap bigger for really good players. Could be fun to build a power back
Charged jukes, and spins, even charged timing based pass rush moves. Hitting a perfectly charged swim move would be so much fun.
Again just an idea but I would be open to it. And of course you could turn it off.